Guan Hai 管亥

RecordsRomance 관해

Profile
OccupationRNGeneralFaction
AppearsRNBiography in
Cause of deathNKilled in battle Unverified
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR2

Profile

Guan Hai was a rebel who besieged Kong Rong, Chancellor of Beihai, at the time when the Yellow Turbans were rampaging. He has no biography of his own in the Records, and his name appears only in the biography of Taishi Ci. Kong Rong had gone out to garrison Duchang when he was surrounded by him. Records, Wu 4 §21

Taishi Ci, who broke out through the siege, asked Liu Bei, Chancellor of Pingyuan, for help, saying, 'Now Guan Hai has risen in violent rebellion and Beihai is besieged,' and when Liu Bei sent 3,000 elite troops to follow Taishi Ci, the rebels lifted the siege and scattered in flight. Chen Shou's main text does not record what became of Guan Hai afterwards. Records, Wu 4 §24–26

In the Romance he appears only in Chapter 11, that is, in 1 of its 120 chapters, and his name is in no chapter title. The Romance portrays him as one of the Yellow Turban band who invades Beihai at the head of tens of thousands of bandits; he cuts down Kong Rong's general Zong Bao and surrounds the city, but is cut down by the Green Dragon Blade of Guan Yu, who comes to the rescue with Liu Bei. Romance, Ch. 11 §7–8 · 17

In the Records

Guan Hai has no biography of his own in the Records and appears in the biography of Taishi Ci in Records of Wu 4. Kong Rong, Chancellor of Beihai, heard of Taishi Ci, who had taken refuge in Liaodong, and thought him remarkable, and he sent people many times to call on his mother and send her gifts. At that time, as the Yellow Turbans were rampaging, Kong Rong had gone out to garrison Duchang and was surrounded by the rebel Guan Hai. Taishi Ci, returning from Liaodong, heard his mother tell him to go to Kong Rong's rescue, and after staying three days he went straight to Duchang alone on foot. Records, Wu 4 §20–21

As the siege was not yet tight, Taishi Ci watched for a gap at night, slipped in and met Kong Rong, and asked for troops to go out and attack the rebels. Kong Rong would not listen and wanted to wait for help from outside, but none came, and the siege tightened day by day. Kong Rong wished to report his plight to Liu Bei, Chancellor of Pingyuan, but no one in the city had a way to get out, and Taishi Ci asked to go himself. Kong Rong hesitated, saying that the rebel siege was very tight and everyone said it could not be done, but after hearing Taishi Ci out he gave his consent. Records, Wu 4 §22–23

At daybreak Taishi Ci took up his bow and mounted, had two horsemen each carry a target, opened the city gate and rode straight out. The rebels on either side below the outer siege lines were all alarmed, and men and horses came rushing out one after another. Taishi Ci set up the targets inside the moat, shot at them and then went straight back in through the gate; the next morning he did the same, and of the besiegers some stood up and some stayed lying down. When he did it once more on the following morning, no one stood up any longer. Then Taishi Ci whipped his horse and dashed straight through the middle of the siege. By the time the rebels realized it, he had already passed, and he shot several more men dead, so that no one dared pursue him. Records, Wu 4 §23–24

Reaching Pingyuan, Taishi Ci told Liu Bei that although he was neither a blood relative nor a fellow townsman of Kong of Beihai, he was bound to him by the duty of sharing calamity and enduring hardship together, and asked for help, saying, 'Now Guan Hai has risen in violent rebellion and Beihai is besieged; it is isolated and helpless, and its danger is a matter of morning or evening.' Liu Bei composed his face and answered, 'So Kong of Beihai knows that there is a Liu Bei in this world!' and at once sent 3,000 elite troops to follow Taishi Ci; hearing that troops were coming, the rebels lifted the siege and scattered in flight. Chen Shou's main text records nothing more of Guan Hai after this, nor does it say in what year these events took place. Records, Wu 4 §25–26

In the Romance

In Chapter 11 of the Romance, when Cao Cao besieges Xu Province, Mi Zhu comes to Beihai on Tao Qian's orders and asks Kong Rong for help. While Kong Rong is conferring, having ordered troops mustered on the one hand and a letter sent to Cao Cao on the other, word comes that Guan Hai of the Yellow Turban band is advancing at the head of tens of thousands of bandits. When Kong Rong hastily musters his troops and goes out of the city to meet him, Guan Hai rides out and says that, knowing Beihai has ample grain, he will withdraw at once if lent just 10,000 dan, but that otherwise he will smash the city and spare neither old nor young. Romance, Ch. 11 §3 · 6–7

When Kong Rong rebukes him, saying that he is a subject of the great Han guarding the land of the great Han and has no grain to give to bandits, Guan Hai flies into a rage, spurs his horse and, brandishing his blade, charges straight at Kong Rong. Within a few bouts he cuts Kong Rong's general Zong Bao, who has come out with his spear levelled, from his horse with his blade, and when Kong Rong's troops fall into great disorder and flee into the city, he divides his forces and surrounds the city on all four sides. Romance, Ch. 11 §8

The next day Taishi Ci rides alone through the bandits' lines into the city, and, taking a letter from Kong Rong, breaks out through the siege again. Learning that someone has left the city and surmising that he must be going to ask for reinforcements, Guan Hai personally leads several hundred horsemen in pursuit and surrounds him on all eight sides. But when Taishi Ci takes up his bow and shoots in every direction, every man falls from his horse at the twang of the string, and the bandits dare not pursue him. Romance, Ch. 11 §9–10 · 13–14

Taishi Ci asks Liu Bei at Pingyuan for help, saying, 'Now Guan Hai has risen in revolt and Beihai is besieged,' and Liu Bei, together with Guan Yu and Zhang Fei, musters 3,000 picked troops and sets out for Beihai Commandery. Seeing the relief army approach, Guan Hai personally leads his troops out to meet it, and, seeing how few Liu Bei's troops are, thinks little of them. When Guan Hai comes straight out in fury and Taishi Ci is about to ride forward, Guan Yu goes out first to engage him, and within a few dozen bouts raises his Green Dragon Blade and cuts Guan Hai down from his horse. Romance, Ch. 11 §15–17

Then Taishi Ci and Zhang Fei charge into the bandits' lines and Liu Bei drives his troops in to fall upon them, and Kong Rong, watching from the city wall, also leads his troops out of the city. Attacked from both sides, the bandits are heavily defeated; those who surrender are beyond counting, and the rest scatter. In the Romance, Guan Hai's name appears only in this battle episode of Chapter 11. Romance, Ch. 11 §18

Where the Romance differs

Where the siege took place: In Chapter 11 of the Romance, Guan Hai invades Beihai, attacks Kong Rong, who has come out of the city, drives him back inside and surrounds the city. In the Records, Kong Rong had gone out to garrison Duchang because the Yellow Turbans were rampaging, and was surrounded there by Guan Hai. Romance, Ch. 11 §7–8Records, Wu 4 §21

The demand for grain: In the Romance, Guan Hai comes at the head of tens of thousands of bandits and asks to be lent 10,000 dan of grain. The biography of Taishi Ci in the Records mentions neither the size of Guan Hai's following nor any demand for grain. Romance, Ch. 11 §7Records, Wu 4 §21–26

Killing Zong Bao: In the Romance, Guan Hai cuts down Kong Rong's general Zong Bao with his blade within a few bouts. Zong Bao does not appear in the biography of Taishi Ci in the Records. Romance, Ch. 11 §8Records, Wu 4 §21–26

Pursuing Taishi Ci: In the Romance, Guan Hai, surmising that Taishi Ci is going to ask for reinforcements, personally leads several hundred horsemen in pursuit and surrounds him. In the Records, Taishi Ci set up targets, shot at them and went back in through the gate on three mornings running until the besiegers no longer stood up, and then dashed through the middle of the siege; by the time the rebels realized it, he had already passed. Nothing is said of Guan Hai pursuing him in person. Romance, Ch. 11 §13–14Records, Wu 4 §23–24

The relief army: In the Romance, Liu Bei musters 3,000 picked troops together with Guan Yu and Zhang Fei and marches to Beihai in person. The Records says only that Liu Bei sent 3,000 elite troops to follow Taishi Ci, and says nothing of Liu Bei, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei going together. Romance, Ch. 11 §16Records, Wu 4 §26

Guan Hai's end: In the Romance, Guan Hai comes out to meet the relief army and is cut down by Guan Yu's Green Dragon Blade, and the bandits, attacked from both sides, are heavily defeated. The Records says only that the rebels, hearing that troops were coming, lifted the siege and scattered in flight; neither a battle nor Guan Hai's death appears. Romance, Ch. 11 §17–18Records, Wu 4 §26

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA5255+3
  • STR4268+26
  • INT3845+7
  • POL3131±0
  • CHA4045+5
  • VIR2215−7
  • ADP3530−5
  • SCH3131±0
  • DIP3335+2
  • DIS3333±0
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

StrengthR42UnverifiedN68 +26

RNo direct record — estimated from his role as a Yellow Turban leaderWu 4 §21

NCut down Zong Bao within a few bouts, and was cut down by Guan Yu after a few dozen boutsCh. 11 §8Ch. 11 §17

9 similar abilities — show evidence
  • LeadershipR52N55 +3

    RLed the Yellow Turbans and besieged Kong Rong at DuchangWu 4 §21Wu 4 §25

    NLed tens of thousands of bandits, routed Kong Rong's army and surrounded the cityCh. 11 §7Ch. 11 §8

  • IntelligenceR38UnverifiedN45 +7

    RNo direct record — estimated from his role as a Yellow Turban leaderWu 4 §21

    NGuessed that the man who had left the city was going for help and gave chaseCh. 11 §13

  • PoliticsR31UnverifiedN31Unverified ±0

    RNo direct record — estimated from his role as a Yellow Turban leaderWu 4 §21

    NNo direct record — estimated from his role as a Yellow Turban leaderCh. 11 §7

  • CharismaR40UnverifiedN45 +5

    RNo direct record — estimated from his role as a Yellow Turban leaderWu 4 §21

    NCommanded a Yellow Turban band of tens of thousandsCh. 11 §7

  • VirtueR22N15 −7

    RRose in violent rebellion and besieged BeihaiWu 4 §25

    NExtorted grain, threatening to spare neither old nor youngCh. 11 §7

  • AdaptabilityR35UnverifiedN30 −5

    RNo direct record — estimated from his role as a Yellow Turban leaderWu 4 §21

    NScorned the relief army for its small numbers, met it in person and was cut downCh. 11 §17

  • ScholarshipR31UnverifiedN31Unverified ±0

    RNo direct record — estimated from his role as a Yellow Turban leaderWu 4 §21

    NNo direct record — estimated from his role as a Yellow Turban leaderCh. 11 §7

  • DiplomacyR33UnverifiedN35 +2

    RNo direct record — estimated from his role as a Yellow Turban leaderWu 4 §21

    NThreatened that he would withdraw only if lent 10,000 dan of grainCh. 11 §7

  • DiscernmentR33UnverifiedN33Unverified ±0

    RNo direct record — estimated from his role as a Yellow Turban leaderWu 4 §21

    NNo direct record — estimated from his role as a Yellow Turban leaderCh. 11 §7

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (1)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Allegiance history

  1. Yellow Turbans · Novel & History · 「時融以黃巾寇暴…為賊管亥所圍」 · 「黃巾賊黨管亥」

Related events (1)

Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).