Battle

Battle of Nanpi 南皮之戰

About this event

The Battle of Nanpi was the campaign of the 1st month of spring in the 10th year of Jian'an (205) in which Cao Cao attacked Yuan Tan, who had fled to Nanpi, and took his head. While Cao Cao was besieging Ye, Yuan Tan seized Ganling, Anping, Bohai and Hejian and even took over Yuan Shang's followers, and Cao Cao, saying he had broken his pledge, severed the marriage alliance with him and advanced. Yuan Tan abandoned Pingyuan and fled to Nanpi, and in the 1st month Cao Cao broke him, beheading Yuan Tan, Guo Tu and others and putting his wife and children to death, and Ji Province was pacified. Records, Wei 1 §87–88Records, Wei 6 §67

Chen Shou recorded this battle in the Annals of Emperor Wu (Records of Wei 1) and the Biographies of Dong Zhuo, the Two Yuans and Liu Biao (Records of Wei 6), and also included parts of it in the biography of Cao Chun in the Biographies of the Xiahou and Cao Clans (Records of Wei 9), the biography of Wang Xiu in the Biographies of Yuan, Zhang, Liang, Guo, Tian, Wang, Bing and Guan (Records of Wei 11), the Biographies of Zhang, Yue, Yu, Zhang and Xu (Records of Wei 17) and elsewhere. The Romance depicts it in the first part of Chapter 33 as a battle in which Yuan Tan fights with the people of Nanpi driven in front of his troops and is killed. Records, Wei 1 §87–89Records, Wei 6 §67Records, Wei 9 §45–46Records, Wei 11 §61–63Records, Wei 17 §21Romance, Ch. 33 §10–22

Course of events in the Records

While Cao Cao was besieging Ye, Yuan Tan attacked and seized Ganling, Anping, Bohai and Hejian, and attacked Yuan Shang at Zhongshan, taking over all the followers of Yuan Shang, who fled to Gu'an and placed himself under Yuan Xi. Cao Cao sent Yuan Tan a letter reproaching him for breaking his pledge, severed the marriage alliance and sent the daughter back, and then advanced. Records, Wei 1 §87Records, Wei 6 §67

Yuan Tan, afraid, abandoned Pingyuan, took Nanpi as well, and camped in person at Longcou. In the 12th month of the 9th year of Jian'an (204) Cao Cao entered Pingyuan, attacked and pacified its counties, and drew up his army before Yuan Tan's gates, but Yuan Tan did not come out and fled at night to Nanpi, where he camped by the Qing River. Records, Wei 1 §87Records, Wei 6 §67

In the 1st month of spring in the 10th year of Jian'an (205) Cao Cao attacked Nanpi. According to the biography of Cao Chun, when Yuan Tan came out to fight and many of Cao Cao's soldiers died, Cao Cao wanted to slacken the attack. Cao Chun, who commanded the Tiger and Leopard Cavalry, said that having come a thousand li, to withdraw without a victory would cost them their prestige, that an army deep in enemy territory could hardly hold out long, and that the enemy was proud in victory while they themselves were fearful in defeat, and that attacking a proud enemy with fearful troops was sure to succeed. Cao Cao approved his words and attacked fiercely, Yuan Tan was defeated, and horsemen under Cao Chun's command took Yuan Tan's head. The biography of Yue Jin records that Yue Jin led the way in through Yuan Tan's east gate. Records, Wei 1 §88Records, Wei 9 §45–46Records, Wei 17 §21

Cao Cao beheaded Yuan Tan, Guo Tu and others and put his wife and children to death, and Ji Province was pacified. Cao Cao issued an order making a fresh start even with those who had joined the Yuans in their evil deeds, and forbade the people to take private vengeance or to hold lavish funerals. When he first attacked Yuan Tan he had ordered that people who had fled to avoid the corvée of breaking the ice not be accepted when they surrendered, and to one who came to the gate of the camp and gave himself up, Cao Cao said to go and hide himself well so as not to be caught by the officials, and sent him back; that man was caught in the end. Records, Wei 1 §88–89Records, Wei 6 §67

Yuan Tan's Attendant Officer with Separate Carriage, Wang Xiu, was transporting grain at Le'an when he heard that Yuan Tan was in danger and hurried to him, but at Gaomi he heard of Yuan Tan's death, and weeping, he asked Cao Cao to let him collect the body and bury it, and was granted permission. After breaking Nanpi, Cao Cao saw that Wang Xiu's house held less than ten hu of grain but several hundred scrolls of books, and sighed that a gentleman does not win his name for nothing. The biographies of Guo Jia, Xun You, Xu Huang and others also record that they took part in the attack on Yuan Tan at Nanpi. Records, Wei 11 §61–63Records, Wei 14 §37Records, Wei 10 §63Records, Wei 17 §60

In the same month Yuan Xi's senior generals Jiao Chu, Zhang Nan and others attacked Yuan Xi and Yuan Shang, and the two fled to the Wuhuan of the Three Commanderies, while Jiao Chu and the others surrendered their counties to Cao Cao and were enfeoffed as full marquises. Records, Wei 1 §88Records, Wei 6 §68

In the Romance

In Chapter 33 of the Romance, when Cao Cao, having pacified Ji Province, summoned Yuan Tan and he did not come, Cao Cao severed the marriage alliance and advanced on Pingyuan. Yuan Tan asked Liu Biao for help, but Liu Biao, on Liu Bei's advice, only sent a letter urging the brothers to make peace, and Yuan Tan abandoned Pingyuan and fled to Nanpi. Romance, Ch. 33 §10–13

When the bitter cold froze the waterways, Cao Cao made the people break the ice and haul the boats, and to the people who had run away and then came back of their own accord to give themselves up, he said to hide in the mountains so as not to be caught by his soldiers, and sent them back. On the field of battle Yuan Tan's general Peng An was cut down by Xu Huang, and Xin Ping, who had gone to arrange a surrender, came back after Cao Cao refused to accept it, and when Yuan Tan suspected him of divided loyalty, he collapsed in indignation and died. Romance, Ch. 33 §14–17

On Guo Tu's advice, Yuan Tan drove the people of Nanpi out in front, opened the four city gates and came out to fight, and when no decision had been reached from the hour of chen to the hour of wu, Cao Cao climbed a hill and beat the drum himself. Yuan Tan was killed in the fighting by Cao Hong's blade, and Guo Tu, fleeing toward the city, was struck by an arrow from Yue Jin and fell into the moat. When Yuan Tan's head was hung outside the north gate, Wang Xiu, Attendant Officer with Separate Carriage of Qing Province, defied the order against mourning and wept for him, and Cao Cao, calling him a man of righteousness, made him General of the Household in Charge of Metals. Romance, Ch. 33 §17–22

Where the Romance differs

Who killed Yuan Tan: In Chapter 33 of the Romance, Yuan Tan was killed in the fighting by Cao Hong's blade. In the biography of Cao Chun in the Records, it was horsemen under Cao Chun's command who took Yuan Tan's head. Romance, Ch. 33 §19Records, Wei 9 §46

The turning point of the battle: In Chapter 33 of the Romance, when Yuan Tan fought with the people driven in front and no decision was reached, Cao Cao beat the drum himself to rouse his officers and men. In the biography of Cao Chun in the Records, when Yuan Tan came out to fight and many soldiers died, Cao Cao wanted to slacken the attack, but on Cao Chun's advice he attacked fiercely and won. Romance, Ch. 33 §17–18Records, Wei 9 §45

Guo Tu's death: In Chapter 33 of the Romance, Guo Tu, fleeing toward the city, was struck by an arrow from Yue Jin and fell into the moat. The account of Yuan Shao in the Records records that Cao Cao took Nanpi and beheaded Yuan Tan, Guo Tu and others. Romance, Ch. 33 §19Records, Wei 6 §67

Wang Xiu's lament: In Chapter 33 of the Romance, Wang Xiu was seized while weeping, against orders, beneath Yuan Tan's head hung outside the north gate. In the biography of Wang Xiu in the Records, Wang Xiu, on his way to rescue Yuan Tan, heard of his death at Gaomi and wept, and went to Cao Cao to ask to collect the body. Romance, Ch. 33 §20–22Records, Wei 11 §61–62

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Belligerents

ItemAB
FactionsWeiYuan Tan faction
CommandersCao Cao, Cao Chun, Guo Jia, Xun You, Zhang Xiu(張繡), Yue Jin, Xu Huang, Zhang HeYuan Tan, Guo Tu

Factions, commanders, strength and casualties are checked against the source texts (3KDEX). Strength and casualties show only figures stated in the sources. Source: Wei 1 §88

Romance chapters (1)

Records volumes (7)