Zhu Ran 朱然

RecordsRomance Wu Courtesy name 義封 Yifeng주연의봉

Profile
OccupationRGeneral · Left Grand MarshalFactionWu
AppearsRNBiography inBook of Wu
BornR182 N? UnverifiedNative place丹陽郡
DiedR249 N222 UnverifiedPlace of death
Cause of deathRIllness NKilled in battle Unverified
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR56

Profile

Zhu Ran, courtesy name Yifeng, was the son of Zhu Zhi's elder sister, and his original surname was Shi. Zhu Zhi, who had no son, made him his heir, and because Zhu Ran had studied together with Sun Quan, he became Chief of Yuyao at the age of nineteen. Records, Wu 11 §12–13

In the 24th year of Jian'an (219), together with Pan Zhang, he cut off Guan Yu's path at Linju and captured him, and succeeding Lü Meng in guarding Jiangling, he withstood a siege by the Wei army for six months from the 1st year of Huangwu (222). He rose through General of Chariots and Cavalry to Left Grand Marshal and died in the 12th year of Chiwu (249) at the age of sixty-eight. Records, Wu 11 §14–19 · 21 · 24

In his assessment, Chen Shou said that Zhu Ran and Zhu Huan 'became renowned for their valor and resolve'. In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 75 as one of the seven senior commanders summoned by Lü Meng and appears in 4 of its 120 chapters; no chapter bears his name in its title. In Chapter 77 he takes part in the ambush that captures Guan Yu, and in Chapter 84 he is run through by Zhao Yun's spear and falls from his horse. Records, Wu 11 §67Romance, Ch. 75 §31Romance, Ch. 77 §1–2Romance, Ch. 84 §30

In the Records

Zhu Ran, courtesy name Yifeng, was the son of Zhu Zhi's elder sister, and his original surname was Shi. Since Zhu Zhi had no son, when Zhu Ran was thirteen Zhu Zhi petitioned Sun Ce to let him make Zhu Ran his heir. Sun Ce ordered Danyang Commandery to summon Zhu Ran with gifts of mutton and wine, and when Zhu Ran arrived in Wu, Sun Ce congratulated him with generous courtesy. Records, Wu 11 §12

Zhu Ran had studied together with Sun Quan and formed a close bond with him. When Sun Quan took charge of the government he made the nineteen-year-old Zhu Ran Chief of Yuyao, later transferring him to Magistrate of Shanyin with the added rank of Colonel Who Breaks the Charge and supervision of five counties. Sun Quan, impressed by his ability, split off part of Danyang to form Linchuan Commandery and made him its Administrator with 2,000 troops, and when mountain bandits rose in force, Zhu Ran pacified them within a month. When Lord Cao came out to Ruxu, Zhu Ran guarded the camps at Dawu and Sanguan and was made Lieutenant General. Records, Wu 11 §13

In the 24th year of Jian'an (219), he accompanied Sun Quan in the attack on Guan Yu and, together with Pan Zhang, went separately to Linju and cut off Guan Yu's line of retreat. In the 12th month, Ma Zhong, a Major under Pan Zhang, captured Guan Yu and his son Guan Ping at Zhangxiang. Zhu Ran was transferred to General Who Displays Martial Might and enfeoffed as Marquis of Xi'an District. Records, Wu 11 §14Records, Wu 2 §28Records, Wu 10 §92

When Lü Meng's illness became grave and Sun Quan asked who could replace him, Lü Meng replied that Zhu Ran had courage and steadfastness in abundance and could be entrusted with the post. When Lü Meng died, Sun Quan gave Zhu Ran a tally of authority and had him guard Jiangling. In the 1st year of Huangwu (222), when Liu Bei attacked Yidu, Zhu Ran led 5,000 men and joined forces with Lu Xun to resist him, and separately broke Liu Bei's vanguard and cut off his line of retreat, putting Liu Bei to flight. He was made General Who Conquers the North and enfeoffed as Marquis of Yong'an. Records, Wu 11 §15Records, Wu 13 §17

In the 9th month, in the autumn of that year, Wei sent Cao Zhen, Xiahou Shang, Zhang He and others to surround Jiangling, while Emperor Wen of Wei, Cao Pi, stayed at Wan in person to support them. When Zhang He occupied the island in the middle of the river, Zhu Ran was cut off from outside, and even the relief forces of Pan Zhang, Yang Can and others could not lift the siege. Inside the city many soldiers suffered from a swelling sickness, and only 5,000 were fit to fight. When the enemy built earthen mounds, dug tunnels and raised towers from which arrows poured down like rain, the officers and men all turned pale, but Zhu Ran calmly encouraged his soldiers, watched for openings and broke two of the enemy's camps. When the siege had lasted six months, Yao Tai, Magistrate of Jiangling, was discovered plotting to collude with the enemy and was executed by Zhu Ran. Xiahou Shang and the others could not prevail and withdrew, and Zhu Ran's name resounded in the enemy state; he was re-enfeoffed as Marquis of Dangyang. Records, Wu 2 §42 · 49Records, Wu 11 §16–18

When Sun Quan personally attacked Shiyang and was withdrawing his army, Pan Zhang, commanding the rearguard, fell into disorder at night and could not hold off the enemy; Zhu Ran turned back to block the enemy and only departed slowly after letting the boats ahead get far away. The Biography of Zhu Ran places this in the 6th year, while the Biography of the Lord of Wu dates the attack on Shiyang to the 7th month of the 5th year of Huangwu (226). In the 1st year of Huanglong (229) he became General of Chariots and Cavalry and Right Protector of the Army, concurrently Governor of Yan Province, but soon afterwards he was relieved of the governorship because Yan Province had been allotted to Shu. In the 3rd year of Jiahe (234), when Sun Quan launched a great campaign on a date agreed with Shu, Zhu Ran and Quan Cong each received the battle-axe and became Left and Right Commanders, but their soldiers fell ill, so they withdrew without attacking. Records, Wu 11 §19Records, Wu 2 §54

According to the Annals of Wei, in the 7th month of the 1st year of Jingchu (237), Zhu Ran and others with 20,000 men surrounded Jiangxia Commandery but withdrew when attacked by Hu Zhi, Inspector of Jing Province, and others. In the 5th month of the 2nd year of Zhengshi (241) he besieged Fancheng, and when the Grand Tutor Sima Yi came to resist him, he withdrew in the 6th month. The Biography of the Lord of Wu places this in the 4th year of Chiwu. Records, Wei 3 §53Records, Wei 4 §12Records, Wu 2 §95

When he attacked Zhazhong in the 5th year of Chiwu (242), the Wei commander Pu Zhong blocked a narrow pass in an attempt to cut off Zhu Ran's rear, with Hu Zhi as his support. Zhu Ran's troops had already gone out in all directions and there was no time to gather them, so Zhu Ran led the 800 men of his headquarters guard in a surprise counterattack, putting Pu Zhong at a disadvantage, and Hu Zhi and the others also withdrew. When he attacked Zhazhong again in the 9th year of Chiwu (246), the Wei commander Li Xing and others cut off his line of retreat with 6,000 infantry and cavalry, but Zhu Ran went out at night to meet them, won and returned. Records, Wu 11 §20Records, Wu 2 §104

Before this, Ma Mao, who had come over to Wu, harbored treacherous intentions and was put to death, which greatly angered Sun Quan. Before setting out, Zhu Ran memorialized that if he won he would fill boats with his captures until they choked the river, to relieve the anger of high and low alike; Sun Quan held back the memorial and did not show it. When Zhu Ran reported his victory, Sun Quan brought out the memorial at a banquet, saying he was 'clear-sighted in foreseeing affairs', and sent an envoy to appoint him Left Grand Marshal and Right Military Adviser. The Biography of the Lord of Wu dates this appointment to the 9th month of the 9th year of Chiwu (246). Records, Wu 11 §21Records, Wu 2 §104

Zhu Ran was less than seven chi tall, but his spirit and bearing were distinct; he applied patterns and ornaments only to military equipment and kept everything else plain. Even when there was nothing to do, he had the drums beaten morning and evening so that the soldiers packed their gear and fell into ranks, so that the enemy never knew where to prepare, and he achieved merit every time he went into battle. Although Zhuge Rong and Bu Xie had each succeeded to their fathers' posts, Sun Quan specially made Zhu Ran Grand Commander over them all. In the first month of the 11th year of Chiwu (248) he built walls at Jiangling. Records, Wu 11 §22Records, Wu 2 §106

With Lu Xun also dead, Zhu Ran was the only one of the meritorious officials and famous commanders still alive. When he had been bedridden for two years and his illness grew steadily worse, Sun Quan reduced his meals by day and could not sleep at night, and the messengers carrying medicine and food were within sight of one another on the road. Chen Shou wrote that of the ailing meritorious officials to whom Sun Quan devoted his concern, Lü Meng and Ling Tong mattered most and Zhu Ran came next. When he died in the 3rd month of the 12th year of Chiwu (249) at the age of sixty-eight, Sun Quan put on plain white mourning clothes and grieved for him. His son Shi Ji succeeded him, and in the Wufeng era Shi Ji submitted a memorial and returned to the original surname Shi. Records, Wu 11 §23–24 · 30Records, Wu 2 §107

In his assessment, Chen Shou said that Zhu Zhi and Lü Fan were employed as long-standing retainers, while Zhu Ran and Zhu Huan became renowned for their valor and resolve. Records, Wu 11 §67

In the Romance

In Chapter 75 of the Romance, when Sun Quan makes Lü Meng Grand Commander, Lü Meng dresses soldiers skilled on the water in white clothes as merchants and has seven senior commanders, Han Dang, Jiang Qin, Zhu Ran, Pan Zhang, Zhou Tai, Xu Sheng and Ding Feng, advance one after another. Zhu Ran first appears as one of these seven senior commanders. Romance, Ch. 75 §31

In Chapter 77, Lü Meng, reckoning that Guan Yu will flee by the byway north of Maicheng, has Zhu Ran lie in ambush with 5,000 elite troops 20 li north of Maicheng, instructing him not to meet Guan Yu head-on but to fall on him from behind and drive him toward Linju, and has Pan Zhang lie in ambush on the byway at Linju. When Guan Yu breaks out through the north gate, Zhu Ran levels his spear and shouts, 'Yunchang, do not flee!', urging him to surrender, then soon flees, and when the hidden troops rise he drives Guan Yu onto the Linju byway. After Guan Yu is captured by Ma Zhong, a subordinate commander of Pan Zhang, Zhu Ran and Pan Zhang surround and capture Guan Ping. Romance, Ch. 77 §1–2 · 6–7 · 9

In Chapter 82, Zhu Ran's naval forces are camped on the river. Wu Ban of Shu sends false deserters to leak to Zhu Ran word of a raid on Sun Huan's camp, and Zhu Ran, about to go to Sun Huan's aid, follows the advice of his subordinate commander Cui Yu and sends him instead with 10,000 troops. Cui Yu, caught in a pincer attack by Guan Xing and Zhang Bao, is captured by Zhang Bao, and Zhu Ran sails his ships fifty or sixty li downstream in retreat. Sun Quan, greatly alarmed, says, 'Zhu Ran has been badly defeated on the river.' Romance, Ch. 82 §31–34 · 36 · 38

In Chapter 84, Lu Xun has Zhu Ran advance his troops by water and, when a strong southeast wind rises the following afternoon, load his boats with thatch and act according to the plan. After the Shu camps are burned, Zhu Ran blocks the path of the First Sovereign, fleeing toward Baidicheng, at the riverbank, making the First Sovereign cry out, 'We shall die here!' But around dawn he runs into Zhao Yun, who has hurried from Jiangzhou, and in less than a single bout he is run through by the spear and falls from his horse. Zhu Ran does not appear again in the Romance after this. Romance, Ch. 84 §20 · 28–30

Where the Romance differs

Origins: The Romance merely introduces Zhu Ran among the names of the seven senior commanders in Chapter 75 and says nothing of his family or career. In the Records, Zhu Ran was the son of Zhu Zhi's elder sister, originally surnamed Shi; he became Zhu Zhi's heir and studied together with Sun Quan. Romance, Ch. 75 §31Records, Wu 11 §12–13

The ambush that captured Guan Yu: In Chapter 77 of the Romance, Lü Meng devises the plan and places Zhu Ran in ambush 20 li north of Maicheng and Pan Zhang on the Linju byway. In the Biographies of the Lord of Wu and of Lü Meng in the Records, Sun Quan sent Zhu Ran and Pan Zhang in advance to cut off Guan Yu's route, and in the Biography of Pan Zhang the two reached Linju and camped at Jiashi. Romance, Ch. 77 §1–2Records, Wu 2 §28Records, Wu 9 §85Records, Wu 10 §92

Defeat on the river: In Chapter 82 of the Romance, Zhu Ran is deceived by false deserters, loses his subordinate commander Cui Yu and retreats downstream. This does not appear in the Biography of Zhu Ran in the Records, which states that in the 1st year of Huangwu (222) he led 5,000 men, joined forces with Lu Xun, separately broke Liu Bei's vanguard and cut off his line of retreat. Romance, Ch. 82 §33–36Records, Wu 11 §15

The duel with Zhao Yun: In Chapter 84 of the Romance, Zhao Yun hurries from Jiangzhou to rescue the First Sovereign and knocks Zhu Ran from his horse with his spear. Chen Shou's Biography of Zhao Yun does not record anything Zhao Yun did in the battle of Yiling. Romance, Ch. 84 §29–30Records, Shu 6 §38–42

Death: In the Romance, Zhu Ran does not appear after being run through by Zhao Yun's spear and falling from his horse in the battle of Yiling in Chapter 84, in the 2nd year of Zhangwu (222). In the Records, Zhu Ran died in the 3rd month of the 12th year of Chiwu (249) at the age of sixty-eight, after two years bedridden with illness. Romance, Ch. 84 §30Romance, Ch. 85 §1Records, Wu 11 §23–24Records, Wu 2 §107

After the defense of Jiangling: The Zhu Ran of the Records withstood the Wei siege of Jiangling for six months from the 1st year of Huangwu (222), campaigned at Zhazhong, Fancheng and Jiangxia, and rose to Left Grand Marshal. Since he does not appear in the Romance after Chapter 84, none of this is in the Romance. Records, Wu 11 §16–21Romance, Ch. 84 §30

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA8455−29
  • STR6845−23
  • INT6838−30
  • POL5535−20
  • CHA5540−15
  • VIR7650−26
  • ADP6840−28
  • SCH4530−15
  • DIP3530−5
  • DIS4035−5
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

IntelligenceR68N38 −30

RKept the enemy guessing where to prepare, and Sun Quan called him clear-sighted in foreseeing affairsWu 11 §21Wu 11 §22

NBelieved the words of false deserters and sent a relief forceCh. 82 §33Ch. 82 §34

AdaptabilityR68N40 −28

RRemained calm even under siege, and his courage did not waver in times of crisisWu 11 §17Wu 11 §22

NFollowed his subordinate Cui Yu's advice and stayed to guard the water camp himselfCh. 82 §34

VirtueR76N50Unverified −26

RKept his conduct clean and plain, and executed Yao Tai for colluding with the enemyWu 11 §22Wu 11 §18Wu 11 §30

NNo direct record — estimated from the record of his volunteering for the campaignCh. 82 §21

StrengthR68N45 −23

RLaunched a surprise counterattack with the 800 men of his headquarters guard; Chen Shou: renowned for valor and resolveWu 11 §20Wu 11 §22Wu 11 §67

NWas run through by Zhao Yun's spear and killed in less than a single boutCh. 84 §30

PoliticsR55N35Unverified −20

RServed as Chief of Yuyao and Magistrate of Shanyin, and as Administrator of Linchuan pacified the mountain bandits within a monthWu 11 §13

NNo direct record — estimated from his career as General of Tiger MightCh. 82 §21

CharismaR55N40Unverified −15

RRecommended by Lü Meng for his courage and steadfastness, he encouraged his officers and men under siegeWu 11 §15Wu 11 §17

NNo direct record — estimated from the record of his campaigning as Right CommanderCh. 82 §21

ScholarshipR45N30Unverified −15

RStudied together with Sun Quan in his youthWu 11 §13

NNo direct record — estimated from his conduct as a military commanderCh. 82 §21

2 similar abilities — show evidence
  • DiplomacyR35UnverifiedN30Unverified −5

    RNo direct record — estimated from the record of stating his intentions in a memorial before a campaignWu 11 §21

    NNo direct record — estimated from his conduct as a military commanderCh. 82 §21

  • DiscernmentR40UnverifiedN35 −5

    RNo direct record — estimated from the record of his leading many commanders as Grand CommanderWu 11 §22

    NEntrusted 10,000 men to Cui Yu, who fell into an ambush and was defeatedCh. 82 §34Ch. 82 §36

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (4)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Allegiance history

  1. Wu · Records · Records vol. 56 「蒙卒,權假然節,鎮江陵」

Family

ChildrenShi Ji(施績) Records
RelativesZhu Zhi Records

Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.

Related events (5)

Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).