Battle
Battle of Yiling 夷陵之戰
About this event
This was the battle in the 13th year of Jian'an (208) in which, while Zhou Yu and Cao Ren were facing each other in Nan Commandery, Gan Ning, sent ahead by Zhou Yu, seized Yiling and was then surrounded by Cao Ren's troops, and Zhou Yu and Lü Meng came to his rescue and defeated the enemy. Gan Ning withstood a siege by 5,000 to 6,000 men with a little over a thousand, and Zhou Yu, following Lü Meng's plan, left Ling Tong in charge of the rear and went to the rescue, killing more than half the enemy and capturing 300 horses. Records, Wu 9 §17 · 60–62Records, Wu 10 §58–59
Chen Shou recorded this battle in the Biography of the Lord of Wu in Records of Wu 2 and in the biographies of Zhou Yu, Lü Meng and Gan Ning in Records of Wu 9 and 10. The Romance depicts this battle in Chapter 51 as one episode of the Battle of Jiangling. Records, Wu 2 §14Records, Wu 9 §17 · 60–62Records, Wu 10 §58–59Romance, Ch. 51 §14–20
Course of events in the Records
When Zhou Yu and Cheng Pu advanced to Nan Commandery and faced Cao Ren across the great river, Zhou Yu sent Gan Ning ahead to seize Yiling before the troops had even crossed blades. According to the biography of Gan Ning, when the attack on Cao Ren in Nan Commandery failed to take the city, Gan Ning proposed the plan of first going straight to take Yiling, and on arriving he took the city at once, entered it and held it. Records, Wu 9 §17Records, Wu 10 §58
Gan Ning had several hundred soldiers under him, and even counting those newly gained he had barely a thousand. Cao Ren divided his forces and surrounded Gan Ning with 5,000 to 6,000 men, attacking for several days, putting up tall towers and shooting arrows into the city like rain. The soldiers were all afraid, but Gan Ning alone talked and laughed calmly. Records, Wu 9 §17Records, Wu 10 §58
When Gan Ning reported his peril, the generals said that their troops were too few to divide, but Lü Meng vouched that if Ling Tong were left behind he could hold out for ten days, and proposed that he himself go with Zhou Yu and Cheng Pu. He also said that if 300 men were sent to block the rugged paths with felled trees, they could capture the enemy's horses when the enemy fled. The Biography of the Lord of Wu likewise records that, on Lü Meng's plan, Ling Tong was left to hold off Cao Ren and half the army went to rescue Gan Ning. Records, Wu 9 §60–61Records, Wu 2 §14Records, Wu 10 §59
When the army reached Yiling it fought that very day and killed more than half the enemy. The enemy fled by night and, meeting the paths blocked with felled trees, the horsemen all abandoned their horses and fled on foot; the soldiers pursued them, captured 300 horses and brought them back loaded on boats. The biography of Lü Meng says that this naturally doubled the spirit of the officers and men. With the siege lifted, Zhou Yu crossed the river and camped on the north bank. Records, Wu 9 §61–62 · 17
In the Romance
In Chapter 51 of the Romance, when Zhou Yu, having lost the first fight at Nan Commandery, wanted to fight a decisive battle with Cao Ren in person, Gan Ning said that Cao Ren had Cao Hong holding Yiling so that the two positions supported each other, and offered to attack Yiling with 3,000 picked troops. Gan Ning fought Cao Hong for more than twenty bouts and took Yiling, but was shut up in the city by the troops of Cao Chun and Niu Jin, who arrived at dusk. Romance, Ch. 51 §14–16
When Cheng Pu urged a quick rescue, Zhou Yu hesitated because he could not leave the key position empty, and Lü Meng said that if it were entrusted to Ling Tong they would return in triumph within ten days. When Ling Tong said he would take it on if it was for ten days, Zhou Yu left more than 10,000 troops and went to Yiling in person, blocking the southern side path with felled trees as Lü Meng advised. Zhou Tai broke through the encirclement and coordinated with Gan Ning from inside and out, Cao Hong, Cao Chun and Niu Jin fled by the side path and abandoned their horses, and the Wu troops captured more than 500 horses. Romance, Ch. 51 §16–20
Where the Romance differs
Who was holding Yiling: In Chapter 51 of the Romance, Cao Hong was defending Yiling and was defeated by Gan Ning, and Cao Chun and Niu Jin surrounded Gan Ning. The biography of Gan Ning in the Records records only that Gan Ning went and took the city at once and that Cao Ren sent 5,000 to 6,000 men to surround him; Cao Hong and Cao Chun do not appear. Romance, Ch. 51 §15–16Records, Wu 10 §58Records, Wu 9 §17
Gan Ning's strength: In Chapter 51 of the Romance, Gan Ning attacked Yiling with 3,000 picked troops. In the biography of Gan Ning in the Records, Gan Ning's soldiers numbered several hundred, and even counting those newly gained he had barely a thousand. Romance, Ch. 51 §14–15Records, Wu 10 §58
The horses captured: In Chapter 51 of the Romance, the Wu troops captured more than 500 horses on the side path. In the biography of Lü Meng in the Records, 300 horses were captured and brought back loaded on boats. Romance, Ch. 51 §20Records, Wu 9 §62
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
Belligerents
| Item | A | B |
|---|---|---|
| Factions | Wu | Wei |
| Commanders | Zhou Yu, Gan Ning, Lü Meng | Cao Ren |
| Strength | 時手下有數百兵,并所新得,僅滿千人 | 曹仁乃令五六千人圍寧 |
| Casualties | 所殺過半 |
Factions, commanders, strength and casualties are checked against the source texts (3KDEX). Strength and casualties show only figures stated in the sources. Source: Wu 9 §61