Sun Jian 孫堅
| Occupation | RGeneral · General Who Smashes the Caitiffs NGeneral · Administrator of Changsha | Faction | Sun Jian faction |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appears | RN | Biography in | Book of Wu |
| Born | R? Unverified | Native place | Wu Commandery Fuchun County |
| Died | R192 Unverified | Place of death | RNMount Xian |
| Cause of death | RKilled in battle NKilled in battle Unverified | ||
| Existence | Historical | Mentions | R54 |
Profile
Sun Jian, courtesy name Wentai, was a native of Fuchun in Wu Commandery. He made his name fighting pirates, sorcerer-rebels and the Yellow Turbans, and as Administrator of Changsha he pacified the bandits and was enfeoffed as Marquis of Wucheng. Records, Wu 1 §2–7 · 11–12
He joined the loyalist forces against Dong Zhuo and, on Yuan Shu's memorial, became acting General Who Smashes the Caitiffs (polu jiangjun) and Inspector of Yu Province; he defeated Dong Zhuo's army at Yangren, entered Luoyang and filled in the tombs that had been dug up. In the 3rd year of Chuping (192), attacking Liu Biao on Yuan Shu's orders, he besieged Xiangyang and was killed on Mount Xian by an arrow shot by Huang Zu's soldiers. He was the father of Sun Ce and Sun Quan, and after Sun Quan proclaimed himself emperor he was posthumously honored as Emperor Wulie. Records, Wu 1 §15 · 17 · 20–22
In his assessment, Chen Shou, author of the Records, wrote that he was brave and resolute and rose from a lonely and humble station with a loyal and heroic spirit, but that he was rash and hasty and lost his life. In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 2 as a commander fighting the Yellow Turbans and appears in 9 of its 120 chapters, and his name is in the titles of Chapter 6, 'Hiding the Jade Seal, Sun Jian Breaks the Covenant', and Chapter 7, 'Sun Jian Crosses the River to Attack Liu Biao'. Records, Wu 1 §41Romance, Ch. 2 §14Romance, Ch. 6 §24Romance, Ch. 7 §31
In the Records
Sun Jian was a native of Fuchun in Wu Commandery, and Chen Shou wrote that he was probably a descendant of Sun Wu. In his youth he became a county clerk. At seventeen he was travelling by boat with his father to Qiantang when the pirate Hu Yu and others, having plundered the goods of merchants, were dividing them on the riverbank. Sun Jian took up a sword, went ashore and, pointing east and west with his hand, made as if he were deploying troops to surround the bandits. The bandits, thinking government soldiers had come to arrest them, abandoned the goods and scattered, and Sun Jian pursued them and came back with one head. This made his name known, and the commandery office made him Acting Commandant (jiawei, a provisional county commandant). Records, Wu 1 §2–4
In the 1st year of Xiping (172) the sorcerer-rebel Xu Chang of Kuaiji rose at Juzhang, styled himself Emperor Yangming and, together with his son Xu Shao, stirred up the counties, gathering followers by the ten thousand. As Commandery Major, Sun Jian recruited more than a thousand brave and bold men and crushed them together with the troops of the province and commandery. When the Inspector Zang Min reported his merit, an edict made him Assistant Magistrate of Yandu; some years later he was transferred to be Assistant Magistrate of Xuyi, and then of Xiapi. Records, Wu 1 §4–5
In the 1st year of Zhongping (184), when Zhang Jue's Yellow Turbans rose, the Han court sent Huangfu Song and Zhu Jun to suppress them. When Zhu Jun memorialized requesting Sun Jian as his Assistant Army Major, Sun Jian gathered more than a thousand men, including young men of his home district, merchants and picked soldiers from the Huai and Si region. When the bandits of Runan and Yingchuan fled to hold Wancheng, Sun Jian personally took charge of one side, was first to scale the wall and enter, and inflicted a great defeat on them. Zhu Jun reported this, and Sun Jian was made Major of a Separate Command (biebu sima). Records, Wu 1 §6–7
In the 3rd year of Zhongping (186), when the Minister of Works Zhang Wen, as acting General of Chariots and Cavalry, set out west against Bian Zhang and Han Sui, he requested Sun Jian as his Military Adviser (canjunshi), and they were stationed at Chang'an. When Dong Zhuo, summoned by Zhang Wen with an edict, arrived only after a long delay and answered him disrespectfully, Sun Jian whispered to Zhang Wen, listing Dong Zhuo's three crimes, and urged him to behead Dong Zhuo under military law, but Zhang Wen, saying that Dong Zhuo had great prestige between Longxi and Shu, could not bring himself to do it. After Bian Zhang and Han Sui surrendered and the army returned, all who heard of these words sighed. Sun Jian was made a Consultant (yilang). Records, Wu 1 §8–11
When the Changsha bandit Ou Xing, calling himself a general, besieged towns with more than ten thousand men, the court made Sun Jian Administrator of Changsha. Sun Jian personally led his officers and men and defeated Ou Xing and the others in little more than a month, and when Zhou Chao and Guo Shi rose in response in Lingling and Guiyang, he crossed the border to pursue and attack them too, so that the three commanderies were quieted. The Han court recorded his merits before and after and enfeoffed him as Marquis of Wucheng. Records, Wu 1 §11–12
When Emperor Ling died and Dong Zhuo seized control of the government, the provinces and commanderies raised loyalist troops, and Sun Jian also raised an army. On the way he killed Wang Rui, Inspector of Jing Province, who had always treated him rudely, and by the time he reached Nanyang his host numbered several tens of thousands. When Zhang Zi, Administrator of Nanyang, failed to provide military supplies, Sun Jian, as Zhang Zi came to return his hospitality at a banquet, beheaded him at the gate of the camp for the crime of delaying the loyalist army. Records, Wu 1 §13–14
When he met Yuan Shu at Luyang, Yuan Shu memorialized making Sun Jian acting General Who Smashes the Caitiffs (polu jiangjun) and concurrently Inspector of Yu Province. While Sun Jian was holding a farewell banquet outside the walls of Luyang for his Chief Clerk Gongqiu Cheng, several tens of light horsemen, the vanguard of the tens of thousands of infantry and cavalry sent by Dong Zhuo, suddenly arrived. Sun Jian went on passing the wine and chatting while ordering his retainers to put their ranks in order, and when more horsemen came, he calmly ended the banquet and led everyone into the city. Seeing how orderly Sun Jian's troops were, Dong Zhuo's soldiers did not dare to attack the city and withdrew. Records, Wu 1 §15–16
When Sun Jian, stationed east of Liang, came under heavy attack from Dong Zhuo's army, he put the red woolen headcloth he always wore on his close commander Zu Mao and broke out of the encirclement with several tens of horsemen. While Dong Zhuo's cavalry chased Zu Mao, Sun Jian escaped by a side road, and Zu Mao placed the headcloth on a burnt pillar among the graves and hid in the grass. Sun Jian gathered his soldiers again, fought at Yangren and inflicted a great defeat on Dong Zhuo's army, beheading its Area Commander Hua Xiong and others and displaying their heads. Records, Wu 1 §16–17
At this time someone sowed discord between Sun Jian and Yuan Shu, and Yuan Shu, growing suspicious, did not send provisions. Sun Jian galloped by night to Luyang, more than a hundred li away, and, drawing on the ground as he spoke, argued that he risked his life without regard for himself in order to punish the rebels for the state above and to avenge the private enmity of the general's family below, and that he himself had no blood feud with Dong Zhuo. Yuan Shu, greatly embarrassed, sent provisions at once. Records, Wu 1 §18
Dong Zhuo, fearing Sun Jian's valor, sent Li Jue and others to seek peace and a marriage alliance, saying that if Sun Jian listed those of his sons and younger kinsmen fit to serve as inspectors or administrators, he would appoint them. Sun Jian refused, saying that if he could not exterminate Dong Zhuo's three sets of kin and display them to all within the four seas, he would not close his eyes even in death, and advanced to Dagu, ninety li from Luoyang. When Dong Zhuo moved the capital west into Guanzhong and burned Luoyang, Sun Jian entered Luoyang, repaired the imperial tombs, filled in the places Dong Zhuo had dug up, and returned to Luyang. Records, Wu 1 §19–20
In the 3rd year of Chuping (192) Yuan Shu had Sun Jian campaign in Jing Province against Liu Biao. He defeated Huang Zu, sent by Liu Biao, between Fan and Deng, crossed the Han River and besieged Xiangyang, but while riding alone past Mount Xian he was killed by an arrow shot by Huang Zu's soldiers. The Biography of Liu Biao records that Sun Jian was killed by a stray arrow and his army was defeated, so that Yuan Shu never overcame Liu Biao. His elder brother's son Sun Ben led the officers and men to join Yuan Shu. Records, Wu 1 §21Records, Wei 6 §83
Sun Jian had four sons born of his wife, Lady Wu: Sun Ce, Sun Quan, Sun Yi and Sun Kuang. After Sun Quan proclaimed himself emperor, he gave Sun Jian the posthumous title Emperor Wulie. Records, Wu 5 §2Records, Wu 1 §22
In his assessment, Chen Shou said that Sun Jian was brave, resolute, upright and steadfast and raised himself from a lonely and humble station, and that in leading Zhang Wen to kill Dong Zhuo and in filling and closing the imperial tombs he showed a loyal and heroic spirit. But he wrote that he and Sun Ce were both rash and hasty, so that they lost their lives and came to failure. Records, Wu 1 §41
In the Romance
In Chapter 2 of the Romance, Sun Jian appears with his troops from due east when Zhu Jun attacks Wancheng, and is introduced as a descendant of Sun Wuzi with a broad forehead and wide face, a tiger's body and a bear's waist. After recounting how he beheaded the pirates of Qiantang and Xu Chang and his son Xu Shao, the chapter has him arrive leading more than 1,500 young men of his home district and picked soldiers of the Huai and Si region; he is first to scale the south gate's wall, cuts down over twenty bandits, and seizes the spear of the charging Zhao Hong and stabs him from his horse. At the end of the same chapter, when the Ten Regular Attendants use a false edict to make him Administrator of Changsha and send him against Ou Xing, he wins in under fifty days and is enfeoffed as Marquis of Wucheng. Romance, Ch. 2 §14–17 · 34
In Chapter 5 he joins the campaign against Dong Zhuo as the sixteenth contingent, the Marquis of Wucheng and Administrator of Changsha, volunteers for the vanguard, and, leading the four commanders Cheng Pu, Huang Gai, Han Dang and Zu Mao, stands before Sishui Pass in silver armor with a red headcloth, holding the Guding saber. When Yuan Shu, hearing that he must not nurture 'the fierce tiger of Jiangdong', withholds provisions, the camp falls into disorder, and Sun Jian is routed by Hua Xiong's night raid and flees. Zu Mao puts on Sun Jian's red headcloth in his place to draw off the enemy and is killed by Hua Xiong's blade. Romance, Ch. 5 §9 · 17 · 22–28
In Chapter 6 Sun Jian goes to Yuan Shu's camp and, drawing lines on the ground with a staff, reproaches him for cutting off the provisions, and he rebukes and sends back Dong Zhuo's envoy Li Jue, who offers to match Dong Zhuo's daughter with Sun Jian's son. Entering Luoyang first, he puts out the fires and covers the tombs that had been dug up, and then, in a well south of the Jianzhang Hall, obtains the Imperial Seal of State from a brocade pouch hung at the neck of the corpse of a woman in palace dress. When, on Cheng Pu's advice, he tries to return to Jiangdong on the pretext of illness, Yuan Shao demands the seal, and Sun Jian, pointing to heaven, swears that if he has hidden it for himself may he die under sword and arrow, and departs. Liu Biao, having received Yuan Shao's letter, blocks the road and surrounds Sun Jian. Romance, Ch. 6 §1–2 · 13 · 22–24 · 27–31 · 36–38
In Chapter 7 Sun Jian, who returns to Jiangdong after Cheng Pu, Huang Gai and Han Dang rescue him at the risk of their lives, becomes Liu Biao's enemy. When a letter from Yuan Shu arrives, his younger brother Sun Jing urges him not to raise a great army over a petty grudge, but Sun Jian, asking whether a man who would range across the realm would leave an enemy unpunished, sets sail with his eldest son Sun Ce. Having his men lie low in the boats until the enemy has spent its arrows, he shoots back the more than a hundred thousand arrows lodged in them and defeats Huang Zu, drives off Cai Mao, who is encamped on Mount Xian, and besieges Xiangyang. When a fierce wind snaps the flagstaff of the central army, Han Dang urges him to withdraw, but he does not listen. Romance, Ch. 7 §1 · 26–28 · 30–33 · 37–39
When, by Kuai Liang's plan, Lü Gong breaks through the siege and flees to Mount Xian, Sun Jian, without even summoning his commanders, pursues him with only thirty-odd horsemen and rides alone ahead into a mountain path. Rocks pour down from the mountain and arrows fly from the woods, and Sun Jian, his skull shattered, dies on Mount Xian together with his horse. The Romance gives his age as thirty-seven. In Chapter 8 Sun Ce returns Huang Zu, whom Huang Gai had captured, receives his father's coffin and buries him on the plain of Qu'e, while Dong Zhuo, hearing that Sun Jian is dead, says that one of the worries in his heart has been removed. Romance, Ch. 7 §39–43 · 45Romance, Ch. 8 §1–3
After this, Sun Jian is only mentioned in the story. In Chapter 15 Sun Ce leaves the seal his father left him with Yuan Shu in exchange for troops, and in Chapter 98 Sun Quan, having ascended the throne, posthumously honors his father Sun Jian as Emperor Wulie. Romance, Ch. 15 §14–15Romance, Ch. 98 §27
Where the Romance differs
The battle of Wancheng: In Chapter 2 of the Romance, Sun Jian is first to scale the wall, cuts down bandits, and seizes Zhao Hong's spear and stabs him to death. The Records only say that Sun Jian personally took charge of one side, was first to scale the wall and enter, and inflicted a great defeat; no bandit commander named Zhao Hong appears. Romance, Ch. 2 §17Records, Wu 1 §7
Dong Zhuo's three crimes: In the Records, Sun Jian, as Zhang Wen's Military Adviser, urged him to behead Dong Zhuo, and Chen Shou in his assessment singled this out as a mark of his spirit. Chapter 2 of the Romance moves straight from the Yellow Turban campaign to his appointment as Administrator of Changsha, and this episode is absent. Romance, Ch. 2 §18 · 34Records, Wu 1 §8–11 · 41
Administrator of Changsha and Marquis of Wucheng: In Chapter 2 of the Romance, the Ten Regular Attendants make Sun Jian Administrator of Changsha with a false edict, and after he wins in under fifty days and Jiangxia is pacified, he is enfeoffed as Marquis of Wucheng. In the Records, he went from Consultant to Administrator of Changsha, defeated Ou Xing in little more than a month, went on to attack Zhou Chao and Guo Shi of Lingling and Guiyang, and was enfeoffed as Marquis of Wucheng for his merits before and after. Romance, Ch. 2 §34Records, Wu 1 §11–12
Wang Rui and Zhang Zi: In the Records, on raising his army, Sun Jian kills Wang Rui, Inspector of Jing Province, and beheads Zhang Zi, Administrator of Nanyang, at the gate of his camp. In Chapter 5 of the Romance, Sun Jian simply joins the coalition of lords as the sixteenth contingent, as Administrator of Changsha, and the killing of these two men does not appear. Romance, Ch. 5 §9Records, Wu 1 §13–14
Hua Xiong: In Chapter 5 of the Romance, Sun Jian is routed by Hua Xiong's night raid and flees, and Hua Xiong later dies at Guan Yu's hand. In the Records, Sun Jian inflicted a great defeat on Dong Zhuo's army at Yangren and beheaded its Area Commander Hua Xiong and others, displaying their heads. Romance, Ch. 5 §26–27 · 36Records, Wu 1 §17
Zu Mao: In Chapter 5 of the Romance, Zu Mao puts on Sun Jian's red headcloth to draw off the enemy and is killed by Hua Xiong. In the Records, Zu Mao placed the headcloth on a burnt pillar and hid in the grass, and Dong Zhuo's cavalry, realizing it was a pillar, left. Nothing is said of Zu Mao dying. Romance, Ch. 5 §28Records, Wu 1 §17
When the provisions were cut off: In Chapter 5 of the Romance, Sun Jian is defeated by Hua Xiong because Yuan Shu has cut off his provisions, and in Chapter 6 Yuan Shu beheads the slanderer by way of apology. In the Records, it was after the victory at Yangren that Yuan Shu, listening to divisive words, stopped sending provisions, and when Sun Jian galloped to him by night to remonstrate, he sent them at once. Romance, Ch. 5 §25Romance, Ch. 6 §1Records, Wu 1 §17–18
Dong Zhuo's peace offer: In Chapter 6 of the Romance, Li Jue offers to match Dong Zhuo's daughter with Sun Jian's son. In the Records, the condition Dong Zhuo put forward was that if Sun Jian listed those of his sons and younger kinsmen fit to serve as inspectors or administrators, he would memorialize their appointment. Romance, Ch. 6 §2Records, Wu 1 §19
The seal: In Chapter 6 of the Romance, Sun Jian obtains the Imperial Seal of State from a well in Luoyang and, after quarrelling with Yuan Shao, finds his road blocked by Liu Biao. The biography of Sun Jian in Chen Shou's main text says only that he entered Luoyang, repaired and filled in the tombs, and returned to Luyang; the seal does not appear. Romance, Ch. 6 §24 · 36–38Records, Wu 1 §1–22
Why he attacked Liu Biao: In Chapter 7 of the Romance, Sun Jian sets out to take revenge on Liu Biao, who had blocked his way home over the seal. In the Records, Yuan Shu had Sun Jian campaign in Jing Province against Liu Biao, and the Biography of Liu Biao records that Yuan Shu joined with Sun Jian in trying to seize Liu Biao's province. Romance, Ch. 7 §27–28Records, Wu 1 §21Records, Wei 6 §83
Death: In Chapter 7 of the Romance, Sun Jian dies at thirty-seven, struck by the rocks and arrows of Lü Gong's ambush, and Sun Ce returns Huang Zu to recover his father's body. In the Records, he was killed by an arrow shot by Huang Zu's soldiers while riding alone past Mount Xian, and his elder brother's son Sun Ben led his followers to join Yuan Shu. Lü Gong's ambush, the exchange for the body and his age are not in Chen Shou's main text. Romance, Ch. 7 §43Romance, Ch. 8 §1–2Records, Wu 1 §21
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
Abilities
The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.
- LEA8480−4
- STR8580−5
- INT6055−5
- POL4242±0
- CHA7270−2
- VIR7250−22
- ADP3228−4
- SCH3131±0
- DIP5850−8
- DIS4245+3
Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more
9 similar abilities — show evidence
Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)
3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.
Romance chapters (9)
AppearsNot present Chapter list →
Allegiance history
- Sun Jian faction · Records
Relations
- Sun Jian faction Led by · Records
Family
| Spouse | Lady Wu (Sun Jian) Novel & History, Dowager Wu Romance |
|---|---|
| Siblings | Sun Jing Novel & History |
| Children | Sun Ce Novel & History, Sun Quan Novel & History, Sun Yi(孫翊) Novel & History, Sun Kuang Novel & History, Lady Sun Novel & History |
| Relatives | Sun He(孫河) Records, Sun Jun Records |
Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.
Related events (7)
- Yellow Turban Rebellion 184 · Command
- Campaign against Dong Zhuo 190~191 · Command
- Battle of Xiangyang 192 · Command
- Battle of Yangcheng · Command
- Battle of Sishui Pass · Command
- Battle of Luyang · Command
- Liang Province rebellion · Command
Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).
Items owned or made (2)
- Gudingdao · Weapon · 190~ · Romance
- Heirloom Seal of the Realm · Treasure · 191~192 · Novel & History Disputed
Ownership and authorship assigned by 3KDEX from source sentences — not yet reviewed (unverified).