RNo direct record — estimated from his enfeoffment as Duke of Shanyang after the abdicationWei 2 §13Wei 2 §17
NTrembled and could not speak whenever danger came, and his secret edicts were discovered twiceCh. 24 §6Ch. 80 §10Ch. 66 §40
| Occupation | RNRuler · Emperor | Faction | Eastern Han |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appears | RN | Biography in | |
| Born | R? Unverified | Native place | |
| Died | R234 Unverified | Place of death | |
| Existence | Historical | Mentions | R27 |
Liu Xie was the young son of Emperor Ling and held the title Prince of Chenliu; when Dong Zhuo deposed Emperor Shao, he was set up as emperor. He was Emperor Xian. Chen Shou's Records contain no biography of him; his record consists of the passages in the Annals of Emperor Wu, the Annals of Emperor Wen, the Biography of Dong Zhuo and elsewhere that refer to him as "the Son of Heaven," "the Emperor of Han" or "the Duke of Shanyang." Records, Wei 6 §8Records, Wei 2 §13 · 17
He was taken to Chang'an by Dong Zhuo, and after Dong Zhuo's death he wandered eastward amid the strife between Li Jue and Guo Si until, in the 1st year of Jian'an (196), he was received by Cao Cao and established his capital at Xu. In the winter of the 1st year of Yankang (220) he yielded the throne to Cao Pi, King of Wei, and became Duke of Shanyang; he died in the 3rd month of the 2nd year of Qinglong (234) and was posthumously titled Emperor Xiaoxian of Han. Records, Wei 6 §11 · 24–28Records, Wei 1 §39Records, Wei 2 §13 · 16–17Records, Wei 3 §35
Chen Shou gave no assessment of him; Wang Su said in a memorial that the Duke of Shanyang had, in advancing, yielded the throne to Wei and, in withdrawing, taken the place of an honored guest. In the Romance his name first appears at the opening of Chapter 1, and he appears in 22 of its 120 chapters; as in the title of Chapter 80, "Cao Pi deposes the emperor and usurps the throne of the Liu of Fire-virtue Han," the novel portrays his abdication as a usurpation. Records, Wei 13 §77Romance, Ch. 1 §2Romance, Ch. 80 §20 · 24
Since Chen Shou's Records contain no biography of Liu Xie, this section gathers in chronological order the records that refer to him as "the Son of Heaven," "the Emperor," "the Emperor of Han" or "the Duke of Shanyang" in the Annals of Emperor Wu, the Annals of Emperor Wen, the Annals of Emperor Ming, the biography of Dong Zhuo and elsewhere. After Emperor Ling died, Dong Zhuo, who had entered the capital, deposed Emperor Shao, making him Prince of Hongnong, and soon afterward killed the Prince of Hongnong and Empress He; he set up Emperor Ling's young son, the Prince of Chenliu, who became Emperor Xian. The Annals of Emperor Wu record that year as the 6th year of Zhongping (189). Records, Wei 6 §8Records, Wei 1 §5–6
In the 1st year of Chuping (190), when armies rose east of the passes to attack Dong Zhuo, in the 2nd month Dong Zhuo moved the Son of Heaven and made Chang'an the capital. Yuan Shao and Han Fu, saying that the young emperor was controlled by treacherous ministers, sought to set up Liu Yu, Governor of You Province, as emperor, but Liu Yu would not accept. The Son of Heaven in Chang'an wished to return east, and had Liu Yu's son Liu He, who was serving as Palace Attendant (shizhong), pretend to flee from Dong Zhuo, slip out through the Wu Pass and tell Liu Yu to come with troops to meet him. But Yuan Shu detained Liu He. Records, Wei 6 §11Records, Wei 1 §8Records, Wei 8 §9–10
In the 4th month of the 3rd year of Chuping (192), when the Son of Heaven, having just recovered from an illness, held a great assembly in the Weiyang Hall, Lü Bu, carrying an imperial edict, killed Dong Zhuo. But Dong Zhuo's generals Li Jue, Guo Si and others took Chang'an and seized control of the court's affairs. Later, when Li Jue and Guo Si came to suspect each other and fought in Chang'an, Li Jue held the Son of Heaven hostage in his own camp, burned the palaces and city gates, and took the emperor's carriages and garments into his own house. Records, Wei 6 §16 · 20–21 · 24
When Zhang Ji came from Shan County and reconciled the two, the Son of Heaven was at last able to get away and reached the area between Xinfeng and Baling, but Guo Si again tried to coerce him into going back to make his capital at Mei. The Son of Heaven fled to Yang Feng's camp, and Yang Feng and Dong Cheng escorted him toward Luoyang. When Li Jue and Guo Si caught up with them at Caoyang in Hongnong and killed the high ministers and the hundred officials, the Son of Heaven fled to Shan County and crossed the Yellow River northward; having lost the baggage train, he went on foot, with only the empress and the Honored Ladies following him. After stopping in a commoner's house at Dayang, he made his capital at Anyi, where he rode in an ox cart and the officials attending him ate jujubes and wild greens. Records, Wei 6 §25–27
Yang Feng, Han Xian and Dong Cheng escorted the Son of Heaven back to Luoyang, but the palaces had all burned down and the streets lay in ruin; officials from the Gentlemen of the Secretariat downward went out themselves to gather firewood and pick wild greens, and some starved to death among the walls. In the 1st year of Jian'an (196), when Cao Cao reached Luoyang and guarded the capital, the Son of Heaven lent him the tally and axe (jieyue) and put him in charge of the affairs of the Secretariat (lu shangshu shi), and in the 9th month the imperial carriage moved to Xu. The Annals of Emperor Wu record that at this point the institutions of the ancestral temples and the altars of state were for the first time established at a court that had grown more disordered by the day since the Son of Heaven moved west. Records, Wei 6 §28Records, Wei 1 §38–39
In the 1st month of the 5th year of Jian'an (200), the plot of Dong Cheng and others leaked out, and all of them were executed. According to the Biography of the First Sovereign, Dong Cheng, saying that he had received a secret edict hidden in the emperor's sash, declared that Cao Cao must be put to death. In the 5th month of the 18th year of Jian'an (213), in the patent appointing Cao Cao Duke of Wei, the Son of Heaven said that in his youth he had met with calamity and turmoil, drifted in the western lands and moved to the old lands of Tang and Wei, in peril like tassels dangling from a banner. In the 7th month of that year he took three of Cao Cao's daughters as Honored Ladies (guiren). Records, Wei 1 §58 · 120–121 · 134Records, Shu 2 §15
In the 11th month of the 19th year of Jian'an (214), it came to light that Empress Fu had earlier sent her father Fu Wan a letter saying that the emperor resented Cao Cao over the execution of Dong Cheng; the empress was deposed and died, and her brothers were all executed. In the 1st month of the 20th year of Jian'an (215) the Son of Heaven made Cao Cao's middle daughter empress, and in the 5th month of the 21st year of Jian'an (216) he raised Cao Cao's rank, making him King of Wei. Records, Wei 1 §136 · 142 · 145 · 154
In the winter of the 1st year of Yankang (220), the Emperor of Han, declaring that the hopes of the multitude lay with Wei, summoned the high ministers, reported to the ancestral temple of Gaozu, and had Zhang Yin, acting Imperial Counsellor, present the imperial seal and ribbons and hand over the throne to Cao Pi, King of Wei. In the patent of abdication he said that the way of Han had gradually declined, that in his own time it had fallen into great chaos and the realm had been overturned, and that he was following the precedent of Yao yielding the throne to Shun. In the 11th month of the 1st year of Huangchu (220), Cao Pi enfeoffed him as Duke of Shanyang with 10,000 households of the town of Shanyang in Henei Commandery, allowing him to use the Han calendar (zhengshuo), to perform the suburban sacrifices with the rites of the Son of Heaven, and not to call himself a subject when submitting documents, and enfeoffed his four sons as marquises. The Duke of Shanyang presented two daughters to Wei as consorts. Records, Wei 2 §12–17Records, Wei 5 §20
The Biography of the First Sovereign records that in this year, when a rumor spread that the Emperor of Han had been killed, Liu Bei announced mourning, put on mourning dress and conferred on him the posthumous title Emperor Xiaomin. But the Duke of Shanyang died on the gengyin day of the 3rd month of the 2nd year of Qinglong (234). Emperor Ming put on white mourning and grieved for him, sent an envoy to take charge of the funeral, posthumously titled him Emperor Xiaoxian of Han, and buried him with the rites of Han. Wang Su said in a memorial that Wei had generously honored the Duke of Shanyang and had not treated him as a subject, and that when he died, the rules for his encoffining and the adornments of his hearse were all the same as for a sovereign. Records, Shu 2 §55Records, Wei 3 §35Records, Wei 13 §77–78
In Chapter 3 of the Romance, Liu Xie, the Prince of Chenliu, was carried off by Zhang Rang and Duan Gui and fled with Emperor Shao to Mount Beimang, then followed the light of fireflies to a farmstead. When Dong Zhuo arrived at the head of his troops, the prince asked him, "Have you come to protect the imperial carriage, or to seize it?", and rebuked him, asking why he did not dismount when the Son of Heaven was there; Dong Zhuo hastily got off his horse and bowed. In Chapter 4, Dong Zhuo deposed Emperor Shao on the first day of the 9th month and set him up in his place; the Romance gives his courtesy name as Bohe and says he was nine years old at the time. Romance, Ch. 3 §17–20 · 25Romance, Ch. 4 §4 · 9
In Chapters 9–10, when Li Jue and Guo Si took Chang'an, he went up the tower of the Xuanping Gate and asked them what they meant to do. In Chapter 13, following Yang Biao's plan, he issued a secret edict to split Li Jue and Guo Si through the jealousy of Guo Si's wife, but Li Jue put the Son of Heaven and Empress Fu in carriages, dragged them off and moved them to the Mei Fortress. On the way east, on the bank of the Yellow River, Fu De carried the empress on his back onto a boat, and when an old man of the fields offered them millet rice, he ate it with the empress but could not swallow it. Romance, Ch. 9 §48Romance, Ch. 13 §11–12 · 16 · 19 · 51–53
In Chapter 14 he returned to a ruined Luoyang and summoned Cao Cao, and when Cao Cao came to his rescue he said, "General Cao is truly a minister of the altars of state!" After Cao Cao moved the capital to Xudu, all great power passed to Cao Cao, and the great affairs of the court were reported first to Cao Cao and only then to the Son of Heaven. Romance, Ch. 14 §2 · 5 · 10 · 26 · 34–35
At the hunt at Xutian in Chapter 20, when Cao Cao shot a deer with the Son of Heaven's bow and gold-tipped arrow and received in his place the ministers' cries of "Long live!", he returned to the palace and told Empress Fu in tears that whenever he saw Cao Cao he felt as if thorns were pricking his back. He bit his finger, wrote a secret edict in blood, had Empress Fu sew it into the lining of a jade belt, and gave it to Dong Cheng. In Chapter 24, after killing Dong Cheng and the others, Cao Cao even killed Dong Guifei, the Honored Consort, who was five months pregnant. Romance, Ch. 20 §14 · 17–18 · 21Romance, Ch. 24 §5
In Chapter 66, trembling before Cao Cao, who had come in wearing a sword, he said that it would be a blessing if Cao Cao would assist him, but if not, he begged to be let go. When Empress Fu had the eunuch Mu Shun carry a secret letter to her father Fu Wan and it was discovered, Hua Xin dragged the empress out from where she was hiding inside a double wall, and the emperor held her in his arms and wept. After going without food for days, on the first day of the 1st month of the 20th year of Jian'an he made Cao Cao's daughter, the Honored Lady Cao, empress. Romance, Ch. 66 §34–37 · 40 · 42 · 47 · 51
In Chapter 80, when Hua Xin, Wang Lang and others urged him to abdicate, he tearfully refused, calling the auspicious omens and prophetic charts empty fabrications; but when Cao Hong and Cao Xiu drew their swords and several hundred Wei soldiers lined up below the steps, he accepted abdication, asking only to be allowed to live out his remaining days. After personally presenting the imperial seal to Cao Pi on the Altar of Accepting Abdication, he was enfeoffed as Duke of Shanyang, and when Hua Xin, gripping his sword hilt, told him not to come to court unless summoned and made him leave that very day, he departed holding back his tears. Romance, Ch. 80 §1–2 · 5 · 10 · 12 · 20 · 24–25
The Prince of Chenliu at Beimang: In Chapter 3 of the Romance, the Prince of Chenliu rebuked Dong Zhuo at Beimang and made him dismount and bow. The Biography of Dong Zhuo in the Records states only that Dong Zhuo met the emperor at Beimang and returned to the palace. Romance, Ch. 3 §25Records, Wei 6 §6
The quarrel between Li Jue and Guo Si: In Chapter 13 of the Romance, Yang Biao, having received the emperor's secret edict, stirred up the jealousy of Guo Si's wife to split the two men. The Biography of Dong Zhuo in the Records states that the two gradually came to suspect each other and fought in Chang'an. Romance, Ch. 13 §11–12Records, Wei 6 §24
Who tried to move him to Mei: In Chapter 13 of the Romance, Li Jue moved the emperor and empress to the Mei Fortress. In the Biography of Dong Zhuo in the Records, Li Jue held the Son of Heaven hostage in his own camp; it was Guo Si who tried to coerce the Son of Heaven into going back to make his capital at Mei, and the Son of Heaven fled to Yang Feng's camp. Romance, Ch. 13 §19Records, Wei 6 §24–25
The edict written in blood: In Chapter 20 of the Romance, the emperor bit his finger and wrote a secret edict in blood, and Empress Fu sewed it into the lining of a jade belt. The Biography of the First Sovereign in the Records states only that Dong Cheng said he had received a secret edict hidden in the emperor's sash. Romance, Ch. 20 §21Records, Shu 2 §15
Empress Fu's letter: In Chapter 66 of the Romance, Empress Fu, saying that Cao Cao meant to usurp the throne, had the eunuch Mu Shun carry a secret letter to Fu Wan, and Fu Wan's reply, proposing an alliance with Sun Quan and Liu Bei, was discovered in Mu Shun's hair. In the Annals of Emperor Wu in the Records, it came to light that the empress had earlier sent Fu Wan a letter saying that the emperor resented Cao Cao over the execution of Dong Cheng, and she was deposed and died. Romance, Ch. 66 §36–37 · 40Records, Wei 1 §142
The manner of the abdication: In Chapter 80 of the Romance, the emperor tearfully accepted abdication while Cao Hong and Cao Xiu drew their swords and Wei soldiers lined up below the steps. The Annals of Emperor Wen in the Records state that the Emperor of Han, declaring that the hopes of the multitude lay with Wei, summoned the high ministers, reported to the ancestral temple of Gaozu, and sent Zhang Yin to present the imperial seal and ribbons and abdicate. Romance, Ch. 80 §10 · 12Records, Wei 2 §13
Treatment as Duke of Shanyang: In Chapter 80 of the Romance, he was made to leave on the very day he was enfeoffed as Duke of Shanyang and was not allowed to come to court unless summoned. In the Annals of Emperor Wen in the Records, he was enfeoffed with 10,000 households of the town of Shanyang, allowed to use the Han calendar, to perform the suburban sacrifices with the rites of the Son of Heaven, and not to call himself a subject when submitting documents, and his four sons were enfeoffed as marquises. Romance, Ch. 80 §24Records, Wei 2 §17
Death: In Chapter 80 of the Romance, Xu Jing said that the Son of Heaven of Han had already been murdered by Cao Pi. The Biography of the First Sovereign in the Records states that a rumor spread that the Emperor of Han had been killed, and in the Annals of Emperor Ming the Duke of Shanyang died in the 3rd month of the 2nd year of Qinglong (234) and was posthumously titled Emperor Xiaoxian of Han. Romance, Ch. 80 §32Records, Shu 2 §55Records, Wei 3 §35
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.
RNo direct record — estimated from his enfeoffment as Duke of Shanyang after the abdicationWei 2 §13Wei 2 §17
NTrembled and could not speak whenever danger came, and his secret edicts were discovered twiceCh. 24 §6Ch. 80 §10Ch. 66 §40
RNo direct record — estimatedWei 1 §121
NAs the young Prince of Chenliu, rebuked Dong Zhuo into dismounting and never misspokeCh. 3 §25
RNo direct record — estimated, as there is no record of his own judgment beyond the patent of appointmentWei 1 §121
NWas called intelligent, and at the abdication refuted the auspicious omens and prophetic charts as empty fabricationsCh. 3 §29Ch. 80 §5
RWang Su memorialized that he served Wei with complete integrityWei 13 §77Wei 3 §35
NBit his finger to write an edict in blood, and said he could not abandon the enterprise of his ancestorsCh. 20 §21Ch. 80 §2Ch. 24 §6
RNo direct record — estimatedWei 1 §121
NWas said to be intelligent and fond of learningCh. 3 §29Ch. 4 §5
RNo direct record — estimated from the record that Dong Cheng received a secret edict hidden in the sashShu 2 §15
NSoldiers and commoners grieved when he left after the abdication, and Mu Shun risked his life for himCh. 80 §25Ch. 66 §37
RNo direct record — estimated from his position of being dragged about by powerful ministersWei 1 §35
NNo direct record — estimatedCh. 13 §57
RNo direct record — estimatedWei 1 §35
NNo direct record — estimatedCh. 13 §57
RNo direct record — estimated from government having been in the hands of powerful ministersWei 1 §121Wei 6 §8
NNo direct record — estimated from his position of being held down by powerful ministersCh. 13 §10
RNo direct record — estimated on the view that appointments reflected the will of powerful ministersWei 1 §39
NRegarded Cao Cao as a minister of the altars of state but came to regret it; trusted and relied on Dong ChengCh. 20 §17Ch. 20 §19
Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)
3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.
AppearsNot present Chapter list →
| Parents | Lingdi Novel & History, Meiren Wang Romance |
|---|---|
| Spouse | Dong Guifei Romance, Cao Jie Novel & History, Empress Fu Novel & History |
| Relatives | Empress Dong Records |
Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.
Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).
Ownership and authorship assigned by 3KDEX from source sentences — not yet reviewed (unverified).