Gan Ning 甘寧

RecordsRomance Wu Courtesy name 興霸 Xingba감녕흥패甘寜甘宁

Profile
OccupationRGeneral · General Who Breaks AssaultsFactionWu
AppearsRNBiography inBook of Wu
BornN? UnverifiedNative placeBa Commandery Linjiang County
DiedN222 UnverifiedPlace of deathNFuchikou
Cause of deathNKilled in battle Unverified
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR35

Profile

Gan Ning, courtesy name Xingba, was a man of Linjiang County in Ba Commandery. In his youth he gathered a band and lived as a knight-errant for more than twenty years before giving it up; he attached himself in turn to Liu Biao and Huang Zu, but when neither of them employed him he came over to Wu. He proposed to Sun Quan a plan to strike Huang Zu first and then take Jing Province. Records, Wu 10 §53–56

Following Zhou Yu, he defeated Lord Cao at Wulin, then took Yiling and held out against Cao Ren's siege; in the battle at Wan he led the way as Commander of the Wall-Scaling Troops and became General Who Breaks Assaults. At Ruxu he raided Lord Cao's camp by night with a hundred-odd men, and at Xiaoyao Ford he fought to the death against Zhang Liao at Sun Quan's side. The Records do not give the year of his death. Records, Wu 10 §58 · 61–65 · 68

In his assessment, Chen Shou, author of the Records, called the generals of this volume, including him, 'tiger-like servants of Jiangbiao.' In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 38 as a subordinate general of Huang Zu and features in 16 of its 120 chapters, and his name appears in the title of Chapter 68, 'Gan Ning raids the Wei camp with a hundred horsemen.' Records, Wu 10 §109Romance, Ch. 38 §30Romance, Ch. 68 §4–9

In the Records

Gan Ning, courtesy name Xingba, was a man of Linjiang County in Ba Commandery. In his youth he was strong and loved the ways of the knight-errant, becoming the leader of a band of reckless young men. They went about in a pack carrying bows and crossbows and wearing bells, so that the people knew Gan Ning had come as soon as they heard the sound of bells. He associated with senior officials who received him lavishly; otherwise he let his followers loose to seize their goods. He lived this way for more than twenty years. Records, Wu 10 §53

Later he gave up plundering and read a good deal of the works of the various philosophers. He went to attach himself to Liu Biao and stayed in Nanyang, but was not given office; he moved on to Huang Zu, but Huang Zu too treated him as an ordinary man. He then came over to Wu, where Zhou Yu and Lü Meng together recommended him, and Sun Quan treated him on the same footing as his long-serving retainers. Records, Wu 10 §54–55

Gan Ning presented a plan: the Han dynasty was declining day by day and Cao Cao would in the end usurp the throne, so Jing Province, the strategic western flank of the state, had to be secured before Cao Cao could take it, and the first step was to strike Huang Zu, who was old and senile and whose army had no discipline. Once Huang Zu was broken and they had established themselves at the Chu Pass in the west, they could gradually plan to take Ba and Shu as well. When Zhang Zhao objected that he feared disorder would break out once the army left, Gan Ning retorted by asking whether one entrusted with the role of Xiao He should be worrying about disorder, and Sun Quan raised his cup and said he would entrust the campaign to Gan Ning. Records, Wu 10 §55–57

Sun Quan at last went west, captured Huang Zu and took over all his soldiers and followers, and gave Gan Ning troops and stationed him at Dangkou. The Biography of the Lord of Wu dates this to the spring of the 13th year of Jian'an (208) and says that Huang Zu was beheaded as he fled by the cavalryman Feng Ze. Records, Wu 10 §57Records, Wu 2 §11

Later, following Zhou Yu, he resisted and defeated Lord Cao at Wulin. When they attacked Cao Ren at Nan Commandery and could not take it, Gan Ning proposed first seizing Yiling, went there, took the city and held it. Even with the men newly gained, he had barely a thousand soldiers, and Cao Ren surrounded him with five or six thousand and rained arrows on the city from tall towers. The soldiers were all afraid, but Gan Ning alone talked and laughed as calmly as ever. When Gan Ning reported his situation, Zhou Yu followed Lü Meng's plan, left Ling Tong to hold off Cao Ren, and went to lift the siege. Zhou Yu and Gan Ning also together urged Sun Quan to take Shu. Records, Wu 10 §58–59Records, Wu 2 §14Records, Wu 9 §60–61 · 49

In the 19th year of Jian'an (214), when Sun Quan attacked Wan, Lü Meng recommended Gan Ning as Commander of the Wall-Scaling Troops to lead the assault at the front. Gripping a silk rope in his hand, Gan Ning climbed the wall himself ahead of the officers and soldiers, and at last the city was taken and Zhu Guang captured. In the reckoning of merit Lü Meng came first and Gan Ning second, and Gan Ning was made General Who Breaks Assaults. Records, Wu 2 §19Records, Wu 9 §67Records, Wu 10 §61

Later, following Lu Su, he guarded Yiyang and resisted Guan Yu. When Guan Yu picked 5,000 elite troops and sent them to a shallow ford a little over ten li upstream of the county, intending to cross by night, Gan Ning, who then commanded 300 soldiers, said that if he were given just 500 more men, Guan Yu would not dare cross on hearing so much as his cough, and if he did cross he would be captured. Lu Su added a thousand men to his force, and when Gan Ning went there by night, Guan Yu did not cross but built a camp of bound brushwood. Chen Shou noted that the place is now called Guan Yu's Shoal. Sun Quan made Gan Ning Administrator of Xiling, with the two counties of Yangxin and Xiazhi under him. Records, Wu 10 §59–60

Later, when Lord Cao came out to Ruxu, Gan Ning became Commander of the Front Division and was ordered to strike the enemy's forward camp. He shared out the rice, wine and food Sun Quan had bestowed among the hundred-odd men under him, and after first drinking two bowls himself from a silver bowl, he poured wine for his commander (dudu). When the commander did not readily accept it, Gan Ning drew his sword, laid it across his knees and rebuked him: even Gan Ning did not begrudge his life, so why should he alone begrudge his? At the second watch they went out with gags in their mouths and struck the enemy, who were startled and withdrew. Gan Ning was held in still higher esteem, and his troops were increased by 2,000 men. Records, Wu 10 §62–63

In the 20th year of Jian'an (215) he went along on the attack on Hefei; after an epidemic broke out and the whole army had withdrawn, only the thousand-odd tiger guards by Sun Quan's carriage and Lü Meng, Jiang Qin, Ling Tong and Gan Ning remained with Sun Quan north of Xiaoyao Ford. Zhang Liao, spying this, suddenly fell on them with infantry and cavalry; Gan Ning drew his bow and shot at the enemy, fighting to the death together with Ling Tong and the others. When Gan Ning loudly demanded why the drums and pipes were not playing, Sun Quan especially praised his bold spirit. Records, Wu 10 §64–65Records, Wu 2 §22

Chen Shou wrote that although Gan Ning was rough and fierce and fond of killing, he was open-hearted and resourceful, made light of wealth and respected men of quality, so that his soldiers gladly gave their lives for him. According to the Biography of Lü Meng, whenever Gan Ning disobeyed Sun Quan's orders and Sun Quan grew angry, Lü Meng asked him to be tolerant, saying that a fighting general like Gan Ning was hard to find. According to the biographies of the ruling house, when Sun Jiao, General Who Conquers Caitiffs, slighted Gan Ning at a drinking party, Sun Quan wrote to Sun Jiao to rebuke him, saying that Gan Ning, though rough and unrestrained, was on the whole a true man; Sun Jiao apologized and afterwards became a close friend of Gan Ning. Records, Wu 10 §64Records, Wu 9 §88–89Records, Wu 6 §12–13 · 16

Once a kitchen boy of Gan Ning's did wrong and ran away to Lü Meng. Lü Meng returned the boy after obtaining Gan Ning's promise not to kill him, but Gan Ning went back to his boat, tied the boy to a mulberry tree and shot him dead with his bow. Lü Meng, enraged, gathered his troops to attack Gan Ning, but Lü Meng's mother came out barefoot and rebuked him for wanting to kill Gan Ning out of private anger. Lü Meng's anger melted away and he called to Gan Ning with a laugh; Gan Ning, weeping, said, 'I have wronged you,' and went back with him, and they feasted happily until the day was done. Records, Wu 10 §66–67

When Gan Ning died, Sun Quan grieved deeply for him. The Records do not give the year or place of his death. The Biography of Pan Zhang records that on Gan Ning's death Pan Zhang took over his troops as well, and then goes on to Liu Bei's advance to Yiling. His son Gan Gui was banished to Kuaiji for a crime and died not long after. In his assessment, Chen Shou said that the generals of this volume were all tiger-like servants of Jiangbiao, men whom the Sun family treated generously. Records, Wu 10 §68 · 92 · 109

In the Romance

In Chapter 38 of the Romance Gan Ning first appears as a subordinate general of Huang Zu and, in the 11th month of the 8th year of Jian'an (203), shoots dead with a single arrow Ling Cao, a subordinate general of Sun Quan who had attacked Xiakou. In the spring of the following year Lü Meng reports to Sun Quan that Gan Ning, who wore copper bells at his waist and made his sails of Xichuan brocade and was therefore called the 'Brocade-Sail Bandit,' had not been given an important post by Huang Zu, who dismissed him as a river pirate, and so, with the help of the commander (dudu) Su Fei, had slipped out of Xiakou and come to surrender. Gan Ning proposes the plan to strike Huang Zu first, and in battle he cuts the thick cables of the mengchong warships from a small boat, leaps aboard and cuts down Deng Long. Romance, Ch. 38 §30 · 42–47 · 49

In Chapter 39 he lies in wait outside the east gate and bars the way of the fleeing Huang Zu, and, fearing that Cheng Pu would compete with him for the credit, shoots Huang Zu in the back, knocks him down and cuts off his head. When Sun Quan is about to behead the captured Su Fei, Gan Ning saves him by offering to give up his own rank and accept punishment in his place. At a banquet, when Ling Tong draws his sword and rushes at him to avenge his father, Gan Ning fends him off by raising a chair, and Sun Quan sends Gan Ning to Xiakou to keep him away from Ling Tong. Romance, Ch. 39 §1–2 · 4–7

In the battle of Red Cliffs, in Chapter 45 he goes out in the vanguard and shoots down Cai Xun, and in Chapter 47, together with Kan Ze, he pretends before Cai Zhong and Cai He to resent Zhou Yu, making them believe in the feigned surrender. In Chapter 50 he enters Cao Cao's camp at Wulin with Cai Zhong leading the way, cuts Cai Zhong down and sets fires, and then cuts down Ma Yan and Zhang Yi. In Chapter 51 he seizes Yiling with 3,000 men and is surrounded, but when Zhou Tai breaks through to him they fight their way out together. Romance, Ch. 45 §26–28Romance, Ch. 47 §15–19Romance, Ch. 49 §25Romance, Ch. 50 §6 · 10Romance, Ch. 51 §15–16 · 19–20

In Chapter 67, at the attack on Wancheng, he carries an iron chain and climbs the wall through arrows and stones, striking down Zhu Guang. At the victory banquet, when Ling Tong approaches him on the pretext of a sword dance, he faces him with two halberds, and Lü Meng separates the two with sword and shield. At Hefei he goes out with the forward detachment and pursues Yue Jin, who is feigning flight, then turns back to rescue Sun Quan at Xiaoyao Ford. Romance, Ch. 67 §39 · 41–42 · 47–48

In Chapter 68 Gan Ning quarrels with Ling Tong, who had asked for 3,000 men, saying he could break the enemy with a hundred horsemen; after Ling Tong returns from fighting Zhang Liao, that night Gan Ning sweeps through Cao Cao's camp at Ruxu with a hundred horsemen wearing white goose feathers in their helmets and returns without losing a single man. Sun Quan says, 'Mengde has Zhang Liao, and I have Gan Xingba.' The next day, when Ling Tong falls from his horse and is about to be speared by Yue Jin, Gan Ning saves him by hitting Yue Jin in the face with an arrow, and from then on the two become friends sworn to live and die together. Romance, Ch. 68 §2–7 · 9–10 · 12–13

In Chapter 82 Gan Ning, though suffering from dysentery, joins the relief force sent to stop Liu Bei. In Chapter 83 he is nursing his illness aboard his boat when the Shu army arrives; he mounts his horse but is struck in the head by an arrow from the barbarian king Shamoke, and on reaching Fuchikou he dies sitting under a large tree. Several hundred crows circle around his body, and Sun Quan gives him a lavish burial and erects a shrine to him. Romance, Ch. 82 §38–39Romance, Ch. 83 §13–14

Where the Romance differs

Who shot Ling Cao: In Chapter 38 of the Romance, Gan Ning, a subordinate general of Huang Zu, shoots Ling Cao dead with an arrow. The Biography of Ling Tong in the Records says only that Ling Cao led the way into Xiakou and was killed by a stray arrow, without naming who shot it. Romance, Ch. 38 §30Records, Wu 10 §70

How he came to Wu: In Chapter 38 of the Romance he slips out of Xiakou with the help of the commander Su Fei and surrenders through Lü Meng. In the Records, he came over to Wu after Liu Biao and Huang Zu failed to employ him, and Zhou Yu and Lü Meng together recommended him. Su Fei does not appear in the Biography of Gan Ning. Romance, Ch. 38 §42–44Records, Wu 10 §54–55

Who killed Huang Zu: In Chapter 39 of the Romance Gan Ning shoots Huang Zu down and cuts off his head. The Biography of Gan Ning in the Records says Sun Quan captured Huang Zu, and the Biography of the Lord of Wu says Huang Zu was beheaded as he fled by the cavalryman Feng Ze. Romance, Ch. 39 §1–2Records, Wu 10 §57Records, Wu 2 §11

Feud with Ling Tong: In Chapters 39 and 67 of the Romance Ling Tong takes up his sword against Gan Ning as his father's killer, and the two become friends only after Gan Ning saves him in Chapter 68. Neither the Biography of Gan Ning nor the Biography of Ling Tong in the Records mentions any enmity between them. Romance, Ch. 39 §6–7Romance, Ch. 67 §41–42Romance, Ch. 68 §13Records, Wu 10 §52–79

Red Cliffs: In Chapters 45–50 of the Romance Gan Ning shoots Cai Xun, deceives Cai Zhong and Cai He, and sets fire to Wulin. The Biography of Gan Ning in the Records records in a single line only that, following Zhou Yu, he resisted and defeated Lord Cao at Wulin. Romance, Ch. 45 §28Romance, Ch. 47 §17–19Romance, Ch. 50 §6Records, Wu 10 §58

Yiling: In Chapter 51 of the Romance he defeats Cao Hong with 3,000 men and takes Yiling, and Zhou Tai breaks through the encirclement to join him and they fight their way out together. In the Records, with a thousand men including the newly gained soldiers, he was surrounded by Cao Ren's five or six thousand, and Zhou Yu, following Lü Meng's plan, left Ling Tong behind and came to lift the siege. Romance, Ch. 51 §15–16 · 19–20Records, Wu 10 §58–59Records, Wu 9 §60–61

Zhu Guang at Wancheng: In Chapter 67 of the Romance Gan Ning strikes Zhu Guang down with an iron chain and the soldiers kill him. In the Records, Gan Ning climbed the wall gripping a silk rope, and when the city fell Zhu Guang was captured. Romance, Ch. 67 §39–40Records, Wu 10 §61Records, Wu 2 §19

Xiaoyao Ford: In Chapter 67 of the Romance Gan Ning pursues Yue Jin with the forward detachment and then turns back to rescue Sun Quan. In the Records he remained with Sun Quan north of Xiaoyao Ford from the start and fought off Zhang Liao's surprise attack. Romance, Ch. 67 §47–48Records, Wu 10 §64–65

Night raid at Ruxu: In Chapter 68 of the Romance he raids with a hundred elite horsemen picked by Sun Quan, and Sun Quan compares Gan Ning to Zhang Liao. In the Records he shared out the rewards among the hundred-odd men under him and then went out with gags in their mouths to strike the enemy's forward camp, and for this merit his troops were increased by 2,000 men. There is no remark comparing him to Zhang Liao. Romance, Ch. 68 §4 · 10Records, Wu 10 §62–63

Yue Jin: In Chapter 68 of the Romance Gan Ning's arrow strikes Yue Jin in the face. The Biography of Yue Jin in the Records mentions no such wound, and Yue Jin died in the 23rd year of Jian'an (218). Romance, Ch. 68 §12Records, Wei 17 §24

Death: In Chapters 82–83 of the Romance he is suffering from dysentery when he is struck by Shamoke's arrow, and he dies at Fuchikou. The Biography of Gan Ning in the Records says only 'Gan Ning died,' giving neither the time, the place nor the cause. In the Biography of Lu Xun in the Records, Shamoke is beheaded by Lu Xun's army in the battle of Yiling. Romance, Ch. 82 §39Romance, Ch. 83 §14Records, Wu 10 §68Records, Wu 13 §21

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA8082+2
  • STR8488+4
  • INT7672−4
  • POL3532−3
  • CHA7270−2
  • VIR2574+49
  • ADP6055−5
  • SCH4532−13
  • DIP5045−5
  • DIS5845−13
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

ScholarshipR45N32Unverified −13

RGave up plundering and read a good deal of the works of the various philosophersWu 10 §54

NNo direct record — estimated from the career of a general who began as a river banditCh. 38 §43

DiscernmentR58N45Unverified −13

RSaw that Liu Biao lacked foresight, his sons were inept, and Huang Zu had grown senileWu 10 §55Wu 10 §56

NNo direct record — estimated from his not forgetting Su Fei's kindnessCh. 39 §4

7 similar abilities — show evidence
  • LeadershipR80N82 +2

    RHeld Yiling with a thousand men against Cao Ren's five or six thousand, and stopped 5,000 of Guan Yu's men from crossing the riverWu 10 §58Wu 10 §59Wu 10 §63

    NTook Yiling and raided Cao Cao's camp with a hundred horsemen without losing one; Sun Quan compared him to Zhang LiaoCh. 51 §15Ch. 68 §6Ch. 68 §10

  • StrengthR84N88 +4

    RClimbed the wall himself to take Wancheng, and fought to the death with his bow at Xiaoyao FordWu 10 §61Wu 10 §65Wu 10 §63

    NBeat Cao Hong after some twenty bouts, charged about with a hundred horsemen, and saved Ling Tong by hitting Yue Jin with an arrowCh. 51 §16Ch. 68 §6Ch. 68 §13

  • IntelligenceR76N72 −4

    RProposed striking Huang Zu first to win Jing Province and Ba-Shu, and seizing Yiling first; said to be resourcefulWu 10 §55Wu 10 §58Wu 10 §64

    NProposed breaking Huang Zu and then winning the Chu Pass and Ba-Shu, and foresaw that Huang Zu would flee toward Jing ProvinceCh. 38 §46Ch. 39 §1

  • PoliticsR35UnverifiedN32Unverified −3

    RNo direct record — estimated from the career of a general appointed Administrator of XilingWu 10 §60

    NNo direct record — estimated from his career as a generalCh. 39 §3

  • CharismaR72N70 −2

    RMade light of wealth and respected men of quality so his soldiers gave their lives for him; recommended by Zhou Yu and Lü MengWu 10 §64Wu 10 §55

    NA band of men ready to die followed his spirit, and he was praised for turning an enemy into a friendCh. 68 §5Ch. 83 §15

  • AdaptabilityR60N55 −5

    RCame over to Wu when Liu Biao and Huang Zu would not employ him, and stayed lying down even when Lü Meng came to attack himWu 10 §54Wu 10 §67

    NCame over to Wu when he was not given an important post, but fled before Shamoke's onslaught and was hit by an arrowCh. 38 §44Ch. 83 §14

  • DiplomacyR50N45Unverified −5

    RRebutted Zhang Zhao's objection to the campaign, and rebuked a hesitant commander into following himWu 10 §57Wu 10 §62

    NNo direct record — estimated from his rebuking his men into fighting to the deathCh. 68 §5

Special — talents Records +10 · Romance +10

  • Archery

    RNSkilled +10 Drew his bow on the enemy at Xiaoyao Ford, and in the Romance killed Ling Cao and hit Yue Jin with arrowsWu 10 §65Ch. 38 §30Ch. 68 §13

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (16)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Allegiance history Changed allegiance 1 times

  1. Liu Biao faction (194~208) Took refuge · Records · Records vol. 55 「止不攻劫,頗讀諸子,乃往依劉表,因居南陽,不見進用,後轉託黃祖,祖又以凡人畜之。」
  2. Wu (208~222) Defected · Records · Records vol. 4 「欽遁走,遂奔吳。」

Related events (14)

Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).