Liu Bei 劉備

RecordsRomance Shu Courtesy name 玄德 Xuande유비현덕유예주소열황제劉豫州昭烈皇帝刘备刘豫州

Profile
OccupationRNRuler · EmperorFactionShu
AppearsRNBiography inBook of Shu
BornR161 N(same) UnverifiedNative placeZhuo Commandery Zhuo County
DiedR223 N(same) UnverifiedPlace of deathRNYongan Palace
Cause of deathRIllness NIllness Unverified
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR798

Profile

Liu Bei, courtesy name Xuande, was a native of Zhuo County in Zhuo Commandery and a descendant of Liu Sheng, Prince Jing of Zhongshan. He lost his father young and made a living selling sandals and weaving mats. He entered official service by fighting the Yellow Turbans, and then placed himself in turn under Gongsun Zan, Tao Qian, Cao Cao, Yuan Shao and Liu Biao. Records, Shu 2 §2–3 · 6–8 · 13 · 17 · 19

After defeating Cao Cao at Chibi (the Red Cliffs) together with Sun Quan, he became Governor of Jing Province (Jingzhou mu); he took Yi Province in the 19th year of Jian'an (214) and became King of Hanzhong in the 24th year of Jian'an (219). In the 26th year of Jian'an (221) he ascended the throne as emperor at Chengdu, but while attacking Wu he was heavily defeated by Lu Xun at Xiaoting, and he died at Yongan Palace in the 3rd year of Zhangwu (223), aged 63. Records, Shu 2 §23–24 · 33 · 38–40 · 65 · 71 · 73Records, Wu 13 §2

In his assessment, Chen Shou wrote that he had the bearing of Emperor Gaozu and the capacity of a hero, and that his entrusting of his orphaned son to Zhuge Liang was a model for all ages, yet that in adaptable stratagem and practical ability he fell short of Emperor Wu of Wei. In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 1 and figures in 81 of its 120 chapters, and the story opens with the Chapter 1 heading, 'At a feast in the peach garden, three heroes swear brotherhood'. Records, Shu 2 §78Romance, Ch. 1 §14 · 21–22

In the Records

The Biography of the First Sovereign refers to him as 'the First Sovereign' (Xianzhu). His courtesy name was Xuande and he was a native of Zhuo County in Zhuo Commandery; Liu Zhen, a son of Liu Sheng, Prince Jing of Zhongshan, lost his marquisate at Zhuo County over the matter of the tribute gold (zhoujin) and settled there. His grandfather was Liu Xiong and his father Liu Hong. He lost his father young and made a living with his mother selling sandals and weaving mats. Beneath the mulberry tree by the fence of his house he said, 'I will surely ride in a carriage with a feathered canopy like this,' and was scolded for it by his uncle Zijing. At fifteen he studied under Lu Zhi together with Gongsun Zan and others, and his clansman Liu Yuanqi always provided him with money, saying, 'He is no ordinary person.' Records, Shu 2 §2–4

He stood seven chi five cun tall; when he let his arms hang, his hands reached below his knees, and when he turned his head he could see his own ears. He spoke little and did not show joy or anger. When the Yellow Turbans rose, he fought under Colonel Zou Jing and was made Commandant of Anxi, but when the commandery inspector (duyou) refused to see him, he went in, tied the man up, gave him two hundred strokes of the rod, then abandoned his post and fled. Later he attached himself to Gongsun Zan, became a Major of a Separate Command (biebu sima), and held off Yuan Shao together with Tian Kai; for his merit in battle he rose to Chancellor of Pingyuan. Records, Shu 2 §5–7

When Cao Cao attacked Xu Province, he went with Tian Kai to rescue Tao Qian, Governor of Xu Province; when Tao Qian reinforced him with four thousand Danyang troops, he transferred his allegiance to Tao Qian and was stationed at Xiaopei as Inspector of Yu Province. When Tao Qian fell gravely ill, he told Mi Zhu, 'Without Liu Bei this province cannot be kept secure.' After Tao Qian died, he declined, saying the province should be given to Yuan Shu, but when Chen Deng and Kong Rong spoke poorly of Yuan Shu and urged him, he took charge of Xu Province. In the 1st year of Jian'an (196), on Cao Cao's recommendation, he became General Who Guards the East and Marquis of Yicheng Village. Records, Shu 2 §8–11

While he was facing Yuan Shu, Lü Bu raided Xiapi and captured his wife and children; later, defeated by Lü Bu, he went over to Cao Cao. After capturing Lü Bu at Xiapi together with Cao Cao, he went to the capital, Xu, and became General of the Left, and Cao Cao had him ride in the same carriage when they went out and sit on the same mat when they sat. When Dong Cheng, uncle of Emperor Xian (Liu Xie), said he had received a secret edict hidden in the emperor's robe sash and proposed killing Cao Cao, he had not yet acted; then Cao Cao said to him, 'The only heroes in the realm today are you, sir, and I,' and he dropped his spoon and chopsticks. Afterwards he plotted with Dong Cheng, but went out to intercept Yuan Shu and never carried out the plan. He killed Che Zhou, Inspector of Xu Province, and seized Xiapi, but in the 5th year of Jian'an (200) he was heavily defeated by Cao Cao, and his wife and children and Guan Yu were captured. Records, Shu 2 §12–16

When he fled to Qing Province, Yuan Tan welcomed him, and Yuan Shao came out two hundred li from Ye to meet him. While he was raiding the area around Xu with Liu Pi of Runan and others on Yuan Shao's orders, Guan Yu escaped and returned to him. Wishing to leave Yuan Shao, he persuaded him to ally with Liu Biao, then joined Gong Du and others in Runan and killed Cai Yang, whom Cao Cao had sent. When Cao Cao defeated Yuan Shao and came south, he took refuge with Liu Biao. Liu Biao stationed him at Xinye, but as the leading men of Jing Province gathered around him, Liu Biao secretly guarded against him. At Bowang he burned his own camp, feigned flight, and defeated Xiahou Dun, Yu Jin and others with an ambush. Records, Shu 2 §17–19

While at Xinye, on Xu Shu's advice he went to visit Zhuge Liang and met him only on the third visit. When Liu Biao died and his son Liu Cong surrendered to Cao Cao, he, stationed at Fan, learned of it only when Cao Cao had reached Wan, and he left leading his followers. When Zhuge Liang urged him to attack Liu Cong, he said, 'I cannot bear to.' By the time he reached Dangyang his followers numbered more than a hundred thousand and he advanced only a little over ten li a day; told to hurry ahead and hold Jiangling, he refused to abandon them, saying, 'To accomplish a great undertaking one must take people as the foundation.' Cao Cao rode over three hundred li in a single day and night with five thousand elite cavalry and caught up with him at Changban, and he fled with Zhuge Liang, Zhang Fei, Zhao Yun and a few dozen other horsemen, abandoning his wife and children. Records, Shu 5 §4Records, Shu 2 §20–22

Meeting Guan Yu's boats, he crossed the Mian River and reached Xiakou together with Liu Qi, Liu Biao's eldest son. He sent Zhuge Liang to ally with Sun Quan, who dispatched a navy of several tens of thousands under Zhou Yu, Cheng Pu and others, and together they crushed Cao Cao at Chibi. When an epidemic broke out as well and Cao Cao withdrew, he brought the four southern commanderies to submission, and when Liu Qi died of illness he became Governor of Jing Province. Sun Quan, fearing him, gave him his younger sister in marriage. Records, Shu 2 §23–24

In the 16th year of Jian'an (211), when Cao Cao was about to attack Zhang Lu in Hanzhong, Liu Zhang, Governor of Yi Province, grew afraid and on Zhang Song's advice sent Fa Zheng to invite him in. He left Jing Province in the hands of Zhuge Liang, Guan Yu and others and entered Yi Province; when Zhang Song, Fa Zheng and Pang Tong urged him to seize Liu Zhang at Fu County, he said, 'This is a great matter; it must not be rushed.' The following year Zhang Song's plot was discovered and he was executed, and the passes were closed to him; he then beheaded Liu Zhang's officer Yang Huai and occupied Fu County. Zhuge Liang, Zhang Fei, Zhao Yun and others came up the river to join him, and after attacking Luo for nearly a year he surrounded Chengdu in the 19th year of Jian'an (214) and received Liu Zhang's surrender. Becoming Governor of Yi Province once more, he gave high posts even to Peng Yang, whom Liu Zhang had shunned, and to Liu Ba, whom he himself had long resented. Records, Shu 2 §27–34

In the 20th year of Jian'an (215), when Sun Quan demanded Jing Province, he replied, 'Once I have taken Liang Province, I will give you Jing Province.' Sun Quan sent Lü Meng to seize three commanderies, but when Cao Cao pacified Hanzhong he made peace with Sun Quan and divided Jing Province between east and west. In spring of the 24th year of Jian'an (219) he had Huang Zhong behead Xiahou Yuan at Mount Dingjun, and when Cao Cao came in person he said, 'Even if Lord Cao comes, he can do nothing; I will surely hold the Han River valley,' and, relying on strong terrain, refused to give battle. In summer Cao Cao withdrew, and he took Hanzhong. Records, Shu 2 §35–39

That autumn, 120 of his subordinates submitted a memorial to the Han emperor proclaiming him King of Hanzhong; he returned the seals and ribbons of General of the Left and Marquis of Yicheng Village, went back to Chengdu, and left Wei Yan to guard Hanzhong. Soon afterwards Sun Quan attacked and killed Guan Yu and took Jing Province. In the 25th year of Jian'an (220), when Emperor Wen of Wei took the imperial title and rumors spread that the Han emperor had been killed, he conferred on him the posthumous title Emperor Xiaomin; in the fourth month of the 26th year of Jian'an (221) he ascended the throne south of Wudan at Chengdu and changed the era name to Zhangwu. In the sixth month Zhang Fei was killed by his own attendants. Long enraged at Sun Quan's attack on Guan Yu, he attacked Wu in the seventh month and refused even Sun Quan's request for peace. Records, Shu 2 §40 · 53–55 · 65 · 68–69

In the second month of the 2nd year of Zhangwu (222) he set up camp at Xiaoting in Yidao, sent Ma Liang to pacify the Man peoples of Wuxi, and gave Huang Quan command of the forces north of the river. Lu Xun of Wu (the Biography of the First Sovereign records him under his original name, Lu Yi) attacked his army, which had strung together dozens of camps from the Wu Gorge to the border of Yiling, by having soldiers carrying bundles of thatch set fires; he broke more than forty camps and killed Feng Xi, Zhang Nan and others (Biography of Lu Xun). He returned overland to Yufu, which he renamed Yong'an, and when Sun Quan asked for peace he accepted. In the 3rd year of Zhangwu (223), when his illness became grave, he entrusted his orphaned son to the Chancellor Zhuge Liang, with Li Yan as his deputy, and in the fourth month he died at Yongan Palace, aged 63. His posthumous title was Emperor Zhaolie. Records, Shu 2 §70–73 · 76Records, Wu 13 §2 · 17 · 21

In his assessment, Chen Shou said that the First Sovereign was broad-minded and resolute, tolerant and generous, able to judge men and treat scholars well, and so had the bearing of Emperor Gaozu and the capacity of a hero. He called the way he entrusted the whole state and his orphaned son to Zhuge Liang without any duplicity of heart a splendid model for all ages. In adaptable stratagem and practical ability he fell short of Emperor Wu of Wei, and so his territory was also narrow; yet Chen Shou wrote that his refusal to bend when broken and his never becoming another's subordinate came from judging that the other side would never tolerate him, and seeking to avoid harm. Records, Shu 2 §78

In the Romance

Chapter 1 of the Romance depicts him as a man whose ears reached his shoulders and whose hands hung below his knees. At twenty-eight, sighing over a notice from Liu Yan, Grand Administrator of You Province, calling for volunteer troops, he met Zhang Fei and then Guan Yu at a tavern; in the peach garden they swore, 'We wish only to die in the same year, the same month and on the same day,' and he became the eldest brother. In Chapter 2, when the inspector (duyou), hoping for a bribe, bore down on him as county commandant, Zhang Fei flogged the inspector with willow switches; he restrained Zhang Fei, then hung his seal of office around the inspector's neck and gave up his post. Romance, Ch. 1 §14 · 17–22Romance, Ch. 2 §22–27

In Chapter 5 he followed Gongsun Zan to the coalition against Dong Zhuo, and at the battle of Hulao Pass he drew his paired swords and surrounded Lü Bu together with Guan Yu and Zhang Fei. In Chapter 11, when he went to relieve Xu Province, besieged by Cao Cao, Tao Qian at once tried to hand the province over to him, and he declined again and again. In Chapter 12 he still declined after Tao Qian's death, and only when the people of Xu Province tearfully begged him did he agree to take charge provisionally. Romance, Ch. 5 §12 · 42 · 49–50Romance, Ch. 11 §28–30 · 41Romance, Ch. 12 §17–20

In Chapter 21, after seeing Dong Cheng's edict hidden in the sash and signing his name as 'General of the Left Liu Bei', he tended vegetables in his back garden to avoid Cao Cao's suspicion. When Cao Cao, over green plums and warmed wine, said, 'The only heroes in the realm are you, sir, and I,' he dropped his spoon and chopsticks, but blamed it on a clap of thunder that happened to sound and so dispelled the suspicion. In Chapter 34, when Cai Mao tried to harm him at a banquet in Xiangyang, he slipped out through the west gate, and his horse Dilu, sunk in the Tan Stream, leapt three zhang in one bound and crossed it. Romance, Ch. 21 §5–7 · 10 · 15–17Romance, Ch. 34 §37–42

In Chapter 36 the departing Xu Shu recommended Zhuge Liang to him, and in Chapter 38, on his third visit, he waited standing at the thatched hall until Zhuge Liang awoke, then met him and heard his plan to divide the realm into three. In Chapter 41, leading more than a hundred thousand soldiers and civilians, he refused to abandon the people when his officers urged him to leave them behind and go ahead, saying, 'One who undertakes a great enterprise must take people as the foundation.' In Chapter 42 he took A Dou (Liu Shan), whom Zhao Yun had carried in his bosom, and threw him to the ground, saying, 'Because of a little child like you, I nearly lost one of my great generals.' Romance, Ch. 36 §33–36Romance, Ch. 38 §6–8 · 16Romance, Ch. 41 §15–17Romance, Ch. 42 §4

In Chapter 54 Zhou Yu tried to trap him using a marriage to Sun Quan's younger sister as bait, but at Ganlu Temple Dowager Wu saw him and was greatly pleased, so the marriage took place, and in Chapter 55 he escaped together with Lady Sun. After entering Western Chuan, when Wei Yan performed a sword dance at a banquet in Fu intending to kill Liu Zhang, he drew his sword to stop it and rebuked Pang Tong (Chapter 61). In Chapter 63 he gave Pang Tong his own white horse, and at Luofeng Slope Pang Tong, riding that horse, was killed by arrows shot by Zhang Ren's ambushers. Romance, Ch. 54 §13 · 16 · 33–36Romance, Ch. 55 §25 · 37Romance, Ch. 60 §62–64Romance, Ch. 61 §1–5Romance, Ch. 63 §12 · 16 · 19

In Chapter 73, in the seventh month, autumn, of the 24th year of Jian'an, he mounted the altar at Mianyang and became King of Hanzhong, naming Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, Zhao Yun, Ma Chao and Huang Zhong the Five Tiger Generals. In Chapter 80, on a rumor that the Han emperor had been harmed, he conferred the posthumous title Emperor Xiaomin, and, pushed by the scheme of Zhuge Liang, who took to his bed feigning illness, he ascended the throne. From this point the narrative calls him 'the First Sovereign', and he soon issued an edict to attack Wu, citing the oath of the peach garden, and rejected the remonstrances of Zhao Yun and Qin Mi. Romance, Ch. 73 §8–9Romance, Ch. 80 §29 · 34–38 · 42–43Romance, Ch. 81 §1–3 · 10–11

In Chapter 83 he took Xiaoting, but in Chapter 84, when fires set by Lu Xun's army burned his camps strung out over more than seven hundred li, he was heavily defeated and, rescued by Zhao Yun, entered Baidicheng with only a hundred or so men. In Chapter 85, after seeing the spirits of Guan Yu and Zhang Fei in a dream, he charged Zhuge Liang at Yongan Palace, 'If my son is worth assisting, assist him; if he lacks ability, you yourself should become master of Chengdu,' and died on the 24th day of the fourth month, in summer of the 3rd year of Zhangwu, aged 63. Romance, Ch. 83 §16Romance, Ch. 84 §10 · 21–23 · 29–31Romance, Ch. 85 §15–17 · 22 · 25

Where the Romance differs

Childhood: In Chapter 1 of the Romance his uncle Liu Yuanqi, calling him 'no ordinary child', regularly helped support the household, and he studied under Zheng Xuan and Lu Zhi. In the Records, Liu Yuanqi was the father of his clansman Liu Deran, the uncle who scolded him over the carriage-canopy remark was Zijing, and only Lu Zhi is recorded as his teacher. Romance, Ch. 1 §16Records, Shu 2 §3–4

The Peach Garden Oath: The oath in the peach garden in Chapter 1 of the Romance does not appear in the Biography of the First Sovereign in the Records. The Records note only that the First Sovereign shared a bed with Guan Yu and Zhang Fei when they slept, and that his affection for them was like that of brothers. Romance, Ch. 1 §21–22Records, Shu 2 §1–76Records, Shu 6 §2

Flogging the inspector: In Chapter 2 of the Romance Zhang Fei flogged the inspector and Liu Bei restrained him. In the Records Liu Bei himself tied up the inspector and gave him two hundred strokes of the rod. Romance, Ch. 2 §25–27Records, Shu 2 §6

The campaign against Dong Zhuo: In Chapter 5 of the Romance he followed Gongsun Zan to the coalition and fought Lü Bu at Hulao Pass. The Biography of the First Sovereign in the Records has no record of his joining the coalition against Dong Zhuo. Romance, Ch. 5 §12 · 49–50Records, Shu 2 §1–76

How he came to govern Xu Province: In Chapters 11–12 of the Romance Tao Qian tried three times to hand over Xu Province while still alive, and the urging of Chen Deng and Kong Rong also came in Tao Qian's presence. In the Records Tao Qian, gravely ill, told Mi Zhu, 'Without Liu Bei this province cannot be kept secure,' and it was after Tao Qian's death, at the urging of Chen Deng and Kong Rong, that he took charge of Xu Province. Romance, Ch. 11 §29–30 · 38–41Romance, Ch. 12 §17–19Records, Shu 2 §9–11

The talk of heroes: In Chapter 21 of the Romance he heard Cao Cao's words after signing Dong Cheng's pledge, and explained away the dropped chopsticks by blaming the thunder. In the Records he heard Cao Cao's words and dropped his spoon and chopsticks before he had taken any action; his plotting with Dong Cheng came afterwards, and there is no story of thunder. Romance, Ch. 21 §5–6 · 16Records, Shu 2 §15

The Tan Stream: The story in Chapter 34 of the Romance of the horse Dilu leaping across the Tan Stream does not appear in the Biography of the First Sovereign in the Records. Romance, Ch. 34 §41–42Records, Shu 2 §1–76

A Dou at Changban: In Chapter 42 of the Romance Liu Bei threw to the ground A Dou (Liu Shan), whom Zhao Yun had rescued. The Biography of the First Sovereign in the Records states that he abandoned his wife and children at Changban and fled, and the biographies of Zhao Yun and of Empress Gan (Xianzhu) state only that Zhao Yun carried the infant Later Sovereign in his arms and protected Lady Gan, so that they escaped harm. Romance, Ch. 42 §4Records, Shu 2 §22Records, Shu 6 §39Records, Shu 4 §3

Conditions for returning Jing Province: In Chapter 54 of the Romance Liu Bei personally wrote a document promising to return Jing Province once he had taken Western Chuan. In the Records, when Sun Quan demanded Jing Province after he had taken Yi Province, he answered, 'Once I have taken Liang Province, I will give you Jing Province,' and after Sun Quan seized three commanderies they divided Jing Province and made peace. Romance, Ch. 54 §7Records, Shu 2 §35

The death of Pang Tong: In Chapter 63 of the Romance Pang Tong, riding Liu Bei's white horse, was killed at Luofeng Slope by arrows shot by Zhang Ren's ambushers. In the Records Pang Tong, while besieging Luo County and attacking its walls, was struck and killed by a stray arrow, and the First Sovereign wept whenever he spoke of him. Romance, Ch. 63 §12 · 16 · 19Records, Shu 7 §11

The flight to Baidicheng: In Chapter 84 of the Romance Zhao Yun rode up, speared Zhu Ran to death and rescued the First Sovereign. In the Records, pursued by Lu Xun, he barely made it into Baidicheng because the post-station men burned gongs and armor to cut off the pursuit behind him, and Zhu Ran died in the 12th year of Chiwu (249), aged 68. Romance, Ch. 84 §29–30Records, Wu 13 §22Records, Wu 11 §24

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA7265−7
  • STR5860+2
  • INT7565−10
  • POL6055−5
  • CHA100100±0
  • VIR90100+10
  • ADP8075−5
  • SCH3028−2
  • DIP7268−4
  • DIS9495+1
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

8 similar abilities — show evidence

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (81)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Allegiance history Changed allegiance 6 times

  1. Gongsun Zan faction (190~194) Took refuge · Records · Records vol. 36(裴注) 「時先主亦依託瓚,每接納雲,雲得深自結託。」
  2. Tao Qian faction (194~194) Defected · Records · Records vol. 32 「既到,謙以丹楊兵四千益先主,先主遂去楷歸謙。」
  3. Lü Bu faction (196~196) Surrendered · Records · Records vol. 32(裴注) 「《英雄記》曰:備軍在廣陵,飢餓困踧,吏士大小自相噉食,窮餓侵逼,欲還小沛,遂使吏請降布。」
  4. Wei (196~199) Defected · Records · Records vol. 32 「呂布惡之,自出兵攻先主,先主敗走歸曹公。」
  5. Yuan Shao faction (200~201) Fled · Records · Records vol. 36 「建安五年,曹公東征,先主奔袁紹。」
  6. Liu Biao faction (201~208) Took refuge · Records · Records vol. 36 「從先主就劉表。」
  7. Shu (208~223) Independent · Records · Records vol. 32 「先主表琦為荊州刺史,又南征四郡。」

Relations

  • Shu Led by · Records

Family

ParentsLiu Hong(劉弘) Novel & History
SpouseLady Mi Novel & History, Lady Sun Novel & History
ChildrenLiu Li Novel & History, Liu Shan Novel & History, Liu Yong Romance
RelativesLiu Feng Records

Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.

Related events (48)

Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).

Items owned or made (3)

Ownership and authorship assigned by 3KDEX from source sentences — not yet reviewed (unverified).

Related works (8)

Linked via Wikidata "depicts" and character names in titles (unverified) — not yet reviewed.