Battle
Battle of Yijing 易京之戰
About this event
The Battle of Yijing was the fight in the 4th year of Jian'an (199) in which Yuan Shao raised his entire army, surrounded Gongsun Zan, who was holding out at Yijing, and destroyed him. Gongsun Zan, who had fallen back to Yijing after repeated defeats, held out by building tall towers inside ten rings of trenches and stockpiling grain, and Yuan Shao's generals could not take it for more than a year. Yuan Shao intercepted a letter from Gongsun Zan, who was waiting for relief from the Heishan bandits, lured him out with false fire signals and crushed him with an ambush, then dug tunnels to bring down his towers. Gongsun Zan killed all his wives and children and then took his own life. Records, Wei 8 §16–20
Chen Shou recorded this fight in Gongsun Zan's biography in the Biographies of the Two Gongsuns, Tao and the Four Zhangs in Records of Wei 8, and also included it in Yuan Shao's biography in Records of Wei 6 and in the Annals of Emperor Wu in Records of Wei 1. The Romance relates the fight through Man Chong's report to Cao Cao in Chapter 21, "Cao Cao warms wine and discusses heroes; Lord Guan tricks open the city gate and beheads Che Zhou." Records, Wei 8 §16–20Records, Wei 6 §49Records, Wei 1 §54Romance, Ch. 21 §22–25
Course of events in the Records
After advancing to Jie Bridge and being defeated by Yuan Shao's general Qu Yi, Gongsun Zan captured Liu Yu, the Governor of You Province, who had attacked him, falsely accused him of planning to proclaim himself emperor, and pressured the envoy Duan Xun into beheading him. Liu Yu's Attendant Officer Xianyu Fu and others led the provincial troops, drew in the Wuhuan and Xianbei, and beheaded the Administrator of Yuyang whom Gongsun Zan had appointed, and Yuan Shao also sent Qu Yi and Liu Yu's son Liu He to attack Gongsun Zan together with them. After repeated defeats, Gongsun Zan's army fell back to Yijing and held it fast. Records, Wei 8 §12 · 13–16
Gongsun Zan ringed the place with ten layers of trenches and inside them built mounds 5 or 6 zhang high topped with towers; the central mound in particular he raised to 10 zhang, lived there himself, and stockpiled 3 million hu of grain. He said that he had once thought the affairs of the realm could be settled with a wave of the hand, but now saw that they were not his to decide; the art of war said a hundred towers are not to be attacked, so by the time this grain was eaten he would know how the affairs of the realm would turn out. The generals Yuan Shao sent could not take it for more than a year. Records, Wei 8 §16–17
In the 4th year of Jian'an (199) Yuan Shao surrounded Yijing with his entire army. Gongsun Zan sent his son to seek relief from the Heishan bandits and planned to lead his shock cavalry out himself along the southwestern mountains, join the Heishan host, ravage Ji Province and cut off Yuan Shao's rear. His Chief Clerk Guan Jing dissuaded him, saying that the officers and men held on only because they longed for their wives, children and homes and looked to the general as their lord, so if he held fast Yuan Shao would withdraw of his own accord, whereas if he left now Yijing would soon be in danger; Gongsun Zan did not go out. Records, Wei 8 §18–19
When the relief force came, Gongsun Zan, wanting to attack Yuan Shao from inside and outside, sent a letter to his son fixing a date and having fires raised as the signal. Yuan Shao's scouts obtained the letter and raised fires on the appointed date, and when Gongsun Zan, thinking the relief had come, came out to fight, Yuan Shao crushed him with an ambush. When Gongsun Zan went back to defend again, Yuan Shao dug tunnels to bring down the towers and gradually closed in on the central mound, and Gongsun Zan, knowing he was sure to lose, killed all his wives and children and committed suicide. Yuan Shao's biography records that Yuan Shao defeated Gongsun Zan at Yijing and absorbed his followers. Records, Wei 8 §19–20Records, Wei 6 §49
The Annals of Emperor Wu record that at this time Yuan Shao, having swallowed up Gongsun Zan, held the lands of four provinces and more than 100,000 troops and meant to attack Xu. Xianyu Fu of You Province led his followers to accept the imperial command, and when Cao Cao faced Yuan Shao at Guandu he came to Cao Cao in person and became General on the Left Who Crosses the Liao. Chen Shou judged that Gongsun Zan guarded Yijing and sat waiting for his destruction. Records, Wei 1 §54Records, Wei 8 §21 · 71
In the Romance
In Chapter 21 of the Romance, Man Chong, back from spying on Yuan Shao, reports before Cao Cao and Liu Bei that Gongsun Zan has already been crushed by Yuan Shao. Gongsun Zan had built walls to enclose himself, erected on them the Yijing Tower, 10 zhang high, and stockpiled 300,000 measures of grain to hold out; but when urged to rescue soldiers surrounded by Yuan Shao, he refused, saying that if he rescued one man, those who fought afterward would only hope for others to rescue them, and so many of his soldiers surrendered to Yuan Shao. Romance, Ch. 21 §22–23
With his position isolated, Gongsun Zan sent a letter to Xudu asking for help, but it was seized on the way by Yuan Shao's troops, and the letter he sent to Zhang Yan proposing to coordinate from inside and outside with fire as the signal was also taken by Yuan Shao. When Yuan Shao set fires outside the walls to lure him out, Gongsun Zan came out in person, lost more than half his troops and horses to an ambush, and when Yuan Shao tunneled in and set fire beneath his tower, he first killed his wives and children and then hanged himself. Hearing this, Liu Bei grieves, remembering how Gongsun Zan had once recommended him. Romance, Ch. 21 §23–25
Where the Romance differs
Towers and grain: In Chapter 21 of the Romance, Gongsun Zan erects the Yijing Tower, 10 zhang high, and stockpiles 300,000 measures of grain. In the Biography of Gongsun Zan in the Records, he ringed the place with ten layers of trenches and built towers on mounds 5 or 6 zhang high, raising only the central mound to 10 zhang, where he lived himself, and stockpiled 3 million hu of grain. Romance, Ch. 21 §22Records, Wei 8 §16
The appeal for relief: In Chapter 21 of the Romance, Gongsun Zan's letter asking Cao Cao in Xudu for help is seized, and he sends a letter to Zhang Yan proposing to coordinate from inside and outside with fire as the signal. In the Records, Gongsun Zan sent his son to the Heishan bandits to ask for relief, and the person to whom he sent the letter proposing fire as the signal was also that son. Romance, Ch. 21 §23Records, Wei 8 §18–19
Why he came out to fight: In Chapter 21 of the Romance, Gongsun Zan is lured out by fires Yuan Shao sets outside the walls. In the Records too, fires were raised according to the letter intercepted by Yuan Shao's scouts, but before that Gongsun Zan had planned to lead his shock cavalry out in person and stopped only because his Chief Clerk Guan Jing dissuaded him. Romance, Ch. 21 §23–24Records, Wei 8 §18–20
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
Belligerents
| Item | A | B |
|---|---|---|
| Factions | Yuan Shao faction | Gongsun Zan faction, Heishan Bandits |
| Commanders | Yuan Shao(袁紹) | Gongsun Zan |
Factions, commanders, strength and casualties are checked against the source texts (3KDEX). Strength and casualties show only figures stated in the sources. Source: Wei 8 §20