RBanditry ceased wherever he served, he pacified Jianchang within a month, and set up military markets to supply goodsWu 10 §89Wu 10 §90Wu 10 §95
NNo direct record — estimated from his career as a warriorCh. 38 §27
| Occupation | RGeneral · General of the Right | Faction | Wu |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appears | RN | Biography in | Book of Wu |
| Born | R? N? Unverified | Native place | Dong Commandery Fagan County |
| Died | R234 N222 Unverified | Place of death | |
| Cause of death | NKilled Unverified | ||
| Existence | Historical | Mentions | R29 |
Pan Zhang, courtesy name Wengui, was a man of Fagan County in Dong Commandery. He had followed Sun Quan since Sun Quan was Chief of Yangxian, and when Sun Quan had him recruit men and he gathered more than a hundred, he was made a commander. In the battle of Hefei he cut down fleeing soldiers and rallied the routed army, and when Guan Yu was attacked, his Major Ma Zhong captured Guan Yu. Records, Wu 10 §89 · 91–92
For this merit he became Administrator of Guling and General Who Spreads Awe (Zhenwei jiangjun) and was enfeoffed as Marquis of Liyang; after resisting Liu Bei at Yiling together with Lu Xun, he became General Who Pacifies the North and Administrator of Xiangyang. When Sun Quan assumed the imperial title he rose to General of the Right, and he died in the 3rd year of Jiahe (234). Records, Wu 10 §92 · 94 · 96
In his assessment, Chen Shou wrote that Sun Quan could forget the faults and remember the merits even of a man who did not cultivate his conduct, such as Pan Zhang, so it was fitting that he held and secured the southeast. In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 38 as one of the commanders Sun Quan acquired, and he appears in 13 of its 120 chapters, though his name is in no chapter title. In Chapter 77 he is charged with the ambush that captures Guan Yu, and in Chapter 83 he dies by the blade of Guan Xing. Records, Wu 10 §109Romance, Ch. 38 §27Romance, Ch. 77 §2 · 9Romance, Ch. 83 §19
Pan Zhang, courtesy name Wengui, was a man of Fagan County in Dong Commandery. When Sun Quan was Chief of Yangxian, he first went to follow him. He was unrestrained and dissolute by nature and fond of wine; though he lived in poverty, he liked to buy wine on credit, and whenever creditors came to his gate he would say he would repay them once he became rich. Sun Quan thought him remarkable and was fond of him, and had him recruit men; when he gathered more than a hundred, Sun Quan finally made him a commander. Records, Wu 10 §89
For his merit in attacking the mountain bandits he was made Major of a Separate Command. Later, when he became Inspector of the Great Market of Wu, theft and banditry ceased, and having made his name by this he was transferred to Chief of Xi'an in Yuzhang. While Liu Biao held Jing Province the people had been raided many times, but after Pan Zhang took office the raiders did not enter the territory. When banditry broke out in the neighbouring county of Jianchang, he was moved to take charge of Jianchang and was given the additional post of Commandant of Martial Ferocity (Wumeng xiaowei); within a month he had pacified it completely, and gathering 800 scattered men, he led them back to Jianye. Records, Wu 10 §89–90
When Sun Quan contended with Liu Bei over the three southern commanderies of Jing Province, Lü Meng, after taking the three commanderies, advanced alongside Lu Su's army together with Sun Jiao and Pan Zhang and held off Guan Yu at Yiyang. Before they fought, Cao Cao entered Hanzhong and Liu Bei sued for peace, and the two sides divided Jing Province. Records, Wu 2 §20–21
In the battle of Hefei, when Zhang Liao suddenly fell upon them, the commanders were unprepared: Chen Wu was killed fighting, and Song Qian and Xu Sheng both broke and fled. Pan Zhang, who was at the rear, at once galloped forward, set his horse across their path and cut down two of the fleeing soldiers of Song Qian and Xu Sheng. At this the soldiers all turned back to fight. Sun Quan thought this very brave and made him Lieutenant General, and Pan Zhang, leading a hundred companies, was stationed at Banzhou. Records, Wu 10 §91
In the 24th year of Jian'an (219), when Sun Quan attacked Guan Yu, Pan Zhang went with Zhu Ran to cut off Guan Yu's escape route, reached Linju and camped at Jiashi. In the 12th month (early 220 CE) Pan Zhang's Major Ma Zhong captured Guan Yu, his son Guan Ping, the Area Commander Zhao Lei and others at Zhangxiang. Sun Quan separated the two counties of Wu and Zigui from Yidu Commandery to create Guling Commandery, made Pan Zhang its Administrator and General Who Spreads Awe, and enfeoffed him as Marquis of Liyang. When Gan Ning died, Pan Zhang also took over his troops. Records, Wu 11 §14Records, Wu 2 §28Records, Wu 10 §92
In the 1st year of Huangwu (222), when Liu Bei came with a great army, Sun Quan made Lu Xun Grand Commander and had him resist with 50,000 men including Zhu Ran, Pan Zhang, Song Qian, Han Dang and Xu Sheng. Pan Zhang's men cut down Liu Bei's Protector of the Army Feng Xi and others and killed and wounded a great many, and Pan Zhang became General Who Pacifies the North and Administrator of Xiangyang. When Liu Bei stayed at Baidi, Xu Sheng, Pan Zhang, Song Qian and others vied in submitting memorials asking to attack again, saying Liu Bei could surely be captured, but Lu Xun said that Cao Pi was massing a great army and proposed returning. Records, Wu 13 §17 · 28Records, Wu 10 §92
In the autumn, in the 9th month of the same year, when Cao Zhen, Xiahou Shang, Zhang He and others of Wei besieged Nan Commandery, Sun Quan sent Zhuge Jin, Pan Zhang and Yang Can to relieve it. When Xiahou Shang and others split off their vanguard of 30,000 men to build a floating bridge and crossed onto Baili Islet day after day, Pan Zhang said that Wei's momentum was just at its height and the river was shallow, so they could not yet give battle. He then cut several million bundles of reeds at a place 50 li upstream of the Wei army and bound them into great rafts, intending to set them alight and send them downstream to burn the floating bridge. Just as the rafts were finished and he was waiting for the water to rise, Xiahou Shang withdrew his army, and Pan Zhang went down to guard Lukou. The Biography of Zhu Ran records that Pan Zhang, Yang Can and others came to the rescue but the siege was not lifted. Records, Wu 2 §41–42Records, Wu 10 §93–94Records, Wu 11 §16
In the 6th year of Huangwu (227), when Sun Quan was returning after personally attacking Shiyang, Pan Zhang covered the rear. Setting out at night, the ranks fell into disorder, and when the enemy pursued, Pan Zhang could not hold them back; Zhu Ran turned back to resist the enemy. In the 1st year of Huanglong (229), when Sun Quan assumed the imperial title, Pan Zhang became General of the Right. Records, Wu 11 §19Records, Wu 2 §61Records, Wu 10 §94
Pan Zhang was rough and fierce by character, but his prohibitions and orders were strict and he was eager to achieve merit. The troops and horses he led numbered no more than a few thousand, yet wherever he was it always seemed as if there were ten thousand. Whenever a campaign halted and he camped, he would set up a military market, and goods not found in other armies could all be obtained there in abundance. But he was extravagant by nature, all the more so in his last years, and his clothing and possessions exceeded his station. He sometimes killed wealthy officials and soldiers and seized their property, and repeatedly failed to uphold the law; the supervising officials impeached him, but Sun Quan, valuing his merit, always pardoned him and did not pursue the matter. Records, Wu 10 §95
He died in the 3rd year of Jiahe (234). His son Pan Ping was banished to Kuaiji for his bad conduct. Pan Zhang's wife was settled at Jianye and granted fields and a house, and 50 households of retainers were exempted from labour service for her. That year Sun Quan had Lü Dai take command of Pan Zhang's troops and station them at Lukou. Records, Wu 10 §96Records, Wu 15 §39
In his assessment, Chen Shou called all the commanders of this scroll tiger-like servants of Jiangbiao whom the Sun family treated generously, and wrote that Sun Quan could forget the faults and remember the merits even of a man who did not cultivate his conduct, such as Pan Zhang, so it was fitting that he held and secured the southeast. Records, Wu 10 §109
In Chapter 38 of the Romance, Pan Zhang is first named among the fine commanders Sun Quan acquired, as 'Pan Zhang of Dong Commandery, courtesy name Wengui'. In the same chapter, when Sun Quan attacks Huang Zu, he captures Huang Zu's commander Su Fei, who is fleeing across the fields, after barely a few bouts, and drags him to Sun Quan on his ship. Romance, Ch. 38 §27 · 50
In Chapter 44, when Zhou Yu sets out, he leads the third division together with Ling Tong. At the battle of Red Cliffs in Chapter 49 he takes 3,000 soldiers all bearing white flags to Hanyang to support Dong Xi, and in Chapter 50 he splits off from Dong Xi to set fires and raise battle cries. In Chapter 51, when Cao Ren's soldiers hurl insults, Zhou Yu sends Pan Zhang out to fight, but before they even clash Zhou Yu spits blood and falls from his horse. This is Zhou Yu's ruse to draw Cao Ren out, and that night Pan Zhang attacks Cao Ren's army from the west together with Zhou Tai. Romance, Ch. 44 §38Romance, Ch. 49 §27Romance, Ch. 50 §7Romance, Ch. 51 §32–33 · 36
In Chapter 55, when Liu Bei flees with Lady Sun, Sun Quan gives Chen Wu and Pan Zhang 500 picked soldiers to pursue them day and night and bring them back. The two join Xu Sheng and Ding Feng and catch up, but withdraw when Lady Sun rebukes them: 'Chen Wu, Pan Zhang, what business brings you here?' Then, hearing Sun Quan's strict orders from Jiang Qin and Zhou Tai, they set off again in pursuit along the river. At Ruxu in Chapter 61 he comes out on the left together with Chen Wu when Sun Quan faces Cao Cao, and in Chapter 67 he commands the rearguard of the army attacking Wan together with Jiang Qin. Romance, Ch. 55 §16 · 28–33Romance, Ch. 61 §44Romance, Ch. 67 §37
In Chapter 75 he is one of the seven senior commanders who advance in succession when Lü Meng crosses the river with soldiers dressed in white. In Chapter 77 Lü Meng foresees that Guan Yu will flee from Maicheng by the byway to Linju, and has Pan Zhang lie in ambush on a remote mountain path at Linju with 500 elite soldiers. Pan Zhang charges Guan Yu at a gallop, brandishing his blade, but is defeated and flees after only three bouts. Afterwards at Jueshi, Pan Zhang's lieutenant Ma Zhong captures Guan Yu with hooks and lassos, and Pan Zhang and Zhu Ran surround and capture Guan Ping. Romance, Ch. 75 §31Romance, Ch. 77 §1–2 · 7–9
In Chapter 81 Liu Bei says that, together with Sun Quan who harmed his brother, Fu Shiren, Mi Fang, Pan Zhang and Ma Zhong are also enemies he hates with gnashing teeth. In Chapter 82, on Zhang Zhao's proposal, Pan Zhang becomes the vanguard of the Wu army, and in Chapter 83, when Huang Zhong singles out Pan Zhang alone to challenge, he meets him wielding the Green Dragon Blade that Lord Guan had used. His lieutenant Shi Ji is cut down by Huang Zhong and Pan Zhang also flees after a few bouts, but the next day, dragging his blade and feigning flight, he lures Huang Zhong into an ambush, and Ma Zhong hits Huang Zhong in the shoulder with an arrow. Romance, Ch. 81 §2Romance, Ch. 82 §38Romance, Ch. 83 §3–5
In Chapter 83, when the Wu army scatters in the battle of Xiaoting, Guan Xing meets his enemy Pan Zhang and pursues him, and Pan Zhang flees into a mountain valley. Late at night Pan Zhang comes looking for lodging at a farmhouse in the mountains where an image of Lord Guan is enshrined, but Guan Xing has arrived there first. As Pan Zhang turns to leave, Lord Guan manifests his divine power and enters; Pan Zhang cries out, his soul flies from him, and he is cut down by Guan Xing's sword. Guan Xing cuts out his heart and offers it in sacrifice before the image of Lord Guan, and recovers his father's Green Dragon Crescent Blade. Romance, Ch. 83 §16–17 · 19–20
Capture of Su Fei: In Chapter 38 of the Romance, Pan Zhang captures the fleeing Su Fei during the attack on Huang Zu. The Biography of Pan Zhang in the Records does not mention the battle against Huang Zu, and the name Su Fei does not even appear in Chen Shou's main text. Romance, Ch. 38 §50Records, Wu 10 §88–96
Red Cliffs: In Chapters 49–50 of the Romance, Pan Zhang supports Dong Xi at Hanyang with 3,000 soldiers bearing white flags and sets fires. The Biography of Pan Zhang in the Records does not mention the battle of Red Cliffs. Romance, Ch. 49 §27Romance, Ch. 50 §7Records, Wu 10 §88–96
Pursuit of Liu Bei: In Chapter 55 of the Romance, Pan Zhang pursues Liu Bei together with Chen Wu and is rebuked by Lady Sun. The Biography of Pan Zhang in the Records has no such episode, and in that biography Chen Wu is killed fighting in the battle of Hefei. Romance, Ch. 55 §16 · 29Records, Wu 10 §88–96 · 91
Hefei: In the Romance, Pan Zhang is only named in Chapter 67 as part of the rearguard of the army attacking Wan. In the Records, when Zhang Liao fell upon them in the battle of Hefei and Song Qian and Xu Sheng broke, he cut down two fleeing soldiers, rallied the army and became Lieutenant General. Romance, Ch. 67 §37Records, Wu 10 §91
The battle that captured Guan Yu: In Chapter 77 of the Romance, Pan Zhang lies in ambush on the byway to Linju, is defeated by Guan Yu in three bouts and flees, and at Jueshi his lieutenant Ma Zhong captures Guan Yu. In the Records, Pan Zhang reached Linju with Zhu Ran and camped at Jiashi, and Pan Zhang's Major Ma Zhong captured Guan Yu at Zhangxiang. There is no record of Pan Zhang fighting Guan Yu in person. Romance, Ch. 77 §7–9Records, Wu 10 §92Records, Wu 2 §28
The Green Dragon Blade: In Chapter 83 of the Romance, Pan Zhang fights Huang Zhong wielding the Green Dragon Blade that Lord Guan had used, and after his death Guan Xing recovers the blade. The Biographies of Pan Zhang and of Guan Yu in the Records contain no story of Guan Yu's blade. Romance, Ch. 83 §3 · 20Records, Wu 10 §88–96Records, Shu 6 §1–13
Battle with Huang Zhong: In Chapter 83 of the Romance, Pan Zhang fights Huang Zhong, who has come out to Yiling in the 2nd year of Zhangwu (222), and Ma Zhong hits Huang Zhong with an arrow. In the Biography of Huang Zhong in the Records, Huang Zhong died the year after Liu Bei became King of Hanzhong and took no part in this battle. Romance, Ch. 83 §1 · 3–5Records, Shu 6 §36–37
Death of Feng Xi: In Chapter 84 of the Romance, Feng Xi is trapped front and rear by the Wu army together with Zhang Nan and dies in the confused fighting. In the Biography of Pan Zhang in the Records, Pan Zhang's men cut down Liu Bei's Protector of the Army Feng Xi and others, and for this merit Pan Zhang became General Who Pacifies the North and Administrator of Xiangyang. Romance, Ch. 84 §37Records, Wu 10 §92
Death: In Chapter 83 of the Romance, Pan Zhang is killed by Guan Xing at a mountain farmhouse during the battle of Xiaoting in the 2nd year of Zhangwu (222). In the Records, he afterwards also went to relieve Jiangling and covered the rear at the battle of Shiyang, became General of the Right and died in the 3rd year of Jiahe (234). Romance, Ch. 83 §1 · 19Records, Wu 10 §93–96Records, Wu 11 §19
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.
RBanditry ceased wherever he served, he pacified Jianchang within a month, and set up military markets to supply goodsWu 10 §89Wu 10 §90Wu 10 §95
NNo direct record — estimated from his career as a warriorCh. 38 §27
RExtravagant, he killed wealthy soldiers to seize their property, and the assessment says he did not cultivate his conductWu 10 §95Wu 10 §109
NNo direct record — estimated from the record of his holding Guan Yu's Green Dragon BladeCh. 83 §20
RSpecially favoured by Sun Quan, he recruited over a hundred men and gathered 800 scattered peopleWu 10 §89Wu 10 §90
NNo direct record — estimated from his career as a warriorCh. 38 §27
RAt Hefei galloped forward and cut down two fleeing soldiersWu 10 §91
NFled after three bouts with Guan Yu, was also chased off by Huang Zhong, and was cut down by Guan XingCh. 77 §8Ch. 83 §4Ch. 83 §19
RFollowed Sun Quan early, and was always pardoned for his merit even when he broke the lawWu 10 §89Wu 10 §95
NPursued by Guan Xing, he lost his wits at Lord Guan's manifestation and was cut downCh. 83 §19
RNo direct record — estimated from the career of a wine-loving warriorWu 10 §89
NNo direct record — estimated from his career as a warriorCh. 38 §27
RNo direct record — estimated from his career as a warriorWu 10 §89
NNo direct record — estimated from his career as a warriorCh. 38 §27
RNo direct record — estimated from the record of his subordinate Ma Zhong capturing Guan YuWu 10 §92
NNo direct record — estimated from his command of his lieutenant Ma ZhongCh. 83 §21
Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)
3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.
AppearsNot present Chapter list →
Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).
Ownership and authorship assigned by 3KDEX from source sentences — not yet reviewed (unverified).