Zhou Yu 周瑜

RecordsRomance Wu Courtesy name 公瑾 Gongjin주유공근주랑周郎

Profile
OccupationRGeneral · Lieutenant General · Administrator of Nan Commandery NGeneral · Grand CommanderFactionWu
AppearsRNBiography inBook of Wu
BornR175 UnverifiedNative placeLujiang Commandery Shu County
DiedR210 UnverifiedPlace of deathRNBaqiu
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR102

Profile

Zhou Yu, courtesy name Gongjin, was a native of Shu County in Lujiang Commandery. Being the same age as Sun Ce, he was close to him from boyhood, and he fought at his side from the time Sun Ce pacified Jiangdong. After Sun Ce's death he served Sun Quan together with Zhang Zhao. Records, Wu 9 §2–3 · 7

In the 13th year of Jian'an (208), when Cao Cao took Jing Province and came south, he argued for meeting him in battle, and together with Cheng Pu he joined forces with Liu Bei and defeated Cao Cao at Red Cliffs. He then drove Cao Ren out of Nan Commandery and became Administrator of Nan Commandery, but while preparing to march against Shu he died of illness at Baqiu. He was thirty-six. Records, Wu 9 §10–16 · 21Records, Wu 2 §15

In his assessment, Chen Shou wrote that when Cao Cao swept through Jing Province all the advisers wavered, but that Zhou Yu and Lu Su, with the clear insight to decide on their own, rose above the crowd and were truly men of extraordinary talent. In the Romance he first appeared in Chapter 15 and was named in 24 of its 120 chapters, and, as in the title of Chapter 51, "Kongming Angers Zhou Gongjin for the First Time," he was portrayed as a rival of Zhuge Liang. Records, Wu 9 §95Romance, Ch. 15 §16Romance, Ch. 51 §41

In the Records

His great-uncle Zhou Jing and Zhou Jing's son Zhou Zhong both served as Grand Commandant of the Han, and his father was Prefect of Luoyang. As he grew up, Zhou Yu was tall and strongly built, with a handsome appearance. When Sun Jian set out against Dong Zhuo and moved his family to Shu, Zhou Yu became especially close to Sun Ce, who was the same age; he gave Sun Ce a large house south of the road, went up into the hall to bow to his mother, and they shared whatever they had or lacked. Records, Wu 9 §2

When he went to pay his respects to his uncle Zhou Shang, then Administrator of Danyang, he received a letter from Sun Ce, who had come to Liyang to cross the river, and led troops to meet him. Sun Ce rejoiced, saying, "Now that I have you, things will go as I wish." Together they took Hengjiang and Dangli, defeated Ze Rong and Xue Li at Moling, and then entered Qu'e, whereupon Liu Yao fled. Zhou Yu returned to Danyang, but when Yuan Shu sent Yuan Yin to replace Zhou Shang, he went to Shouchun; judging that Yuan Shu would never achieve anything, he asked to be made Chief of Juchao, and in the 3rd year of Jian'an (198) he returned from Juchao to Wu. Records, Wu 9 §2–4

Sun Ce went out in person to welcome Zhou Yu, made him General of the Household Who Establishes Might (jianwei zhonglang jiang), and gave him 2,000 troops and 50 horses. He was then twenty-four, and the people of Wu called him "Zhou Lang" (Young Master Zhou). He guarded Niuzhu and concurrently served as Chief of Chungu, and when Sun Ce sought to take Jing Province, he became Central Protector of the Army (zhong hujun) and Administrator of Jiangxia and took Wan County. At this time they obtained the two daughters of Lord Qiao; Sun Ce took Daqiao as his wife and Zhou Yu took Xiaoqiao. He then defeated Liu Xun near Xunyang, attacked Jiangxia, pacified Yuzhang and Luling, and stayed behind to guard Baqiu. Records, Wu 9 §5–6

When Sun Ce died in the 5th year of Jian'an (200), Zhou Yu led his troops to the mourning and stayed on in Wu, where, as Central Protector of the Army, he took charge of affairs together with the Chief Clerk Zhang Zhao. The Dowager had Sun Quan serve Zhou Yu as an elder brother, and at a time when the generals and guests still observed only simple courtesies, Zhou Yu alone took the lead in observing the etiquette of a subject. Zhou Yu, who had earlier befriended Lu Su when Lu Su gave him an entire granary, held Lu Su back when he was about to go north and recommended him to Sun Quan. Records, Wu 9 §7 · 22 · 32–33 · 35–36

In the 11th year of Jian'an (206) he led Sun Yu and others to attack the two strongholds of Ma and Bao, and when Huang Zu sent his general Deng Long into Chaisang, Zhou Yu pursued him and captured Deng Long. In the spring of the 13th year (208), when Sun Quan attacked Jiangxia, he served as Chief Commander of the Vanguard (qianbu dadu). In the 9th month of that year Cao Cao entered Jing Province and Liu Cong surrendered; now also in possession of the navy, Cao Cao had ships and infantry numbering in the hundreds of thousands, and the officers and men were all afraid. Records, Wu 9 §8

When Sun Quan asked for plans, his officials said that Cao Cao held the Son of Heaven in his grasp and now shared the natural barrier of the Yangtze with them, so it would be better to welcome him. Zhou Yu, who had been away at Poyang and was summoned back at Lu Su's urging, said that Cao Cao was a traitor to the Han; that the north was not at peace and Ma Chao and Han Sui were still west of the passes; that fighting from boats was not the forte of men of the Central Plains; and that in the depth of winter there was no fodder for the horses, while the unfamiliar water and climate would surely bring sickness. He then asked for 30,000 picked troops to advance to Xiakou, promising to crush Cao Cao, and Sun Quan said that Heaven had given him to him. Records, Wu 9 §9–13 · 45

Sun Quan sent Zhou Yu, Cheng Pu and others to join forces with Liu Bei, and they met Cao Cao at Red Cliffs. Cao Cao's army, already stricken by disease, lost the first engagement and withdrew to the north bank of the river. When his subordinate general Huang Gai pointed out that the enemy's ships were lined up bow to stern and could be set on fire and put to flight, they filled several dozen mengchong assault ships and fighting vessels with brushwood and oil, and first sent a letter feigning surrender. Huang Gai cast the ships loose and set them alight; the wind happened to be very fierce, and even the camps on the riverbank burned down. Cao Cao fell back to Nan Commandery, then left Cao Ren and others at Jiangling and returned north. Records, Wu 9 §14–16

Zhou Yu and Cheng Pu advanced to Nan Commandery and faced Cao Ren across the river. He first sent Gan Ning to seize Yiling, and when Cao Ren surrounded Gan Ning, he followed Lü Meng's plan, leaving Ling Tong to guard the rear, and went in person with Lü Meng to relieve him. On the day set for the great battle, Zhou Yu rode out in person and swept through the enemy lines, but was struck in the right side by a stray arrow. When Cao Ren heard that Zhou Yu was lying in bed unable to rise, he drew up his troops for battle; Zhou Yu got up by himself, went round the camps and roused his officers and men, and Cao Ren withdrew. In the 14th year of Jian'an (209), after a standoff of more than a year, Cao Ren abandoned the city and fled. Records, Wu 9 §17–18Records, Wu 2 §15

Sun Quan made Zhou Yu Lieutenant General (pian jiangjun) and Administrator of Nan Commandery, granted him four counties as his fief, and stationed him at Jiangling. When Liu Bei came to Jing to meet Sun Quan, Zhou Yu submitted a memorial saying that Liu Bei had the makings of a fierce hero and commanded bear- and tiger-like generals such as Guan Yu and Zhang Fei, so he should be moved to Wu, where palaces and beautiful women would delight his eyes and ears, and the two generals should be separated from him; to carve off land for him, he warned, would be like letting a dragon obtain clouds and rain. Sun Quan, reasoning that with Cao Cao in the north he ought to gather heroes widely, and that Liu Bei would be hard to subdue quickly, did not accept it. Records, Wu 9 §19–20

When Liu Zhang, Governor of Yi Province, was invaded by Zhang Lu, Zhou Yu went to Jing and proposed that he and Sun Yu, General Who Displays Might (fenwei jiangjun), take Shu, absorb Zhang Lu and ally with Ma Chao, and then return to hold Xiangyang with Sun Quan and press Cao Cao hard. Sun Quan agreed, and on his way back to Jiangling to make preparations Zhou Yu died of illness at Baqiu, aged thirty-six. When his illness became critical he memorialized that Lu Su was fit to replace him. Sun Quan put on plain mourning clothes and wailed for him, went out as far as Wuhu to meet his coffin, and bore all the funeral expenses. The man who escorted the coffin to Wu was Pang Tong. Records, Wu 9 §20–21 · 47–48Records, Shu 7 §4

Zhou Yu was broad-minded and magnanimous and generally won people's hearts, but he did not get on with Cheng Pu alone. From youth he was expert in music, and even after three rounds of wine, if a performer made a mistake he would always notice and turn his head, so a song arose: "If the tune is wrong, Zhou Lang turns to look." His daughter married the Crown Prince Sun Deng. Later Zhuge Jin and Bu Zhi praised his merit, saying that Zhou Yu had crushed Cao Cao at Wulin and put Cao Ren to flight at Ying. Records, Wu 9 §22–25

In his assessment, Chen Shou said that when Lord Cao, using his position as Chancellor of the Han as a springboard, swept through Jing Province and cast his eyes eastward, all the advisers were doubtful and divided in mind, but Zhou Yu and Lu Su alone established the clear insight to decide on their own and rose above the crowd; they were truly men of extraordinary talent. He also judged apt, and so recorded, Sun Quan's assessment to Lu Xun: "Gongjin was heroic and fierce, his courage and strategy surpassed other men's, and so he defeated Mengde and opened up Jing Province." Records, Wu 9 §95 · 90

In the Romance

In Chapter 15 of the Romance he appeared at the head of troops before Sun Ce, who was on his way to Liyang. He was introduced as being the same age as Sun Ce and his sworn brother, born two months later and so serving Sun Ce as his elder brother, and he recommended Zhang Zhao and Zhang Hong to Sun Ce. In Chapter 29, on hearing of Sun Ce's death, he hurried back from Baqiu, pledged his loyalty to Sun Quan, and recommended Lu Su, going in person to bring him. Romance, Ch. 15 §16–18Romance, Ch. 29 §39–41 · 44–45

In Chapter 44, when Zhuge Liang, claiming that Cao Cao wanted the two Qiao women of Jiangdong, recited the "Rhapsody on the Bronze Sparrow Terrace," Zhou Yu pointed north and cursed, saying that Daqiao was Sun Ce's wife and Xiaoqiao his own. Before Sun Quan he listed the military taboos Cao Cao had violated and urged war, and Sun Quan cut off a corner of his desk with his sword, then gave him the sword and made him Grand Commander. Yet, holding that Kongming's talents were a notch above his own, Zhou Yu sought to kill him, and he also charged him with making 100,000 arrows within ten days. Romance, Ch. 44 §16–17 · 22 · 29–30 · 36Romance, Ch. 46 §4–6

In Chapter 45 he welcomed his old friend Jiang Gan, sent by Cao Cao, with the Gathering of Heroes banquet, feigned heavy drunkenness, and let Jiang Gan steal a letter forged to look as if Cai Mao and Zhang Yun had sent it, so that Cao Cao had the two beheaded. In Chapter 46 he used the self-injury ruse: in collusion with Huang Gai, he had him flogged in front of the generals so that his feigned surrender would be believed. Romance, Ch. 45 §37–38 · 46–48 · 53–54Romance, Ch. 46 §36–42

In Chapter 49, worrying over the direction of the wind, he coughed up blood and collapsed; Kongming put his finger on the root of the illness and borrowed the southeast wind at the Seven Stars Altar on Mount Nanping. Zhou Yu dispatched his various divisions and personally urged on the battle together with Cheng Pu aboard a great ship. Romance, Ch. 49 §1 · 6–8 · 25–28

In Chapter 51, attacking the city of Nan Commandery, he was hit in the left side by a crossbow bolt at a pitfall inside the city gate. At Cao Ren's taunts he pretended to cough up blood and fall from his horse, spread word that he had died, lured Cao Ren out and defeated him; but in the meantime Zhao Yun took Nan Commandery on Kongming's orders, and when Jingzhou and Xiangyang were lost as well, Zhou Yu cried out and his wound burst open. Romance, Ch. 51 §25 · 31–37 · 39–41

In Chapter 54 he tried to lure the widowed Liu Bei to Nanxu and hold him there, on the pretext of marrying him to Sun Quan's sister, but in Chapter 55 Liu Bei escaped together with the sister, and Zhou Yu, in pursuit, heard the shout, "Zhou Lang's brilliant plan to pacify the realm has cost him a wife and his troops besides," and his wound burst open. In Chapter 56 he planned to attack Jing Province under the pretext of attacking Xichuan, but in Chapter 57, on reaching Baqiu and receiving a letter from Kongming, he sighed, "Since Heaven made Zhou Yu, why did it also make Zhuge Liang?" and died at thirty-six. Kongming went to Chaisang, read a funeral oration and offered his condolences. Romance, Ch. 54 §13Romance, Ch. 55 §41–42Romance, Ch. 56 §37Romance, Ch. 57 §2–5 · 10–11

Where the Romance differs

Bond with Sun Ce: In Chapter 15 of the Romance the two swore brotherhood, and Sun Ce, born two months earlier, became the elder brother. The biography of Zhou Yu in the Records says only that the two were the same age and especially close. Romance, Ch. 15 §16Records, Wu 9 §2

Reason for fighting: In Chapter 44 of the Romance, Zhou Yu was enraged on hearing, from the "Rhapsody on the Bronze Sparrow Terrace" recited by Zhuge Liang, that Cao Cao had designs on the two Qiao women. The reasons Zhou Yu gave in the biography of Zhou Yu in the Records were matters of circumstance: that Cao Cao was a traitor to the Han, the threat at his rear in the north, unfamiliar naval warfare, and the lack of fodder and the disease of deep winter; there is no story about the Qiao women. Romance, Ch. 44 §16–22Records, Wu 9 §10–12 · 1–30

Command at Red Cliffs: In Chapter 44 of the Romance, Sun Quan made Zhou Yu Grand Commander and Cheng Pu Vice Commander. In the Biography of the Lord of Wu in the Records, Zhou Yu and Cheng Pu served as Left and Right Commanders, each leading 10,000 men. Romance, Ch. 44 §30Records, Wu 2 §13

Jiang Gan: In Chapter 45 of the Romance, Zhou Yu deceived Jiang Gan and so brought about the deaths of Cai Mao and Zhang Yun. Jiang Gan does not appear in the biography of Zhou Yu in the Records. Romance, Ch. 45 §46–48 · 53–54Records, Wu 9 §1–30

The self-injury ruse: In Chapter 46 of the Romance, Huang Gai, in collusion with Zhou Yu, took a flogging so that his feigned surrender would be believed. In the biography of Zhou Yu in the Records, Huang Gai merely proposed the fire attack and sent a letter feigning surrender; there is no story of a beating. Romance, Ch. 46 §37 · 41–42Records, Wu 9 §15

The southeast wind: In Chapter 49 of the Romance, Kongming borrowed the southeast wind at the Seven Stars Altar. The biography of Zhou Yu in the Records says only that the wind happened to be very fierce when the fire was set. Romance, Ch. 49 §7–8Records, Wu 9 §16

The arrow in his side: In Chapter 51 of the Romance, Zhou Yu was hit in the left side by a crossbow bolt before a pitfall inside the gate of the city of Nan Commandery. In the Records, on the day set for a great battle, he rode in person through the enemy lines and was hit in the right side by a stray arrow, and Cao Ren withdrew when Zhou Yu rose and went round the camps. Romance, Ch. 51 §24–25Records, Wu 9 §17–18

Who took Nan Commandery: In Chapter 51 of the Romance, Zhao Yun took Nan Commandery while Zhou Yu was fighting Cao Ren. In the Records, after Zhou Yu and Cao Ren had faced each other for more than a year, Cao Ren abandoned the city and fled, and Sun Quan made Zhou Yu Administrator of Nan Commandery. Romance, Ch. 51 §39Records, Wu 2 §15

Scheme against Liu Bei: In Chapter 54 of the Romance, Zhou Yu tried to lure Liu Bei to Nanxu with Sun Quan's sister as bait and hold him there. In the biography of Zhou Yu in the Records, when Liu Bei came to Jing of his own accord, Zhou Yu memorialized that he should be kept in Wu and entertained with palaces and beautiful women, but Sun Quan did not accept this. Romance, Ch. 54 §13Records, Wu 9 §19–20

Death: In Chapters 51, 55 and 57 of the Romance, Zhou Yu was angered by Kongming three times, his wound bursting open again and again, and he died at Baqiu sighing, "Since Heaven made Zhou Yu, why did it also make Zhuge Liang?" In the Records he died of illness at Baqiu while preparing to march against Shu, and when his illness became critical he submitted a memorial recommending Lu Su as his successor. Romance, Ch. 51 §41Romance, Ch. 55 §42Romance, Ch. 57 §4–5Records, Wu 9 §21 · 47–48

Condolences: In Chapter 57 of the Romance, Kongming went to Chaisang with Zhao Yun and read a funeral oration. In the Records, the man who escorted Zhou Yu's coffin to Wu was Pang Tong. Romance, Ch. 57 §10–11Records, Shu 7 §4

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA9388−5
  • STR6655−11
  • INT9084−6
  • POL4842−6
  • CHA8476−8
  • VIR7650−26
  • ADP8858−30
  • SCH7070±0
  • DIP8478−6
  • DIS8078−2
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

VirtueR76N50 −26

RTook the lead in showing a subject's courtesy; recorded as having given his life in utmost loyaltyWu 9 §22Wu 9 §25

NRepeatedly tried to kill Zhuge Liang and Liu Bei; said to have brought on his death by his narrow-mindednessCh. 45 §5Ch. 46 §4Ch. 57 §15

StrengthR66N55 −11

RRode in person through the enemy lines and was struck in the side by an arrowWu 9 §17Wu 9 §25

NLed troops in person against the city, but no feats of personal prowess are recordedCh. 51 §23Ch. 51 §25

7 similar abilities — show evidence
  • LeadershipR93N88 −5

    RAs Left Commander, defeated Lord Cao at Red Cliffs and drove Cao Ren out of Nan CommanderyWu 9 §14Wu 9 §17Wu 9 §90

    NDirected the fire attack at Red Cliffs, but was defeated by Zhuge Liang's ambushes at Nan Commandery and HuangzhouCh. 49 §28Ch. 44 §39Ch. 55 §41

  • IntelligenceR90N84 −6

    RReckoned that Cao Cao's army had broken the taboos of warfare, and proposed a plan to take ShuWu 9 §11Wu 9 §12Wu 9 §21

    NUsed the double-agent ruse on Jiang Gan and the self-injury ruse, but lamented that Zhuge Liang was ten times his betterCh. 45 §47Ch. 46 §45Ch. 45 §10

  • PoliticsR48UnverifiedN42Unverified −6

    RNo direct record — estimated from his handling of affairs with Zhang Zhao as Central Protector of the ArmyWu 9 §7

    NNo direct record — estimated from his role as the general in charge of external affairsCh. 29 §41

  • CharismaR84N76 −8

    RHis kindness and good faith were known in Lujiang, and his broad magnanimity won people's heartsWu 9 §5Wu 9 §22

    NWon Cheng Pu's submission and led the heroes of Jiangdong at the Gathering of HeroesCh. 44 §39Ch. 45 §45Ch. 57 §6

  • ScholarshipR70N70 ±0

    RExpert in music from youth, he never failed to notice a mistake in a performanceWu 9 §23

    NUnderstood refined sentiments through strings and song, and composed and sang a song while performing a sword danceCh. 57 §6Ch. 45 §45

  • DiplomacyR84N78 −6

    RSun Quan praised his brilliant eloquence and argument; persuaded Sun Quan to resistWu 9 §92Wu 9 §10Wu 9 §35

    NArgued for resistance before Sun Quan and rebuffed Jiang Gan's persuasionCh. 44 §28Ch. 45 §44Ch. 44 §29

  • DiscernmentR80N78 −2

    RRecommended Lu Su and Gan Ning, and adopted the plans of Lü Meng and Huang GaiWu 9 §36Wu 10 §55Wu 9 §17

    NRecommended Lu Su, and again as his successor, and used Huang Gai's planCh. 29 §41Ch. 57 §8Ch. 46 §37

Special — talents Records +35 · Romance +35

  • Music

    RNMaster +25 Expert in music, giving rise to the song "If the tune is wrong, Zhou Lang turns to look"Wu 9 §23Ch. 57 §6

  • Naval warfare

    RNSkilled +10 Led the naval battle at Red Cliffs; the Romance records him as equal to naval warfareWu 9 §16Ch. 45 §7

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (24)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Allegiance history Changed allegiance 1 times

  1. Sun Ce faction (198~200) · Records · 「遂自居巢還吳」 · 「策親自迎瑜,授建威中郎將」(sgz-wu-09:s4-5)
  2. Wu · Records · Records vol. 54 「權拜瑜偏將軍,領南郡太守」

Family

SpouseXiaoqiao Romance

Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.

Related events (15)

Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).

Related works (6)

Linked via Wikidata "depicts" and character names in titles (unverified) — not yet reviewed.