Tao Qian 陶謙

RecordsRomance Tao Qian faction Courtesy name 恭祖 Gongzu도겸공조陶谦

Profile
OccupationRRuler · Governor of Xu Province NRuler · Administrator of Xu ProvinceFactionTao Qian faction
AppearsRNBiography inBook of Wei
BornR132 UnverifiedNative placeDanyang Commandery
DiedR194 UnverifiedPlace of death
Cause of deathRIllness NIllness Unverified
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR51

Profile

Tao Qian, courtesy name Gongzu, was a native of Danyang. When the Yellow Turbans rose in Xu Province, he became Inspector of Xu Province and defeated them, and for sending tribute to Chang'an during Dong Zhuo's disorders he became General Who Pacifies the East (andong jiangjun) and Governor of Xu Province and was enfeoffed as Marquis of Liyang. Records, Wei 8 §24–25

He was attacked twice by Cao Cao, in the 4th year of Chuping (193) and the 1st year of Xingping (194), and he recommended Liu Bei as Inspector of Yu Province and had him stay at Xiaopei. Dying of illness in the 1st year of Xingping, he told his Attendant Officer Mi Zhu, 'No one but Liu Bei can bring peace to this province.' Records, Wei 8 §27–28Records, Shu 2 §9

In his assessment, Chen Shou, author of the Records, said, 'Tao Qian was muddled and disorderly and died in anxiety,' and wrote that although he held a province and commanderies as his stronghold, he did not even measure up to a common man. In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 5 as Inspector of Xu Province, the twelfth contingent among the seventeen lords marching against Dong Zhuo, and appears in 7 of its 120 chapters; as the title of Chapter 12, 'Tao Gongzu Thrice Offers Xu Province', suggests, he is portrayed as a kindly man who wants to hand Xu Province to Liu Bei. Records, Wei 8 §71Romance, Ch. 5 §8Romance, Ch. 12 §19

In the Records

Tao Qian, courtesy name Gongzu, was a native of Danyang. In his youth he loved learning and became a student of the classics. After serving in the province and commandery, he was recommended as Abundant Talent (maocai) and became Magistrate of Lu; he was transferred to be Inspector of You Province, was then summoned to become a Consultant (yilang), and took part in the army of the General of Chariots and Cavalry Zhang Wen, campaigning west against Han Sui. When the Yellow Turbans happened to rise in Xu Province, he became Inspector of Xu Province and attacked and defeated them. The Biography of Zang Ba records that Zang Ba followed Tao Qian in defeating the Yellow Turbans and became Cavalry Commandant. Records, Wei 8 §24Records, Wei 18 §20

When the provinces and commanderies raised troops during Dong Zhuo's disorders and the Son of Heaven made Chang'an his capital, cutting off communication with the four quarters, Tao Qian sent envoys by secret routes to present tribute. According to the Biography of Wang Lang, his Headquarters Officer (zhizhong) Wang Lang and his Attendant Officer (biejia) Zhao Yu urged him, in keeping with the principles of the Spring and Autumn Annals, to exert himself for the royal house and send envoys to the Son of Heaven, and Tao Qian sent Zhao Yu to Chang'an bearing a memorial. The Son of Heaven commended this and made Tao Qian General Who Pacifies the East (andong jiangjun), and the Biography of Tao Qian records that he was transferred to be Governor of Xu Province and enfeoffed as Marquis of Liyang. Records, Wei 8 §25Records, Wei 13 §44–45

At this time Xu Province had a large population and ample grain, and many displaced people gathered there. But Chen Shou wrote that Tao Qian abandoned the right way and acted on his own feelings. He kept at a distance Zhao Yu, Administrator of Guangling and a famous scholar of Xu Province, because he was loyal and upright, while he kept close and trusted Cao Hong and others, slanderous and wicked petty men. Punishments and government lost their balance, many good people suffered harm, and because of this the province gradually fell into disorder. Records, Wei 8 §25–26

He also appears in other biographies. According to the Biography of Zhang Zhao, when Zhang Zhao did not respond to his recommendation as Abundant Talent, Tao Qian, saying Zhang Zhao was slighting him, had him seized and imprisoned. In the Biography of Lü Fan he took Lü Fan for a spy of the Yuan family and hinted to the county that he should be seized and flogged, and in the Biography of Sun Ce he greatly disliked Sun Ce. According to the Biography of Ze Rong, Ze Rong, who had placed himself under Tao Qian, was put in charge of transporting supplies for Guangling and Pengcheng, and then killed people at will and seized the supplies of three commanderies. Records, Wu 7 §2Records, Wu 11 §33Records, Wu 1 §25Records, Wu 4 §8

When a rift opened between Yuan Shu and Yuan Shao, Gongsun Zan stationed Tao Qian at Fagan to put pressure on Yuan Shao, but Cao Cao, together with Yuan Shao, attacked and defeated him. When Que Xuan of Xiapi gathered several thousand men and called himself Son of Heaven, Tao Qian at first raised troops together with him, seized Hua and Fei in Taishan and plundered Rencheng, but later he killed Que Xuan and absorbed his followers. Records, Wei 1 §24 · 26Records, Wei 8 §26

According to the Annals of Emperor Wu, Cao Cao's father Cao Song, who had taken refuge from Dong Zhuo's disorders in Langya, was harmed by Tao Qian, and so Cao Cao attacked eastward to take revenge. In the autumn of the 4th year of Chuping (193) Cao Cao attacked Tao Qian, took more than ten cities, and fought a great battle at Pengcheng. Tao Qian's troops were routed and fled, the dead numbering in the tens of thousands so that the Si River ceased to flow, and Tao Qian withdrew to hold Tan. Cao Cao, short of provisions, went back. Records, Wei 1 §26 · 28Records, Wei 8 §27

According to the Biography of the First Sovereign, when Cao Cao attacked Xu Province, Tao Qian sent envoys to Tian Kai to report his peril, and Tian Kai and Liu Bei came together to his rescue. When Tao Qian added 4,000 Danyang soldiers to Liu Bei's forces, Liu Bei left Tian Kai and came over to Tao Qian. Tao Qian memorialized making Liu Bei Inspector of Yu Province and had him stationed at Xiaopei. Records, Shu 2 §8–9

In the summer of the 1st year of Xingping (194) Cao Cao again attacked eastward and overran the counties of Langya and Donghai. Tao Qian's commander Cao Bao, together with Liu Bei, tried to stop him east of Tan but was defeated, and many people died wherever Cao Cao passed. Tao Qian, in fear, was about to flee to Danyang, but just then Zhang Miao rebelled and welcomed Lü Bu, and Cao Cao went back to attack Lü Bu. Records, Wei 1 §28Records, Wei 8 §28

That year Tao Qian died of illness. When his illness became critical he told his Attendant Officer Mi Zhu, 'No one but Liu Bei can bring peace to this province,' and when Tao Qian died, Mi Zhu, carrying out his last wishes, led the people of the province to welcome Liu Bei at Xiaopei. According to the Biography of Xun Yu, Cao Cao wanted to take Xu Province while it was vulnerable after Tao Qian's death, but Xun Yu dissuaded him, saying that even with Tao Qian dead Xu Province would not easily fall. Records, Wei 8 §28Records, Shu 2 §9Records, Shu 8 §21Records, Wei 10 §9 · 11

In his assessment, Chen Shou named Tao Qian together with Gongsun Zan, Gongsun Du, Zhang Yang and others, saying, 'Tao Qian was muddled and disorderly and died in anxiety,' and wrote that they had all held provinces and commanderies as their strongholds yet did not even measure up to common men, so that there was truly nothing about them worth discussing. Records, Wei 8 §71

In the Romance

In Chapter 5 of the Romance his name is listed as Inspector of Xu Province, the twelfth contingent among the lords who answer Cao Cao's call to arms, and when Dong Zhuo posts troops at Hulao Pass he is also among the eight lords Yuan Shao sends there. Romance, Ch. 5 §8 · 42

In Chapter 10 the Romance calls him Administrator of Xu Province and portrays him as a kindly and simple man who had long wished to befriend Cao Cao. When Cao Cao's father Cao Song passes through Xu Province, Tao Qian goes out beyond the border to bow to him twice and holds banquets for two days, and when Cao Song leaves he has the Commandant Zhang Kai escort him with 500 soldiers. But Zhang Kai, a former member of the Yellow Turban remnants, kills Cao Song's family at an old temple between Hua and Fei, seizes their goods and flees to Huainan. Saying, 'Tao Qian let loose his soldiers to kill my father,' Cao Cao orders the people of Xu Province to be massacred, and he does not listen even when Chen Gong tries to dissuade him, saying that Tao Qian is a benevolent gentleman and this was Zhang Kai's crime alone. Romance, Ch. 10 §27–31 · 33–36

Tao Qian looks up to heaven and wails, lamenting that because of his own fault the people of Xu Province are suffering great calamity. When he leads his troops out on Cao Bao's advice, Cao Cao comes out in white mourning clothes under a white banner inscribed with the four characters 'Avenge the wrong, wipe out the grievance'. When Tao Qian bows and says that he had merely entrusted the escort to Zhang Kai and the fault is not his, Cao Cao rebukes him as an 'old wretch'. Back in the city, Tao Qian says he will bind himself and go to Cao Cao's camp to save the people's lives, but Mi Zhu stops him and proposes a plan to ask Kong Rong of Beihai and Tian Kai of Qingzhou for help. Romance, Ch. 10 §37–40Romance, Ch. 11 §2–3

In Chapter 11, when Liu Bei comes to the rescue and enters the city of Xuzhou, Tao Qian, seeing his imposing bearing and forthright speech, at once has Mi Zhu bring the seal of Xu Province and tries to hand it over to him. When Liu Bei declines, asking whether Tao Qian suspects him of wanting to swallow another's land, Tao Qian says it is 'this old man's true heart'. After Cao Cao withdraws on news of Lü Bu's attack on Yan Province, Tao Qian tries again at a banquet to hand it over, weeping, 'If you abandon me and leave, I shall not close my eyes even in death,' and when Liu Bei still will not accept, he has him keep his troops at nearby Xiaopei. Romance, Ch. 11 §28–30 · 34–38 · 40–42

In Chapter 12, when Tao Qian, at sixty-three, falls gravely ill, he summons Liu Bei to his bedchamber at Mi Zhu's urging and entrusts the seal to him once more. He says that his two sons, Shang and Ying, lack ability and must not be given charge of the province's affairs, recommends Sun Qian of Beihai as an Attendant Officer, tells Mi Zhu to serve Lord Liu well, and, pointing to his heart with his hand, breathes his last. Liu Bei takes charge of Xu Province for the time being and buries him on a plain by the Yellow River, and Cao Cao, hearing of it, angrily declares that he will first kill Liu Bei and then desecrate Tao Qian's corpse. Romance, Ch. 12 §16–21

Where the Romance differs

The campaign against Dong Zhuo: In Chapter 5 of the Romance, Tao Qian, as Inspector of Xu Province, is among the lords who attack Dong Zhuo and also goes out to Hulao Pass. Tao Qian is not among those whom the Annals of Emperor Wu in the Records list as raising troops together in the 1st year of Chuping (190), and the Biography of Tao Qian records that during Dong Zhuo's disorders he sent tribute to Chang'an by secret routes and became General Who Pacifies the East and Governor of Xu Province. Romance, Ch. 5 §8 · 42Records, Wei 1 §7Records, Wei 8 §25

Office: Chapter 10 of the Romance calls him Administrator of Xu Province. In the Records, he became Governor of Xu Province after serving as Inspector of Xu Province. Romance, Ch. 10 §28Records, Wei 8 §24–25

Character: In Chapters 10-11 of the Romance he is kindly and simple, and Chen Gong and Liu Bei call him a benevolent gentleman. Chen Shou wrote that he abandoned the right way and acted on his own feelings, keeping the loyal and upright Zhao Yu at a distance and trusting the wicked Cao Hong and others, and in his assessment called him muddled and disorderly. Romance, Ch. 10 §28 · 35Romance, Ch. 11 §19Records, Wei 8 §25–26 · 71

Cao Song's death: In Chapter 10 of the Romance, the Commandant Zhang Kai, to whom Tao Qian entrusted the escort, kills Cao Song's family for their goods. The Annals of Emperor Wu in the Records say that Cao Song, having taken refuge in Langya, was harmed by Tao Qian, and Zhang Kai does not appear in Chen Shou's main text. Romance, Ch. 10 §29–31Records, Wei 1 §28

Que Xuan: In the Records, Tao Qian raised troops together with Que Xuan, who had called himself Son of Heaven, seized Hua and Fei in Taishan, and later killed him and absorbed his followers. Chapter 10 of the Romance uses Hua and Fei only as the place where Cao Song dies, and Que Xuan does not appear. Records, Wei 1 §26Records, Wei 8 §26Romance, Ch. 10 §28

Cao Cao's two campaigns: In Chapters 10-11 of the Romance, Cao Cao attacks Xu Province once and withdraws when, after receiving Liu Bei's letter, Lü Bu attacks Yan Province. In the Records, in the first campaign in the autumn of the 4th year of Chuping (193) the dead of the great battle at Pengcheng numbered in the tens of thousands and Cao Cao went back for lack of provisions, and in the 1st year of Xingping (194) he invaded again and went back because of Zhang Miao's rebellion. Romance, Ch. 11 §32 · 34–37Records, Wei 8 §27–28Records, Wei 1 §26 · 28

The explanation before the lines: In Chapter 10 of the Romance, Tao Qian comes out before the battle lines and, bowing, tells Cao Cao the fault is not his. In the Records, Tao Qian's troops were routed at Pengcheng and fled, Tao Qian withdrew to hold Tan, and the Annals of Emperor Wu record that he held the city and did not dare come out. Romance, Ch. 10 §38Records, Wei 8 §27Records, Wei 1 §26

How Liu Bei was called in: In Chapter 11 of the Romance, Mi Zhu goes to Kong Rong of Beihai, and at Kong Rong's urging Liu Bei borrows troops from Gongsun Zan and comes. In the Biography of the First Sovereign in the Records, Tao Qian reported his peril to Tian Kai, Tian Kai and Liu Bei came together, and when Tao Qian added 4,000 Danyang soldiers to his forces, Liu Bei left Tian Kai and came over to Tao Qian. Romance, Ch. 11 §2 · 19–20Records, Shu 2 §8

Handing over Xu Province: In Chapters 11-12 of the Romance, Tao Qian tries three times to hand the seal to Liu Bei, and when Liu Bei will not accept, has him stay at Xiaopei. In the Records, he memorialized making Liu Bei Inspector of Yu Province and had him stationed at Xiaopei, and when his illness became critical he only told Mi Zhu that no one but Liu Bei could bring peace to the province; after Tao Qian's death, Mi Zhu led the people of the province to welcome Liu Bei. Romance, Ch. 11 §28–30 · 40–42Romance, Ch. 12 §17–19Records, Shu 2 §9Records, Shu 8 §21

Death: In Chapter 12 of the Romance, Tao Qian dies of illness at sixty-three, speaking of his two sons and recommending Sun Qian. Chen Shou's main text says only that he died of illness in the 1st year of Xingping (194), recording neither his age, his two sons nor the recommendation of Sun Qian, and writes that before his death, fearing Cao Cao's attack, he was about to flee to Danyang. Romance, Ch. 12 §16–19Records, Wei 8 §28Records, Shu 8 §25

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA3830−8
  • STR3130−1
  • INT2535+10
  • POL2560+35
  • CHA4570+25
  • VIR2585+60
  • ADP2238+16
  • SCH5040−10
  • DIP4550+5
  • DIS2565+40
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

VirtueR25N85 +60

RAbandoned the right way and plundered alongside Que Xuan before killing him, though he sent tribute to the courtWei 8 §25

NKindly and simple; offered to bind himself for the people's sake and yielded Xu ProvinceCh. 10 §28Ch. 10 §40Ch. 11 §38

DiscernmentR25N65 +40

RKept the loyal Zhao Yu at a distance and trusted Cao Hong, but recognized Liu Bei as his successorWei 8 §25Shu 2 §9

NRecognized Liu Bei, recommended Sun Qian, and saw his two sons' shortcomingsCh. 11 §28Ch. 12 §18

PoliticsR25N60 +35

RPunishments and government lost their balance and good people suffered harmWei 8 §25

NWas said to have governed Xu Province long, so that the people were grateful for his kindnessCh. 10 §40

CharismaR45N70 +25

RDisplaced people flocked to Xu Province, and after his death the people of the province followed his last wishesWei 8 §25Shu 2 §9

NThe people were grateful to him, Kong Rong came to his aid, and after his death the people wept and bowedCh. 10 §40Ch. 11 §6Ch. 12 §19

AdaptabilityR22N38 +16

RJoined hands with Que Xuan and then betrayed him, and in fear of Cao Cao was about to fleeWei 8 §26Wei 8 §28

NOnly offered to sacrifice himself, and chose a successor only when his illness grew graveCh. 10 §40Ch. 12 §16

IntelligenceR25N35 +10

RAssessment: muddled and disorderly, he died in anxietyWei 8 §71Wei 8 §25

NBrought disaster by entrusting Cao Song's escort to Zhang Kai, a former Yellow TurbanCh. 10 §28

ScholarshipR50N40Unverified −10

RLoved learning in his youth and became a student of the classicsWei 8 §24

NNo direct record — estimated from his conduct as provincial governorCh. 10 §28

3 similar abilities — show evidence
  • LeadershipR38N30 −8

    RDefeated the Yellow Turbans of Xu Province, but lost badly at Pengcheng, where tens of thousands diedWei 8 §24Wei 8 §27

    NCame out to face Cao Cao but hurriedly fled back into his linesCh. 10 §37

  • StrengthR31UnverifiedN30Unverified −1

    RNo direct record — estimated from his conduct as provincial governorWei 8 §24

    NNo direct record — estimated from his flight from the battlefieldCh. 10 §39

  • DiplomacyR45N50 +5

    RSent envoys by secret routes to present tribute, and asked Tian Kai for helpWei 8 §25Shu 2 §8

    NSent Mi Zhu and Chen Deng and won help from Kong Rong and Tian KaiCh. 11 §2Ch. 11 §24

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (7)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Allegiance history

  1. Tao Qian faction · Records

Relations

Related events (3)

Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).