Rebellion · Coup
Liang Province rebellion 涼州之亂
About this event
The Liang Province rebellion was the revolt raised at the end of Emperor Ling's reign in the Eastern Han by Bian Zhang and Han Sui of Jincheng, who killed the inspector and the administrators in Liang Province. The Annals of Emperor Wu record that their following numbered more than a hundred thousand and the realm was thrown into turmoil. The Han court sent the General of the Household Dong Zhuo to resist them, but he achieved nothing, and in the 3rd year of Zhongping (186) it had the Minister of Works Zhang Wen act as General of Chariots and Cavalry and campaign westward. On hearing that a great army was coming, the followers of Bian Zhang and Han Sui scattered and they begged to surrender, but it was only in the 3rd year of Chuping (192) that Han Sui, together with Ma Teng, led his following to Chang'an and surrendered. Records, Wei 1 §5Records, Wu 1 §8 · 10Records, Wei 6 §22
Chen Shou did not gather this rebellion into a single volume. Its course is in the Annals of Emperor Wu in Records of Wei 1, the biography of Dong Zhuo in volume 6 and the Biography of Sun Jian in Records of Wu 1, and related passages are scattered through the biographies of Tao Qian, Gongsun Zan and Zhang Xiu, the Biographies of Liu Yan and Liu Zhang in Records of Shu 1 and the biography of Ma Chao in volume 6. The rebellion does not appear in the Romance. Records, Wei 1 §5Records, Wei 6 §4Records, Wu 1 §8–11Records, Wei 8 §4 · 24 · 56Records, Shu 1 §5Records, Shu 6 §25
Course of events in the Records
The biography of Gongsun Zan records that when bandits rose in Liang Province during the Guanghe era, three thousand assault cavalry of You Province were levied and put under Gongsun Zan's command, but when the troops reached Ji County, Zhang Chun of Yuyang enticed the Wuhuan into revolt. The biography of Ma Chao says that his father Ma Teng rose in the western lands at the end of Emperor Ling's reign together with Bian Zhang, Han Sui and others. According to the biography of Zhang Xiu, when Bian Zhang and Han Sui raised their revolt, Qu Sheng of Jincheng attacked and killed Liu Jun, Chief of Zuli County, and Zhang Xiu, then a county clerk, watched for his chance and killed Qu Sheng. Records, Wei 8 §4 · 56Records, Shu 6 §25
When Han Sui and others rose in Liang Province, Dong Zhuo was again made General of the Household and resisted Han Sui in the west. Surrounded north of Wangyuan Gorge by tens of thousands of Qiang and Hu and with his provisions exhausted, Dong Zhuo pretended to be catching fish, dammed the water he would have to cross on his way back to make a pond, secretly sent his troops across below the dam and then broke the dam. When the Qiang and Hu came in pursuit, the water was too deep to cross. Of the six armies that had gone up into Longxi at this time, five were defeated, and Dong Zhuo alone brought his troops back intact and garrisoned Fufeng. The Biography of Sun Jian, speaking of this, records that the General of the Household Dong Zhuo resisted and campaigned against them but achieved nothing. Records, Wei 6 §4Records, Wu 1 §8
In the 3rd year of Zhongping (186), the Minister of Works Zhang Wen, acting as General of Chariots and Cavalry, set out west to attack Bian Zhang and the others, and memorialized to have Sun Jian take part in military affairs, stationing himself at Chang'an. Tao Qian also took part in Zhang Wen's army and attacked Han Sui in the west. Dong Zhuo, whom Zhang Wen summoned by edict, came only after a long delay, and his replies were not respectful. Sun Jian whispered to Zhang Wen, urging him to behead Dong Zhuo under military law, listing three crimes: that Dong Zhuo slighted his superior and was discourteous, that he obstructed the army and sowed doubt among the troops by proposing to delay the campaign, and that he exalted himself despite having achieved nothing and arriving late when summoned. Zhang Wen could not bring himself to do it, saying that Dong Zhuo had high prestige and renown between Longxi and Shu, and that if he were killed there would be no one to rely on in advancing west. Records, Wu 1 §8–10Records, Wei 8 §24
When Bian Zhang and Han Sui heard that a great army was about to arrive, their followers scattered and they all begged to surrender. When the army returned, those who deliberated did not fix merits and rewards, on the grounds that the army had not faced the enemy, but on hearing that Sun Jian had listed Dong Zhuo's three crimes and urged his beheading, there was no one who did not sigh in admiration. Sun Jian became a Consultant. Records, Wu 1 §10–11
Even after that the west did not settle down. The Annals of Emperor Wu record, as an event following the failure of the plot by Wang Fen and others to depose the emperor, that Bian Zhang and Han Sui of Jincheng killed the inspector and the administrators and revolted, with a following of more than a hundred thousand. The Biographies of Liu Yan and Liu Zhang say that the killing of the inspector Zhang Yi in Bing Province and of the inspector Geng Bi in Liang Province allowed Liu Yan's proposal for provincial governors to be put into effect. Dong Zhuo became General of the Front, was enfeoffed as Marquis of Taixiang and was summoned to be Governor of Bing Province. Records, Wei 1 §4–5Records, Shu 1 §5Records, Wei 6 §4
In the 3rd year of Chuping (192), the year Dong Zhuo died, Han Sui and Ma Teng led their followings to Chang'an and surrendered. The Han court made Han Sui General Who Guards the West and sent him back to Liang Province, and made Ma Teng General Who Conquers the West and had him station himself at Mei County. The biography of Xiahou Yuan records that Song Jian of Fuhan, taking advantage of the turmoil in Liang Province, styled himself King of Heshou Who Pacifies the Han and was destroyed by Xiahou Yuan more than thirty years later. Records, Wei 6 §22Records, Shu 6 §25Records, Wei 9 §22
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
Belligerents
| Item | A | B |
|---|---|---|
| Factions | Eastern Han | |
| Commanders | Dong Zhuo, Sun Jian, Zhang Wen(張溫), Tao Qian | Han Sui, Ma Teng |
| Strength | 衆十餘萬 |
Factions, commanders, strength and casualties are checked against the source texts (3KDEX). Strength and casualties show only figures stated in the sources. Source: Wei 6 §22