Battle

Battle of Shiting 石亭之戰

About this event

The Battle of Shiting was the battle in the 7th year of Huangwu (228; 2nd year of Taihe in Wei) in which Zhou Fang, Wu's Administrator of Poyang, lured out Cao Xiu, Grand Marshal of Wei, by pretending to defect, and Lu Xun crushed Cao Xiu at Shiting. The Biography of the Lord of Wu records that Zhou Fang lured out Cao Xiu in the 5th month, summer, and that in the 8th month, autumn, Sun Quan arrived at Wankou and had Lu Xun command the generals, while the Annals of Emperor Ming record that in the 9th month, autumn, Cao Xiu reached Wan, fought at Shiting and was defeated. Cao Xiu's army was pursued as far as Jiashi, and Cao Xiu went back, developed an abscess on his back and died. Records, Wu 2 §60Records, Wei 3 §9–10Records, Wu 13 §30–31

Chen Shou divided his account of this battle among the Biography of the Lord of Wu in Records of Wu 2, the Biography of Lu Xun in Records of Wu 13, the biographies of Zhu Huan, Quan Cong and Zhou Fang in Records of Wu 11 and 15, the Annals of Emperor Ming in Records of Wei 3, the Biography of Cao Xiu in Records of Wei 9, and the biographies of Jia Kui, Jiang Ji and Man Chong in Records of Wei 15, 14 and 26. The Romance depicts the battle in Chapter 96, "Zhou Fang Cuts Off His Hair to Deceive Cao Xiu." Records, Wu 2 §60Records, Wu 13 §30–31Records, Wu 11 §53–54Records, Wu 15 §26 · 72–73Records, Wei 3 §9Records, Wei 9 §58–59Records, Wei 15 §81–83Records, Wei 14 §124–125Records, Wei 26 §10–11Romance, Ch. 96 §23–43

Course of events in the Records

In the 2nd year of Taihe (228) Emperor Ming of Wei, planning to attack Wu by two routes, sent Sima Yi down the Han River and had the Grand Marshal Cao Xiu lead the armies toward Xunyang. Jia Kui's biography records that Jia Kui, in command of four armies including those of Man Chong and Hu Zhi, was to advance from Xiyang toward Dongguan, Cao Xiu from Wan, and Sima Yi from Jiangling. Records, Wei 9 §58Records, Wei 15 §81

In Wu, Sun Quan ordered Zhou Fang, Administrator of Poyang, to find among the old clans and chieftains of the mountains someone known to the north and have him lure out Cao Xiu. Zhou Fang replied that such men could not be trusted and the matter might leak, and asked instead to send his confidants Dong Cen and Shao Nan, posing as defectors, to Cao Xiu with a letter in seven articles. In the letter he said that he had been censured by the ruler of Wu and that disaster was only moments away, and that if Cao Xiu came from Wan to the riverbank with ten thousand troops he would lead the officials and people in rising from within, and he asked for seals of general and marquis and the like. When court gentlemen bearing edicts frequently came to question him on various matters, Zhou Fang cut off his hair at the gate of the commandery office to apologize, and Cao Xiu, hearing of it, had no further suspicions. Records, Wu 15 §50–53 · 58 · 67 · 73

Cao Xiu submitted a memorial saying that among the enemy there were men asking to surrender and that he would advance deep to meet them; an edict halted Sima Yi's army and had Jia Kui go east to join Cao Xiu. Jia Kui reckoned that the enemy would concentrate its forces at Wan, and that if Cao Xiu went deep and gave battle he would surely be defeated. Jiang Ji also submitted a memorial warning that if Cao Xiu went deep into enemy territory, Zhu Ran and others upstream would fall on his rear, and Man Chong memorialized that Cao Xiu's route had a lake at its back and ran along the river, easy to advance by and hard to retreat by; but before any reply came, Cao Xiu had already gone deep. Cao Xiu led 100,000 infantry and cavalry, his baggage trains filling the roads, straight into Wan. Records, Wei 15 §81Records, Wei 14 §124Records, Wei 26 §10–11Records, Wu 15 §72Records, Wu 11 §53

Sun Quan arrived at Wan, summoned Lu Xun, granted him the yellow axe and made him Grand Commander. With Lu Xun as commander-in-chief, Quan Cong and Zhu Huan became the Left and Right Commanders, each leading 30,000 men. Zhu Huan said that if Cao Xiu were defeated he would surely flee by Jiashi and Guache, and that if they blocked the road with 10,000 men they could capture Cao Xiu alive and take Shouchun; but Lu Xun, whom Sun Quan consulted, said it would not do, and the plan was not carried out. Records, Wu 13 §30Records, Wu 15 §26Records, Wu 11 §53–54

Cao Xiu realized he had been deceived, but trusting in his numbers he gave battle. Lu Xun took the central division himself, with Zhu Huan and Quan Cong as the left and right wings, and advancing by three routes they struck Cao Xiu's ambush and drove it off, pursuing the fleeing enemy as far as Jiashi. The Biography of Lu Xun says that more than ten thousand were killed or captured, that oxen, horses, mules, donkeys and 10,000 carts were taken, and that the military supplies and equipment were almost all seized; Zhou Fang's biography likewise records that those killed or captured ran to ten thousand or more. The Biography of Cao Xiu records that, having gone deep because of the false surrender, he fared badly, withdrew and camped at Shiting, where at night the army took fright, the soldiers fell into disorder, and a great deal of armor, weapons and baggage was abandoned. Records, Wu 13 §30Records, Wu 15 §72Records, Wei 9 §59

When Jia Kui learned from captured enemy soldiers that Cao Xiu had been defeated and that Sun Quan had sent troops to cut off Jiashi, he rejected his generals' suggestion to wait for the rear army, pressed on day and night and set out many flags and drums as a decoy force. The Wu army withdrew, and Jia Kui occupied Jiashi and supplied Cao Xiu with troops and provisions, so that Cao Xiu's army at last recovered. Jiang Ji's biography says that Wu meant to block Jiashi, but relief troops arrived and the government army escaped annihilation, and Man Chong's biography records that Zhu Ling and others came up from behind and ran into the enemy, who fled in alarm, so that Cao Xiu's army was able to return. Records, Wei 15 §82–83Records, Wei 14 §125Records, Wei 26 §11

Cao Xiu submitted a letter apologizing, and Emperor Ming sent Yang Ji, Colonel of Garrison Cavalry, to console him and treated him with even greater courtesy and gifts, but because of this affair Cao Xiu developed an abscess on his back and died. The Annals of Emperor Ming record that Cao Xiu died on the gengzi day of the 9th month, and that year Man Chong replaced him in command of the armies of Yang Province. In Wu, when the army passed through Wuchang, Sun Quan had Lu Xun covered with his own imperial canopy as he went in and out of the palace gates, and at a banquet he told Zhou Fang that by cutting off his hair and taking duty upon himself he had accomplished a great undertaking, and granted him the title of Assistant General and the rank of Marquis Within the Passes. Records, Wei 9 §59Records, Wei 3 §10Records, Wei 26 §11Records, Wu 13 §31Records, Wu 15 §73

In the Romance

In Chapter 96 of the Romance, Cao Xiu, Grand Commander of Yang Province, submitted a memorial to Cao Rui, ruler of Wei, reporting that Zhou Fang, Wu's Administrator of Poyang, wished to surrender with his commandery and had set out seven matters. Sima Yi said that Wu would be destroyed, but Jia Kui, General Who Establishes Might, said that Zhou Fang was a man of wit and strategy who would never surrender and that this was a ruse to lure out the army. Cao Rui had Sima Yi and Jia Kui support Cao Xiu: Cao Xiu advanced on Wancheng, Jia Kui with Man Chong and Hu Zhi toward Dongguan, and Sima Yi toward Jiangling. Romance, Ch. 96 §23–24

At Wuchang, on Gu Yong's recommendation, Sun Quan made Lu Xun General-in-Chief Who Supports the State and Grand Marshal Who Pacifies the North, granting him the white yak-tail banner and the golden axe, and Lu Xun, with Zhu Huan and Quan Cong as left and right commanders, sent more than 700,000 troops of Jiangnan forward by three routes. Zhu Huan proposed cutting off Jiashi and Guache to capture Cao Xiu, but Lu Xun did not accept, saying he had another clever use in mind. At Wancheng, when Cao Xiu voiced his doubts, Zhou Fang tried to stab himself in the throat with a sword and then cut off his hair and threw it on the ground, and Cao Xiu came to trust him deeply. Romance, Ch. 96 §25–31

Jia Kui remonstrated that Zhou Fang's cutting of his hair was a trick, and Cao Xiu was about to behead him but, at his generals' urging, only stripped him of his command. Stationed at Shiting as Zhou Fang had advised, Cao Xiu saw that the Wu army held the mouth of the hills and realized he had been deceived, and had Zhang Pu and Xue Qiao each lie in ambush with 20,000 men north and south of Shiting. But Zhu Huan beheaded Zhang Pu and Quan Cong routed Xue Qiao and set fire to the rear of the camp, and when Xu Sheng attacked from the front, Cao Xiu fled by the Jiashi road. Jia Kui, appearing from a side road, blocked the pursuit and set up many flags as a decoy force, and Xu Sheng, suspecting an ambush, did not pursue. Romance, Ch. 96 §32–41

Lu Xun captured countless carts, oxen, horses and military supplies, and the troops who surrendered numbered several tens of thousands; Sun Quan came out of Wuchang to welcome Lu Xun, covering him with the parasol of the imperial carriage, and enfeoffed the hairless Zhou Fang as Marquis Within the Passes. The opening of Chapter 97 says that Cao Xiu, heavily defeated at Shiting in the 9th month, autumn, of the 6th year of Jianxing, fell ill from grief and, on reaching Luoyang, died when an abscess on his back burst, and Wu sent an envoy to Shu proposing to attack Wei. Romance, Ch. 96 §42–43Romance, Ch. 97 §1–3

Where the Romance differs

Zhou Fang's cutting of his hair: In Chapter 96 of the Romance, when Cao Xiu voiced his doubts, Zhou Fang cut off his hair with a sword in front of him and threw it on the ground. In the Biography of Zhou Fang in the Records, when court gentlemen bearing edicts frequently came to question him, Zhou Fang cut off his hair at the gate of the commandery office to apologize, and Cao Xiu, hearing of it secondhand, had no suspicions. Romance, Ch. 96 §29–31Records, Wu 15 §73

Jia Kui: In Chapter 96 of the Romance, Jia Kui remonstrated from the start that Zhou Fang's surrender was a ruse, was stripped of his command by Cao Xiu, and then rescued Cao Xiu at Jiashi. In the Biography of Jia Kui in the Records, Jia Kui was heading separately from Xiyang toward Dongguan when an edict had him join Cao Xiu; reckoning that Cao Xiu would surely be defeated if he went deep, he occupied Jiashi and supplied troops and provisions. There is no mention of his doubting Zhou Fang's surrender. Romance, Ch. 96 §23–24 · 32–33 · 40–41Records, Wei 15 §81–83

Strength of the armies: In Chapter 96 of the Romance, Lu Xun led more than 700,000 troops of Jiangnan, and Cao Xiu gave Zhang Pu and Xue Qiao 20,000 men each to lie in ambush. In Zhu Huan's biography in the Records, Cao Xiu reached Wancheng with 100,000 infantry and cavalry, and Quan Cong and Zhu Huan each led 30,000 men. Romance, Ch. 96 §27 · 37Records, Wu 11 §53

Course of the battle: In Chapter 96 of the Romance, Zhu Huan and Quan Cong went around behind the camp and broke Cao Xiu's ambush, while Xu Sheng, as vanguard, attacked from the front. In the Biography of Lu Xun in the Records, Lu Xun took the center and Zhu Huan and Quan Cong the left and right wings, advancing by three routes to drive off Cao Xiu's ambush and pursue as far as Jiashi. Xu Sheng's biography does not include this battle and records only that he died during the Huangwu era. Romance, Ch. 96 §34 · 38–40Records, Wu 13 §30Records, Wu 10 §85–87

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Belligerents

ItemAB
FactionsWuWei
CommandersLu Xun(陸遜), Zhou Fang, Zhu Huan, Quan Cong, Sun QuanCao Xiu, Jia Kui(賈逵)
Strength全琮與桓為左右督,各督三萬人休將步騎十萬至皖城以迎魴
Casualties斬獲萬餘,牛馬騾驢車乘萬輛

Factions, commanders, strength and casualties are checked against the source texts (3KDEX). Strength and casualties show only figures stated in the sources. Source: Wu 2 §60

Romance chapters (2)

Records volumes (9)