Cao Xiu 曹休

RecordsRomance Wei Courtesy name 文烈 Wenlie조휴문열

Profile
OccupationRNGeneral · Grand MarshalFactionWei
AppearsRNBiography inBook of Wei
BornR? N? UnverifiedNative placePei Commandery Qiao County Unverified
DiedR228 N(same) UnverifiedPlace of deathNLuoyang County
Cause of deathRIllness NIllness Unverified
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR66

Profile

Cao Xiu, courtesy name Wenlie, was a clan nephew of Taizu (Cao Cao). Having lost his father in childhood, he took his aged mother across the Yangtze to Wu, then changed his name and returned north to meet Taizu. Taizu called him "the thousand-li colt of our family" and had him live with Emperor Wen. Records, Wei 9 §54

He joined Cao Hong's army at Xiabian and defeated Wu Lan; under Emperor Wen, as General-in-Chief Who Conquers the East, he attacked Lü Fan of Wu at Dongpu, and under Emperor Ming he commanded Yang Province as Grand Marshal. In the 2nd year of Taihe (228), deceived by a feigned surrender from Wu, he advanced deep into enemy territory and was defeated at Shiting, and in the 9th month of that year he died of an abscess on his back. Records, Wei 9 §55–59Records, Wei 3 §9–10

In his assessment, Chen Shou grouped him with Xiahou Dun, Cao Ren, Cao Hong and others as close kinsmen and old friends who assisted in the great enterprise at their lord's side and rendered meritorious service. In the Romance he first appeared in Chapter 56 at the archery contest at the Bronze Sparrow Terrace and featured in 11 of its 120 chapters, and in Chapter 96 he fell into Zhou Fang's trap and suffered a crushing defeat at Shiting. Records, Wei 9 §132Romance, Ch. 56 §10Romance, Ch. 96 §35–40

In the Records

Cao Xiu, courtesy name Wenlie, was a clan nephew of Taizu. When the realm fell into chaos and his clan scattered, he lost his father when he was a little over ten years old. Alone with one retainer he carried the coffin and gave his father a temporary burial, then took his aged mother across the Yangtze to Wu. When Taizu raised his loyalist army, Cao Xiu changed his name and moved to Jing Province, then returned north by byways to meet Taizu. Taizu told those around him, "This boy is the thousand-li colt of our family," and had him live with Emperor Wen, treating him like a son. Records, Wei 9 §54

He constantly accompanied the campaigns and commanded the Tiger and Leopard Cavalry as a palace guard. When Liu Bei sent his general Wu Lan to garrison Xiabian, Taizu sent Cao Hong to attack him, making Cao Xiu Chief Commandant of Cavalry and a participant in Cao Hong's military affairs, and told him, "Though you are an adviser, you are in fact the commander." Cao Hong, hearing this, also left matters to Cao Xiu. According to the biography of Xin Pi, Xin Pi also took part at this time, and Taizu issued an order saying that "the concerns of Zuozhi and Wenlie are not light." Records, Wei 9 §55Records, Wei 25 §8

When Liu Bei stationed Zhang Fei at Gushan to cut off the army's rear, the council wavered. Cao Xiu said that if the enemy truly meant to cut the road, they would have hidden their troops and moved in secret; since they were loudly announcing their strength beforehand, it meant they could not do it. He urged a swift attack on Wu Lan before the enemy could assemble, saying that Zhang Fei would then flee of his own accord. Cao Hong followed this and crushed Wu Lan, and Zhang Fei did indeed flee. The Annals of Emperor Wu record that in the 3rd month of the 23rd year of Jian'an (218) Zhang Fei and Ma Chao fled to Hanzhong. Records, Wei 9 §55–56Records, Wei 1 §160

When Taizu withdrew his army from Hanzhong and the armies returned to Chang'an, Cao Xiu became Central Commander of the Army. When Emperor Wen took the royal throne, he became General Who Commands the Army, and for his merits early and late he was made Marquis of Dongyang Village. When Xiahou Dun died, he became General Who Guards the South and, bearing the Tally, commanded the armies; Emperor Wen came in person to see him off, stepping down from his carriage to clasp his hand in farewell. Records, Wei 9 §56

When Sun Quan sent a general to garrison Liyang, Cao Xiu arrived and defeated him, and he separately sent troops across the Yangtze to burn several thousand households of the enemy camp at Wuhu. He was transferred to General Who Conquers the East, concurrently Inspector of Yang Province, and promoted to Marquis of Anyang District. When Emperor Wen attacked Sun Quan, Cao Xiu became General-in-Chief Who Conquers the East and was granted the Yellow Axe; leading Zhang Liao and others and more than twenty armies from the provinces and commanderies, he defeated Sun Quan's senior general Lü Fan and others at Dongpu. Records, Wei 9 §57

According to the biography of Dong Zhao, in the 3rd year of Huangchu (222), facing the Yangtze at Dongpukou, Cao Xiu submitted a memorial saying he would lead elite troops to sweep through the lands south of the river. Emperor Wen, worried that he would cross the river at once, sent an edict by post horse to stop him, and Dong Zhao said that if Zang Ba and the others did not advance, Cao Xiu's resolve would falter of its own accord. Soon afterwards a violent wind drove the enemy's ships to the foot of the camps of Cao Xiu and the others, and they beheaded and captured many, but the armies failed to advance in time and the enemy's relief ships arrived. The biography of the Sovereign of Wu records that in the winter of that year Cao Xiu had Zang Ba raid Xuling with five hundred light boats and ten thousand death-defying men. Records, Wei 14 §70–72Records, Wu 2 §47

He became Governor of Yang Province. In the 5th month of the 7th year of Huangchu (226), when Emperor Wen became gravely ill, he summoned Cao Xiu together with Cao Zhen, Chen Qun and Sima Yi to receive his testamentary edict and assist the succeeding ruler. When Emperor Ming took the throne, Cao Xiu was promoted to Marquis of Changping. When the Wu general Shen De garrisoned Wan, Cao Xiu attacked him and took his head, and Han Zong, Di Dan and others came one after another with their followers to surrender. His fief was increased by 400 households to 2,500 in all, and he was transferred to Grand Marshal, commanding Yang Province as before. The Annals of Emperor Ming record that in that year Cao Xiu defeated a detached Wu commander at Xunyang and became Grand Marshal in the 12th month. Records, Wei 9 §58Records, Wei 2 §52Records, Wei 3 §1 · 4

In the 2nd year of Taihe (228), when Emperor Ming attacked Wu along two routes, Sima Yi went down along the Han River while Cao Xiu led the armies toward Xunyang. In Wu, on Sun Quan's orders, Zhou Fang, Administrator of Poyang, sent a confidant with a letter of seven articles to lure Cao Xiu, and Cao Xiu submitted a memorial saying that since there were enemies asking to surrender, he would advance deep to respond to them. Man Chong submitted a memorial saying that Cao Xiu was intelligent and decisive but had seldom commanded troops, and that the road he was now taking was easy to advance along and hard to retreat on; but before a reply came, Cao Xiu had advanced deep. Records, Wei 9 §58–59Records, Wu 15 §50Records, Wei 15 §81Records, Wei 26 §10–11

Cao Xiu entered Wan with a hundred thousand infantry and cavalry. Zhu Huan said that Cao Xiu had been appointed only because he was a kinsman and was no wise and brave famous general, and proposed cutting the roads at Jiashi and Guache, but Lu Xun rejected it and it was not carried out. Lu Xun himself took the center, with Zhu Huan and Quan Cong as the left and right wings; advancing along three routes, they fell upon Cao Xiu's ambushing troops and pursued them as far as Jiashi, killing or capturing more than ten thousand men. Cao Xiu withdrew and halted at Shiting, where the army panicked at night and the soldiers fell into disorder, abandoning a great deal of armor, weapons and baggage. Records, Wu 11 §53–54Records, Wu 13 §30Records, Wu 15 §72Records, Wei 9 §59

When the Wu army cut off Jiashi and blocked the road home, Jia Kui advanced his army day and night and displayed many flags and drums, and the enemy withdrew. Jia Kui occupied Jiashi and supplied Cao Xiu with troops and provisions, and only then did Cao Xiu's army recover. The two had never been on good terms: during the Huangchu era, when Emperor Wen wished to grant Jia Kui a tally, Cao Xiu had blocked it, saying that Jia Kui was headstrong by nature and looked down on the other generals, so he could not be a commander. Chen Shou wrote that when Cao Xiu was defeated at Jiashi, his army would scarcely have been saved had it not been for Jia Kui. Records, Wei 15 §82–83

When Cao Xiu submitted a letter apologizing for his offense, Emperor Ming sent Yang Ji, Colonel of Garrison Cavalry, to console and reassure him, and the courtesies and gifts he received were even more generous. Because of this affair Cao Xiu developed an abscess on his back and died on the day gengzi in the 9th month of the 2nd year of Taihe (228). He was posthumously named Valiant Marquis (Zhuanghou), and his son succeeded him. Records, Wei 9 §59Records, Wei 3 §9–10

In his assessment, Chen Shou said that since the Xiahou and Cao families had intermarried for generations, Xiahou Dun, Xiahou Yuan, Cao Ren, Cao Hong, Cao Xiu, Xiahou Shang, Cao Zhen and others were all honored and valued in their time as close kinsmen and old friends, assisted in the great enterprise at their lord's side, and all rendered meritorious service. Records, Wei 9 §132

In the Romance

In Chapter 56 of the Romance, when Cao Cao held an archery contest among his military officers at the Bronze Sparrow Terrace, the young general Cao Xiu, from the side of the Cao clan in red battle robes, was the first to gallop out, and he hit the red bull's-eye of the target. Watching from the terrace, Cao Cao was delighted and said, "This boy is the thousand-li colt of our family." Romance, Ch. 56 §9–10

In the battle of Ruxu in Chapter 68, on Cao Cao's orders he hid behind Zhang Liao and shot the horse Ling Tong was riding. In Chapter 69, when Geng Ji, Jin Yi and others rose in revolt in Xudu, he was alerted by Wang Bi, hastily put on his armor and led a thousand or more men to resist the rebels within the city. After the revolt was over, Cao Cao put him in overall command of the troops and horses of the Imperial Guards, and in the Hanzhong campaign of Chapter 71 entrusted him with the rear army. Romance, Ch. 68 §12Romance, Ch. 69 §36 · 43Romance, Ch. 71 §5

In Chapter 80, together with Cao Hong he entered wearing a sword and pressed Emperor Xian to come out to the hall, and drawing his sword he shouted, "Where is the Keeper of the Seals?" After Cao Pi took the throne, in Chapter 84 he led an army out toward Dongkou, but in Chapter 85 a report came that Cao Xiu too had been defeated by Lü Fan. In the campaign against Wu in Chapter 86 he again commanded the rear army. Romance, Ch. 80 §6 · 10Romance, Ch. 84 §12Romance, Ch. 85 §14Romance, Ch. 86 §28

In Chapter 91, when Cao Pi died, together with Cao Zhen, Chen Qun and Sima Yi he set Cao Rui on the throne and became Grand Marshal. When word spread that Sima Yi was plotting rebellion, on Cao Rui's orders he went ahead with troops to confront him and demand an explanation, and after Sima Yi was stripped of office and sent home, he took overall command of the troops and horses of Yong and Liang provinces. Romance, Ch. 91 §19 · 29–31

In Chapter 96, when Zhou Fang, the Administrator of Poyang in Eastern Wu, submitted seven matters offering to surrender, Cao Xiu reported them in a memorial and led a great army to Wancheng. When Cao Xiu tested him with his words, Zhou Fang tried to cut his own throat and then cut off his hair with a sword and threw it on the ground, and Cao Xiu trusted him deeply. When Jia Kui remonstrated that Zhou Fang's oath was a deception, Cao Xiu flew into a rage and was about to have him dragged out and beheaded, but at the entreaty of the generals he instead left Jia Kui's troops behind in camp. Romance, Ch. 96 §23–24 · 29–33

Having encamped at Shiting as Zhou Fang advised, Cao Xiu realized he had fallen into a trap only when he saw that the Wu army had seized the mouth of the valley. He set Zhang Pu and Xue Qiao in ambush to the south and north, but Zhu Huan and Quan Cong, on Lu Xun's orders, circled behind the camp, set fire to it and beheaded Zhang Pu, and the Wei army collapsed. Fleeing along the Jiashi road, Cao Xiu met Jia Kui coming out of a side road and said in shame, "I did not use your words, and have indeed suffered this defeat"; Jia Kui covered the rear, and Cao Xiu escaped with his life. Romance, Ch. 96 §35–41

Chapter 97 states that in the 9th month, in autumn, of the 6th year of Jianxing, Cao Xiu, having suffered a crushing defeat at Shiting, was so terrified that he fell ill from accumulated anxiety, and on reaching Luoyang died when an abscess on his back burst. Cao Rui had him given a generous funeral. Romance, Ch. 97 §1

Where the Romance differs

The words "thousand-li colt": In Chapter 56 of the Romance, Cao Cao said this on seeing Cao Xiu hit the target at the archery contest at the Bronze Sparrow Terrace. In the Records, these were words spoken when the young Cao Xiu, having returned north by way of Wu and Jing Province, first met Taizu. Romance, Ch. 56 §10Records, Wei 9 §54

The revolt in Xudu: In Chapter 69 of the Romance, Cao Xiu resisted the revolt of Geng Ji and Jin Yi within the city. In the Annals of Emperor Wu in the Records, the revolt of the 1st month of the 23rd year of Jian'an (218) was put down by Wang Bi, Chief Clerk to the Chancellor, together with Yan Kuang, Agricultural General of the Household of Yingchuan, and the affair does not appear in Cao Xiu's biography. At this time Cao Xiu was attacking Wu Lan at Xiabian under Cao Hong. Romance, Ch. 69 §36Records, Wei 1 §158–160Records, Wei 9 §55–56

His role at the abdication: In Chapter 80 of the Romance he pressed Emperor Xian together with Cao Hong, wearing a sword. Cao Xiu's biography in the Records says only that when Emperor Wen took the royal throne he became General Who Commands the Army, and does not record anything he did at the abdication. Romance, Ch. 80 §6 · 10Records, Wei 9 §56

The outcome of the battle at Dongkou: In Chapter 85 of the Romance, a report came that Cao Xiu too had been defeated by Lü Fan. In Cao Xiu's biography in the Records, Cao Xiu defeated Lü Fan and others at Dongpu, and the biography of the Sovereign of Wu records that several thousand of the troops of Lü Fan and the others drowned in a great wind. Romance, Ch. 85 §14Records, Wei 9 §57Records, Wu 2 §47

The affair with Sima Yi: In Chapter 91 of the Romance, Cao Xiu confronted Sima Yi, who was suspected of rebellion, and after Sima Yi was dismissed he took overall command of the troops and horses of Yong and Liang provinces. In the Records, Cao Xiu was transferred to Grand Marshal and commanded Yang Province as before, and in the same 12th month Sima Yi became General-in-Chief of Agile Cavalry. Sima Yi's dismissal appears neither in Cao Xiu's biography nor in the Annals of Emperor Ming. Romance, Ch. 91 §29–31Records, Wei 9 §58Records, Wei 3 §4

Zhou Fang's hair: In Chapter 96 of the Romance, Zhou Fang won Cao Xiu's trust by cutting off his hair with a sword in front of him. In Zhou Fang's biography in the Records, when court gentlemen bearing edicts came repeatedly to question him, Zhou Fang cut off his hair at the gate of the commandery office to apologize, and Cao Xiu, hearing of it, suspected him no further. Romance, Ch. 96 §31Records, Wu 15 §73

Jia Kui: In Chapter 96 of the Romance, Cao Xiu was about to behead Jia Kui for remonstrating and instead left his troops behind in camp. In the Records, Jia Kui was heading separately for Dongguan when he received an edict to come east and join forces with Cao Xiu, and he occupied Jiashi and supplied Cao Xiu with troops and provisions. The discord between the two stemmed from Cao Xiu's blocking the grant of a tally to Jia Kui during the Huangchu era. Romance, Ch. 96 §32–33Records, Wei 15 §81–83

The battle of Shiting: In Chapter 96 of the Romance, Cao Xiu set Zhang Pu and Xue Qiao in ambush but was attacked from behind his camp by Zhu Huan and Quan Cong. In Lu Xun's biography in the Records, Lu Xun took the center with Zhu Huan and Quan Cong as the left and right wings, and they advanced along three routes and fell upon Cao Xiu's ambushing troops; Zhang Pu and Xue Qiao do not appear. Romance, Ch. 96 §37–39Records, Wu 13 §30

Place of death: In Chapter 97 of the Romance, Cao Xiu died on reaching Luoyang when an abscess on his back burst. The Records say only that because of this affair Cao Xiu developed an abscess on his back and died, and do not record where he died. Romance, Ch. 97 §1Records, Wei 9 §59Records, Wu 13 §31

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA7248−24
  • STR5062+12
  • INT6225−37
  • POL4835−13
  • CHA6242−20
  • VIR7035−35
  • ADP4530−15
  • SCH3531−4
  • DIP4035−5
  • DIS4525−20
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

IntelligenceR62N25 −37

RSaw through Zhang Fei's bluff and defeated Wu Lan, but ignored warnings and went deep after a feigned surrenderWei 9 §55Wei 9 §56Wei 26 §11

NBelieved Zhou Fang's feigned surrender, entered Shiting and lamented falling into the enemy's trapCh. 96 §35Ch. 96 §36

VirtueR70N35 −35

RAt a little over ten he buried his father and crossed the river caring for his aged motherWei 9 §54

NDrew his sword to demand the imperial seal from Emperor Xian, and tried to behead Jia Kui for remonstratingCh. 80 §10Ch. 96 §33

CharismaR62N42Unverified −20

RTaizu called him the family's thousand-li colt, and the Wu generals Han Zong and Di Dan surrendered one after anotherWei 9 §54Wei 9 §58

NNo direct record — estimated from his command of the Imperial GuardsCh. 69 §43

DiscernmentR45UnverifiedN25 −20

RNo direct record — estimated from his summoning Zhao Yan as military adviserWei 23 §62

NRejected Jia Kui's remonstrance and trusted that Zhou Fang would not deceive himCh. 96 §33Ch. 96 §30

AdaptabilityR45N30 −15

RBelieved Zhou Fang's feigned surrender and advanced deep, and his army collapsedWei 9 §59Wu 15 §72

NKept fighting after falling into the trap but was defeated, and died of illness from accumulated anxietyCh. 96 §36Ch. 97 §1

PoliticsR48UnverifiedN35Unverified −13

RNo direct record — estimated from his posts as Inspector and Governor of Yang ProvinceWei 9 §57Wei 9 §58

NNo direct record — estimated from his overall command of the troops of Yong and Liang provincesCh. 91 §31

StrengthR50UnverifiedN62 +12

RNo direct record — estimated from his commanding the Tiger and Leopard Cavalry as a palace guardWei 9 §55

NHit the bull's-eye at full gallop, and with a hidden shot struck Ling Tong's horseCh. 56 §10Ch. 68 §12

2 similar abilities — show evidence
  • ScholarshipR35UnverifiedN31Unverified −4

    RNo direct record — estimated from his career as a military commanderWei 9 §54

    NNo direct record — estimated from his career as a military commanderCh. 56 §10

  • DiplomacyR40UnverifiedN35Unverified −5

    RNo direct record — little beyond his letter apologizing after the defeatWei 9 §59

    NNo direct record — little beyond meeting Sima Yi face to face to convey the situationCh. 91 §29Ch. 91 §30

Special — talents Records +0 · Romance +10

  • Archery

    NSkilled +10 Hit the bull's-eye at the archery contest at the Bronze Sparrow Terrace, and shot and struck Ling Tong's horseCh. 56 §10Ch. 68 §12

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (11)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Allegiance history

  1. Wei · Records · Records vol. 9 「以休爲騎都尉,參洪軍事」

Family

ChildrenCao Zhao Records

Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.

Related events (9)

Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).