Battle

Battle of Mount Dingjun 定軍山之戰

About this event

The Battle of Mount Dingjun was the battle in the spring of the 24th year of Jian'an (219), during the Hanzhong Campaign, in which Liu Bei's army defeated and beheaded Xiahou Yuan in the area of Mount Dingjun. Liu Bei, who had been confronting the enemy at Yangping Pass for more than a year, crossed the Mian River and set up camp at Mount Dingjun, and when Xiahou Yuan came to contest the ground, Huang Zhong, following Fa Zheng's advice, attacked from the heights and routed him. After Xiahou Yuan and Zhao Yong, Inspector of Yi Province, and others were killed, the Wei army put forward Zhang He as its commander and restored order to the camps. Records, Wei 9 §24Records, Shu 2 §38Records, Shu 7 §31–32Records, Wei 17 §48–49

Chen Shou recorded this battle in parts, in Records of Shu 2 (the Biography of the First Sovereign), Records of Shu 6 (the Biographies of Guan, Zhang, Ma, Huang and Zhao) and Records of Shu 7 (the Biographies of Pang Tong and Fa Zheng), and in Records of Wei 9 (the Biographies of the Xiahou and Cao Clans), Records of Wei 17 (the Biographies of Zhang, Yue, Yu, Zhang and Xu) and Records of Wei 26 (the Biographies of Man, Tian, Qian and Guo). The Romance depicts this battle at the end of Chapter 70, where Huang Zhong volunteers to attack Mount Dingjun, and in Chapter 71, "Occupying the Opposite Hill, Huang Zhong Waits at Ease for the Weary Enemy." Records, Shu 2 §38Records, Shu 6 §36Records, Shu 7 §31–32Records, Wei 9 §24–25Records, Wei 17 §48–49Records, Wei 26 §63–64Romance, Ch. 70 §49–52Romance, Ch. 71 §1–31

Course of events in the Records

In the 23rd year of Jian'an (218) Liu Bei halted at Yangping Pass, confronting Xiahou Yuan, Zhang He and others, and the Biography of Xiahou Yuan records that this standoff lasted into the next year. According to the Biography of Zhang He, Liu Bei was stationed at Yangping and Zhang He at Guangshi, and when Liu Bei divided more than 10,000 picked troops into ten units and made a sudden night attack on Zhang He, Zhang He led his personal troops in hand-to-hand fighting and Liu Bei could not win. Cao Cao had reached Chang'an in the 9th month of that year and was staying there. Records, Shu 2 §37Records, Wei 9 §24Records, Wei 17 §47–48Records, Wei 1 §163

In the 1st month of the 24th year (219) Liu Bei burned the abatis of the encircling works at night. The Biography of Xiahou Yuan records that Xiahou Yuan had Zhang He guard the eastern siege lines while he himself guarded the southern ones with lightly armed troops, and that when Liu Bei challenged Zhang He to battle and Zhang He's army fared badly, Xiahou Yuan split off half of the troops under him to help Zhang He, was attacked by Liu Bei and was killed in battle. The Biography of Zhang He records that when Liu Bei burned the main siege lines at Zouma Valley, Xiahou Yuan went to put out the fire, met Liu Bei on another road, and died fighting at close quarters with short weapons. Records, Wei 9 §24Records, Wei 17 §48

The Biography of the First Sovereign records that in the spring of the 24th year Liu Bei crossed the Mian River southward from Yangping, advanced little by little along the mountains and set up camp using the terrain of Mount Dingjun, and the Biography of Fa Zheng says that he set up camp at Dingjun and Xingshi. When Xiahou Yuan came with troops to contest the ground, Fa Zheng said they could attack, and Liu Bei had Huang Zhong climb to the heights and attack with drums beating and battle cries, routing Xiahou Yuan's army and beheading Xiahou Yuan and Zhao Yong, whom Cao Cao had appointed Inspector of Yi Province, among others. Records, Shu 2 §38Records, Shu 7 §31–32

The Biography of Huang Zhong records that although Xiahou Yuan's troops were very well trained, Huang Zhong pressed forward relentlessly with spearheads in front, urging on his men, so that gongs and drums shook the heavens and battle cries echoed through the valleys, and in a single battle he beheaded Xiahou Yuan and routed his army. Huang Zhong was promoted to General Who Conquers the West. Records, Shu 6 §36

Having lost their commander, the three armies of Wei all turned pale, fearing that Liu Bei would take advantage of the moment. Xiahou Yuan's Major Guo Huai, who had been kept from the battle by illness, gathered the scattered soldiers and put Zhang He forward as commander of the army, saying that Zhang He was a famous general of the state whom Liu Bei feared. Zhang He put the troops in order and steadied the camps, and the generals accepted his command, while the Biography of Du Xi records that Du Xi took charge of the armies' affairs together with Zhang He and Guo Huai. Zhang He returned to Yangping. Records, Wei 17 §48–49Records, Wei 26 §63Records, Wei 23 §39–40

The next day, when Liu Bei wanted to cross the Han River to attack, the generals wanted to deploy along the river to resist him. Guo Huai said that this would be showing weakness, and proposed deploying far from the river and striking when the enemy was halfway across; when they had deployed, Liu Bei grew suspicious and did not cross. Cao Cao, at Chang'an, approved of this, lent Zhang He the tally of authority and made Guo Huai Major again, and he made Cao Zhen Protector of the Army for the Campaign against Shu, leading Xu Huang and others to defeat Liu Bei's detached general Gao Xiang at Yangping. Records, Wei 26 §64Records, Wei 17 §49Records, Wei 9 §63

The Biography of Xiahou Yuan records that although Xiahou Yuan won many battles, Cao Cao always warned him that a general must at times know fear and that one who relies on valor alone is a match only for a single man. Xiahou Yuan's posthumous title was Marquis Min. On hearing of Fa Zheng's plan, Cao Cao said that he had known Xuande was incapable of such a thing and must have been taught by someone. In the 3rd month Cao Cao himself came out through the Xie Valley and reached Yangping. Records, Wei 9 §24–25Records, Shu 7 §32Records, Wei 1 §166

In the Romance

At the end of Chapter 70 of the Romance, Liu Bei asked Huang Zhong, who had taken Mount Tiandang, whether he could take Mount Dingjun, saying that it was the bulwark protecting Nanzheng and the place where grain and fodder were stored. Zhuge Liang said that Xiahou Yuan was not to be compared with Zhang He and that Guan Yu must be summoned from Jing Province, whereupon Huang Zhong, saying that he was not yet seventy, volunteered to bring back Xiahou Yuan's head with the 3,000 troops of his own command. Romance, Ch. 70 §49–52

In Chapter 71, Zhuge Liang sent Fa Zheng along with him and had Zhao Yun, Liu Feng and Meng Da back him up. Cao Cao, staying at Nanzheng, sent Xiahou Yuan a letter in his own hand saying that a general must use both firmness and gentleness and that one who relies on valor alone is a match only for a single man, and ordered him to advance, and Xiahou Yuan set out, brushing aside Zhang He's attempt to stop him. Xiahou Shang feigned defeat and captured Huang Zhong's lieutenant Chen Shi, but Huang Zhong, following Fa Zheng's advice, advanced building camps at every step and captured Xiahou Shang, and at the exchange of prisoners shot an arrow into Xiahou Shang's back as he returned. Romance, Ch. 71 §1–2 · 13–22

At Fa Zheng's urging, Huang Zhong attacked the opposite mountain west of Mount Dingjun by night, drove off Du Xi and took the summit. Even when Xiahou Yuan's troops surrounded the mountain, hurling abuse and challenging him to battle, Fa Zheng raised a white flag to hold the troops back, and when after noon the enemy grew weary and dismounted to rest, he waved a red flag. Huang Zhong led the way down the mountain, chased Xiahou Yuan to beneath his parasol, and with his treasured sword cut him down from the head to the shoulder. Romance, Ch. 71 §24–28

Zhang He, fleeing in defeat, found his road blocked by Zhao Yun, and on hearing from Du Xi that Mount Dingjun had already been taken by Liu Feng and Meng Da, he fell back to the Han River and set up camp. Cao Cao wailed aloud at the news of Xiahou Yuan's death and only then understood Guan Lu's prophecy, that "three and eight crossing" meant the 24th year of Jian'an and "the yellow pig meets the tiger" meant the 1st month of the jihai year, and he set out for Mount Dingjun in person to take revenge. Liu Bei promoted Huang Zhong, who had presented Xiahou Yuan's head, to Grand General Who Conquers the West. Romance, Ch. 71 §29–31 · 33

Where the Romance differs

Who held Mount Dingjun: In Chapters 70 and 71 of the Romance, Mount Dingjun was a great Wei camp held by Xiahou Yuan, and Huang Zhong attacked it. In the Biography of the First Sovereign in the Records, when Liu Bei crossed the Mian River and set up camp at Mount Dingjun, Xiahou Yuan came to contest the ground. Romance, Ch. 70 §49Romance, Ch. 71 §16–17Records, Shu 2 §38

Xiahou Yuan's end: In Chapter 71 of the Romance, Huang Zhong came down from the opposite mountain and cut down Xiahou Yuan with his treasured sword beneath his parasol. The Biography of Xiahou Yuan in the Records says that after the abatis was burned he split off troops to help Zhang He and was killed in battle when he was attacked; the Biography of Zhang He says that he went to put out the fire at Zouma Valley, met Liu Bei and died fighting with short weapons; and the Biography of Huang Zhong records that Huang Zhong beheaded Xiahou Yuan in a single battle. Romance, Ch. 71 §28Records, Wei 9 §24Records, Wei 17 §48Records, Shu 6 §36

Fa Zheng's plan: In Chapter 71 of the Romance, Fa Zheng occupied the opposite mountain and signaled the moment with white and red flags. In the Biography of Fa Zheng in the Records, Fa Zheng said they could attack when Xiahou Yuan came to contest the ground, and Huang Zhong attacked from the heights with drums beating. Romance, Ch. 71 §24–27Records, Shu 7 §32

Cao Cao's warning: In Chapter 71 of the Romance, Cao Cao, at Nanzheng, ordered Xiahou Yuan to advance with a letter in his own hand telling him not to rely on valor alone. The Biography of Xiahou Yuan in the Records records these words as a warning Cao Cao habitually gave, and at this time Cao Cao was at Chang'an, reaching Yangping only in the 3rd month, after Xiahou Yuan's death. Romance, Ch. 71 §13–14Records, Wei 9 §25Records, Wei 17 §49Records, Wei 1 §166

After Xiahou Yuan's death: In Chapter 71 of the Romance, Zhang He, his road blocked by Zhao Yun and Mount Dingjun lost to Liu Feng and Meng Da, fell back to the Han River. In the Records, Guo Huai, Du Xi and others put forward Zhang He as commander of the army and steadied the camps, and Zhang He returned to Yangping. Romance, Ch. 71 §29–30Records, Wei 17 §48–49Records, Wei 26 §63Records, Wei 23 §40

Huang Zhong's office: In Chapter 71 of the Romance, Liu Bei promoted Huang Zhong to Grand General Who Conquers the West. In the Biography of Huang Zhong in the Records, the office to which Huang Zhong was promoted was General Who Conquers the West. Romance, Ch. 71 §33Records, Shu 6 §36

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Belligerents

ItemAB
FactionsShuWei
CommandersFa Zheng, Huang Zhong, Liu BeiXiahou Yuan, Zhang He

Factions, commanders, strength and casualties are checked against the source texts (3KDEX). Strength and casualties show only figures stated in the sources. Source: Shu 2 §38

Romance chapters (2)

Records volumes (8)

Related works (1)

Linked via Wikidata "depicts" and character names in titles (unverified) — not yet reviewed.