Gongsun Zan 公孫瓚
| Occupation | RRuler · General of the Front NRuler · Administrator of Beiping | Faction | Gongsun Zan faction |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appears | RN | Biography in | Book of Wei |
| Born | R? Unverified | Native place | Liaoxi Commandery Lingzhi County |
| Died | R199 Unverified | Place of death | RNYijing |
| Cause of death | RSuicide NSuicide Unverified | ||
| Existence | Historical | Mentions | R61 |
Profile
Gongsun Zan, courtesy name Bogui, was a native of Lingzhi County in Liaoxi Commandery. He studied the classics under Lu Zhi of Zhuo Commandery, and by fighting the Xianbei and Wuhuan on the frontier of You Province he became a General of the Household (zhonglang jiang) and Marquis of a Chief Village (duting hou). After Dong Zhuo entered Luoyang, he became General of Vehement Might (fenwu jiangjun) and Marquis of Ji. Records, Wei 8 §2–5 · 8
Quarrelling with Liu Yu, Governor of You Province, he captured him and coerced the court's envoy into beheading him, and rose to General of the Front and Marquis of Yi. After fighting Yuan Shao for years, he shut himself up at Yijing behind layer upon layer of walls, and in the 4th year of Jian'an (199), when Yuan Shao surrounded it with his whole army and brought down his towers, he killed his wife and children and then killed himself. Records, Wei 8 §14 · 16–20
In his assessment, Chen Shou said, 'Gongsun Zan guarded Yijing and sat waiting for his destruction.' In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 1 as a friend who studied together with Liu Bei and appears in 11 of its 120 chapters; as the title of Chapter 7, 'Yuan Shao Fights Gongsun at the Pan River', suggests, he is portrayed as a northern warlord standing against Yuan Shao. Records, Wei 8 §71Romance, Ch. 1 §16Romance, Ch. 7 §10
In the Records
Gongsun Zan, courtesy name Bogui, was a native of Lingzhi County in Liaoxi Commandery. He became an Assistant Clerk of the Gate Office (menxia shuzuo) in his commandery, and because he had a fine bearing and a resounding voice, Administrator Hou thought him a man of capacity, gave him his daughter in marriage and sent him to Lu Zhi of Zhuo Commandery to study the classics. The Biography of Liu Bei records that Liu Bei served Lu Zhi together with Gongsun Zan and treated the older Gongsun Zan as an elder brother. Records, Wei 8 §2Records, Shu 2 §4
When he was again a commandery clerk, Administrator Liu was implicated in an affair and summoned before the Commandant of Justice, and Gongsun Zan drove his carriage and personally took on the menial tasks of a servant. On the day Administrator Liu was to be exiled to Rinan, Gongsun Zan sacrificed to his ancestors on Mount Beimang and prayed that, having now become another man's subject, he must go to Rinan and, fearing he might not return, was taking his leave of them; all who saw it sobbed. Administrator Liu was pardoned on the way and returned. Records, Wei 8 §2–3
He became a Gentleman as Filial and Incorrupt (xiaolian) and was appointed Chief Clerk of the Dependent State of Liaodong. While patrolling the frontier with several tens of horsemen, he encountered several hundred Xianbei horsemen, withdrew into an empty post-station (ting), and, saying that if they did not break through they would all die, charged out with a spear bladed at both ends, killing or wounding several tens of men. He lost half of the horsemen with him but got away, and afterwards the Xianbei no longer dared to enter the frontier. He was transferred to be Magistrate of Zhuo. Records, Wei 8 §3–4
In the Guanghe era, when bandits rose in Liang Province, he was put in command of 3,000 shock cavalry (tuji) of You Province. When his army reached Ji, Zhang Chun of Yuyang induced the Wuhuan leader Qiuliju and others to rebel, and for his merit in pursuing and suppressing them he became Cavalry Commandant. When the Wuhuan king Tanzhi came to surrender, he was promoted to General of the Household (zhonglang jiang) and enfeoffed as Marquis of a Chief Village (duting hou); stationed in the Dependent State, he fought the barbarians for five or six years but could not stop the raids of Qiuliju and the others. Records, Wei 8 §4–5
When the court made Liu Yu Governor of You Province, Qiuliju and the others came over to submit, but Gongsun Zan, jealous of Liu Yu gaining the merit, secretly had the barbarians' envoys killed. Liu Yu abolished the garrisons and left only Gongsun Zan, with 10,000 infantry and cavalry, stationed at Youbeiping. When Dong Zhuo reached Luoyang, Liu Yu became Grand Marshal, and Gongsun Zan became General of Vehement Might (fenwu jiangjun) and was enfeoffed as Marquis of Ji. Records, Wei 8 §7–8
When Liu Yu, having received a letter from his son Liu He, who was being held by Yuan Shu, was about to send several thousand horsemen, Gongsun Zan tried to stop him, saying that Yuan Shu harbored other intentions, but Liu Yu did not listen. Fearing Yuan Shu's resentment, Gongsun Zan sent his cousin Gongsun Yue to Yuan Shu with 1,000 horsemen, and secretly urged Yuan Shu to seize Liu He and take his troops. Because of this the rift between Liu Yu and Gongsun Zan grew wider. Records, Wei 8 §10–11
Gongsun Yue, sent by Yuan Shu, attacked Yuan Shao's commander Zhou Ang together with Sun Jian and was killed by an arrow. Saying, 'The calamity of my brother's death began with Yuan Shao,' Gongsun Zan stationed himself at the Pan River, and Yuan Shao, afraid, gave the seal and ribbon of Administrator of Bohai to Gongsun Zan's cousin Gongsun Fan. When Gongsun Fan helped him with the troops of Bohai and they defeated the Yellow Turbans of Qing and Xu provinces, his power grew even stronger and he advanced to Jieqiao. According to the Biography of Yuan Shao, Yuan Shao had Gao Gan and Xun Chen unsettle Han Fu by saying that Gongsun Zan was coming south on the strength of his victories, so that Han Fu handed over Ji Province. Records, Wei 8 §12Records, Wei 6 §40–41
Gongsun Zan installed Yan Gang, Tian Kai and Shan Jing as Inspectors of Ji, Qing and Yan provinces and set up commanderies and counties. When Liu Bei, defeated by bandits, came to him for refuge, he memorialized making him Major of a Separate Command (biebu sima) and had him resist Yuan Shao together with Tian Kai; Zhao Yun also followed Liu Bei at this time and took charge of his cavalry. Yuan Shao encamped at Guangchuan and sent Qu Yi forward as his vanguard, capturing Yan Gang alive, and Gongsun Zan's troops fled to Bohai. When he returned to Ji and built a small walled town southeast of the main city, he was close to Liu Yu, and they came to resent each other. Records, Wei 8 §13Records, Shu 2 §7Records, Shu 6 §39
Liu Yu raised troops and attacked him, but was defeated by Gongsun Zan and fled to Juyong; Gongsun Zan took Juyong and captured Liu Yu alive. When Dong Zhuo died, the Son of Heaven sent the envoy Duan Xun to have Liu Yu supervise six provinces and made Gongsun Zan General of the Front and Marquis of Yi. Gongsun Zan falsely accused Liu Yu of intending to claim the imperial title and coerced Duan Xun into beheading him; thereafter he grew arrogant, remembering others' faults and forgetting their good deeds, and harmed many people. According to the Biography of Tian Chou, he seized Tian Chou, who had wept at Liu Yu's grave, but, admiring his reply, released him. Records, Wei 8 §14Records, Wei 11 §38–39
Liu Yu's Attendant Officer Xianyu Fu and others put forward Yan Rou as Wuhuan Major and gathered several tens of thousands of barbarians and Han Chinese, and north of Lu they beheaded Zou Dan, the Administrator of Yuyang whom Gongsun Zan had installed. Yuan Shao also sent Qu Yi and Liu He to attack him together with them, and the Biography of the Wuhuan records that Tadun helped Yuan Shao defeat Gongsun Zan. After repeated defeats, Gongsun Zan withdrew to Yijing, surrounded it with ten rings of trenches and built towers on earthen mounds five or six zhang high; he himself lived on a central mound ten zhang high and stored three million hu of grain. Records, Wei 8 §15–16Records, Wei 30 §9
Gongsun Zan said that he had once thought the affairs of the realm could be settled with a mere wave of the finger, but now saw that they were not his to decide, and that he would hold out behind his thousand layers of towers until he had eaten all his grain. He meant by this to wear Yuan Shao down, and Yuan Shao could not take Yijing for several years. Records, Wei 8 §16–17
In the 4th year of Jian'an (199), when Yuan Shao surrounded Yijing with his whole army, Gongsun Zan sent his son to ask the Black Mountain bandits for help and intended to lead his shock cavalry out in person to cut Yuan Shao off from the rear. His Chief Clerk Guan Jing dissuaded him, saying that if he left his base Yijing would soon be in danger, and he gave up the plan. When the relief force came, he sent his son a letter arranging to signal by raising a fire, but Yuan Shao's scouts obtained the letter and raised the fire on the appointed day. Gongsun Zan went out to fight, was badly defeated by an ambush and returned to hold the fortress; when Yuan Shao dug tunnels, brought down the towers and reached the central mound, he knew he was sure to be defeated, killed his wife and children and then killed himself. Records, Wei 8 §18–20
In his assessment, Chen Shou said that Gongsun Zan guarded Yijing and sat waiting for his destruction. He then wrote that he, together with Gongsun Du, Tao Qian, Zhang Yang and others, had all held provinces and commanderies as their strongholds yet did not even measure up to common men, so that there was truly nothing about them worth discussing. Records, Wei 8 §71
In the Romance
In Chapter 1 of the Romance, the fifteen-year-old Liu Bei studies under Zheng Xuan and Lu Zhi and becomes friends with Gongsun Zan and others. In Chapter 2 Gongsun Zan memorializes Liu Bei's past merits, recommends him as Major of a Separate Command (biebu sima), and has him serve as Magistrate of Pingyuan. Romance, Ch. 1 §16Romance, Ch. 2 §36
In Chapter 5 Gongsun Zan, Administrator of Beiping, marches with 15,000 picked troops as the fourteenth contingent of the lords against Dong Zhuo and meets Liu Bei at Pingyuan. Hearing that Guan Yu and Zhang Fei are a mounted archer and a foot archer, he sighs that this is 'burying heroes', takes the three men with him, and introduces Liu Bei's merits and lineage before Yuan Shao. At Hulao Pass he faces Lü Bu brandishing a lance but flees after a few bouts, and just as Lü Bu's halberd is about to reach his back, Zhang Fei charges in. Romance, Ch. 5 §8 · 10–12 · 30–31 · 48–49
In Chapter 7 Yuan Shao, following Feng Ji's plan, sends a letter proposing that they attack Ji Province together and divide it, and Gongsun Zan raises his army that very day. But Ji Province falls to Yuan Shao, and his younger brother Gongsun Yue, sent to ask for a share of the land, is killed by the arrows of a band claiming to be commanders of Chancellor Dong. In great anger, Gongsun Zan rebukes Yuan Shao at the Pan River bridge as having 'a wolf's heart and a dog's conduct', but, chased by Wen Chou, he tumbles down a slope and is rescued by Zhao Yun, who suddenly appears. Romance, Ch. 7 §2–3 · 7–13
The next day Gongsun Zan deploys his white-horse troops, as when he fought the Qiang he had picked white horses for his vanguard and been called the White Horse General, but when his vanguard commander Yan Gang is cut down by Qu Yi and his embroidered banner falls, he flees down from the bridge. Zhao Yun stabs Qu Yi to death and presses Yuan Shao hard, and Liu Bei, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei rush in and drive Yuan Shao back. When the Grand Tutor Ma Midi and the Minister Coachman Zhao Qi, sent by Dong Zhuo, deliver an edict, Gongsun Zan makes peace with Yuan Shao and recommends Liu Bei as Chancellor of Pingyuan. Parting from the departing Liu Bei, Zhao Yun laments that Gongsun Zan is no better than the likes of Yuan Shao. Romance, Ch. 7 §14–18 · 22–25
In Chapter 11, when Liu Bei comes to borrow troops to rescue Tao Qian of Xu Province, Gongsun Zan asks why he should exert himself for others when he has no quarrel with Cao Cao, yet lends him 2,000 cavalry and infantry and also allows Zhao Yun to go with him. Romance, Ch. 11 §22–23
Gongsun Zan's end is made known in Chapter 21 through Man Chong's report. He built the Yijing Tower, ten zhang high, and held it with 300,000 dan of grain stored up, but he would not rescue his besieged subordinates, saying that if he saved one man the soldiers after him would not fight to the death, so many surrendered. His letter asking Xudu for help and his letter to Zhang Yan were both seized by Yuan Shao, and when he went out to fight at the false fire signal Yuan Shao raised, he lost more than half of his men and horses. When Yuan Shao set fire beneath the tower through tunnels, he killed his wife and children and hanged himself, and his whole household perished in the flames. In Chapter 28 Zhao Yun tells Liu Bei that Gongsun Zan would not listen to others and burned himself to death. Romance, Ch. 21 §22–24Romance, Ch. 28 §56
Where the Romance differs
His tie to Liu Bei: In Chapter 2 of the Romance, Gongsun Zan memorializes Liu Bei's past merits and recommends him as Major of a Separate Command. In the Biography of Liu Bei in the Records, when Liu Bei, defeated by bandits, fled to Gongsun Zan for refuge, Gongsun Zan memorialized making him Major of a Separate Command and had him resist Yuan Shao together with Tian Kai. Romance, Ch. 2 §36Records, Shu 2 §7
The coalition against Dong Zhuo: In Chapter 5 of the Romance, Gongsun Zan, Administrator of Beiping, joins the coalition as the fourteenth contingent and fights Lü Bu at Hulao Pass. In the Annals of Emperor Wu in the Records, Gongsun Zan is not among those who raised troops in the 1st year of Chuping (190), and in the Biography of Gongsun Zan he receives the posts of General of Vehement Might and Marquis of Ji from Dong Zhuo at this time. Romance, Ch. 5 §8 · 48Records, Wei 1 §7Records, Wei 8 §8
Why he came to Ji Province: In Chapter 7 of the Romance, Yuan Shao lures Gongsun Zan with a letter proposing that they attack Ji Province together and divide it, and Gongsun Zan raises his army. In the Biography of Yuan Shao in the Records, Yuan Shao merely had Gao Gan and Xun Chen persuade Han Fu by saying that Gongsun Zan was coming south on the strength of his victories; Yuan Shao sent no letter to Gongsun Zan. Romance, Ch. 7 §2–3Records, Wei 6 §40–41
Gongsun Yue's death: In Chapter 7 of the Romance, Yuan Shao has men disguised as Dong Zhuo's soldiers shoot Gongsun Yue dead. In the Records, Gongsun Yue, sent by Yuan Shu, was killed by an arrow while attacking Yuan Shao's commander Zhou Ang together with Sun Jian, and Gongsun Zan sent out his army saying the calamity began with Yuan Shao. Romance, Ch. 7 §8–9Records, Wei 8 §12
The battle of Jieqiao: In Chapter 7 of the Romance, Yan Gang is cut down by Qu Yi, and Zhao Yun stabs Qu Yi to death while Liu Bei and his sworn brothers drive Yuan Shao back. In the Records, Qu Yi captured Yan Gang alive and Gongsun Zan's troops fled to Bohai. There is no record of Zhao Yun and Liu Bei saving Gongsun Zan in this battle. Romance, Ch. 7 §16–18 · 22Records, Wei 8 §13
The White Horse General and the peace envoys: The story of the White Horse General in Chapter 7 of the Romance, and that of Dong Zhuo sending Ma Midi and Zhao Qi to reconcile him with Yuan Shao, are not in the Biography of Gongsun Zan in the Records (Chen Shou's main text). Romance, Ch. 7 §14 · 24–25Records, Wei 8 §1–20
Liu Yu: In the Records, Gongsun Zan quarrelled with Liu Yu, Governor of You Province, captured him and coerced Duan Xun into beheading him. In the Romance, Liu Yu appears only in Chapter 2 as the man who attacks Zhang Chun and employs Liu Bei; there is no story of him quarrelling with Gongsun Zan or being killed by him. Records, Wei 8 §14Romance, Ch. 2 §35–36
The scale of Yijing: Chapter 21 of the Romance says that 300,000 dan of grain were stored in the Yijing Tower, ten zhang high. In the Records, earthen mounds five or six zhang high were built within ten rings of trenches, and the central mound, ten zhang high, held three million hu of grain. Romance, Ch. 21 §22Records, Wei 8 §16
The call for help: In Chapter 21 of the Romance, his letter asking Xudu for help and his letter to Zhang Yan are seized by Yuan Shao. In the Records, he sent his son to ask the Black Mountain bandits for help, and when the relief force came, his letter to his son fell into the hands of Yuan Shao's scouts. There was no request for help to Xudu. Romance, Ch. 21 §23Records, Wei 8 §18–20
His end: In Chapter 21 of the Romance, Gongsun Zan kills his wife and children and hangs himself, his whole household burns, and Yuan Shao sets fire beneath the tower through tunnels. In the Records, when Yuan Shao dug tunnels, brought down the towers and reached the central mound, Gongsun Zan killed his wife and children and then killed himself. Nothing is said of setting fire. Romance, Ch. 21 §24Records, Wei 8 §20
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
Abilities
The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.
- LEA6055−5
- STR7850−28
- INT3530−5
- POL3838±0
- CHA5550−5
- VIR2242+20
- ADP2525±0
- SCH4532−13
- DIP4038−2
- DIS3058+28
Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more
RJealous of Liu Yu's merit, killed his envoys, and by false accusation had Liu Yu beheadedWei 8 §7Wei 8 §14
NSpoke of upholding the Han house, but never rescued his besieged menCh. 21 §23Ch. 5 §12
6 similar abilities — show evidence
RDeceived by a false signal fire and defeated. Assessment: guarded Yijing and sat waiting for destructionWei 8 §20Wei 8 §71
NHis letters for help were intercepted, and he went out at a false signal and lost more than half his troopsCh. 21 §23Ch. 21 §24
RStored three million hu of grain, but grew arrogant and harmed many peopleWei 8 §16Wei 8 §14
NNo direct record — estimated from the record of storing 300,000 dan of grainCh. 21 §22
RAll wept when he saw off his former administrator, but later tens of thousands of barbarians and Han turned against himWei 8 §3Wei 8 §5Wei 8 §15
NZhao Yun came to him for refuge, but he did not rescue his men, so many surrenderedCh. 7 §13Ch. 21 §23
RSecretly played both sides with Yuan Shu. Assessment: sat waiting for destructionWei 8 §11Wei 8 §20Wei 8 §71
NWent out in person at Yijing, was defeated by an ambush, killed his wife and children and took his own lifeCh. 21 §24
Special — talents Records +10 · Romance +10
-
Horsemanship
RNSkilled +10 Charged on horseback to spear Xianbei horsemen, and was called the White Horse General for his white-horse vanguardWei 8 §3Ch. 7 §14
Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)
3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.
Romance chapters (11)
AppearsNot present Chapter list →
Allegiance history
- Gongsun Zan faction · Records
Relations
- Gongsun Zan faction Led by · Records
Family
| Siblings | Gongsun Yue Romance |
|---|---|
| Relatives | Gongsun Yue Records |
Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.
Related events (5)
- Battle of Yijing 199 · Command
- Battle of Jieqiao · Command
- Three Heroes Fight Lü Bu · Appears (Romance scene)
- Battle of Hulao Pass · Command
- Yuan Shao Battles Gongsun Zan at the Pan River Romance ch. 7 · Appears (Romance scene)
Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).
Related works (1)
Linked via Wikidata "depicts" and character names in titles (unverified) — not yet reviewed.