Rebellion · Coup

Yellow Turban Rebellion 黃巾之亂

About this event

This was the rising launched in Wei Commandery by Zhang Jue, leader of the Yellow Turbans, at the end of the reign of Emperor Ling of the Eastern Han, and the campaign to suppress it. The Biography of Sun Jian records that on the jiazi day of the 3rd month of the 1st year of Zhongping (184) thirty-six bands rose all at once, burning commanderies and counties and killing the senior officials. The Han court sent Huangfu Song, General of Chariots and Cavalry, and Zhu Jun, General of the Household, and Sun Jian, serving under Zhu Jun, crushed the bandits of Runan and Yingchuan who had fled to Wan City. Records, Wu 1 §6–7

Even after that, bands known as Yellow Turbans rose in Xu Province, Qing Province, Runan and elsewhere. In the 3rd year of Chuping (192) Cao Cao accepted the surrender of the Qing Province Yellow Turbans who had entered Yan Province, and in the 1st year of Jian'an (196) he defeated the Yellow Turbans of Runan and Yingchuan. Around the time Cao Cao pacified Ji Province, Xing Yong said, "It is more than twenty years since the Yellow Turbans rose." Records, Wei 8 §24Records, Wei 1 §22–23 · 38Records, Wei 12 §58

Chen Shou did not gather this rebellion into a single volume. The rising and the first campaigns are in the Biography of Sun Jian in Records of Wu 1, and the part played by Cao Cao, Liu Bei and Dong Zhuo is scattered across the Annals of Emperor Wu, the Biography of the First Sovereign and the Biography of Dong Zhuo. The Romance portrays the rising of the three Zhang Jue brothers and the first fight of Liu Bei, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei ("Heroes Win First Glory Slaying the Yellow Turbans") in Chapter 1, and the end of the Zhang Jue brothers and the fight at Wan City in Chapter 2. Records, Wu 1 §6Records, Wei 1 §3Records, Shu 2 §6Records, Wei 6 §3Romance, Ch. 1 §7–11 · 25–28Romance, Ch. 2 §8–9 · 17–18

Course of events in the Records

In the 1st year of Zhongping (184), Zhang Jue, leader of the Yellow Turbans, rose in Wei Commandery. Claiming the authority of the spirits, he sent out eight emissaries, saying they would convert the realm with the good Way, while secretly linking his followers together, and he styled himself 'Huangtian Taiping' (Yellow Heaven, Great Peace). On the jiazi day of the 3rd month, when thirty-six bands rose together in a single morning, the realm responded, burning commanderies and counties and killing the senior officials. The Annals of Emperor Wu record this rising as an event of "the end of Guanghe," and the Biography of the First Sovereign as one of "the end of Emperor Ling's reign." Records, Wu 1 §6Records, Wei 1 §3Records, Shu 2 §6

The Han court gave troops to Huangfu Song, General of Chariots and Cavalry, and Zhu Jun, General of the Household, to suppress them. When Zhu Jun memorialized to make Sun Jian his Assistant Army Major, the young men of his home district who had followed Sun Jian at Xiapi all went with him, and Sun Jian recruited merchants, travelers and elite troops of the Huai and Si regions besides, leading a little over a thousand men. Fighting together with Zhu Jun, he met no one who could stand before him wherever he went. When the bandits of Runan and Yingchuan, hard pressed, fled to hold Wan City, Sun Jian personally took charge of one side and was the first to climb the wall, his men swarming up after him like ants, and he dealt them a heavy defeat. On Zhu Jun's report Sun Jian became a Major of a Separate Command. Cheng Pu, who followed Sun Jian, also attacked the Yellow Turbans at Wan and Deng. Records, Wu 1 §6–7Records, Wu 10 §2

Other generals also joined the campaign. Cao Cao was appointed Chief Commandant of Cavalry and attacked the bandits of Yingchuan, and was afterward transferred to Chancellor of Jinan. When the provinces and commanderies each raised volunteer troops, Liu Bei led his own followers under the Colonel Zou Jing against the Yellow Turban bandits and, having won merit, became Commandant of Anxi County. Dong Zhuo was transferred to General of the Household and campaigned against the Yellow Turbans, but his army was defeated and he was punished. Zhang He answered the call for recruits at the end of the Han, campaigned against the Yellow Turbans, became an Army Major and was attached to Han Fu. Records, Wei 1 §3Records, Shu 2 §6Records, Wei 6 §3Records, Wei 17 §42

The rising found support in many places. At Dong'e County in Dong Commandery, the county deputy Wang Du answered the Yellow Turbans and burned the granaries, and the magistrate climbed over the wall and fled. Cheng Yu secretly sent a few horsemen to raise banners on the hill to the east and had Xue Fang and others, on seeing them, shout "The bandits have already come!", leading the officials and people who had fled back to the city; then, holding the city together with the magistrate, he opened the gates, charged out and drove off Wang Du's band. Zhang Yan of Zhending in Changshan gathered young men into a bandit troop when the Yellow Turbans rose, and his following later reached a million and was called the Heishan (Black Mountain). When the Yellow Turbans rose in Xu Province, the court made Tao Qian Inspector of Xu Province, and Tao Qian defeated them and drove them off. Records, Wei 14 §2–4Records, Wei 8 §52–53 · 24

Gongsun Zan's cousin Gongsun Fan helped Gongsun Zan with the troops of Bohai to defeat the Yellow Turbans of Qing and Xu Provinces. In Beihai, Kong Rong, Chancellor of Beihai, went out to station himself at Douchang because of the Yellow Turbans' raids and was surrounded by the bandit Guan Hai. When Taishi Ci broke through the encirclement, went to Pingyuan and asked Liu Bei for help, Liu Bei sent 3,000 elite troops with him, and the bandits, hearing that relief was coming, lifted the siege and scattered in flight. Records, Wei 8 §12Records, Wu 4 §21–22 · 25–26

In the 3rd year of Chuping (192), the Yellow Turbans of Qing Province, a host of a million, entered Yan Province, killed Zheng Sui, Chancellor of Rencheng, and moved on into Dongping. Bao Xin advised that since the bandits had no baggage train and lived only by plunder, they should first hold firm and wait for them to scatter, but Liu Dai did not listen, fought them and was killed. Bao Xin came to Dong Commandery with the provincial officer Wan Qian and others and welcomed Cao Cao to take charge as Governor of Yan Province. Cao Cao attacked the Yellow Turbans east of Shouzhang; Bao Xin fought hard and died, and they were barely defeated. When Cao Cao pursued them as far as Jibei, the Yellow Turbans asked to surrender, and in winter Cao Cao took in more than 300,000 surrendered soldiers and over a million men and women, calling the elite among them the Qingzhou troops. Records, Wei 1 §22–23

In the 1st year of Jian'an (196), He Yi, Liu Pi, Huang Shao, He Man and others of the Yellow Turbans of Runan and Yingchuan each had a following of tens of thousands; they first answered Yuan Shu and then attached themselves to Sun Jian. In the 2nd month Cao Cao advanced and defeated them, beheading Liu Pi, Huang Shao and others, and He Yi and his followers all surrendered. The Biography of Yu Jin records that when Huang Shao and others raided Cao Cao's camp by night, Yu Jin led his own troops to defeat them, beheaded Huang Shao and the others and made all their followers surrender. Yet the Biography of the First Sovereign records that in the 5th year of Jian'an (200), when Cao Cao faced Yuan Shao at Guandu, the Runan Yellow Turban Liu Pi and others betrayed Cao Cao and answered Yuan Shao, so that Liu Pi, whom the Annals of Emperor Wu say was beheaded in 196, appears again. Records, Wei 1 §38Records, Wei 17 §28Records, Shu 2 §16–17

The later records concern the suppression of bands that remained in various places. After attacking Yuan Tan and Yuan Shang at Liyang, Yue Jin separately defeated the Yellow Turbans and pacified Le'an Commandery. When the Yellow Turbans of Jinan and Le'an under Xu He, Sima Ju and others attacked cities and killed senior officials, Xiahou Yuan crushed them with the troops of the Taishan, Qi and Pingyuan commanderies and beheaded Xu He, and Lü Qian and Zang Ba also attacked them together with Xiahou Yuan. In Wu, Zhu Zhi, who became Administrator of Wu Commandery in the 7th year of Jian'an (202), captured or beheaded the Yellow Turban remnants Chen Bai, Wan Bing and others. Records, Wei 17 §21Records, Wei 9 §15Records, Wei 18 §43 · 25Records, Wu 11 §5

Chen Shou gave no separate assessment of this rebellion. The edict of the 5th month of the 18th year of Jian'an (213) making Cao Cao Duke of Wei counted among his merits that when the Yellow Turbans invaded three provinces and the calamity reached the common people, Cao Cao cut them down and brought peace to the eastern lands. Xing Yong said, "It is more than twenty years since the Yellow Turbans rose; the realm seethes like a cauldron and the people wander," and Deng Ai held that after the Yellow Turbans were defeated in former times, the occasion was used to open military farms, store grain at Xudu and so control the four quarters. Records, Wei 1 §121 · 123Records, Wei 12 §58Records, Wei 28 §51

In the Romance

Chapter 1 says that the eunuchs wielded power so that people's hearts came to long for upheaval, and then brings Zhang Jue forward. Zhang Jue, a scholar of Julu Commandery who had failed the examinations, received the three volumes of the 'Essential Arts of Great Peace' from the Old Immortal of Nanhua in the mountains and learned to summon wind and rain; when a pestilence spread in the 1st month of the 1st year of Zhongping (184), he cured the sick with water in which talismans had been burned and styled himself the 'Great Worthy and Good Teacher'. Zhang Jue set up thirty-six 'fang' (districts) and spread the saying, 'The Blue Heaven is already dead; the Yellow Heaven shall arise. When the year is jiazi, the realm will have great fortune.' Romance, Ch. 1 §6–9

Zhang Jue had Ma Yuanyi try to make the eunuch Feng Xu an inside agent in the palace, but his disciple Tang Zhou reported it to the authorities, so the emperor had He Jin behead Ma Yuanyi and throw Feng Xu and the others into prison. When the affair came to light, Zhang Jue raised troops that very night and styled himself 'General of Heaven', naming his younger brothers Zhang Bao and Zhang Liang 'General of Earth' and 'General of Man', and those who wrapped their heads in yellow turbans and followed him numbered four to five hundred thousand. He Jin sent the Generals of the Household Lu Zhi, Huangfu Song and Zhu Jun along three routes. Romance, Ch. 1 §10–12

When Liu Yan gathered volunteer troops to stop the band that had invaded You Province, Liu Bei, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei swore brotherhood, went out under Zou Jing, crushed Cheng Yuanzhi's 50,000 at the foot of Mount Daxing and lifted the siege of Qing Province. At Guangzong, Lu Zhi's 50,000 faced Zhang Jue's 150,000, and Huangfu Song and Zhu Jun attacked with fire Zhang Liang and Zhang Bao, who had fallen back to Changshe and camped in the grass. Cao Cao, Chief Commandant of Cavalry, blocked the two men as they fled and took more than ten thousand heads. Lu Zhi refused to pay a bribe and was arrested on the slander of Zuo Feng of the Yellow Gate, and Dong Zhuo, who took over his troops, was defeated by Zhang Jue and, pursued, was rescued by Liu Bei and his two companions. Romance, Ch. 1 §13 · 21 · 25–26 · 28–31 · 33–36 · 40 · 43–47

In Chapter 2, Liu Bei, following Zhu Jun, broke Zhang Bao's sorcery with the blood of pigs, sheep and dogs and with filth, as Zhu Jun had planned, and shot Zhang Bao in the left arm. Huangfu Song won seven victories, beheaded Zhang Liang at Quyang, dug up the coffin of Zhang Jue, who was already dead, cut off the head and sent it to the capital. Zhang Bao, shut up in Yangcheng, was stabbed to death by the bandit officer Yan Zheng. Next, when the Yellow Turban remnants Zhao Hong, Han Zhong and Sun Zhong took Wan City, Zhu Jun, on Liu Bei's advice, left the southeast open, attacked the northwest and shot down Han Zhong as he fled. Sun Jian, on the wall, snatched Zhao Hong's spear and stabbed him with it, and Liu Bei shot Sun Zhong from his horse, and the dozen or so commanderies of the Nanyang region were pacified. Romance, Ch. 2 §3–9 · 10–14 · 17–18

When Liu Bei, despite his merit, long went without office, the Gentleman of the Palace Zhang Jun memorialized that the root of the Yellow Turbans' rebellion lay in the Ten Regular Attendants' selling of offices and titles. The tale of the campaign ends with the Ten Regular Attendants deliberating and making Liu Bei Commandant of Anxi County. The Yellow Turbans appear again later, with the surrender of the Qing Province Yellow Turbans and the Qingzhou troops in Chapter 10 and the campaign against He Yi and Huang Shao in Chapter 12. Romance, Ch. 2 §18–20Romance, Ch. 10 §17–19Romance, Ch. 12 §23–27 · 33

Where the Romance differs

How the rising began: In Chapter 1 of the Romance, Zhang Jue raised troops that very night when Ma Yuanyi's collusion with Feng Xu was exposed by the report of his disciple Tang Zhou. The Biography of Sun Jian in the Records says only that Zhang Jue sent out eight emissaries and secretly linked his followers together, and that thirty-six bands rose all at once on the jiazi day of the 3rd month; there is no story of a report to the authorities. Romance, Ch. 1 §10–11Records, Wu 1 §6

The Zhang Jue brothers: In Chapters 1 and 2 of the Romance, Zhang Jue became General of Heaven and Zhang Bao and Zhang Liang Generals of Earth and Man, and Zhang Jue had already died when his coffin was dug up. In Chen Shou's text Zhang Jue's name appears in only one place, the Biography of Sun Jian, and Zhang Bao, Zhang Liang and Zhang Jue's death are not recorded. Romance, Ch. 1 §11Romance, Ch. 2 §8Records, Wu 1 §6–7

The generals of the campaign: In Chapter 1 of the Romance, Lu Zhi, Huangfu Song and Zhu Jun set out along three routes, and Lu Zhi was arrested on Zuo Feng's slander. The only generals named in the Biography of Sun Jian in the Records are Huangfu Song and Zhu Jun, and Chen Shou's text has no record of Lu Zhi fighting the Yellow Turbans. Romance, Ch. 1 §12 · 43–44Records, Wu 1 §6Records, Shu 2 §4Records, Wei 8 §2

Dong Zhuo's defeat: In Chapter 1 of the Romance, Dong Zhuo, who took over Lu Zhi's troops, was defeated by Zhang Jue and, pursued, was rescued by Liu Bei and his two companions. The Biography of Dong Zhuo in the Records says only that he campaigned against the Yellow Turbans as General of the Household, was defeated and was punished, and the Biography of the First Sovereign has no account of Liu Bei saving Dong Zhuo either. Romance, Ch. 1 §44 · 46–47Records, Wei 6 §3Records, Shu 2 §6

Cao Cao's merit: In Chapter 1 of the Romance, Cao Cao, Chief Commandant of Cavalry, blocked Zhang Liang and Zhang Bao as they fled from Yingchuan and took more than ten thousand heads. The Annals of Emperor Wu in the Records say only that he attacked the bandits of Yingchuan as Chief Commandant of Cavalry, giving neither the names of enemy leaders nor the number of heads taken. Romance, Ch. 1 §40Records, Wei 1 §3

Liu Bei's fighting: In Chapters 1 and 2 of the Romance, Liu Bei's party crushed Cheng Yuanzhi, saved Qing Province and hit Zhang Bao with an arrow. The Biography of the First Sovereign in the Records says only that Liu Bei followed the Colonel Zou Jing against the Yellow Turbans and, having won merit, became Commandant of Anxi County. Romance, Ch. 1 §25–26 · 31Romance, Ch. 2 §7Records, Shu 2 §6

The fight at Wan City: In Chapter 2 of the Romance, the Yellow Turban remnants Zhao Hong, Han Zhong and Sun Zhong took Wan City, and Sun Jian snatched Zhao Hong's spear and stabbed him with it. In the Biography of Sun Jian in the Records, the hard-pressed bandits of Runan and Yingchuan fled to hold Wan City, and Sun Jian was the first to climb the wall and defeated them; no enemy leader is named. Romance, Ch. 2 §10 · 17Records, Wu 1 §7

The surrender of the Qing Province Yellow Turbans: In Chapter 10 of the Romance, Li Jue, on Zhu Jun's recommendation, issued an edict to Cao Cao, and Cao Cao fought alongside Bao Xin at Shouyang. In the Annals of Emperor Wu in the Records, Bao Xin and others welcomed Cao Cao from Dong Commandery to take charge as Governor of Yan Province, and the battlefield was east of Shouzhang. Romance, Ch. 10 §17–19Records, Wei 1 §23

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Belligerents

ItemAB
FactionsEastern HanYellow Turbans
CommandersCao Cao, Dong Zhuo, Liu Bei, Sun Jian, Zhu Jun, Huangfu Song, Zou JingZhang Jue

Factions, commanders, strength and casualties are checked against the source texts (3KDEX). Strength and casualties show only figures stated in the sources. Source: Wu 1 §7

Sub-events and Romance scenes (5)

Romance chapters (7)

Records volumes (16)

Related works (2)

Linked via Wikidata "depicts" and character names in titles (unverified) — not yet reviewed.