Battle

Lü Meng's invasion of Jing Province 麥城之戰

About this event

Lü Meng's invasion of Jing Province was the fight in the winter of the 24th year of Jian'an (219) in which Sun Quan struck from behind at Guan Yu, who had gone out to Fancheng, took Jing Province and captured Guan Yu. When Lü Meng, with soldiers disguised as merchants, captured the lookouts along the river, induced Shi Ren at Gong'an and Mi Fang in Nan Commandery to surrender and took Jiangling, the troops of Guan Yu, who was withdrawing from the Battle of Fancheng, scattered. Guan Yu fell back to Maicheng, and while fleeing from there he was captured and killed together with his son Guan Ping in the 12th month (early 220 CE). Records, Wu 2 §27–28Records, Wu 9 §82–85Records, Shu 6 §12

Chen Shou recorded this battle in the Biography of the Lord of Wu (Records of Wu 2), and also included it in scattered places such as Records of Wu 9, 10, 11 and 13 and the Biographies of Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, Ma Chao, Huang Zhong and Zhao Yun (Records of Shu 6). The Romance depicts Guan Yu's death at the beginning of Chapter 77, by way of Chapter 75, "Lü Ziming Crosses the River in White," and Chapter 76, "Guan Yunchang Is Defeated and Flees to Maicheng." Records, Wu 2 §26–28Records, Wu 9 §77–86Records, Wu 10 §92Records, Wu 11 §14Records, Wu 13 §9–13Records, Shu 6 §11–12Romance, Ch. 75 §16–42Romance, Ch. 76 §1–46Romance, Ch. 77 §1–18

Course of events in the Records

Lü Meng, who was stationed at Lukou after Lu Su's death, judged that Guan Yu was valiant, had a mind to swallow up others and occupied the upper reaches above the state, so that the situation could not last long, and he secretly proposed to Sun Quan that they attack Guan Yu and take the whole of the Yangtze. Earlier, Sun Quan had asked for Guan Yu's daughter for his son, but Guan Yu had berated and insulted the envoy and refused, and Sun Quan was furious. Mi Fang, Administrator of Nan Commandery at Jiangling, and General Shi Ren at Gong'an resented Guan Yu's slighting of them, and when Guan Yu, having taken the field, said that they had not properly supplied his army and that he would deal with them when he returned, they were afraid. Records, Wu 9 §77–80Records, Shu 6 §11–12

When Guan Yu, attacking Fan, left many defending troops at Gong'an and Nan Commandery, Lü Meng submitted a memorial proposing that he return to Jianye on the pretext of illness so as to make Guan Yu withdraw those troops, and Sun Quan recalled him by an open dispatch. Lü Meng recommended Lu Xun, who was not yet well known and so would not alarm Guan Yu, and when Lu Xun, on arriving at Lukou, sent him a humble letter, Guan Yu was greatly reassured. Guan Yu gradually withdrew troops and sent them to Fan, and when his men and horses numbered in the tens of thousands after he captured Yu Jin and the others, he took the rice of Xiang Pass (湘關) on his own authority, claiming a lack of provisions. Hearing of this, Sun Quan finally set out. Records, Wu 9 §81–82Records, Wu 13 §9–12

In the intercalary month Sun Quan attacked Guan Yu, sending Lü Meng ahead. At Xunyang Lü Meng hid his elite soldiers inside covered boats and had men in white clothes, dressed as merchants, row them, and he seized and bound all the lookouts Guan Yu had posted along the river, so that Guan Yu knew nothing of it. The Biography of the Lord of Wu records that Lü Meng raided Gong'an and captured Shi Ren, and that when he reached Nan Commandery, Mi Fang surrendered the city; the Biography of Lü Meng records that Shi Ren and Mi Fang both surrendered. Yu Fan urged Lü Meng to enter quickly and take hold of the keys, since not everyone in the city could be trusted, and because of this a plan for an ambush inside the city was never carried out. Lu Xun separately took Yidu and garrisoned Yiling to guard the mouth of the Gorges. Records, Wu 2 §27Records, Wu 9 §82–83Records, Wu 12 §7–8Records, Wu 13 §12–13

Lü Meng, having taken Jiangling, secured and comforted all the families of Guan Yu and his officers and men; he forbade his army to intrude on people's homes, and with tears he beheaded a soldier from his own home district who had used a commoner's rain hat to cover an official suit of armor. He had the elderly looked after and gave physicians and medicine to the sick, and sealed Guan Yu's storehouses to await Sun Quan. When Guan Yu, on his way back, repeatedly sent envoys, Lü Meng let the envoys go all around the city, and Guan Yu's officers and men, hearing that their families were safe, lost their will to fight. Sun Quan released Yu Jin and the other prisoners. Records, Wu 9 §83–84Records, Wu 2 §27

Guan Yu, having been defeated by Xu Huang and withdrawn, found his troops scattering because Sun Quan had already taken Jiangling and captured the wives and children of his officers and men; he returned to Dangyang and to the west held Maicheng. When Sun Quan sent someone to induce him to surrender, Guan Yu pretended to surrender, set up flags and straw figures on the walls and fled, but his soldiers all scattered and only a dozen or so horsemen remained. The Biography of Wu Fan records that when Guan Yu at Maicheng sent an envoy asking to surrender, Wu Fan said it was a trick because he showed signs of wanting to flee. Records, Shu 6 §12Records, Wu 2 §27–28Records, Wu 18 §5

Sun Quan had already sent Zhu Ran and Pan Zhang to cut off his route, and in the 12th month Ma Zhong, Major under Pan Zhang, captured Guan Yu, his son Guan Ping, the Commander Zhao Lei and others at Zhangxiang, and Jing Province was at last pacified. The Biography of Pan Zhang says that Pan Zhang and Zhu Ran reached Linju and stationed themselves at Jiashi, and the Biography of Guan Yu records that Guan Yu and Guan Ping were beheaded at Linju. A great epidemic broke out that year, and Sun Quan exempted the people of Jing Province from taxes, while Cao Cao memorialized the throne to make Sun Quan General of Agile Cavalry and Governor of Jing Province. The Annals of Emperor Wu record that in the 1st month of the 25th year of Jian'an Sun Quan beheaded Guan Yu and sent his head. Records, Wu 2 §28Records, Wu 10 §92Records, Wu 11 §14Records, Shu 6 §12Records, Wei 1 §171

Liu Feng and Meng Da at Shangyong had been repeatedly asked to send troops after Guan Yu surrounded Fan and Xiangyang, but did not comply, on the grounds that the mountain commanderies had only just submitted. When Guan Yu was defeated, Liu Bei resented them, and Meng Da surrendered to Wei. Lü Meng was appointed Administrator of Nan Commandery and enfeoffed as Marquis of Canling, but soon his illness flared up and he died at forty-two. Records, Shu 10 §4–5Records, Wu 9 §86–87

In the Romance

In Chapter 75 of the Romance, Lü Meng, unable to attack Jing Province because of the beacon towers Guan Yu has built along the river, stays in on the pretext of illness and, following Lu Xun's plan, resigns his post. When Lu Xun, who has taken charge of Lukou on Lü Meng's recommendation, sends a humble letter and gifts, Guan Yu laughs that they have made such a callow youth a general and moves most of the Jing Province troops to Fancheng. Romance, Ch. 75 §19–28

Lü Meng, now Grand Commander, has men in white clothes dressed as merchants row more than eighty fast boats with elite soldiers hidden in covered boats, captures all the soldiers guarding the beacon towers, then sends them ahead to get the city gates opened, and takes Jing Province by surprise. Lü Meng beheads a man from his home district who covered an official suit of armor with a commoner's rain hat, and Sun Quan releases Yu Jin from prison and sends him back to Cao Cao. Fu Shiren, on receiving Yu Fan's letter, surrenders Gong'an, and in Chapter 76 Mi Fang too surrenders Nan Commandery, together with Fu Shiren, who beheads the envoy pressing for Guan Yu's provisions. Romance, Ch. 75 §31–41Romance, Ch. 76 §1–4

At the news that Jing Province is lost, Guan Yu's wound bursts open in his rage and he collapses, regretting that he did not heed Wang Fu. On the road back to Jing Province, word spreads that Lü Meng is caring for the families of the officers and men, and deserters increase; surrounded by Jiang Qin, Han Dang, Zhou Tai, Ding Feng and Xu Sheng, and with the men of Jing Province on the hills calling out names, Guan Yu is left with only some three hundred followers. Guan Ping and Liao Hua break through the encirclement, rescue Guan Yu and enter Maicheng. Romance, Ch. 76 §19–22 · 27–33

Liao Hua breaks through the encirclement and goes to Shangyong to ask for help, but Liu Feng and Meng Da refuse on the grounds that the mountain cities have only just submitted, and Guan Yu sends away Zhuge Jin, who has come to urge him to surrender, saying that jade may be smashed but its whiteness cannot be changed. In Chapter 77 Guan Yu, slipping out by the north gate, is pursued by the ambushes of Zhu Ran and Pan Zhang, and at Jueshi his horse is caught by hooks and falls, and he is captured by Ma Zhong, a subordinate general of Pan Zhang; after refusing to surrender before Sun Quan, he is put to death together with Guan Ping on the advice of the Registrar Zuo Xian. The Romance gives the time as the 12th month in the winter of the 24th year of Jian'an, when Guan Yu was 58 years old. Romance, Ch. 76 §35–45Romance, Ch. 77 §1–13

Where the Romance differs

Shi Ren's name and surrender: In Chapters 75 and 76 of the Romance, the commander at Gong'an is Fu Shiren, who surrenders on receiving Yu Fan's letter, then goes to Mi Fang, beheads the envoy pressing for Guan Yu's provisions, and surrenders together with him. The Ji Han Fuchen Zan in the Records calls him Shi Ren, courtesy name Junyi, a man of Guangyang, and the Biography of the Lord of Wu records that Lü Meng raided Gong'an and captured him. In the Biography of Yu Fan, what Yu Fan did was to urge Lü Meng, after Mi Fang surrendered, to enter the city quickly. Romance, Ch. 75 §38–42Romance, Ch. 76 §1–4Records, Shu 15 §82Records, Wu 2 §27Records, Wu 12 §7–8

The way out of Maicheng: In Chapter 77 of the Romance, Guan Yu leads some two hundred men out through the north gate. In the Biography of the Lord of Wu in the Records, Guan Yu pretended to surrender to Sun Quan, set up flags and straw figures on the walls and fled, and his soldiers scattered until only a dozen or so horsemen remained. Romance, Ch. 77 §6Records, Wu 2 §28

Where Guan Yu was captured and his end: In Chapter 77 of the Romance, Guan Yu is captured at Jueshi, brought before Sun Quan, and put to death on Zuo Xian's advice. In the Records, the Biography of the Lord of Wu says that Ma Zhong captured him at Zhangxiang, the Biography of Pan Zhang gives Jiashi in Linju, and the Biography of Guan Yu records that he was beheaded at Linju; there is no exchange with Sun Quan. Romance, Ch. 77 §8–13Records, Wu 2 §28Records, Wu 10 §92Records, Shu 6 §12

Liao Hua: In Chapter 76 of the Romance, Liao Hua breaks through the encirclement of Maicheng, goes to Shangyong to ask for help and then leaves for Chengdu. In the Biography of Liao Hua in the Records, Liao Hua, who had been Guan Yu's Registrar, came under Wu when Guan Yu was defeated, then feigned death, took his old mother west and met Liu Bei at Zigui. Romance, Ch. 76 §35–41Records, Shu 15 §24

Shangyong's refusal: In Chapter 76 of the Romance, Meng Da blocks the relief by citing Guan Yu's saying that Liu Feng, being an adopted son, should not be made heir. The Biography of Liu Feng in the Records records only that after Guan Yu surrounded Fan and Xiangyang he repeatedly called on them, but the two did not comply, on the grounds that the mountain commanderies had only just submitted. Romance, Ch. 76 §38–40Records, Shu 10 §4

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Belligerents

ItemAB
FactionsWuShu
CommandersLu Xun(陸遜), Lü Meng, Sun Quan, Zhu Ran, Pan Zhang, Ma Zhong(馬忠)Guan Yu, Guan Ping, Zhao Lei
Casualties兵皆解散,尚十餘騎

Factions, commanders, strength and casualties are checked against the source texts (3KDEX). Strength and casualties show only figures stated in the sources. Source: Wu 2 §28

Sub-events and Romance scenes (1)

Romance chapters (3)

Records volumes (10)