Battle

Battle of Jiangling 江陵之戰

About this event

This was the battle in which, in the 13th year of Jian'an (208), Zhou Yu, Cheng Pu and Liu Bei attacked in Nan Commandery Cao Ren, whom Cao Cao, defeated at the Red Cliffs, had left at Jiangling on his way back north, and made him abandon the city and flee. According to the Biography of the Lord of Wu, Zhou Yu and Cao Ren faced each other for more than a year, with very many killed and wounded, and when Cao Ren abandoned the city and fled in the 14th year of Jian'an (209), Sun Quan made Zhou Yu Administrator of Nan Commandery. During the fighting Gan Ning seized Yiling and was then besieged there, and Zhou Yu was hit in the side by an arrow. Records, Wu 9 §16–17Records, Wu 2 §13 · 15Records, Wei 18 §17

Chen Shou recorded this battle in the Biography of the Lord of Wu in Records of Wu 2 and in the biographies of Zhou Yu, Lü Meng, Cheng Pu, Gan Ning, Ling Tong and Zhou Tai in Records of Wu 9 and 10, and also included it in the biographies of Cao Ren, Xu Huang and Li Tong in Records of Wei 9, 17 and 18. The Romance depicts this battle in Chapter 51, "Cao Ren Fights a Great Battle with the Troops of Eastern Wu; Kongming Angers Zhou Gongjin for the First Time." Records, Wu 2 §13–15Records, Wu 9 §16–19 · 60–62Records, Wu 10 §5 · 29 · 58–59 · 73Records, Wei 9 §36–38Records, Wei 17 §60Records, Wei 18 §17Romance, Ch. 51 §1 · 11

Course of events in the Records

Cao Cao's army, defeated at the Red Cliffs, fell back to hold Nan Commandery, and when Liu Bei, Zhou Yu and the others pursued again, he left Cao Ren and others in the city of Jiangling and returned north. The Biography of the Lord of Wu records that he left Cao Ren and Xu Huang at Jiangling and Yue Jin at Xiangyang. According to the biography of Cao Ren, Cao Ren stayed at Jiangling as acting General Who Conquers the South to hold off the Wu general Zhou Yu. Records, Wu 9 §16Records, Wu 2 §13Records, Wei 9 §36

Zhou Yu and Cheng Pu advanced to Nan Commandery and faced Cao Ren across the great river. The biography of Cao Ren records that when Zhou Yu came to attack with a host of several tens of thousands and his vanguard of several thousand had just arrived, Cao Ren gathered 300 men and sent his retainer commander Niu Jin against them. When Niu Jin was surrounded, Cao Ren, despite being held back by his Chief Clerk Chen Jiao and others, rode out of the city with several dozen stalwart horsemen, broke through the encirclement and rescued him, and when he went back in to rescue the rest of the men, the enemy withdrew. Chen Jiao and the others sighed, "The General is truly a man from heaven." Records, Wu 9 §17Records, Wei 9 §36–38

Before battle was joined, Zhou Yu sent Gan Ning ahead to seize Yiling. According to the biography of Gan Ning, Gan Ning held the city with barely a thousand men, including those newly gained, and even when the 5,000 to 6,000 men sent by Cao Ren put up tall towers and shot arrows like rain, he talked and laughed calmly. According to the biography of Lü Meng, Lü Meng proposed leaving Ling Tong to hold out for ten days while he went with Zhou Yu and Cheng Pu to the rescue, and had 300 men block the rugged paths with felled trees. When they killed half the enemy at Yiling, the enemy horsemen fleeing by night abandoned their horses, and 300 horses were captured. Records, Wu 9 §17 · 60–62Records, Wu 10 §58–59

Having lifted the siege, Zhou Yu crossed the river and camped on the north bank, intending to fight a great battle on an appointed day, but as he rode out in person and swept through the enemy lines he was hit in the right side by a stray arrow and went back. When Cao Ren heard that Zhou Yu was lying in bed unable to rise and drew up his troops for battle, Zhou Yu got up by himself, went round the camps and roused his officers and men, and Cao Ren withdrew. Records, Wu 9 §17–18

Liu Bei's side also took part in the fighting. The biography of Li Tong records that when Liu Bei and Zhou Yu besieged Cao Ren at Jiangling and Liu Bei separately sent Guan Yu to cut the northern road, Li Tong dismounted, pulled up the abatis and fought his way into the encirclement to meet Cao Ren's army. The biography of Xu Huang also says that Xu Huang attacked Zhou Yu at Jiangling together with Cao Ren, and the biographies of Cheng Pu, Ling Tong and Zhou Tai record that they attacked Cao Ren in Nan Commandery. Records, Wei 18 §17Records, Wei 17 §60Records, Wu 10 §5 · 29 · 73

In the 14th year of Jian'an (209), after Zhou Yu and Cao Ren had held out against each other for more than a year, with very many killed and wounded, Cao Ren abandoned the city and fled. The biography of Lü Meng says that they thereby took Nan Commandery and settled Jing Province, and the biography of Cheng Pu records that they attacked Nan Commandery and put Cao Ren to flight. Sun Quan appointed Zhou Yu Lieutenant General and concurrently Administrator of Nan Commandery, stationing him at Jiangling, while Liu Bei, concurrently Governor of Jing Province, was stationed at Gong'an. Records, Wu 2 §15Records, Wu 9 §62 · 19Records, Wu 10 §5

In the Romance

In Chapter 51 of the Romance, Zhou Yu, setting out to attack Nan Commandery, visited Liu Bei, who was stationed at Youjiangkou, and promised that if he himself could not take Nan Commandery, Liu Bei was welcome to take it. Jiang Qin, Xu Sheng and Ding Feng crossed the river first, but Cao Ren, who rode out of the city with several hundred horsemen to rescue Niu Jin, broke through the encirclement and went back in to rescue even the remaining soldiers, and the Wu troops were defeated. Romance, Ch. 51 §1–14

When Gan Ning defeated Cao Hong at Yiling and took the city but was then surrounded by Cao Chun and Niu Jin, Zhou Yu, on Lü Meng's advice, entrusted his position to Ling Tong for ten days and went in person to the rescue, capturing more than 500 of the fleeing enemy's horses on a side path blocked with felled trees. Cao Ren opened the sealed letter left by Cao Cao and, making the city look deserted, lured Zhou Yu into the barbican, where Zhou Yu was hit in the left side by a crossbow bolt. Romance, Ch. 51 §14–25

When Cao Ren came before his camp and hurled abuse, Zhou Yu rode out, then spat blood and fell from his horse; turning this into a stratagem, he sent soldiers to feign surrender and report that he had died. Cao Ren, raiding the camp by night, was heavily defeated by ambushes on every side and, unable to return to Nan Commandery, fled toward Xiangyang. Romance, Ch. 51 §27–38

But when Zhou Yu reached the city of Nan Commandery, Zhao Yun was on its walls. Zhuge Liang, having taken Nan Commandery, used the military tallies of the captured Chen Jiao to call out the troops of Jingzhou and Xiangyang, and Zhang Fei took Jingzhou and Guan Yu took Xiangyang. Hearing this, Zhou Yu gave a great cry and his wound burst open. Romance, Ch. 51 §39–41

Where the Romance differs

Zhou Yu's wound: In Chapter 51 of the Romance, Zhou Yu fell for Cao Ren's ruse of making the city look deserted and was hit in the left side by a crossbow bolt in the barbican. In the biography of Zhou Yu in the Records, he was hit in the right side by a stray arrow as he rode out in person and swept through the enemy lines, intending to fight a great battle on an appointed day. Romance, Ch. 51 §24–25Records, Wu 9 §17

Zhou Yu lying in bed: In Chapter 51 of the Romance, Zhou Yu, after spitting blood and collapsing, pretended to be dead and crushed Cao Ren's night raid with an ambush. In the biography of Zhou Yu in the Records, when Cao Ren heard that Zhou Yu was lying in bed and drew up his troops for battle, Zhou Yu got up by himself, went round the camps and roused his officers and men, and Cao Ren withdrew. Romance, Ch. 51 §32–37Records, Wu 9 §18

The fighting at Yiling: In Chapter 51 of the Romance, Gan Ning defeated Cao Hong, who was holding Yiling, took the city, and was then surrounded by Cao Chun and Niu Jin. The biography of Gan Ning in the Records records only that Gan Ning went and took the city at once and held it, and that Cao Ren surrounded him with 5,000 to 6,000 men; Cao Hong and Cao Chun do not appear. Romance, Ch. 51 §15–16Records, Wu 10 §58Records, Wu 9 §17

How Nan Commandery fell: In Chapter 51 of the Romance, while Cao Ren was out of the city, Nan Commandery, Jingzhou and Xiangyang were taken by Zhao Yun, Zhang Fei and Guan Yu through Zhuge Liang's stratagem. In the Biography of the Lord of Wu in the Records, Cao Ren abandoned the city and fled in the 14th year of Jian'an (209) after a standoff of more than a year, and Sun Quan made Zhou Yu Administrator of Nan Commandery and stationed him at Jiangling. Romance, Ch. 51 §39–41Records, Wu 2 §15Records, Wu 9 §19

Liu Bei's side in the fighting: In Chapter 51 of the Romance, Liu Bei stayed at Youjiangkou and did not fight. In the biography of Li Tong in the Records, Liu Bei besieged Cao Ren at Jiangling together with Zhou Yu and sent Guan Yu to cut the northern road. Romance, Ch. 51 §10Records, Wei 18 §17

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Belligerents

ItemAB
FactionsShu, WuWei
CommandersCheng Pu, Guan Yu, Ling Tong, Zhou Yu, Liu Bei, Gan Ning, Lü Meng, Zhou Tai(周泰)Cao Ren, Li Tong, Xu Huang, Niu Jin
Strength瑜將數萬眾來攻,前鋒數千人

Factions, commanders, strength and casualties are checked against the source texts (3KDEX). Strength and casualties show only figures stated in the sources. Source: Wu 2 §15

Sub-events and Romance scenes (2)

Romance chapters (1)

Records volumes (7)