Zheng Xuan 鄭玄
| Occupation | RScholar NScholar · Master of Writing | Faction | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appears | RN | Biography in | |
| Born | R127 Unverified | Native place | |
| Died | R? Unverified | Place of death | |
| Existence | Historical | Mentions | R40 |
Profile
Zheng Xuan was a classical scholar of the late Eastern Han. He has no biography of his own in the Records; his name appears in the biographies of Cui Yan, Guo Yuan, Cheng Bing and others who studied under him, and in passages recording the disputes over classical scholarship in Wei. Records, Wei 12 §2Records, Wei 11 §29Records, Wu 8 §18
According to the biography of Cui Yan, when the Yellow Turbans of Xu Province overran Beihai, Zheng Xuan took refuge from the turmoil on Mount Buqi with his disciples, and when even grain ran out he sent his students home. In Wei, Wang Su disparaged and revised his interpretations, and his disciple Sun Shuran, Wang Ji and others opposed him. Records, Wei 12 §2Records, Wei 13 §96–97Records, Wei 27 §52
As he has no biography, there is no assessment by Chen Shou either. In the Romance his name first appears in Chapter 1 as Liu Bei's teacher, and he appears in 2 of its 120 chapters; in Chapter 22, at Liu Bei's request, he writes a letter to Yuan Shao. No chapter title bears his name. Romance, Ch. 1 §16Romance, Ch. 22 §4
In the Records
At the age of twenty-nine Cui Yan went with Gongsun Fang and others to study under Zheng Xuan. Before he had studied for a full year, the Yellow Turbans of Xu Province attacked and overran Beihai, and Zheng Xuan went with his disciples to Mount Buqi to take refuge from the turmoil. When even the grain that could be bought in the county ran out, Zheng Xuan took leave of his students and sent them home, and Cui Yan wandered for four years, with bandits everywhere and the roads blocked, before returning home. Records, Wei 12 §2–3
Many others also studied under him. Guo Yuan, after taking Zheng Xuan as his teacher, took refuge in Liaodong with Bing Yuan, Guan Ning and others, and later took charge of the agricultural garrisons under Cao Cao. Cheng Bing, after studying under Zheng Xuan, took refuge in Jiao Province, where he discussed the great principles of the classics with Liu Xi, and later became Grand Tutor to the Heir Apparent of Wu. Sun Shuran of Le'an studied under Zheng Xuan and was called the great Confucian of the eastern provinces. Xu Ci of Shu took Liu Xi as his teacher and excelled in the learning of the Zheng school. Records, Wei 11 §29Records, Wu 8 §18Records, Wei 13 §96Records, Shu 12 §26
Wang Su of Wei favored the learning of Jia Kui and Ma Rong and disliked that of the Zheng school, and he wrote commentaries on the various classics that were adopted by the official academies. When Wang Su compiled the Evidence from the Sages to disparage Zheng Xuan, Sun Shuran refuted it. When Wang Su, in settling court ritual, altered Zheng Xuan's old interpretations, Wang Ji firmly upheld Zheng Xuan's views and constantly opposed him. Li Zhuan of Shu, in writing commentaries on the classics, took Jia Kui and Ma Rong as his standard and differed from Zheng Xuan. Records, Wei 13 §96–97Records, Wei 27 §52Records, Shu 12 §47
In the 4th month of the 1st year of Ganlu (256), Cao Mao, Duke of Gaoguixiang, visited the Imperial Academy and questioned the scholars. The emperor asked why, if Confucius's not combining the Tuan commentary and the Xiang commentary with the classic text was to be called modesty, Zheng Xuan alone had not been modest, and the Erudite of the Changes Chunyu Jun could not answer in the end. In the lecture on the Book of Documents he asked which was right: Zheng Xuan, who glossed 'jigu' as meaning 'being one with Heaven', or Wang Su, who glossed it as 'following and examining the ancient way'. When the Erudite Yu Jun said Wang Su's reading was better, the emperor countered that Yao's great excellence lay in modeling himself on Heaven. Records, Wei 4 §48 · 60–68
In the Romance
In Chapter 1 of the Romance, at fifteen, Liu Bei goes away to study at his mother's wish, takes Zheng Xuan and Lu Zhi as his teachers, and becomes friends with Gongsun Zan and others. Romance, Ch. 1 §16
In Chapter 22, Chen Deng proposes to Liu Bei that they ask Yuan Shao for help, obtaining a letter from Zheng Kangcheng, that is, Zheng Xuan, whose family had been on friendly terms with Yuan Shao's for three generations. The Romance relates that when Zheng Xuan studied under Ma Rong he did not once glance aside in three years, so that Ma Rong exclaimed, 'The only one who has grasped the deep meaning of my learning is Zheng Xuan,' and that in his household even the maidservants were versed in the Mao Odes. Romance, Ch. 22 §1–3
It also says that Zheng Xuan had risen to Master of Writing under Emperor Huan but had given up office because of the turmoil of the Ten Attendants and was living in Xu Province, and that Liu Bei had taken him as his teacher in Zhuo Commandery and even after becoming Governor of Xu Province would visit him from time to time to seek his instruction. When Liu Bei and Chen Deng call on him, Zheng Xuan gladly writes the letter, and when Sun Qian delivers it, Yuan Shao raises troops, saying that the request of Master of Writing Zheng carries great weight. Yuan Shao sends Sun Qian back and has him inform Zheng Xuan as well. Romance, Ch. 22 §4–5 · 9
Where the Romance differs
Liu Bei's teacher: In Chapter 1 of the Romance, Liu Bei takes Zheng Xuan and Lu Zhi as his teachers. The Biography of the First Sovereign in the Records says only that at fifteen Liu Bei served Lu Zhi together with his clansman Liu Deran and Gongsun Zan of Liaoxi; Zheng Xuan does not appear. Romance, Ch. 1 §16Records, Shu 2 §4
The letter to Yuan Shao: In Chapter 22 of the Romance, Yuan Shao, receiving Zheng Xuan's letter, takes the request seriously and raises troops. The Records say only that Liu Bei sent Sun Qian to join hands with Yuan Shao; Zheng Xuan's letter appears in neither the Biography of the First Sovereign nor the biography of Sun Qian. Romance, Ch. 22 §4–5Records, Shu 2 §16Records, Shu 8 §25
His whereabouts during the turmoil: In Chapter 22 of the Romance, Zheng Xuan has given up office and is living in Xu Province. In the Records, while Cui Yan was studying under Zheng Xuan, the Yellow Turbans of Xu Province overran Beihai, and Zheng Xuan took refuge on Mount Buqi with his disciples and sent his students home when grain ran out. Romance, Ch. 22 §4Records, Wei 12 §2
Relationship with Ma Rong: Chapter 22 of the Romance portrays Zheng Xuan as the only disciple who truly carried on Ma Rong's learning. In Chen Shou's main text, Ma Rong's learning is instead contrasted with Zheng Xuan's: it records that Wang Su of Wei and Li Zhuan of Shu followed Jia Kui and Ma Rong and differed from Zheng Xuan. Romance, Ch. 22 §2–3Records, Wei 13 §96Records, Shu 12 §47
Disciples and disputes: The Records record those who studied under Zheng Xuan, such as Cui Yan, Guo Yuan, Cheng Bing and Sun Shuran, and the dispute over Zheng Xuan's interpretations between Wang Su and Wang Ji. These matters do not appear in Chapters 1 and 22, where the Romance features Zheng Xuan. Records, Wei 12 §2Records, Wei 11 §29Records, Wu 8 §18Records, Wei 13 §96–97Records, Wei 27 §52Romance, Ch. 1 §16Romance, Ch. 22 §2–4
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
Abilities
The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.
- LEA3131±0
- STR3131±0
- INT4545±0
- POL4045+5
- CHA6672+6
- VIR5566+11
- ADP4855+7
- SCH10095−5
- DIP4070+30
- DIS4242±0
Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more
8 similar abilities — show evidence
RGuo Yuan, Cui Yan, Cheng Bing and others came to study with him, and his disciple Sun Shuran was called a great ConfucianWei 11 §29Wei 12 §2Wu 8 §18
NLiu Bei served him as a teacher with special courtesy, and Yuan Shao gave great weight to his requestCh. 22 §4Ch. 22 §5
RThe emperor discussed his commentary on the Changes alongside Confucius, and Wang Ji and others firmly upheld his interpretationsWei 4 §64Wei 4 §67Wei 27 §52
NMa Rong said he alone had grasped the deep meaning of his learning, and even his maidservants were versed in the Mao OdesCh. 22 §3Ch. 22 §2
Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)
3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.
Romance chapters (2)
AppearsNot present Chapter list →
Related works (1)
- 明 仇英 临宋人画册 Art
Linked via Wikidata "depicts" and character names in titles (unverified) — not yet reviewed.