Warlord
Gongsun Zan faction 公孫瓚
About this faction
This faction was a warlord power raised at the end of the Eastern Han by Gongsun Zan, a man of Liaoxi, on the strength of the cavalry of You Province, and it contested Hebei with Yuan Shao. Gongsun Zan made his name fighting the Xianbei and Wuhuan on the frontier, and after Dong Zhuo entered Luoyang he became General of Vehement Might (fenwu jiangjun) and was enfeoffed as Marquis of Ji. When his cousin Gongsun Yue was killed fighting Yuan Shao's side, he sent troops against Yuan Shao, and he extended his power by entrusting Ji, Qing and Yan provinces to his subordinates. Records, Wei 8 §2–5 · 8 · 12–13
After being defeated by Yuan Shao at Jieqiao, he killed Liu Yu, Governor of You Province, and made Duan Xun, whom he had recommended, Inspector of You Province; but pressed by the combined attacks of Liu Yu's former subordinates, the Wuhuan and Xianbei, and Yuan Shao, he shut himself up in Yijing. In the 4th year of Jian'an (199), when Yuan Shao surrounded Yijing with his whole army, he killed all his wife and children and then killed himself, and the Yuan Shao faction absorbed his followers. Records, Wei 8 §13–16 · 18–20Records, Wei 6 §49
Chen Shou recorded this faction in the Biography of Gongsun Zan within the Biographies of the Two Gongsuns, Tao and the Four Zhangs (Records of Wei 8). The Romance first gives his name in Chapter 1 as a friend Liu Bei made, counts him in Chapter 5 as the fourteenth contingent, the Administrator of Beiping, among the lords who answered Cao Cao's call to arms, and in Chapter 7 portrays the faction as a power facing Yuan Shao in the fighting at the Pan River and Jieqiao. Records, Wei 8 §1–2Romance, Ch. 1 §16Romance, Ch. 5 §8Romance, Ch. 7 §9–10
Rise and fall in the Records
Gongsun Zan was a native of Lingzhi in Liaoxi. Recommended as Filial and Incorrupt (xiaolian), he became a Gentleman and then Chief Clerk of the Liaodong Dependent State. Patrolling the frontier with several tens of horsemen, he met several hundred Xianbei horsemen and broke through them wielding a spear bladed at both ends, after which the Xianbei no longer dared to enter the frontier. In the Guanghe era, while he was leading 3,000 shock cavalry of You Province, Zhang Chun of Yuyang induced Qiuliju and others of the Wuhuan of Liaoxi to rebel; Gongsun Zan pursued and attacked them, and after serving as Cavalry Commandant he became General of the Household and Marquis of a Chief Village, stationed in the Dependent State and fighting the barbarians for five or six years. Yet he could not stop Qiuliju and the others when they plundered Qing, Xu, You and Ji provinces. Records, Wei 8 §2–5
When the court made Liu Yu Governor of You Province, the barbarians wished to submit to him, and Gongsun Zan, jealous of Liu Yu winning the merit, secretly had the barbarians' envoys killed. Liu Yu abolished the various garrisons and left only Gongsun Zan, with 10,000 infantry and cavalry, stationed at Youbeiping. When Dong Zhuo reached Luoyang, Liu Yu became Grand Marshal and Gongsun Zan became General of Vehement Might and Marquis of Ji. When Liu Yu's son Liu He, setting out on the Emperor's orders to bring back Liu Yu's troops, was detained by Yuan Shu, Gongsun Zan secretly urged Yuan Shu to seize Liu He and take his troops, and sent his cousin Gongsun Yue with 1,000 horsemen to ally himself with Yuan Shu. Because of this the rift with Liu Yu grew wider. Records, Wei 8 §7–11
As Gongsun Zan came south on the strength of his victories and the commanderies responded to him, Gao Gan, Xun Chen and others, sent by Yuan Shao, used this to persuade Han Fu to hand Ji Province over to Yuan Shao. When Yuan Shao had Zhou Ang seize the post at Yangcheng where Sun Jian, sent by Yuan Shu, was stationed, Gongsun Yue attacked Zhou Ang together with Sun Jian and was killed by an arrow. Saying that his brother's death began with Yuan Shao, Gongsun Zan sent his army to the Pan River. Yuan Shao, afraid, gave the seal and ribbon of Administrator of Bohai to Gongsun Zan's cousin Gongsun Fan, but Gongsun Fan used the troops of Bohai to help Gongsun Zan defeat the Yellow Turbans of Qing and Xu provinces, and his army grew even stronger. Gongsun Zan entrusted Ji Province to Yan Gang, Qing Province to Tian Kai and Yan Province to Shan Jing and set up commanderies and counties, and when Yuan Shao confronted him at Jieqiao, Li Shao, Administrator of Julu, and others wished to go over to him because his forces were strong. Records, Wei 6 §40–43Records, Wei 8 §12–13Records, Wei 14 §45
Gongsun Zan, who had also made peace with Liu Dai, Inspector of Yan Province, and sent his Attendant Officer Fan Fang with cavalry to help him, told Liu Dai after defeating Yuan Shao's army to send away Yuan Shao's wife and children and break with Yuan Shao. Liu Dai followed Cheng Yu's advice that Gongsun Zan was no match for Yuan Shao, and before Fan Fang had even returned, Gongsun Zan was heavily defeated by Yuan Shao. Advancing to Jieqiao, Gongsun Zan had Yan Gang captured by Qu Yi, the vanguard of Yuan Shao, who was encamped at Guangchuan, and fled to Bohai. Gongsun Zan made Liu Bei Major of a Separate Command (biebu sima) and had him resist Yuan Shao together with Tian Kai, and at Yuan Shu's request he stationed Liu Bei, Shan Jing and Tao Qian at Gaotang, Pingyuan and Fagan to press Yuan Shao, but the Annals of Emperor Wu record that in the 3rd year of Chuping (192) Cao Cao and Yuan Shao defeated them all. Zhang Yan of Heishan also sent his commander Du Chang and others to help Gongsun Zan, but they were defeated by Yuan Shao. Records, Wei 14 §5–7Records, Wei 8 §13 · 54Records, Shu 2 §7Records, Wei 1 §24
Back at Ji, Gongsun Zan built a small walled town southeast of the main city, which brought him close to Liu Yu, and their mutual resentment deepened. Liu Yu raised troops first and attacked him but was defeated and fled to Juyong, and Gongsun Zan took Juyong and captured Liu Yu. After Dong Zhuo died, the Emperor sent the envoy Duan Xun to have Liu Yu supervise six provinces and made Gongsun Zan General of the Front and Marquis of Yi, whereupon Gongsun Zan falsely accused Liu Yu of intending to claim the imperial title and coerced Duan Xun into beheading him. Gongsun Zan recommended Duan Xun as Inspector of You Province, and from then on he grew arrogant, remembering others' faults and forgetting their good deeds, and harmed many people. Records, Wei 8 §13–14
Xianyu Fu and others, formerly Liu Yu's Attendant Officers, put forward Yan Rou as Wuhuan Major to take revenge on Gongsun Zan. Yan Rou called in the Wuhuan and Xianbei, gained several tens of thousands of barbarians and Han Chinese, and beheaded Zou Dan, the Administrator of Yuyang installed by Gongsun Zan, north of Lu; Yuan Shao also sent Qu Yi and Liu Yu's son Liu He to attack Gongsun Zan together with Xianyu Fu. Gongsun Zan's commander Wang Men even went over to Yuan Shao's side and came to attack Tian Yu, Magistrate of Dongzhou. After repeated defeats, Gongsun Zan withdrew to Yijing. Records, Wei 8 §15–16Records, Wei 26 §26
At Yijing, Gongsun Zan surrounded himself with ten rings of trenches and built watchtowers on earthen mounds five or six zhang high; he himself lived on the central mound, ten zhang high, and stored three million hu of grain. He said that he had once thought the affairs of the realm could be settled with a wave of the finger, but that it was now better to rest his troops, work the fields and store grain, and that since his towers stood a thousand layers deep, by the time he had eaten all this grain he would know how the affairs of the realm had turned out. His aim was to wear Yuan Shao down, and Yuan Shao could not take Yijing for several years. Records, Wei 8 §16–17
In the 4th year of Jian'an (199), when Yuan Shao surrounded Yijing with his whole army, Gongsun Zan sent his son to the Heishan bandits to ask for help and intended to lead his shock cavalry out in person to cut Yuan Shao off from the rear. When his Chief Clerk Guan Jing dissuaded him, saying that if the general left his base Yijing would soon be in danger, Gongsun Zan did not go out. Yuan Shao's scouts obtained the letter he had sent his son, arranging to raise a fire when the relief force arrived and attack from inside and outside, and raised the fire on that day; Gongsun Zan came out to fight and was crushed by an ambush. When Yuan Shao brought down the towers by tunneling and closed in on the central mound, Gongsun Zan, knowing he was sure to lose, killed all his wife and children and then killed himself. The Annals of Emperor Wu record that at this time Yuan Shao absorbed Gongsun Zan and held the territory of four provinces. Records, Wei 8 §18–20Records, Wei 1 §54
After Gongsun Zan's fall, Xianyu Fu led his followers to accept the court's orders and, as General Who Establishes Loyalty, supervised the six commanderies of You Province, and Yan Rou also sent an envoy to Cao Cao and became Colonel Protector of the Wuhuan. Gongsun Zan had known that Tian Yu was skilled in stratagems but had not been able to give him an important post; Tian Yu, who became Xianyu Fu's Chief Clerk, advised him to submit, saying that the one who would ultimately bring the realm under order was the Cao clan. Records, Wei 8 §21Records, Wei 26 §27
In his assessment in Records of Wei 8, Chen Shou said that Gongsun Zan guarded Yijing and sat waiting for his destruction, and counted him among those who held provinces and commanderies as their strongholds yet did not measure up even to common men. Records, Wei 8 §71
In the Romance
In Chapter 2 of the Romance, Gongsun Zan memorialized Liu Bei's past merits, recommended him as Major of a Separate Command and had him serve as Magistrate of Pingyuan. In Chapter 5, as Administrator of Beiping and the fourteenth contingent answering Cao Cao's call to arms, he led 15,000 picked troops past Pingyuan, and on seeing Guan Yu and Zhang Fei, who were serving only as a mounted archer and a foot archer, he urged Liu Bei to join him in attacking the rebel and took the three men with him. At Hulao Pass he brandished a lance and fought Lü Bu in person but was chased, and Zhang Fei came forward to save him. Romance, Ch. 2 §36Romance, Ch. 5 §8 · 10–12 · 48–49
In Chapter 7 Gongsun Zan received a letter from Yuan Shao proposing that they attack Ji Province together and divide its land equally, and raised his army; but his brother Gongsun Yue, whom he had sent to ask for a share of the land from Yuan Shao, now master of Ji Province, was killed by the arrows of soldiers claiming to be commanders of Chancellor Dong. Enraged that Yuan Shao had lured him into attacking Han Fu and had even killed his brother, Gongsun Zan invaded Ji Province; chased by Wen Chou at the bridge over the Pan River, he tumbled down a slope and owed his life to Zhao Yun. Romance, Ch. 7 §3 · 8–13
The next day Gongsun Zan deployed his troops in two wings, more than half of their over 5,000 horses being white; the Romance says that once, fighting the Qiang, he had picked white horses for his vanguard and been called the White Horse General. But when his vanguard Yan Gang was checked by Qu Yi's archers and crossbowmen and cut down, and even his embroidered commander's banner was felled, Gongsun Zan fled, and the tide turned only when Zhao Yun stabbed Qu Yi from his horse. After Liu Bei, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei came from Pingyuan and drove Yuan Shao back, the two sides faced each other for more than a month, until an edict brought by Ma Midi and Zhao Qi, sent by Dong Zhuo, reconciled the two men. Romance, Ch. 7 §14–18 · 22 · 24–25
After the reconciliation Gongsun Zan recommended Liu Bei as Chancellor of Pingyuan, and Zhao Yun lamented that Gongsun Zan too was merely one of the same sort as Yuan Shao. In Chapter 11, when Liu Bei said he would go to rescue Xu Province, Gongsun Zan asked why he should exert himself for others when he had no quarrel with Cao Cao, but lent him 2,000 cavalry and infantry and sent Zhao Yun along as well. Romance, Ch. 7 §25Romance, Ch. 11 §22–23
In Chapter 21 Gongsun Zan's end was reported to Cao Cao by Man Chong, returning from observing Yuan Shao. Pressed by Yuan Shao, Gongsun Zan had built a walled town, raised a tower ten zhang high and stored 300,000 dan of grain, but he refused to rescue his besieged men, saying that if he saved one, those who fought after him would only hope to be rescued, and so many surrendered. His letter asking Xudu for help and his letter proposing a fire signal to Zhang Yan were both seized by Yuan Shao, and, lured out by a fire Yuan Shao set, Gongsun Zan lost more than half his men and horses to an ambush. When Yuan Shao's troops came in through tunnels and set fire beneath the tower, Gongsun Zan killed his wife and children and hanged himself, and his whole household burned. Romance, Ch. 21 §22–24
In Chapter 28 Zhao Yun, meeting Liu Bei again, told him that Gongsun Zan had not listened to others, so that his army was defeated and he burned himself to death. Romance, Ch. 28 §56
Where the Romance differs
The coalition against Dong Zhuo: In Chapter 5 of the Romance, Gongsun Zan came as Administrator of Beiping, the fourteenth contingent answering Cao Cao's call to arms, bringing Liu Bei, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei. Gongsun Zan is not among those who raised troops together in the first month of the 1st year of Chuping (190) as recorded in the Annals of Emperor Wu in the Records, and in the Biography of Gongsun Zan he became General of Vehement Might and was enfeoffed as Marquis of Ji when Dong Zhuo reached Luoyang. Romance, Ch. 5 §8 · 10–12Records, Wei 1 §7Records, Wei 8 §8
His tie to Liu Bei: In Chapters 2 and 5 of the Romance, Gongsun Zan recommended Liu Bei and made him Magistrate of Pingyuan. In the Biography of the First Sovereign in the Records, when Liu Bei, then Magistrate of Gaotang, was defeated by bandits and went to General of the Household Gongsun Zan for refuge, Gongsun Zan memorialized making him Major of a Separate Command and had him resist Yuan Shao together with Tian Kai, and for his merit in battle Liu Bei became acting Magistrate of Pingyuan. Romance, Ch. 2 §36Romance, Ch. 5 §10Records, Shu 2 §7
Why he fought Yuan Shao: In Chapter 7 of the Romance, Yuan Shao lured Gongsun Zan with a letter proposing that they attack Ji Province together and then took Ji Province for himself, and Gongsun Yue was killed by soldiers claiming to be commanders of Chancellor Dong. In the Records, Yuan Shao had Zhou Ang seize the post at Yangcheng where Sun Jian, sent by Yuan Shu, was stationed, and Gongsun Yue, attacking Zhou Ang together with Sun Jian on Yuan Shu's orders, was killed by an arrow. Romance, Ch. 7 §3 · 8Records, Wei 8 §11–12
The White Horse General: In Chapter 7 of the Romance, Gongsun Zan was said to have picked white horses for his vanguard while fighting the Qiang and been called the White Horse General. The Biography of Gongsun Zan in Chen Shou's main text records only that he broke through Xianbei horsemen on the frontier and fought the Wuhuan in the Dependent State; there is no story of white horses. Romance, Ch. 7 §14Records, Wei 8 §3–5 · 1–20
The battle of Jieqiao and the reconciliation: In Chapter 7 of the Romance, Yan Gang was cut down by Qu Yi, Qu Yi was killed by Zhao Yun, and the two men, facing each other, were reconciled by an edict brought by Ma Midi and Zhao Qi, sent by Dong Zhuo. In the Records, Qu Yi captured Yan Gang alive and the defeated Gongsun Zan fled to Bohai, and the reconciliation by edict does not appear in Chen Shou's main text. Romance, Ch. 7 §16–18 · 24–25Records, Wei 8 §13 · 1–20
Liu Yu: In the Romance, Liu Yu appears only in Chapter 2 as the Governor of You Province who made Liu Bei a Commandant and attacked Zhang Chun, and his quarrel with Gongsun Zan is not depicted. In the Records, Gongsun Zan clashed with Liu Yu, captured him, falsely accused him of intending to claim the imperial title, and coerced the envoy Duan Xun into beheading him. Romance, Ch. 2 §35–36Records, Wei 8 §14
Yijing: In Chapter 21 of the Romance, 300,000 dan of grain were stored in a tower ten zhang high, and his letter asking Xudu for help and his letter to Zhang Yan were seized by Yuan Shao. In the Records, he piled up earthen mounds layer upon layer and kept three million hu of grain, sent his son to the Heishan bandits to ask for help, and Yuan Shao's scouts obtained the letter he sent his son. Romance, Ch. 21 §22–23Records, Wei 8 §16 · 18–20
His end: In Chapter 21 of the Romance, he killed his wife and children and hanged himself, after which his whole household burned. The Biography of Gongsun Zan in the Records says only that he killed all his wife and children and then killed himself. Romance, Ch. 21 §24Records, Wei 8 §20
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
Lineage
- Destroyed by: Yuan Shao faction — 「擊破瓚於易京,并其衆」 · 「袁紹旣并公孫瓚」(sgz-wei-01:s54)
Members (4)
Related events (2)
- Battle of Yijing 199 · Combatant
- Battle of Jieqiao · Combatant
Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).