Man Chong 滿寵

RecordsRomance Wei Courtesy name 伯寧 Boning満寵만총백녕满宠

Profile
OccupationRGeneral · General Who Conquers the East NStrategist · Staff AdviserFactionWei
AppearsRNBiography inBook of Wei
BornR? UnverifiedNative placeShanyang Commandery Changyi County
DiedR242 UnverifiedPlace of death
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR33

Profile

Man Chong, courtesy name Boning, was a man of Changyi County in Shanyang Commandery. At eighteen he became Investigator (duyou) of his commandery, and when Cao Cao took charge of Yan Province he was summoned as an Attendant Officer, and served as Prefect of Xu and Administrator of Runan. When Guan Yu besieged Fancheng, he helped Cao Ren hold the city. Records, Wei 26 §2–3 · 5–8

Under Emperor Ming, as General Who Conquers the East, he commanded the military affairs of Yang Province and repeatedly repelled Sun Quan's attacks at Hefei, and he had the city of Hefei moved to a strong position to the west and built anew. In the 2nd year of Jingchu (238) he became Grand Commandant, and he died in the 3rd year of Zhengshi (242). Records, Wei 26 §11–13 · 17–20 · 22–23

In his assessment Chen Shou, author of the Records, said of him that he was 'firm and resolute in purpose, brave and also resourceful'. In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 10 as a man recommended by Liu Ye and appears in 12 of its 120 chapters; no chapter title bears his name. He is portrayed as an adviser who persuades Xu Huang to come over and who urges Cao Ren at Fancheng to hold the city firmly. Records, Wei 26 §80Romance, Ch. 10 §23Romance, Ch. 14 §29–32Romance, Ch. 74 §39–40

In the Records

At eighteen Man Chong became Investigator of his commandery and brought to heel Li Shuo and others, who kept private troops and preyed on the common people, so that they never plundered again. While acting as Prefect of Gaoping, when Zhang Bao, a man of Gaoping County serving as Investigator of the commandery, took bribes and disrupted the administration, Man Chong arrested him, interrogated him until he died that same day, and then abandoned his office and went home. Records, Wei 26 §2

When Cao Cao took charge of Yan Province, Man Chong became an Attendant Officer, and when Cao Cao became General-in-Chief, he became Prefect of Xu after serving as Clerk of the Western Bureau. When retainers of Cao Hong repeatedly broke the law in Xu, he arrested and punished them, ignored a letter from Cao Hong, and, sensing that Cao Cao meant to pardon them, quickly had them executed. Cao Cao was pleased and said, 'Is this not just how a man in charge of affairs should be?' When the former Grand Commandant Yang Biao was handed over to prison, Xun Yu and Kong Rong asked that he not be tortured, but Man Chong interrogated him according to the law and then told Cao Cao that if Yang Biao's guilt was not clear, he would greatly lose the trust of the people, so that Yang Biao was pardoned that same day. Xun Yu and Kong Rong thought all the better of Man Chong for this. Records, Wei 26 §3–4

When Yuan Shao was powerful north of the Yellow River, in Runan, Yuan Shao's home commandery, his disciples and retainers held out with troops under their command. Made Administrator of Runan, Man Chong gathered 500 men, took more than twenty fortified camps, lured out more than ten chieftains who had not surrendered and killed them on the spot, and so pacified the commandery. He obtained 20,000 households and 2,000 soldiers and set them to farming. Records, Wei 26 §5

In the 13th year of Jian'an (208) he followed the campaign against Jing Province and remained at Dangyang as acting General of Vigorous Might; he then became Administrator of Runan again and was granted the rank of Marquis Within the Passes. When Guan Yu besieged Xiangyang, Man Chong helped Cao Ren and was stationed at Fancheng, but the armies of Yu Jin and others were engulfed and routed by water swollen by the long rains, and Fancheng too collapsed in many places. When someone proposed escaping by boat at night, Man Chong said that water coming down from the mountains would not last long, and that Guan Yu, who had sent detached commanders as far as the vicinity of Jia County yet did not dare advance, was afraid of being struck from behind; if they fled now, the land south of the great river would no longer belong to the state. Records, Wei 26 §6–7

When Cao Ren followed this advice, Man Chong drowned a white horse and swore an oath with the soldiers. When the relief army of Xu Huang and others arrived, he fought hard and won merit, and Guan Yu withdrew. He was enfeoffed as Marquis of Anchang Precinct. Records, Wei 26 §8

When Emperor Wen became King, Man Chong became General Who Displays Martial Might, and for his merit in defeating Wu at Jiangling he became General Who Calms the Waves and was stationed at Xinye. When he faced the enemy across the water at Jinghu, he had his troops prepare, saying that with the wind so fierce the enemy was sure to come and set fires, and in the middle of the night he defeated ten enemy detachments that came, and became Marquis of Nanxiang. In the 3rd year of Huangchu (222) he was granted the staff and battle-axe of authority, and in the 5th year (224) he became General of the Front. Records, Wei 26 §8–9

When Emperor Ming took the throne, Man Chong became Marquis of Changyi, and in the 2nd year of Taihe (228) he concurrently served as Inspector of Yu Province. When Cao Xiu was to advance south from Lujiang, Man Chong submitted a memorial saying that the route was easy to advance along but hard to retreat by, and that they should guard against Wuqiangkou. Before a reply came, Cao Xiu went deep into enemy territory and had his way back cut off at Jiashi, and only managed to return when Zhu Ling and others came up from behind. When Cao Xiu died, Man Chong, as General of the Front, replaced him in command of the military affairs of Yang Province. Records, Wei 26 §10–11

In the 4th year of Taihe (230) he became General Who Conquers the East. That winter, when Sun Quan withdrew, an edict came ordering the troops to be disbanded, but Man Chong judged it a feigned retreat and did not disband them; ten days or so later Sun Quan did indeed come again and attacked the city of Hefei, but could not take it. The next year, when the Wu general Sun Bu asked to surrender and requested that troops be sent to receive him, Man Chong judged it a ruse and gave no troops to the Inspector Wang Ling, and the 700 infantry and cavalry that Wang Ling sent separately were attacked by Sun Bu at night, with more than half killed or wounded. Records, Wei 26 §12–14

When Wang Ling's faction slandered Man Chong as old, worn out and unreasonable, Emperor Ming summoned him, but seeing that he was sturdy in body and vigour, sent him back. When Man Chong repeatedly asked to stay at court, Emperor Ming cited Lian Po and Ma Yuan, asked how he could call himself old when he was not, and had him guard the frontier. The next year, when Lu Xun came against Lujiang, Man Chong advanced to Yangyikou, saying that the enemy had left their boats and come 200 li so that their rear was empty, and the enemy fled that night. Records, Wei 26 §15–16

In the 1st year of Qinglong (233) Man Chong submitted a memorial proposing that, since the city of Hefei was close to the water and hard to relieve, a new city be built on strong ground 30 li to the west. Jiang Ji opposed this as a show of weakness, but Man Chong submitted memorial after memorial citing the words of Sunzi, and the Master of Writing Zhao Zi judged his plan the better, so permission was granted. That year Sun Quan, because the new city was far from the water, could not leave his boats for twenty days, and when he came ashore to parade his strength, several hundred of his men were beheaded by 6,000 troops that Man Chong had hidden in ambush at Feicheng. Records, Wei 26 §17–20

The following year, when Sun Quan reached the New City of Hefei claiming 100,000 men, Man Chong had a few dozen stout men pour hemp oil on pine torches and set fires from upwind, burning the siege engines, and shot and killed Sun Tai, the son of Sun Quan's younger brother. The Annals of Emperor Ming record that at this time Man Chong wanted to withdraw the garrison of the New City, but Emperor Ming would not allow it, and Sun Quan fled before Emperor Ming's army arrived. In the 8th month of the 3rd year of Qinglong (235) Man Chong smashed the Wu military farms north of the Yangtze and burned their grain. Records, Wei 26 §20–21Records, Wei 3 §37–38

In the 2nd year of Jingchu (238), because of his advanced age, he was summoned to court and became Grand Commandant. Since he had no wealth left in his household, Emperor Ming granted him fields, grain and money to make known his pure and frugal integrity, and his fief came to 9,600 households in all. He died in the 3rd month of the 3rd year of Zhengshi (242) and was given the posthumous title Marquis Jing. In his assessment Chen Shou said that he was firm and resolute in purpose, brave and also resourceful. Records, Wei 26 §22–23 · 80Records, Wei 4 §13

In the Romance

In Chapter 10 of the Romance, Liu Ye recommends him together with Lü Qian, describing him as 'a man of Changyi in Shanyang, surnamed Man, named Chong, with the courtesy name Boning', and Cao Cao makes the two of them Attendant Officers in the Army. Man Chong and Lü Qian in turn recommend Mao Jie. In Chapter 14, when Cao Cao wants to win over Xu Huang, a general under Yang Feng and Han Xian, by stratagem rather than force, Man Chong, an Attendant Officer with the army, says that he once made Xu Huang's acquaintance, disguises himself as a common soldier and slips into his camp at night. Romance, Ch. 10 §23Romance, Ch. 14 §28–29

Man Chong persuades Xu Huang, saying, 'A good bird chooses the tree it nests in, and a worthy minister chooses the lord he serves,' and when Xu Huang refuses his suggestion to kill Yang Feng and Han Xian as a gift of introduction, Man Chong calls him 'a truly righteous gentleman'. Xu Huang comes over to Cao Cao with Man Chong that very night, and after the imperial carriage is brought to Xudu, Man Chong becomes Prefect of Xudu. Romance, Ch. 14 §30–32 · 34

In Chapter 20, Cao Cao has Yang Biao falsely accused of colluding with Yuan Shu, throws him into prison and has Man Chong interrogate him, but on Kong Rong's remonstrance merely strips him of office and sends him home. In Chapter 21, Man Chong returns from spying on Yuan Shao and, with Liu Bei present, reports how Gongsun Zan built and held the Yijing Tower and was crushed by Yuan Shao. In Chapter 23, when Cao Cao boasts of his men, saying, 'Lü Qian and Man Chong serve as Attendant Officers,' Mi Heng mocks Man Chong as fit only 'to drink wine and eat the dregs'. In Chapter 31 he guards Runan together with Xiahou Dun to hold off Liu Biao. Romance, Ch. 20 §9Romance, Ch. 21 §22Romance, Ch. 23 §12–13Romance, Ch. 31 §44

In Chapter 73, following Sima Yi's plan, Cao Cao gives Man Chong a letter and sends him to Sun Quan, and Man Chong asks for a joint attack on Jing Province, proposing that they divide the land after defeating Liu Bei. Sun Quan treats him with the courtesy due a guest and sends him back to Xudu. Man Chong then becomes a staff adviser assisting Cao Ren at Fancheng; when Guan Yu comes, he urges that holding firm is the best plan, only to be told by Xiahou Cun that these are 'the words of a scholar', and even after Cao Ren has lost Xiangyang he keeps saying 'we must only hold firm', for which the subordinate general Lü Chang scoffs at 'the words of you civil officials'. Romance, Ch. 73 §16–19 · 21 · 24 · 40–41 · 48–49

In Chapter 74, when Yu Jin's seven armies are engulfed by the water, the walls of Fancheng too collapse and the commanders propose escaping by boat, Man Chong remonstrates that water coming down from the mountains will drain away in less than ten days, and that Guan Yu, having already sent detached commanders to Jiaxia yet not advancing, is wary of being struck from behind; if they abandon the city, the land south of the Yellow River will no longer belong to the state. Cao Ren says, 'Had it not been for Boning's counsel, I would almost have ruined a great matter,' rides a white horse up onto the wall and swears an oath with his commanders, and within ten days the water recedes. Romance, Ch. 74 §38–40

In Chapter 96, when Cao Xiu, deceived by Zhou Fang, advances into Wu, Jia Kui leads the General of the Front Man Chong and Hu Zhi, Administrator of Dongguan (東莞), toward Dongguan (東關); in Chapter 98 a memorial from Man Chong and others reports to Cao Rui that Sun Quan has proclaimed himself emperor and that Lu Xun is training troops at Wuchang. In Chapter 103, when Sun Quan invades along three routes, Man Chong goes with Cao Rui to relieve Hefei, and seeing the Wu warships lined up at the mouth of Lake Chao, proposes a night attack on their water camp that very night. Zhang Qiu and Man Chong, each with 5,000 men, strike in the second watch and burn the warships, provisions and equipment, and Zhuge Jin flees to Miankou. Romance, Ch. 96 §24Romance, Ch. 98 §46Romance, Ch. 103 §4–5

Where the Romance differs

Entering service: In Chapter 10 of the Romance, he becomes an Attendant Officer in the Army on Liu Ye's recommendation. In the Records, he became Investigator of his commandery at eighteen and abandoned his office while acting as Prefect of Gaoping, and when Cao Cao took charge of Yan Province he summoned him and made him an Attendant Officer. No one is recorded as having recommended him. Romance, Ch. 10 §23Records, Wei 26 §2–3

Xu Huang's defection: In Chapter 14 of the Romance, Man Chong disguises himself as a common soldier, enters Xu Huang's camp, persuades him and brings him over. In the Biography of Xu Huang in the Records, Xu Huang urged Yang Feng to submit to Cao Cao, and when Yang Feng changed his mind, Xu Huang came over to Cao Cao on his own when Cao Cao attacked Yang Feng at Liang. The Biography of Man Chong also contains nothing about persuading Xu Huang. Romance, Ch. 14 §29–32Records, Wei 17 §57Records, Wei 26 §1–23

Yang Biao's imprisonment: In Chapter 20 of the Romance, Cao Cao heeds Kong Rong's remonstrance and merely strips Yang Biao of office and sends him home. In the Records, Xun Yu and Kong Rong asked that he not be tortured, but Man Chong interrogated him according to the law, and Yang Biao was pardoned that same day after Man Chong told Cao Cao that if his guilt was not clear, the trust of the people would be lost. Romance, Ch. 20 §9Records, Wei 26 §3–4

Runan: In Chapter 31 of the Romance, in the 7th year of Jian'an (202) he guards Runan together with Xiahou Dun to hold off Liu Biao. In the Records, he became Administrator of Runan when Yuan Shao was powerful, and pacified it by taking more than twenty fortified camps held by Yuan Shao's disciples and retainers. Romance, Ch. 31 §44Records, Wei 26 §5

Envoy to Sun Quan: In Chapter 73 of the Romance, Man Chong goes to Sun Quan with a letter from Cao Cao and asks for a joint attack on Jing Province. This episode does not appear in the Biography of Man Chong in the Records. The Records says only that when Guan Yu besieged Fancheng, Sima Yi and Jiang Ji proposed having Sun Quan strike at Guan Yu's rear, and Cao Cao followed this advice. Romance, Ch. 73 §17–19Records, Wei 26 §1–23Records, Shu 6 §11

The oath of the white horse: In Chapter 74 of the Romance, Cao Ren, having heard Man Chong's remonstrance, rides a white horse up onto the wall and swears an oath with his commanders. In the Records, when Cao Ren agreed, saying 'Good', Man Chong drowned a white horse and swore an oath with the soldiers, and when Xu Huang's relief army arrived, he fought hard and won merit. Romance, Ch. 74 §40Records, Wei 26 §8

His position at Fancheng: In Chapter 73 of the Romance, Man Chong is a staff adviser assisting Cao Ren and is called 'a scholar' and 'a civil official' by the generals. In the Records, Man Chong was at that time Administrator of Runan and Marquis Within the Passes and was stationed at Fancheng helping Cao Ren, and earlier he had also been stationed at Dangyang as acting General of Vigorous Might. Romance, Ch. 73 §24 · 40–41 · 49Records, Wei 26 §6

The fighting at Hefei: In Chapter 103 of the Romance, he goes to Hefei with Cao Rui and, together with Zhang Qiu, raids the Wu water camp at the mouth of Lake Chao by night and burns the warships. In the Records, when Sun Quan reached the New City of Hefei in the 2nd year of Qinglong (234), Man Chong had a few dozen stout men burn the siege engines with torches and shot and killed Sun Tai, the son of Sun Quan's younger brother, and Emperor Ming set out east on campaign in person, but Sun Quan fled while the emperor's army was still several hundred li away. There is no raid on a water camp. Romance, Ch. 103 §4–5Records, Wei 26 §20–21Records, Wei 3 §37–38

His death: In the Romance, Man Chong does not appear after Chapter 103, and his death is not recorded. In the Records, he became Grand Commandant in the 2nd year of Jingchu (238), died in the 3rd year of Zhengshi (242) and received the posthumous title Marquis Jing. Romance, Ch. 103 §49Records, Wei 26 §22–23

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA8062−18
  • STR5540−15
  • INT8274−8
  • POL6845−23
  • CHA7045−25
  • VIR8245−37
  • ADP7058−12
  • SCH4038−2
  • DIP6074+14
  • DIS5555±0
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

VirtueR82N45 −37

RDid not build up property and was praised as pure, loyal and frugal, though he also had a man die under interrogationWei 26 §22Wei 26 §4

NUrged holding Fancheng, but advised Xu Huang to kill his former masters as a gift of introductionCh. 14 §31Ch. 74 §39

CharismaR70N45Unverified −25

RWhen he left, the soldiers and people of Runan missed him so much that they followed him in crowds and could not be stoppedWei 26 §11

NNo direct record — estimated from the record of his being recommended for his reputationCh. 10 §23

PoliticsR68N45Unverified −23

RAs Prefect of Xu he dealt with a powerful man's retainers according to the law, and set 20,000 households in Runan to farmingWei 26 §3Wei 26 §5

NNo direct record — estimated from official roles such as interrogating Yang BiaoCh. 20 §9

LeadershipR80N62 −18

RPacified more than twenty fortified camps in Runan with 500 men and routed Sun Quan's troops with an ambush; the assessment calls him brave and resourcefulWei 26 §5Wei 26 §20Wei 26 §80

NStruck the Wu water camp from the east bank with 5,000 men and won a great victoryCh. 103 §5

StrengthR55N40Unverified −15

RFought hard and won merit at Fancheng; the assessment calls him braveWei 26 §8Wei 26 §80

NNo direct record — estimated from his part in the raid on the water campCh. 103 §5

DiplomacyR60N74 +14

RPersuaded Taizu to pardon Yang Biao, and answered Sun Bu's feigned surrender with a letterWei 26 §4Wei 26 §13

NSlipped in secretly and persuaded Xu Huang to come over, and as envoy urged Sun Quan to a joint attack on Jing ProvinceCh. 14 §31Ch. 14 §32Ch. 73 §19

AdaptabilityR70N58 −12

RResolved to hold Fancheng when it was flooded and everyone wanted to flee; handled a case and then abandoned his officeWei 26 §7Wei 26 §2

NStopped Cao Ren from abandoning the city and had him hold it, and the water receded in ten daysCh. 74 §39Ch. 74 §40

3 similar abilities — show evidence
  • IntelligenceR82N74 −8

    RForesaw the enemy's night attack and feigned retreat, and his plan to move Hefei to a new city was adoptedWei 26 §8Wei 26 §12Wei 26 §19

    NSaw that the water would soon recede and read Guan Yu's intentions, urging the defence of Fancheng, and proposed a night raidCh. 74 §39Ch. 73 §48Ch. 103 §4

  • ScholarshipR40UnverifiedN38Unverified −2

    RNo direct record — estimated from his career as an Attendant Officer, county prefect and other official postsWei 26 §3

    NNo direct record — estimated from his conduct as a civil official serving as an Attendant OfficerCh. 10 §23

  • DiscernmentR55N55 ±0

    RJudged Cao Xiu to be intelligent and decisive but inexperienced in war, and warned against his planWei 26 §10

    NRecognized Xu Huang's valour and resourcefulness and brought him to Cao CaoCh. 14 §30

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (12)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Allegiance history

  1. Wei · Records · Records vol. 26 「景初二年,以寵年老徵還,遷爲太尉」

Related events (4)

Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).