Zhang He 張郃

RecordsRomance Wei Courtesy name 雋乂 Junyi장합준예张郃

Profile
OccupationRGeneral · General of Chariots and Cavalry Who Conquers the WestFactionWei
AppearsRNBiography inBook of Wei
BornR? N? UnverifiedNative placeHejian Commandery Mao County
DiedR231 N(same) UnverifiedPlace of deathRNMumendao
Cause of deathNKilled in battle Unverified
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR65

Profile

Zhang He, courtesy name Junyi, was a native of Mao County in Hejian Commandery. He served Han Fu and Yuan Shao, then went over to Cao Cao during the Battle of Guandu. Records, Wei 17 §42–44

In Hanzhong he held off Liu Bei together with Xiahou Yuan, and when Xiahou Yuan was killed in battle he took command of the army at the men's urging. Under Cao Rui he crushed Zhuge Liang's general Ma Su at Jieting and rose to General of Chariots and Cavalry Who Conquers the West (zhengxi juji jiangjun), and in the 9th year of Jianxing (231), while pursuing the withdrawing Zhuge Liang, he was struck by an arrow and died. Records, Wei 17 §47–49 · 51 · 53 · 55Records, Shu 3 §12

In his assessment, Chen Shou wrote that Zhang He was praised for his deft adaptability, but that his deeds did not match his reputation, perhaps because something had been omitted from the records. In the Romance his name first appeared in Chapter 22, when Kong Rong listed him among Yuan Shao's famous generals, and he featured in 23 of its 120 chapters; his name appears in the title of Chapter 101, "Rushing to Jiange, Zhang He Falls into a Trap." Records, Wei 17 §74Romance, Ch. 22 §30Romance, Ch. 101 §49

In the Records

At the end of the Han he answered a call for recruits to fight the Yellow Turbans, became a Major of the Army (jun sima), and was attached to Han Fu. When Han Fu was defeated he took his troops over to Yuan Shao and, as a Colonel, held off Gongsun Zan; for his many merits when Gongsun Zan was crushed he was transferred to General of the Household Who Pacifies the State (ningguo zhonglang jiang). Records, Wei 17 §42

At Guandu, when Cao Cao personally attacked Chunyu Qiong at Wuchao, Zhang He told Yuan Shao that Lord Cao's troops were elite and Chunyu Qiong had to be relieved at once. When Guo Tu said that attacking Cao Cao's main camp would resolve the matter of itself, Zhang He countered that Lord Cao's camp was strong and would not fall, and that if Chunyu Qiong were captured they would all become prisoners. Yuan Shao sent only light cavalry to the rescue and attacked Cao Cao's camp with his main army, but could not take it, and when Chunyu Qiong was defeated Yuan Shao's army collapsed. Guo Tu, ashamed, slandered Zhang He, claiming he had rejoiced at the defeat and spoken insolently, and Zhang He, afraid, went over to Cao Cao. Records, Wei 17 §42–44

The Annals of Emperor Wu record that Yuan Shao had sent Zhang He and Gao Lan to attack Cao Hong, and that they came and surrendered on hearing that Chunyu Qiong had been defeated; the biography of Xun You records that the two burned their siege towers and surrendered, and that when Cao Hong was suspicious, Xun You persuaded him to accept them, saying, "Zhang He has come in anger because his plan was not used." Cao Cao, overjoyed, likened him to Weizi leaving Yin and Han Xin going over to Han, and made him Lieutenant General (pian jiangjun) and Marquis of a Chief Precinct (duting hou). Records, Wei 1 §70Records, Wei 10 §60Records, Wei 17 §45

He took part in the capture of Ye and the attack on Yuan Tan at Bohai, and in the campaign against Liucheng he served in the vanguard with Zhang Liao, for which he was transferred to General Who Pacifies the Di (pingdi jiangjun). With Zhang Liao he defeated Chen Lan and Mei Cheng, took part in the defeat of Ma Chao and Han Sui at Weinan, and besieged Anding, forcing Yang Qiu to surrender. With Xiahou Yuan he campaigned against Liang Xing and the Di of Wudu, and pacified Song Jian. Records, Wei 17 §45–46

In the 20th year of Jian'an (215), when Cao Cao campaigned against Zhang Lu, Zhang He first attacked Dou Mao, king of the Di of Xinghe, and cleared the way ahead with 5,000 infantry. After Zhang Lu surrendered, he stayed in Hanzhong with Xiahou Yuan and others to hold off Liu Bei. He forced Badong and Baxi to submit and moved their people to Hanzhong, then advanced to Dangqu but was checked by Zhang Fei and fell back to Nanzheng. The biography of Zhang Fei records that after a standoff of more than fifty days Zhang Fei blocked him by another route and fought him, and that because the mountain paths were narrow Zhang He's front and rear could not support each other and he was defeated; Zhang He abandoned his horse, climbed into the mountains, and made his way back to Nanzheng by a byway with some ten men. Records, Wei 1 §145–146Records, Wei 17 §46–47Records, Shu 6 §19

When Liu Bei was stationed at Yangping and Zhang He at Guangshi, Liu Bei divided more than ten thousand picked troops into ten units and launched a sudden night attack, but Zhang He led his personal guard into close combat and held him off. Later, when Xiahou Yuan was killed fighting Liu Bei, the three armies blanched. Xiahou Yuan's major Guo Huai put Zhang He forward as commander of the army, saying, "General Zhang is a famous general of the state and the man Liu Bei fears," and Du Xi, together with Guo Huai, gathered up the various units. When Zhang He put the troops in order, the men's hearts were calmed, and Cao Cao sent an envoy to lend him the tally (jia jie). Records, Wei 17 §47–49Records, Wei 23 §40

When Cao Pi became King of Wei, Zhang He was made General of the Left and Marquis of a Chief District (duxiang hou), and when Cao Pi took the imperial throne he was raised to Marquis of Mao. With Cao Zhen he campaigned against the Lushui Hu and the Eastern Qiang, and with Xiahou Shang he attacked Jiangling, crossing the Yangtze to take the fortified camp on a sandbar. When Cao Rui came to the throne he was stationed in Jing Province, and with Sima Yi he pursued Sun Quan's detached commander Liu A and others as far as Qikou and defeated them. Records, Wei 17 §50

When Zhuge Liang came out to Mount Qi, Zhang He was given the rank of Specially Advanced (tejin) and, commanding the various armies, held off Ma Su at Jieting. Ma Su relied on the steep ground of the Southern Mountain and did not come down to hold the town; Zhang He cut off his route for drawing water, attacked, and crushed him. He also pacified Nan'an, Tianshui and Anding, which had risen in response to Zhuge Liang, and his fief grew to 4,300 households. The biography of Guo Huai dates this to the 2nd year of Taihe (228), and the biography of Wang Ping records that as the army scattered, only Wang Ping's thousand men held firm, beating their drums, so that Zhang He, suspecting an ambush, did not approach. Records, Wei 17 §51–52Records, Wei 26 §68Records, Shu 13 §36

When Zhuge Liang came out again and pressed his attack on Chencang, Cao Rui summoned Zhang He by post-horse, saw him off in person at Henan City, gave him 30,000 troops, and asked whether, if he arrived late, Zhuge Liang would not already have taken Chencang. Knowing that Zhuge Liang's army had no grain, Zhang He replied, "Before your servant arrives, Zhuge Liang will already have fled; his provisions will not last ten days." He pressed on day and night, and when he reached Nanzheng Zhuge Liang withdrew; Zhang He was made General of Chariots and Cavalry Who Conquers the West. Records, Wei 17 §52–53

Zhang He understood the workings of change and was skilled at laying out camps and formations; whenever he assessed the course of battle and the terrain, everything went as he had reckoned, so that all, from Zhuge Liang down, feared him. Though a military man, he cherished Confucian scholars and recommended Bei Zhan of his home district, and Cao Rui, commending his intent, made Bei Zhan an Erudite (boshi). Records, Wei 17 §54

When Zhuge Liang came out to Mount Qi once more, Zhang He, commanding the generals, reached Lueyang, and when Zhuge Liang turned back to hold Mount Qi, Zhang He pursued him as far as Mumen and engaged him, but a stray arrow struck his right knee and he died. He was posthumously titled Marquis Zhuang, and Cao Rui divided his fief to enfeoff four of his sons as full marquises (liehou). The Biography of the Later Sovereign records that in the 6th month of the 9th year of Jianxing (231) Zhang He pursued Zhuge Liang, who was withdrawing because his provisions had run out, as far as Qingfeng and was killed by an arrow, while the biography of Zhuge Liang records that Zhuge Liang shot Zhang He dead. Records, Wei 17 §55Records, Shu 3 §12Records, Shu 5 §37

In his assessment, Chen Shou wrote that among Cao Cao's five fine generals, Zhang He was praised for his deft adaptability, but that on examining his deeds they did not match the reputation one heard of; perhaps something had been omitted from the records, so that his were not set out in as full detail as those of Zhang Liao and Xu Huang. Records, Wei 17 §74

In the Romance

His name first appeared in Chapter 22 of the Romance, when Kong Rong listed him together with Gao Lan and Chunyu Qiong as famous generals under Yuan Shao. At Guandu in Chapter 30 he fought Zhang Liao for forty or fifty bouts without a decision, and when fire broke out at Wuchao he offered to go to the rescue with Gao Lan, but on Guo Tu's advice they attacked Cao Cao's camp instead and were badly defeated by the combined assault of Xiahou Dun, Cao Ren and Cao Hong. When Guo Tu slandered the two, claiming they had deliberately held back, and Yuan Shao summoned them, Gao Lan beheaded the envoy and the two surrendered to Cao Cao. Cao Cao likened this to Weizi leaving Yin and Han Xin returning to Han, and made Zhang He Lieutenant General and Marquis of a Chief Precinct. Romance, Ch. 22 §30Romance, Ch. 30 §7 · 42–43 · 46–50

At Changban in Chapter 41, riding behind a banner inscribed "Zhang He of Hejian," he fought Zhao Yun for more than ten bouts and gave chase, and just as he was about to spear Zhao Yun, who had tumbled into a pit, Zhao Yun's horse leapt out amid a flash of red light. In the archery contest at the Bronze Bird Terrace in Chapter 56, he galloped, twisted around in the saddle, and shot backward to hit the center of the target. Romance, Ch. 41 §58Romance, Ch. 56 §12–13

In Chapter 70 he set up three camps at Dangqu, Mengtou and Dangshi with 30,000 troops and held out against Zhang Fei for more than fifty days. When Zhang Fei got drunk every day and hurled abuse at him, he raided the camp by night, but the Zhang Fei in the tent was a straw dummy; he lost all three camps and Wakou Pass and entered Nanzheng on foot. When Cao Hong wanted to behead him, Guo Huai talked him out of it. He then lost to Huang Zhong and Yan Yan, and lost Mount Tiandang as well. Romance, Ch. 70 §1 · 5 · 9–11 · 20–21 · 29 · 46

In Chapter 95 Cao Rui made him vanguard and sent him with Sima Yi, and at Jieting, following Sima Yi's dispositions, he surrounded the hill and fought Wang Ping for dozens of bouts. In Chapter 99 he and Dai Ling were lured by Zhuge Liang and surrounded; after breaking out, finding Dai Ling missing, he charged back into the encirclement and brought him out. Romance, Ch. 95 §1 · 22–25Romance, Ch. 99 §12–13

In Chapter 101, when Zhuge Liang withdrew, he volunteered to pursue, and when Sima Yi tried to stop him on account of his hasty temper, he said, "When a true man gives his life to repay his country, he has no regret though he die ten thousand deaths." Drawn on by Wei Yan and Guan Xing, who took turns feigning defeat, he chased them into Mumendao, where the way was blocked with logs and stones, and he was killed together with more than a hundred of his officers by crossbow bolts pouring down from both sides. Sima Yi lamented, "Zhang Junyi's death is my fault," and the ruler of Wei gave him a lavish burial. Romance, Ch. 101 §41–49 · 52

Where the Romance differs

Surrender at Guandu: In Chapter 30 of the Romance, when Yuan Shao summoned them to answer for their failure, Gao Lan beheaded the envoy, and Zhang He, saying he too had long harbored such thoughts, surrendered with him. The biography of Zhang He in the Records states that he went over out of fear of Guo Tu's slander; the Annals of Emperor Wu, that he surrendered on hearing of Chunyu Qiong's defeat while attacking Cao Hong; and the biography of Xun You, that he burned the siege towers and surrendered. There is no episode of Gao Lan beheading an envoy. Romance, Ch. 30 §47–49Records, Wei 17 §44Records, Wei 1 §70Records, Wei 10 §60

Attack on Cao Cao's camp: In Chapter 30 of the Romance, Zhang He and Gao Lan attacked Cao Cao's camp and were badly defeated by the combined assault of Xiahou Dun, Cao Ren and Cao Hong. The biography of Zhang He in the Records says only that Yuan Shao attacked Cao Cao's camp with his main army but could not take it. Romance, Ch. 30 §46Records, Wei 17 §43

Zhao Yun at Changban: The scene in Chapter 41 of the Romance in which Zhang He tried to spear Zhao Yun, who had fallen into a pit, and let him escape is not in Zhang He's biography in the Records. Romance, Ch. 41 §58Records, Wei 17 §41–55

Defeat at Dangqu: In Chapter 70 of the Romance, Zhang Fei feigned drunkenness, set up a straw dummy, and turned Zhang He's raid against him, and when Zhang He returned defeated, Cao Hong wanted to behead him but Guo Huai talked him out of it. In the biography of Zhang Fei in the Records, Zhang Fei blocked Zhang He's army by another route, and because the mountain paths were narrow its front and rear could not support each other, so it was defeated. There is no story of the dummy or of Cao Hong's punishment. Romance, Ch. 70 §9–10 · 21Records, Shu 6 §19Records, Wei 17 §47

After Xiahou Yuan's death: In Chapter 71 of the Romance, Zhang He, his way blocked by Zhao Yun, fled and met Du Xi, and together they received Cao Cao. In the Records, when the three armies had blanched, Guo Huai put Zhang He forward as commander of the army, calling him "a famous general of the state," and Du Xi also helped gather up the various units and steady the men. Romance, Ch. 71 §30 · 32Records, Wei 17 §48–49Records, Wei 23 §40

The battle of Jieting: In Chapter 95 of the Romance, Sima Yi surveyed the situation at Jieting and laid the plan, while Zhang He, as vanguard, surrounded the hill and fought Wang Ping. The biography of Zhang He in the Records states that Zhang He, commanding the various armies, cut off the water route and crushed Ma Su, and the Annals of Emperor Ming also name the general who crushed Zhuge Liang at Jieting as General of the Right Zhang He. Romance, Ch. 95 §22–25Records, Wei 17 §51Records, Wei 3 §8

Chencang: In Chapter 98 of the Romance, Zhuge Liang raided and took Chencang while Zhang He was on his way to replace the ailing Hao Zhao. In the Records, when Zhuge Liang pressed his attack on Chencang, Cao Rui summoned Zhang He and saw him off; Zhang He reckoned that Zhuge Liang's provisions would not last ten days, and when he reached Nanzheng Zhuge Liang withdrew. The Biography of the Later Sovereign also records that Zhuge Liang besieged Chencang and withdrew when his provisions ran out. Romance, Ch. 98 §37Records, Wei 17 §52–53Records, Shu 3 §9

Place and manner of death: In Chapter 101 of the Romance, he brushed aside Sima Yi's attempt to hold him back, gave chase, fell into the ambush at Mumendao, and was killed together with more than a hundred of his officers by a hail of crossbow bolts. The biography of Zhang He in the Records states that he pursued as far as Mumen, joined battle, and died when a stray arrow struck his right knee, and the Biography of the Later Sovereign names the place as Qingfeng. Sima Yi's attempt to stop him is not in Zhang He's biography. Romance, Ch. 101 §41 · 49Records, Wei 17 §55Records, Shu 3 §12

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA8866−22
  • STR7082+12
  • INT7862−16
  • POL4035−5
  • CHA7052−18
  • VIR5855−3
  • ADP7245−27
  • SCH4532−13
  • DIP3832−6
  • DIS5850−8
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

AdaptabilityR72N45 −27

RWent over to Taizu when slandered by Guo Tu; Taizu likened him to Weizi and Han XinWei 17 §43

NSurrendered to Cao Cao with Gao Lan; badly defeated after underestimating Zhang Fei; killed at the end of a reckless pursuitCh. 30 §48Ch. 69 §48Ch. 101 §42

CharismaR70N52 −18

RPut forward after Xiahou Yuan fell, he steadied the army, and the men accepted his commandWei 17 §48Wei 23 §40

NCao Cao likened him to Weizi and Han Xin; at his death Sima Yi and the ruler of Wei mourned himCh. 30 §50Ch. 101 §52

ScholarshipR45N32Unverified −13

RThough a military man, he cherished Confucian scholarsWei 17 §54

NNo direct record — estimated from his career as a warriorCh. 101 §8

StrengthR70N82 +12

RHeld off Liu Bei in close combat with his personal guard; an edict said he prevailed wherever he wentWei 17 §48Wei 17 §51

NFought Zhang Liao to a draw over forty or fifty bouts; broke through the encirclement to rescue Dai Ling; valor ten thousand men could not withstandCh. 30 §7Ch. 99 §13Ch. 99 §24

4 similar abilities — show evidence
  • PoliticsR40UnverifiedN35Unverified −5

    RNo direct record — estimated from his moving the people of Badong and BaxiWei 17 §47

    NNo direct record — estimated as a commander defending strategic pointsCh. 67 §55

  • VirtueR58N55 −3

    RLeft Yuan Shao after being slandered; received an edict saying he kept the court in his heartWei 17 §44Wei 17 §54

    NSaid he cherished loyalty and wished to repay his country; Guo Huai doubted his surrenderCh. 101 §8Ch. 70 §30

  • DiplomacyR38UnverifiedN32Unverified −6

    RNo direct record — estimated from his career as a warriorWei 17 §47

    NNo direct record — only his rebuke of KongmingCh. 99 §12

  • DiscernmentR58N50 −8

    RRecommended Bei Zhan, versed in the classics and upright in conduct, who was made an EruditeWei 17 §54

    NJudged that Huang Zhong combined resourcefulness and valorCh. 71 §15Ch. 70 §43

Special — talents Records +0 · Romance +10

  • Archery

    NSkilled +10 Galloping, twisted around in the saddle and shot backward to hit the center of the targetCh. 56 §12

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (23)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Allegiance history Changed allegiance 2 times

  1. Han Fu faction (190~191) Served · Records · Records vol. 17 「漢末應募討黃巾,爲軍司馬,屬韓馥。」
  2. Yuan Shao faction (191~200) Defected · Records · Records vol. 17 「馥敗,以兵歸袁紹。」
  3. Wei (200~231) Defected · Records · Records vol. 17 「」郃懼,乃歸太祖。」

Related events (27)

Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).