Precursor

Sun Jian faction 孫堅

Also known as: 孫堅勢力

About this faction

This faction was a warlord force that grew out of the army Sun Jian, Administrator of Changsha, raised to attack Dong Zhuo. When Emperor Ling died and Dong Zhuo seized control of the government, Sun Jian raised loyalist troops in Changsha, and by the time he reached Nanyang his host numbered several tens of thousands. Meeting Yuan Shu at Luyang, he became, on Yuan Shu's memorial, acting General Who Smashes the Caitiffs (polu jiangjun) and Inspector of Yu Province; after inflicting a great defeat on Dong Zhuo's army at Yangren, he entered Luoyang and repaired the imperial tombs. Records, Wu 1 §13 · 15 · 17 · 20Records, Wu 6 §25

In the 3rd year of Chuping (192), when Sun Jian, attacking Liu Biao in Jing Province on Yuan Shu's orders, was killed by an arrow on Mount Xian while besieging Xiangyang, his elder brother's son Sun Ben led the officers, men and followers to join Yuan Shu. In the 1st year of Xingping (194) Yuan Shu returned Sun Jian's retainers to his son Sun Ce, and what followed continues as the Sun Ce faction. Records, Wu 1 §21 · 25

Chen Shou recorded this faction in the biography of Sun Jian in the Biographies of Sun Jian and Sun Ce, Records of Wu 1. The Romance first brings Sun Jian onstage in Chapter 2 with Zhu Jun's army fighting the Yellow Turbans, lists him in Chapter 5 as the sixteenth contingent, the Marquis of Wucheng and Administrator of Changsha, among the lords gathered to attack Dong Zhuo, and depicts his death on Mount Xian in Chapter 7. Records, Wu 1 §1Romance, Ch. 2 §14Romance, Ch. 5 §9Romance, Ch. 7 §43

Rise and fall in the Records

The foundation of the faction was the troops Sun Jian commanded as an official of the Han. In the 1st year of Zhongping (184), when the Yellow Turbans rose, Sun Jian became Assistant Army Major on the memorial of Zhu Jun, General of the Household, and gathered a thousand or so men, including young men of his home district who had followed him at Xiapi, merchants and travellers, and picked soldiers from the Huai and Si region; when Wancheng was attacked he was first to scale the wall, and became Major of a Separate Command. Later, as Administrator of Changsha, he defeated the bandit Ou Xing in little more than a month, and crossing the border he also attacked Zhou Chao and Guo Shi, who had risen in response in Lingling and Guiyang, bringing quiet to the three commanderies; for his merits before and after he was enfeoffed as Marquis of Wucheng. Records, Wu 1 §6–7 · 11–12

From this time those who followed him became the backbone of the faction. Cheng Pu of Youbeiping followed Sun Jian in attacking the Yellow Turbans at Wan and Deng and in defeating Dong Zhuo at Yangren; Huang Gai of Lingling joined Sun Jian when he raised his loyalist troops; and Han Dang of Liaoxi won favor for his archery and horsemanship and became Major of a Separate Command. Zhu Zhi of Danyang became a Major in the 5th year of Zhongping (188) and joined in attacking the bandits of the three commanderies. Wu Jing, younger brother of Sun Jian's wife Lady Wu, also constantly followed his campaigns and won merit; his elder brother's son Sun Ben left his post to follow Sun Jian when he raised loyalist troops at Changsha; and his youngest brother Sun Jing gathered men of the district and five or six hundred members of the clan as a defense force. Records, Wu 10 §2 · 8 · 16Records, Wu 11 §2Records, Wu 5 §2–3Records, Wu 6 §25 · 2

When Emperor Ling died and Dong Zhuo seized control of the government, the provinces and commanderies raised loyalist troops, and Sun Jian too raised an army. On the way he killed Wang Rui, Inspector of Jing Province, who had always treated him rudely, and by the time he reached Nanyang his host numbered several tens of thousands. When Zhang Zi, Administrator of Nanyang, neither repaired the roads nor provided military supplies, Sun Jian beheaded him at the gate of his camp for the crime of delaying the loyalist army, and the whole commandery trembled, so that nothing he asked for was withheld. The Biography of Yuan Shu records that it was because Sun Jian killed Zhang Zi that Yuan Shu was able to take Nanyang Commandery. Records, Wu 1 §13–14Records, Wei 6 §72

Sun Jian met Yuan Shu at Luyang, and Yuan Shu memorialized making him acting General Who Smashes the Caitiffs and concurrently Inspector of Yu Province. Sun Jian put his troops in order at the city of Luyang and sent his Chief Clerk Gongqiu Cheng back to the province to press for provisions. While Sun Jian was seeing Gongqiu Cheng off outside the east gate of the city, several tens of light horsemen, the vanguard of the tens of thousands of infantry and cavalry sent by Dong Zhuo, arrived first, but Sun Jian told his retainers to keep their ranks in order and not move, then calmly ended the gathering and went into the city. Dong Zhuo's soldiers, seeing how orderly his troops were, did not dare attack the city and withdrew. Records, Wu 1 §15–16

Having moved to camp east of Liang, Sun Jian came under heavy attack from Dong Zhuo's army and broke out of the encirclement with several tens of horsemen, while his close commander Zu Mao put on his red woolen headcloth and drew off Dong Zhuo's cavalry. Sun Jian gathered his troops again, fought at Yangren and inflicted a great defeat on Dong Zhuo's army, beheading its Area Commander Hua Xiong and others and displaying their heads. According to the Biography of Gongsun Zan, Yuan Shu stationed Sun Jian at Yangcheng to hold off Dong Zhuo, but Yuan Shao had Zhou Ang seize that position, and Gongsun Yue, sent by Yuan Shu, attacked Zhou Ang together with Sun Jian without success. Records, Wu 1 §16–17Records, Wei 8 §12

When someone slandered Sun Jian, Yuan Shu grew suspicious and did not send provisions. Sun Jian galloped by night to Luyang, more than a hundred li from Yangren, and argued that he risked his life without regard for himself in order to punish the rebels for the state above and to avenge the private enmity of the general's family below, and Yuan Shu at once sent the provisions. Dong Zhuo sent his general Li Jue and others to seek peace, offering to employ Sun Jian's sons and younger kinsmen as inspectors and administrators, but Sun Jian refused and advanced to Dagu, ninety li from Luoyang. When Dong Zhuo moved the capital west into Guanzhong and burned Luoyang, Sun Jian entered Luoyang, repaired the imperial tombs and filled in the places that had been dug up, and then returned to stay at Luyang. Records, Wu 1 §18–20

While in Nanyang, Yuan Shu allied with Sun Jian, intending to seize Liu Biao's province. In the 3rd year of Chuping (192) Sun Jian, setting out on Yuan Shu's orders to attack Jing Province, defeated Huang Zu, sent by Liu Biao, between Fan and Deng, crossed the Han River and besieged Xiangyang, but while riding alone past Mount Xian he was killed by an arrow shot by Huang Zu's soldiers. The Biography of Liu Biao records that Sun Jian was killed by a stray arrow and his army was defeated, so that Yuan Shu never overcame Liu Biao. Records, Wei 6 §83Records, Wu 1 §21

Sun Ben gathered the remaining followers, escorted the coffin, and then led the officers, men and followers to join Yuan Shu, who again memorialized making him Inspector of Yu Province. Sun Jian's son Sun Ce, who had moved with his mother to live at Shu County when Sun Jian raised his loyalist troops, buried his father at Qu'e, and when he joined Yuan Shu in the 1st year of Xingping (194), Yuan Shu, thinking him remarkable, returned Sun Jian's retainers to him. Zhu Zhi helped Sun Ce and went with him to rely on Yuan Shu, and Cheng Pu and Huang Gai also followed Sun Ce after Sun Jian's death. After Sun Quan proclaimed himself emperor, he gave Sun Jian the posthumous title Emperor Wulie. Records, Wu 1 §21–22 · 24–25Records, Wu 6 §25Records, Wu 11 §3Records, Wu 10 §3 · 8

In his assessment Chen Shou said that Sun Jian was brave, resolute, upright and steadfast, rose from a lonely and humble station, urged Zhang Wen to execute Dong Zhuo and filled and closed the imperial tombs, and so had a loyal and heroic spirit. But he wrote that he and Sun Ce were both rash and hasty, so that they lost their lives and came to failure. Records, Wu 1 §41

In the Romance

In Chapter 5 of the Romance, among the lords who gather in answer to Cao Cao's call to arms, Sun Jian is listed as the sixteenth contingent, the Marquis of Wucheng and Administrator of Changsha. After Yuan Shao becomes leader of the alliance, Sun Jian volunteers for the vanguard and arrives before Sishui Pass leading four commanders, Cheng Pu, Huang Gai, Han Dang and Zu Mao. When Cheng Pu spears Hua Xiong's lieutenant Hu Zhen from his horse, Sun Jian charges up to the pass, then returns to camp east of Liang, reports the victory to Yuan Shao and presses Yuan Shu for provisions. Romance, Ch. 5 §9 · 17 · 22–24

But Yuan Shu, told that Sun Jian is the fierce tiger of Jiangdong and that withholding provisions will make his army scatter, sends him neither grain nor fodder. Hua Xiong makes a night raid on Sun Jian's camp, thrown into disorder by the lack of food, and Sun Jian, fleeing with a broken bow, exchanges his red headcloth for Zu Mao's helmet. Zu Mao hangs the headcloth on a half-burnt pillar and hides in the woods, then rushes out and is killed by Hua Xiong's blade. Romance, Ch. 5 §25–28

In Chapter 6 Sun Jian goes to Yuan Shu's camp and, drawing lines on the ground, reproaches him for cutting off the provisions, and he rebukes and sends back Dong Zhuo's general Li Jue, who has come to propose a marriage alliance. Arriving first in burning Luoyang, Sun Jian puts out the fires and covers over the tombs Dong Zhuo had dug up, and obtains the Imperial Seal of State from a brocade pouch hung at the neck of a woman in palace dress, drawn up from a well south of a palace hall. Cheng Pu tells him it is a gift from Heaven and urges him to return quickly to Jiangdong. Romance, Ch. 6 §1–3 · 13 · 22–27

When Sun Jian says that he will return to Changsha on the pretext of illness, Yuan Shao demands the seal; Sun Jian swears that if he has secretly hidden it he will die under sword and arrow, and after commanders on both sides draw their swords, he leaves Luoyang. Liu Biao, Inspector of Jing Province, on receiving a letter from Yuan Shao, sends Kuai Yue and Cai Mao to block his road and comes out leading troops himself, and at the start of Chapter 7 Sun Jian barely escapes through the hard fighting of Cheng Pu, Huang Gai and Han Dang, losing more than half his troops before returning to Jiangdong. From this time Sun Jian and Liu Biao are enemies. Romance, Ch. 6 §28–31 · 36–38Romance, Ch. 7 §1

In Chapter 7, when Yuan Shu urges him by letter to attack Liu Biao, Sun Jian raises troops, saying that he will avenge himself without relying on Yuan Shu's help. Ignoring the objections of his younger brother Sun Jing, he takes ship with his eldest son Sun Ce, defeats Huang Zu after making him use up his arrows, drives off Cai Mao, who is encamped on Mount Xian, and surrounds Xiangyang. When a violent wind snaps the pole of the central army's banner bearing the character 'commander', Han Dang urges him to turn back, but Sun Jian does not listen. Romance, Ch. 7 §26–28 · 30–33 · 37–39

When Lü Gong breaks through the siege by Kuai Liang's plan, Sun Jian, without even summoning his commanders, pursues him with only thirty-odd horsemen, rides alone into a mountain path, and dies struck by rocks and arrows. His body is carried into the city by Liu Biao's soldiers. In Chapter 8 Sun Ce returns Huang Zu, captured by Huang Gai, receives his father's coffin and buries him on the plain of Qu'e, then leads his troops to stay at Jiangdu, inviting worthy men and receiving scholars. Romance, Ch. 7 §40–45Romance, Ch. 8 §2

Where the Romance differs

Raising troops: In Chapter 5 of the Romance, Sun Jian is merely named as the sixteenth contingent, the Administrator of Changsha, among the lords who answered Cao Cao's call to arms. In the Records, Sun Jian raised troops at Changsha, killed Wang Rui, Inspector of Jing Province, on the way, beheaded Zhang Zi, Administrator of Nanyang, at the gate of his camp, and, meeting Yuan Shu at Luyang, became acting General Who Smashes the Caitiffs and Inspector of Yu Province on his memorial. Romance, Ch. 5 §9Records, Wu 6 §25Records, Wu 1 §13–15

When the provisions were cut off: In Chapter 5 of the Romance, Yuan Shu does not send provisions, and Sun Jian's starving troops collapse under Hua Xiong's night raid. In the Records, it was after Sun Jian had inflicted a great defeat on Dong Zhuo's army at Yangren that Yuan Shu, listening to divisive words, stopped sending provisions, and when Sun Jian galloped by night to Luyang to remonstrate, he sent them at once. Romance, Ch. 5 §25–26Records, Wu 1 §17–18

Hua Xiong: In Chapter 5 of the Romance, Sun Jian is defeated by Hua Xiong and flees, and it is Guan Yu who brings back Hua Xiong's head. In the Records, Sun Jian defeated Dong Zhuo's army at Yangren and beheaded its Area Commander Hua Xiong and others, displaying their heads. Romance, Ch. 5 §26–27 · 36Records, Wu 1 §17

Zu Mao: In Chapter 5 of the Romance, Zu Mao hangs Sun Jian's red headcloth on a pillar, then rushes out and is cut down by Hua Xiong. In the Records, Zu Mao placed the headcloth on a burnt pillar and lay hidden in the grass, and Dong Zhuo's cavalry, realizing it was a pillar, left. Romance, Ch. 5 §28Records, Wu 1 §17

Dong Zhuo's peace offer: In Chapter 6 of the Romance, Li Jue says that Dong Zhuo wishes to form a marriage alliance with Sun Jian. In the Records, the condition Dong Zhuo put forward through Li Jue and others was that if Sun Jian listed those of his sons and younger kinsmen fit to serve as inspectors or administrators, he would memorialize their appointment. Romance, Ch. 6 §2Records, Wu 1 §19

The seal: In Chapter 6 of the Romance, Sun Jian obtains the Imperial Seal of State from a well in Luoyang and, after quarrelling with Yuan Shao over it, finds his road home blocked by Liu Biao. The biography of Sun Jian in Chen Shou's main text says only that he entered Luoyang, repaired and filled in the tombs, and returned to Luyang; the seal does not appear. Romance, Ch. 6 §24 · 29–31Records, Wu 1 §1–22

Why he attacked Liu Biao: In Chapter 7 of the Romance, Sun Jian sets out to take revenge himself on Liu Biao, who had earlier cut off his road home. In the Records, Yuan Shu had Sun Jian campaign in Jing Province against Liu Biao, and the Biography of Liu Biao records that Yuan Shu allied with Sun Jian intending to seize Liu Biao's province. Romance, Ch. 7 §27–28Records, Wu 1 §21Records, Wei 6 §83

Sun Jian's death: In Chapter 7 of the Romance, Sun Jian, pursuing Lü Gong, dies struck by rocks from the mountain and arrows from the woods. In the Records, he was killed by an arrow shot by Huang Zu's soldiers while riding alone past Mount Xian, and Lü Gong does not appear in Chen Shou's main text. Romance, Ch. 7 §42–43Records, Wu 1 §21 · 1–22

The remaining followers: In Chapter 8 of the Romance, Sun Ce receives his father's coffin in exchange for Huang Zu, returns to Jiangdong and stays at Jiangdu gathering men. In the Records, Sun Jian's elder brother's son Sun Ben led the officers, men and followers to join Yuan Shu, and Sun Ce, after burying his father at Qu'e, recovered Sun Jian's retainers from Yuan Shu in the 1st year of Xingping (194). Romance, Ch. 8 §2Records, Wu 1 §21 · 24–25

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Lineage

  • Succeeded by: Sun Ce faction (194) — 「術甚奇之,以堅部曲還策」

Members (8)

Related events (1)

Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).