Lü Meng 呂蒙

RecordsRomance Wu Courtesy name 子明 Ziming여몽자명吕蒙

Profile
OccupationRGeneral · General of Tiger Might NGeneral · Grand CommanderFactionWu
AppearsRNBiography inBook of Wu
BornNative placeRunan Commandery Fubo County
DiedPlace of deathRGong'an County
Cause of deathRIllness Unverified
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR82

Profile

Lü Meng, courtesy name Ziming, was a man of Fubo County in Runan Commandery. As a youth he crossed the Yangtze and relied on his sister's husband Deng Dang, a commander under Sun Ce; when Deng Dang died, Lü Meng succeeded to his post and fought as a commander under Sun Ce and Sun Quan. Records, Wu 9 §56–58

In the 24th year of Jian'an (219), when Guan Yu attacked Fancheng, Lü Meng claimed to be gravely ill and pretended to be recalled, then had men in white clothes row the boats and, disguised as merchants, sailed up the river and took Nan Commandery. When Guan Yu was captured and Jing Province pacified, he became Administrator of Nan Commandery and was enfeoffed as Marquis of Chanling, but before the enfeoffment was conferred his illness flared up and he died at the age of forty-two. Records, Wu 2 §26Records, Wu 9 §81–87

In his assessment, Chen Shou, author of the Records, called him 'brave and also resourceful' and singled out his deception of Hao Pu and his capture of Guan Yu as the most brilliant of his deeds. In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 38 as one of the men of talent Sun Quan had gathered and appears in 18 of its 120 chapters; his name is in the title of Chapter 75, 'Lü Ziming Crosses the River in White Clothes'. Records, Wu 9 §95Romance, Ch. 38 §27Romance, Ch. 75 §31

In the Records

As a youth he crossed the Yangtze southward and relied on his sister's husband Deng Dang. Deng Dang was a commander under Sun Ce, and at fifteen or sixteen Lü Meng secretly followed him to attack the enemy; to his angry mother he said, 'If you do not search the tiger's den, how can you get the tiger's cub?' Later he killed with his sword an official who had mocked and insulted him and fled, then gave himself up; Sun Ce summoned him, found him remarkable and kept him at his side. When Deng Dang died, on Zhang Zhao's recommendation he replaced him as Major of a Separate Command. Records, Wu 9 §56–57

After Sun Quan took charge of affairs and planned to merge the units of commanders with few troops, Lü Meng bought crimson uniforms and leggings for his men on credit and drilled them, and instead received more troops. He distinguished himself in the campaign against Danyang and became Commandant Who Pacifies the North. When Huang Zu was attacked in the 13th year of Jian'an (208), he led the vanguard and personally cut off the head of Huang Zu's Area Commander Chen Jiu, and was made General of the Household Who Sweeps the Plains. Records, Wu 9 §58–59Records, Wu 2 §11

That year, together with Zhou Yu and Cheng Pu, he defeated Lord Cao at Wulin and besieged Cao Ren at Nan Commandery. When Gan Ning at Yiling was surrounded by Cao Ren, Lü Meng vouched that Ling Tong could hold out for ten days and proposed that they go to the rescue together, and urged Zhou Yu to send 300 men to block the steep road with felled trees. At Yiling they killed more than half of the enemy, and from the enemy who abandoned their horses and fled they captured 300 horses. When Cao Ren withdrew and they took Nan Commandery, he became Lieutenant General. Records, Wu 9 §60–62

On his way to Lukou to replace Zhou Yu, Lu Su called on Lü Meng. Lü Meng warned Lu Su, who would now be Guan Yu's neighbor, that Guan Yu was a man like a bear or a tiger and laid out five plans for him; Lu Su patted his back and said, 'I did not know your talent and strategy had reached this point,' then paid his respects to Lü Meng's mother and bound himself to him in friendship. When Sun Quan wished to attach the troops of three commanders who had died to Lü Meng, he declined, saying that although their sons and brothers were young, their units should not be abolished. Records, Wu 9 §63–65

When resisting Lord Cao at Ruxu, he advised building a fort flanking the mouth of the river, and Lord Cao could not take it and withdrew. When Zhu Guang, whom Lord Cao had sent as Administrator of Lujiang, opened up extensive rice fields at Wan, Lü Meng advised that he be eliminated early. In the 19th year of Jian'an (214), when Wan was attacked, he recommended Gan Ning as Commander of the Wall-Scaling Troops and beat the drum with his own hands, and the city fell by about breakfast time. Zhu Guang was captured, and Lü Meng became Administrator of Lujiang. Records, Wu 9 §66–68Records, Wu 2 §19

In the 20th year of Jian'an (215) Sun Quan sent Lü Meng to seize the three commanderies of Changsha, Lingling and Guiyang. While Hao Pu, Administrator of Lingling, held out, Liu Bei sent Guan Yu, and Sun Quan wrote to Lü Meng to come back and help Lu Su. Lü Meng concealed the letter and had Deng Xuanzhi, an old friend of Hao Pu, tell him that the General of the Left was surrounded by Xiahou Yuan in Hanzhong and no relief would come. When Hao Pu, afraid, came out of the city, Lü Meng showed him the letter, clapped his hands and laughed, and Hao Pu was so ashamed that he wished to sink into the ground. Later, when Liu Bei asked for an alliance, Sun Quan returned Lingling. Records, Shu 2 §35Records, Wu 9 §69–75

When the army was withdrawing from Hefei and was attacked by Zhang Liao, he and Ling Tong fought to the death to protect Sun Quan. When Lord Cao again came out to Ruxu, Lü Meng, as commander, placed 10,000 strong crossbows on the fort and broke Lord Cao's vanguard before it had finished setting up camp. He became Left Protector of the Army and General of Tiger Might. When Lu Su died in the 22nd year of Jian'an (217), he was stationed at Lukou and took over Lu Su's troops. Records, Wu 9 §76–77 · 53

Lü Meng judged that Guan Yu had a mind to swallow up others and that, being upstream of the state, his position could not last long, and he secretly advised that Guan Yu should be dealt with while Wu was still strong. When Sun Quan asked about attacking Xu Province, he replied that even if Xu Province were taken, Cao Cao would soon come to contest it, and that it would be better to attack Guan Yu and hold the whole of the Yangtze. At Lukou he outwardly redoubled his kindness and kept on good terms with Guan Yu. Records, Wu 9 §77–80

When Guan Yu, attacking Fancheng, left garrisons at Gong'an and Nan Commandery, Lü Meng memorialized that if he returned to Jianye on the pretext of treating his illness, Guan Yu would withdraw the garrisons, and they could then strike the undefended places. He then claimed to be gravely ill, and Sun Quan openly recalled him while secretly making plans with him. Asked who should replace him, he recommended Lu Xun, who was not yet well known and whom Guan Yu would not be wary of. Guan Yu did indeed gradually send his garrison troops to Fancheng. Records, Wu 9 §81–82Records, Wu 13 §9

At Xunyang, Lü Meng hid his elite troops inside covered boats, had men in white clothes row, and, disguised as merchants, pressed on day and night; he captured all the lookouts along the river so that Guan Yu learned nothing. When he reached Nan Commandery, Shi Ren and Mi Fang surrendered. Lü Meng comforted the families of Guan Yu and his officers and men, and with tears beheaded a man from his home region who had taken a single bamboo hat from a commoner's house to cover government armor. He treated Guan Yu's messengers generously and let them know that the families were safe, so that Guan Yu's troops lost the will to fight; Guan Yu fled to Maicheng and was captured when Zhu Ran and Pan Zhang cut off his path. Records, Wu 9 §82–85

He became Administrator of Nan Commandery and was enfeoffed as Marquis of Chanling, but before the enfeoffment was conferred his illness flared up. Sun Quan kept him in the inner hall at Gong'an and bored a hole in the wall to watch whether he could swallow his food. Lü Meng died in the inner hall at the age of forty-two; he had deposited the gold, treasures and gifts he had received in the government storehouse, instructed that they all be returned on the day he died, and asked for a simple funeral. The Records do not give the year of his death. When his illness was grave he recommended Zhu Ran as his successor. Later, discussing men with Lu Xun, Sun Quan said that once Ziming had grown up his learning had increased and his strategies were extraordinary, ranking next to Gongjin, and that in his plan to take Guan Yu he surpassed Zijing. Records, Wu 9 §86–87 · 90 · 92Records, Wu 11 §15

In his assessment, Chen Shou said that Lü Meng was brave and also resourceful and decisive in military planning, and that his deception of Hao Pu and capture of Guan Yu were the most brilliant. Though at first rash and bold and quick to kill without cause, in the end he mastered himself and had the capacity of a gentleman of national stature; how could he be merely a military commander? Chen Shou also recorded Sun Quan's assessment, saying it weighed merits and shortcomings fittingly. Records, Wu 9 §95

In the Romance

In Chapter 38 of the Romance he first appears among the men of talent Sun Quan had gained, as 'Lü Meng of Runan, courtesy name Ziming'. As Commandant Who Pacifies the North he reports to Sun Quan that Gan Ning, a subordinate commander of Huang Zu, has come over to surrender, and in the campaign against Huang Zu he becomes the vanguard of the front army. When Gan Ning cuts the cables of the mengchong warships, Lü Meng leaps down into a small boat, rows it himself to set fire to the fleet, and pursues Chen Jiu as he tries to land, cutting him down with a single stroke of his sword. Romance, Ch. 38 §27 · 42 · 45 · 47 · 49–50

In Chapter 51, when Gan Ning is trapped at Yiling, Lü Meng says he must be rescued, proposing that Ling Tong be left to take over Zhou Yu's duties and that, if he himself leads the vanguard, they will return in triumph within ten days. He also advises that if the byway south of Yiling is cut off by felling trees with 500 men, they can capture the horses of the fleeing enemy. In Chapter 61 he proposes building a fort at the mouth of the Ruxu, and when the other commanders call it useless he retorts that if they suddenly meet the enemy there will be no time to board the boats; Sun Quan says, 'Ziming's foresight is far-reaching indeed,' and has the Ruxu fort built. Romance, Ch. 51 §17–18Romance, Ch. 61 §28–29

In Chapter 67 he proposes attacking Wancheng first, saying that Zhu Guang, Administrator of Lujiang, is cultivating fields at Wancheng to supply grain to Hefei. He argues that earthen mounds and cloud ladders would take days and that they should attack at once while their spirits are keen, and he beats the drum himself to send the soldiers up the walls. Gan Ning strikes Zhu Guang down with an iron chain and the soldiers kill him. At the banquet, when Lü Meng seats Gan Ning in the place of honor and praises him, Ling Tong, remembering his father's killer, asks to perform a sword dance. At Xiaoyao Ford in the same chapter he forms the front unit together with Gan Ning, but while turning back to rescue Sun Quan, who has fallen into Zhang Liao's ambush, he is blocked, loses his troops and flees to the south bank of the river. Romance, Ch. 67 §36–41 · 47–48 · 52–53

In Chapter 75 he urges Sun Quan to attack Jing Province while Guan Yu is occupied besieging Fancheng, and when Sun Quan asks about Xu Province he replies that even if it were taken it would be hard to hold. But on returning to Lukou and seeing the beacon towers lined along the river, he has no plan and stays in, pleading illness. When Lu Xun, visiting him in his sickness, proposes the plan of withdrawing on the pretext of illness to make Guan Yu arrogant, he is overjoyed, and at Jianye he recommends Lu Xun as his successor. When Sun Quan tells him to go with Sun Jiao, he cites the discord between Zhou Yu and Cheng Pu and asks that only one man be used, and so becomes Grand Commander. Romance, Ch. 75 §16–25 · 28–31

He has men in white clothes, dressed as merchants, row more than 80 boats with elite troops hidden inside, captures the soldiers of the beacon towers, and has them lead the way so that the gates of Jingzhou are opened in the middle of the night. He beheads a man from his home region who covered his armor with a commoner's bamboo hat, bringing strict discipline to the three armies, and in Chapter 76 he treats Guan Yu's messenger as a guest and spreads the news that the families of the officers and men are safe. In Chapter 77 he devises the plan of placing Zhu Ran and Pan Zhang in ambush, predicting that Guan Yu will flee by the byway north of Maicheng. Romance, Ch. 75 §31–37Romance, Ch. 76 §27–29Romance, Ch. 77 §1–2

After Guan Yu's death, when Sun Quan, at a banquet, offers him wine, saying that the taking of Jing Province is entirely Ziming's achievement and that he far surpasses Zhou Yu and Lu Su, Lü Meng hurls down the cup, seizes Sun Quan and reviles him as a 'green-eyed brat'. Sitting in Sun Quan's seat, he cries out, 'I am Guan Yunchang, Marquis of Hanshou Precinct!', then collapses and dies bleeding from the seven orifices. Sun Quan posthumously grants him the titles of Administrator of Nan Commandery and Marquis of Chanling and has his son Lü Ba inherit the rank. Romance, Ch. 77 §24–27

Where the Romance differs

The byway at Yiling: In Chapter 51 of the Romance, Lü Meng proposes cutting off the byway with 500 men. In the Records, he urged Zhou Yu to send 300 men to block the steep road with felled trees, and on this byway they captured 300 horses. Romance, Ch. 51 §18Records, Wu 9 §61–62

The Ruxu fort: In Chapter 61 of the Romance, Lü Meng argues with the commanders who call the fort useless, and Sun Quan praises his foresight. Chen Shou's main text says only that Lü Meng advised building a fort flanking the mouth of the river and that the defenses were so thorough that Lord Cao withdrew. Romance, Ch. 61 §28–29Records, Wu 9 §66

Wancheng and Zhu Guang: In Chapter 67 of the Romance, Wancheng is attacked after Cao Cao has pacified Hanzhong and the three commanderies have been returned, and Zhu Guang is struck down by Gan Ning and killed by the soldiers. In the Records, the campaign against Wancheng took place in the 19th year of Jian'an (214), before the dispute over the three commanderies, and Zhu Guang was captured and later, around the 24th year of Jian'an (219), sent back to Wei by Sun Quan. Romance, Ch. 67 §36 · 39–40Records, Wu 2 §19 · 29Records, Wu 10 §61

The three commanderies and Hao Pu: In Chapter 67 of the Romance, Liu Bei sends Yi Ji to return the three commanderies of Jiangxia, Changsha and Guiyang, and Lu Su takes them over. In the Records, Lü Meng went to seize the three commanderies of Changsha, Lingling and Guiyang and, through Deng Xuanzhi, tricked Hao Pu, Administrator of Lingling, into surrendering. Hao Pu does not appear in the Romance. Romance, Ch. 67 §34 · 36Records, Wu 9 §69–74

The plan to seize Jing Province: In Chapter 75 of the Romance, Lü Meng, seeing the beacon towers and having no plan, takes to his bed pleading illness, and it is Lu Xun who devises the plan of withdrawing on the pretext of illness to make Guan Yu arrogant. In the Records, Lü Meng himself memorialized proposing that he withdraw on the pretext of treating his illness in order to draw off Guan Yu's garrisons. In the Biography of Lu Xun, Lu Xun tells Lü Meng, who has come to Jianye, that it is time to attack Guan Yu, and Lü Meng replies that Guan Yu is not an easy opponent to take. Romance, Ch. 75 §19–23Records, Wu 9 §81Records, Wu 13 §7–8

How Nan Commandery was entered: In Chapter 75 of the Romance, the captured beacon soldiers are sent ahead to trick the gates of Jingzhou open in the middle of the night, and the two commanders of Gong'an and Nan Commandery are later persuaded separately to surrender. In the Records, when Lü Meng reached Nan Commandery, Shi Ren and Mi Fang both surrendered, and when Mi Fang opened the gates and came out to surrender, it was Yu Fan, who accompanied Lü Meng, who urged him to enter the city quickly. Romance, Ch. 75 §33–34 · 38Records, Wu 9 §83Records, Wu 12 §7–8

The plan to capture Guan Yu: In Chapter 77 of the Romance, Lü Meng points out the byway north of Maicheng and places Zhu Ran and Pan Zhang in ambush. The Records state that Sun Quan sent Zhu Ran and Pan Zhang to cut off the road, and Lü Meng's name does not appear in connection with this plan. Romance, Ch. 77 §1–2Records, Wu 9 §85Records, Wu 18 §5

Death: In Chapter 77 of the Romance, Lü Meng is possessed by Guan Yu's spirit at a banquet and dies bleeding from the seven orifices. In the Records, his illness flared up and Sun Quan cared for him in the inner hall at Gong'an, but he died in the inner hall at the age of forty-two. Romance, Ch. 77 §26–27Records, Wu 9 §86–87

Administrator of Nan Commandery and Marquis of Chanling: In Chapter 77 of the Romance, these titles are granted posthumously. In the Records, after Jing Province was pacified he became Administrator of Nan Commandery and was enfeoffed as Marquis of Chanling while still alive, but his illness flared up before the enfeoffment was conferred. Romance, Ch. 77 §27Records, Wu 9 §86

Sun Quan's assessment: In Chapter 77 of the Romance, Sun Quan says at the banquet that Lü Meng far surpasses Zhou Yu and Lu Su. In the Records, discussing men with Lu Xun, Sun Quan ranked Lü Meng next to Gongjin, said his eloquence did not match Gongjin's, and said that only in his plan to take Guan Yu did he surpass Zijing. Romance, Ch. 77 §25Records, Wu 9 §92

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA8885−3
  • STR7674−2
  • INT9080−10
  • POL6055−5
  • CHA7666−10
  • VIR7245−27
  • ADP7466−8
  • SCH4035−5
  • DIP6258−4
  • DIS8056−24
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

VirtueR72N45 −27

RBeheaded even a soldier from his home region by the law and returned his rewards, but killed rashly in his youthWu 9 §83Wu 9 §87Wu 9 §95

NBeheaded even a man from his home region by the law, but deceived and captured Lord Guan and died possessed by his spiritCh. 75 §36Ch. 77 §26

DiscernmentR80N56 −24

RProtected Xi Su's troops, recommended Gan Ning, and even recommended Cai Yi, who had denounced himWu 9 §60Wu 9 §67Wu 9 §88

NRecognized the little-known Lu Xun, whom Yunchang would not be wary of, and vouched for him as his successorCh. 75 §24

IntelligenceR90N80 −10

RLaid out five plans for Lu Su, and Chen Shou called his deception of Hao Pu and capture of Guan Yu brilliantWu 9 §64Wu 9 §81Wu 9 §95

NFirst proposed the Ruxu fort and devised the ambush on the Maicheng byway, but the feigned-illness plan was added by Lu XunCh. 61 §28Ch. 75 §17Ch. 77 §1

CharismaR76N66 −10

RTreated Guan Yu's families generously, so that Guan Yu's men lost the will to fight and all surrenderedWu 9 §66Wu 9 §84

NCared for the soldiers' families to sway the hearts of Guan Yu's army, and won over captives to serve as guidesCh. 76 §27Ch. 75 §34

6 similar abilities — show evidence
  • LeadershipR88N85 −3

    RTook Wan by breakfast time and seized Nan Commandery by surprise to pacify Jing Province, keeping strict military disciplineWu 9 §68Wu 9 §82Wu 9 §93

    NAs Grand Commander he led boats in white disguise to surprise Jing Province, and broke WanchengCh. 67 §40Ch. 75 §31Ch. 75 §34

  • StrengthR76N74 −2

    RAs vanguard he personally cut down Chen Jiu, and at Hefei fought to the death to guard Sun QuanWu 9 §59Wu 9 §76Wu 9 §95

    NRowed in person to set the fire and cut down Chen Jiu with a single strokeCh. 38 §50Ch. 67 §40

  • PoliticsR60N55 −5

    RAfter taking Nan Commandery he forbade intrusion on homes and provided for the elderly, medicine for the sick and relief for the poorWu 9 §83

    NForbade plunder in Jing Province and supplied food and physicians to the families of soldiers on campaignCh. 75 §35Ch. 76 §27

  • AdaptabilityR74N66 −8

    RHid the order to withdraw and made Hao Pu surrender, and judged it was time to strike Guan Yu rather than Xu ProvinceWu 9 §70Wu 9 §79

    NWithdrew on the pretext of illness to create an opening, and declined joint command with Sun Jiao to receive full authorityCh. 75 §24Ch. 75 §29

  • ScholarshipR40N35Unverified −5

    RDid not study the classics and histories in youth and dictated his letters, but his learning grew as he maturedWu 9 §88Wu 9 §92

    NNo direct record — estimated from his career as introduced among the commanders of JiangdongCh. 38 §27

  • DiplomacyR62N58 −4

    RCrafted the words to win over Hao Pu and made him surrender, but was judged less eloquent than Zhou YuWu 9 §70Wu 9 §92

    NPersuaded Sun Quan to give him sole command, and treated Guan Yu's messenger with courtesy before sending him backCh. 75 §29Ch. 76 §28

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (18)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Allegiance history

  1. Wu · Records · Records vol. 54 「權以蒙為督,據前所立塢」

Related events (14)

Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).

Related works (1)

Linked via Wikidata "depicts" and character names in titles (unverified) — not yet reviewed.