Sima Yi 司馬懿

RecordsRomance Wei Zhongda사마의중달仲達司马懿仲达

Profile
OccupationRNGeneral · Grand TutorFactionWei
AppearsRNBiography in
BornR179 N? UnverifiedNative placeHenei Commandery Wen County Unverified
DiedR251 N(same) UnverifiedPlace of death
Cause of deathNIllness Unverified
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR266

Profile

Sima Yi was a minister of Wei who received deathbed edicts in turn from Emperor Wen, Cao Pi, and Emperor Ming, Cao Rui. The main text of Chen Shou's Records does not give his courtesy name or origin, stating only that his elder brother Sima Lang was a native of Wen County in Henei Commandery; the Romance introduces him as a man of Wen County, Henei, with the courtesy name Zhongda. Records, Wei 2 §52Records, Wei 3 §65Records, Wei 12 §16Records, Wei 15 §15Romance, Ch. 39 §21

Under Emperor Ming he beheaded Meng Da, faced Zhuge Liang south of the Wei River, and destroyed Gongsun Yuan of Liaodong. Under Cao Fang, Prince of Qi, he became Grand Tutor (taifu), had Cao Shuang and his brothers removed from office in the 1st year of Jiaping (249), and died in the autumn of the 3rd year of Jiaping (251), the same year he suppressed Wang Ling's plot. Records, Wei 4 §5 · 28 · 32–33

Chen Shou's Records has no biography of Sima Yi. His deeds are scattered across several volumes, including the Annals of Emperor Wen, the Annals of Emperor Ming, the Annals of the Three Young Emperors, and the biographies of Cao Shuang, Zhuge Liang and Gongsun Du, and Chen Shou usually calls him "Sima Xuanwang" (Sima, King Xuan) or simply "Xuanwang." In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 39 and appears in 29 of its 120 chapters; as the title of Chapter 95, "Wuhou Plays the Zither and Drives Off Zhongda," suggests, it repeatedly depicts him confronting Zhuge Liang. Records, Wei 2 §52Records, Wei 3 §4 · 7Records, Wei 9 §80Records, Shu 5 §38Records, Wei 8 §47Romance, Ch. 39 §21Romance, Ch. 95 §43–45

In the Records

Cui Yan told his friend Sima Lang that his younger brother, just come of age, was intelligent, clear-sighted, firm and decisive, and that Sima Lang himself would likely not match him; Sima Lang did not think so. Yang Jun met Sima Yi when he was sixteen or seventeen and said, "This is no ordinary man." Records, Wei 12 §16Records, Wei 23 §27

In the 24th year of Jian'an (219), when Guan Yu besieged Fancheng and Cao Cao discussed moving the capital away from Xu, Sima Yi and Jiang Ji argued that Sun Quan would not want Guan Yu to succeed; if Sun Quan were promised the lands south of the Yangtze as a fief and urged to strike at Guan Yu's rear, the siege would lift of itself. Cao Cao followed this advice. Under Emperor Wen, as Deputy Director of the Imperial Secretariat, he joined Wang Xiang and Xun Wei in the 3rd year of Huangchu (222) in kowtowing until their foreheads bled to plead for Yang Jun, who had been arrested after angering the emperor, but they were refused. In the 5th month of the 7th year of Huangchu (226), when Emperor Wen fell gravely ill, Sima Yi, as General-in-Chief Who Pacifies the Army, received the deathbed edict together with Cao Zhen, Chen Qun and Cao Xiu to assist the heir. Records, Shu 6 §10–11Records, Wei 23 §32Records, Wei 2 §52

When Emperor Ming took the throne, Sima Yi opened his own administrative office along with Cao Xiu, Cao Zhen and Chen Qun. In the 8th month of that year, when the Wu general Zhuge Jin and others raided Xiangyang, he defeated them and beheaded Zhang Ba, and together with Zhang He he pursued Sun Quan's detached commander Liu A and others as far as Qikou and defeated them. In the 12th month he became General-in-Chief of Agile Cavalry. In the 12th month of the 1st year of Taihe (early 228), when Meng Da, Administrator of Xincheng, rebelled, he received an edict to suppress him, and in the 1st month of the 2nd year of Taihe (228) he took Xincheng, beheaded Meng Da and sent his head on. Records, Wei 22 §20Records, Wei 3 §3–4 · 6–7Records, Wei 17 §50

Around that time he trained a navy in Jing Province, intending to go down the Mian River into the Yangtze to attack Wu; Zhang He came with the armies of Guanzhong to join him, but it was winter and the water was too shallow for large ships. In the 2nd month of the 4th year of Taihe (230) he became General-in-Chief and set out against Shu with the Grand Marshal Cao Zhen, planning to go up the Han River and meet Cao Zhen at Nanzheng. But heavy rains fell for more than thirty days and some of the plank roads were cut, and in the 9th month an edict recalled the army. Records, Wei 17 §52Records, Wei 3 §18–19Records, Wei 9 §67

In the 3rd month of the 5th year of Taihe (231), after Cao Zhen died and Zhuge Liang raided Tianshui, he received an edict to resist him. At Mount Qi, Sima Yi attacked Zhuge Liang while Zhang He attacked Wang Ping at the southern siege lines, but Wang Ping held firm and Zhang He could not prevail. In the 6th month, when Zhuge Liang withdrew for lack of provisions, Zhang He pursued him and was killed by an arrow. As General-in-Chief, Sima Yi held Huang Quan, who had surrendered from Shu, in high regard, asking him, "How many men like you are there in Shu?", and in a letter to Zhuge Liang he wrote that Huang Quan was always praising Zhuge Liang. Records, Wei 3 §21Records, Shu 13 §37 · 9Records, Shu 3 §12

In the 9th month of the 1st year of Qinglong (233), when the Xiongnu chieftain Hubo Juzizhi and others in Anding rebelled, he sent Hu Zun and others, who defeated them and forced their surrender. In the 2nd year of Qinglong (234), when Zhuge Liang came out through the Xie Valley, occupied the Wuzhang Plains and confronted him south of the Wei River, Emperor Ming issued an edict ordering him to hold his walls firmly and to pursue the enemy when it fled. Sima Yi approved Guo Huai's judgment that Zhuge Liang would contest the Northern Plain and stationed Guo Huai there. When Sima Yi repeatedly asked to give battle, Emperor Ming refused and sent Xin Pi as Military Adviser to the General-in-Chief. Zhuge Liang challenged him to battle several times, but Sima Yi strengthened his ramparts and did not respond; after a standoff of more than a hundred days, Zhuge Liang died of illness in camp in the 8th month. After the Shu army withdrew, Sima Yi inspected the site of its camp and said, "A genius of the realm!" Records, Wei 3 §32 · 36 · 40Records, Shu 5 §38Records, Wei 26 §69Records, Wei 25 §22

In the 1st month of the 3rd year of Qinglong (235) he became Grand Commandant. In the 1st month of the 2nd year of Jingchu (238) he received an edict to attack Gongsun Yuan of Liaodong. When officials objected that 40,000 troops were too many and the cost would be hard to bear, Emperor Ming said that a campaign of 4,000 li was no time to count costs and sent 40,000 men. Arriving in Liaodong in the 6th month, he sent Hu Zun to defeat Bei Yan and others, who had ringed Liaosui with more than twenty li of trenches, then headed southeast before swiftly turning northeast and making straight for Xiangping. While he besieged Xiangping, rains fell for more than thirty days, and some urged that he be recalled. Emperor Ming said, "Sima Yi meets danger by mastering change; the capture of Gongsun Yuan can be awaited by counting the days." In the 8th month Gongsun Yuan broke through the siege and fled, and was beheaded together with his son Gongsun Xiu at the spot where a meteor had fallen; Liaodong, Daifang, Lelang and Xuantu were all pacified. Records, Wei 3 §42 · 57 · 61–62Records, Wei 8 §47–49

In the 12th month of the 2nd year of Jingchu, when Emperor Ming fell ill, Liu Fang and others urged that the Grand Commandant Sima Yi be summoned at once to hold the imperial house together. The emperor had the summoning edict halted and then had it written again. In the 1st month of the 3rd year of Jingchu (239), Sima Yi, who had returned to Henei, was summoned by post horse and led into the emperor's bedchamber; Emperor Ming took his hand, charged him to assist his young son together with Cao Shuang, and died that day. When Cao Fang, Prince of Qi, took the throne, Sima Yi assisted in the government together with Cao Shuang, and in the 2nd month he became Grand Tutor, while continuing as before to command troops and oversee the armies. According to the Biography of Cao Shuang, the move to Grand Tutor was Ding Mi's scheme, meant to honor him outwardly while having the business of the Imperial Secretariat pass through Cao Shuang first. Records, Wei 3 §63 · 65Records, Wei 14 §151–153Records, Wei 4 §2 · 5Records, Wei 9 §72

In the 5th month of the 2nd year of Zhengshi (241), when Zhu Ran of Wu and others besieged Fancheng, he led forces to resist them, and the Wu army withdrew in the 6th month. He approved Deng Ai's proposal for military-agricultural colonies along the Huai River and had it carried out in full. According to the Biography of the Lord of Wu, in the 6th year of Chiwu (243) Sima Yi led an army into Shu County and Zhuge Ke moved to Chaisang; Sun Quan later remarked that Sima Yi had withdrawn within ten days. In the 5th year of Zhengshi (244), when Cao Shuang sought to attack Shu, Sima Yi tried to dissuade him but could not stop him. Records, Wei 4 §12Records, Wu 2 §96 · 99 · 101Records, Wei 28 §52–53Records, Wei 9 §74

At first Cao Shuang served Sima Yi like a father, but after he promoted He Yan and others, affairs no longer went through Sima Yi, who pleaded illness to avoid Cao Shuang while secretly making preparations. In the winter of the 9th year of Zhengshi (248), when Li Sheng, about to leave as Inspector of Jing Province, came to call, Sima Yi pretended to be gravely ill and showed himself frail, and Li Sheng believed it. In the 1st month of the 1st year of Jiaping (249), when the emperor went to pay respects at the Gaoping Tomb with Cao Shuang and all his brothers in attendance, Sima Yi first seized the arsenal and then stationed himself at the floating bridge over the Luo River. In his memorial he stated that when he returned from Liaodong, the late emperor had grasped his arm and entrusted him with affairs after his death, and that by order of the Empress Dowager he was relieving Cao Shuang and his brothers of their military command. Urged by Xu Yun and Chen Tai, Cao Shuang admitted his guilt and was dismissed. Later, on the testimony of Zhang Dang, Cao Shuang, He Yan and others were found to have plotted rebellion, and their clans were exterminated to the third degree. Sima Yi was appointed Chancellor but firmly declined. Records, Wei 9 §76 · 79–85 · 87–88Records, Wei 4 §28–29

In the 3rd year of Jiaping (251), on receiving a report that the Grand Commandant Wang Ling was plotting to depose the emperor and enthrone Cao Biao, Prince of Chu, Sima Yi led the central army by water, first issuing a pardon, and pressed him by bringing the main force to Baichi. When Wang Ling came out having bound himself, Sima Yi untied him, returned his seal and ribbon and his tally and axe, and had him escorted to the capital, but Wang Ling took poison and died at Xiang County. Sima Yi went on to Shouchun and pursued the affair to the end; Cao Biao was ordered to die, and those implicated had their clans exterminated to the third degree. When Sima Yi died on the wuyin day that autumn, his son Sima Shi became General-in-Chief Who Pacifies the Army and Controller of the Imperial Secretariat. Records, Wei 4 §32–33Records, Wei 28 §8–10

The assessments of him preserved in Chen Shou's text are all the words of others. An edict of the 3rd year of Jingchu said that he embodied the Way, was upright and straight, had served three generations with loyalty, captured Meng Da in the south, crushed Shu in the west and destroyed Gongsun Yuan in the east. In the 11th month of the year he died, when the meritorious officials to be honored in the temple of Taizu were re-ranked by office, he was placed at the very top for his high merit and noble rank. Zhuge Ke of Wu remarked that Sima Yi had killed Wang Ling and then died himself, and that his son was young and weak, so now was the time to attack Wei. Records, Wei 4 §5 · 33Records, Wu 19 §35

In the Romance

In Chapter 39 of the Romance, Cao Cao, on becoming Chancellor, appointed Sima Yi as Literary Clerk. The Romance introduces him as the grandson of Sima Jun, Administrator of Yingchuan, the son of Sima Fang, Intendant of Jingzhao, and the younger brother of the Registrar Sima Lang. As Cao Cao's Registrar, he urged in Chapter 67 that Cao Cao follow up the capture of Hanzhong by attacking Shu; in Chapter 75 he proposed not moving the capital but having Sun Quan strike at Guan Yu's rear; and in Chapter 77 he offered Cao Cao a plan concerning Guan Yu's head, which Wu had sent. Romance, Ch. 39 §21Romance, Ch. 67 §30–31Romance, Ch. 75 §13–14Romance, Ch. 77 §31–33

In Chapter 91, Cao Pi summoned three men, Cao Zhen, Chen Qun and Sima Yi, and entrusted Cao Rui to them. When Cao Rui took the throne, Sima Yi became General-in-Chief of Agile Cavalry in charge of the troops of Yong and Liang provinces, but a proclamation spread by Ma Su brought him under suspicion of rebellion. Hua Xin, saying that Taizu had once remarked, "Sima Yi glares like a hawk and looks back like a wolf; he must not be given military command," urged that he be put to death, and Cao Rui went to Anyi, stripped him of office and sent him home. Romance, Ch. 91 §17 · 19–31

In Chapter 94, restored to office as Commander Who Pacifies the West on Zhong Yao's recommendation, he received a report that Meng Da intended to rebel and, without waiting for an imperial order, made his troops cover two days' march in one and rushed to Xincheng. Xu Huang was killed by Meng Da's arrow, and Meng Da died on Shen Dan's spear. In Chapter 95, seeing that the Shu troops at Jieting were camped on a hill, he cut off their route for drawing water and defeated Ma Su, and seized Lieliu before Guo Huai could. At Xicheng, however, seeing Zhuge Liang playing the zither with the city gates left open, he withdrew his army; later, learning that there had been only 2,500 soldiers in the city, he sighed, "I am no match for Kongming!" Romance, Ch. 94 §26–27 · 39–41 · 48–50Romance, Ch. 95 §19–26 · 32 · 43–45 · 58–59

In Chapter 103, lured by Zhuge Liang's ruse into Shangfang Valley, he was trapped by fire and wept with his two sons in his arms, but a sudden downpour put out the flames and he escaped. At the Wuzhang Plains, when Zhuge Liang sent him a woman's headdress and clothing to shame him, he accepted them with a smile, and after asking the envoy about Zhuge Liang's sleep and meals, he reckoned that a man who ate little and had so much work could not last long. Romance, Ch. 103 §27–31 · 38–41

In Chapter 104, giving chase after Zhuge Liang's death, he saw Zhuge Liang seated in his carriage, concluded that he had fallen into a trap, fled more than fifty li and asked, "Is my head still on?" The Zhuge Liang on the carriage was a wooden figure, and the Romance records that a saying arose among the people of Shu: "A dead Zhuge put a living Zhongda to flight." Romance, Ch. 104 §30–34

In Chapter 106, setting out against Liaodong, he said that 40,000 troops would suffice, divided Gongsun Yuan's possible responses into the best, middling and worst plans, and said that a year would be enough for the round trip. During the long rains he beheaded an officer who proposed moving camp, and he beheaded Gongsun Yuan and his son where a star had fallen. When Cao Rui was dying, the eight-year-old Cao Fang clung to Sima Yi's neck. Later, raised to Grand Tutor at Cao Shuang's urging, he withdrew on the pretext of illness, and when Li Sheng came to take his leave, he misheard Jing Province as Bing Province and let his soup spill, playing an old man at death's door. Romance, Ch. 106 §6–7 · 14–15 · 19 · 24–26 · 30–32 · 35–37 · 43–47

In Chapter 107, while Cao Shuang was away accompanying Cao Fang to pay respects at Emperor Ming's tomb, Sima Yi petitioned Empress Dowager Guo and seized the arsenal; then, sending word that he meant only to take away the military command, he obtained Cao Shuang's surrender and exterminated his clan to the third degree. In Chapter 108, when his illness grew grave in the 8th month, autumn of the 3rd year of Jiaping, he admonished his two sons, "Be careful! Be careful!" and died. In Chapter 119, when his son Sima Zhao became King of Jin, Sima Yi was given the posthumous title King Xuan, and his grandson Sima Yan honored him posthumously as Emperor Xuan. Romance, Ch. 107 §1–3 · 9 · 19–23Romance, Ch. 108 §2–3Romance, Ch. 119 §31 · 47

Where the Romance differs

Emperor Wen's deathbed edict: In Chapter 91 of the Romance, Cao Pi summoned three men, Cao Zhen, Chen Qun and Sima Yi, and entrusted Cao Rui to them. In the Annals of Emperor Wen in the Records, four men, including Cao Xiu, received the edict. Romance, Ch. 91 §17Records, Wei 2 §52

The sowing of discord and his dismissal: In Chapter 91 of the Romance, Ma Su's scheme to sow discord got Sima Yi stripped of office and sent home. The Annals of Emperor Ming in the Records contain no such episode; there Sima Yi defeated the Wu army at Xiangyang in the 8th month of that year, became General-in-Chief of Agile Cavalry in the 12th month, and in the 12th month of the following year received an edict to attack Meng Da. Romance, Ch. 91 §31Records, Wei 3 §1–7

The campaign against Meng Da: In Chapter 94 of the Romance, Sima Yi marched without waiting for an imperial order. The Annals of Emperor Ming in the Records state that when Meng Da rebelled, an edict was issued ordering Sima Yi to suppress him. Romance, Ch. 94 §41Records, Wei 3 §6

Xu Huang's death: In Chapter 94 of the Romance, Xu Huang was killed at Xincheng by Meng Da's arrow. In the Biography of Xu Huang in the Records, he fell gravely ill, left his final instructions and died in the 1st year of Taihe (227). Romance, Ch. 94 §48Records, Wei 17 §69–70

Jieting and Lieliu: In Chapter 95 of the Romance, Sima Yi surrounded Jieting, defeated Ma Su and also took Lieliu first. In the Records, while the General-in-Chief Cao Zhen oversaw the region west of the passes, Zhang He defeated Ma Su at Jieting, and Guo Huai defeated Gao Xiang at Lieliu. Romance, Ch. 95 §22–23 · 32Records, Wei 3 §8Records, Wei 17 §51Records, Wei 26 §68

The zither at Xicheng: The scene in Chapter 95 of the Romance in which Zhuge Liang opens the city gates and plays the zither to drive off Sima Yi does not appear in the main text of the Biography of Zhuge Liang in the Records. That biography states only that after the defeat at Jieting he moved over a thousand households of Xi County and returned to Hanzhong. Romance, Ch. 95 §43–45Records, Shu 5 §1–54 · 33

The dead Zhuge Liang and the wooden figure: The pursuit and flight of Chapter 104 of the Romance are not in the Records. The Annals of Emperor Ming say that the Shu army withdrew when Zhuge Liang died, and the Biography of Zhuge Liang states only that after the army withdrew, Sima Yi inspected the site of its camp and said "A genius of the realm." Romance, Ch. 104 §31–34Records, Wei 3 §40Records, Shu 5 §38

The 40,000 troops for Liaodong: In Chapter 106 of the Romance, Cao Rui worried that the force was too small and Sima Yi said 40,000 would suffice. In the Annals of Emperor Ming in the Records, officials said 40,000 was too many and the cost would be hard to bear, and Emperor Ming insisted on 40,000. Romance, Ch. 106 §6Records, Wei 3 §61–62

Gongsun Yuan's end: In Chapter 106 of the Romance, Gongsun Yuan and his son, surrounded, dismounted and surrendered, and were then beheaded. In the Biography of Gongsun Du in the Records, when his forces collapsed he broke through the siege and fled southeast, and was beheaded after being pursued. Romance, Ch. 106 §25–26Records, Wei 8 §49

Li Sheng's visit: In Chapter 106 of the Romance, after the era name was changed to Jiaping, Cao Shuang sent Li Sheng to check on Sima Yi's illness. In the Biography of Cao Shuang in the Records, Li Sheng's visit took place in the winter of the 9th year of Zhengshi (248), and in the Annals of the Three Young Emperors the era name was changed to Jiaping in the 4th month, after Sima Yi had ousted Cao Shuang. Romance, Ch. 106 §43–44Records, Wei 9 §79Records, Wei 4 §28–30

Final years: Wang Ling's plot does not appear in the Romance, and in Chapter 108 Sima Yi died of illness in the 3rd year of Jiaping. In the Records, that year he suppressed Wang Ling's plot, dealt with the affair at Shouchun, and died in the autumn. Romance, Ch. 108 §2–3Records, Wei 28 §8–10Records, Wei 4 §32–33

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA9288−4
  • STR3545+10
  • INT8893+5
  • POL7258−14
  • CHA7065−5
  • VIR5235−17
  • ADP9288−4
  • SCH5048−2
  • DIP5850−8
  • DIS8583−2
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

PoliticsR72N58 −14

RCarried out all of Deng Ai's colony-farming and canal plans and answered the debate on the official systemWei 28 §53Wei 24 §65Wei 9 §118

NStayed at Xuchang during Cao Pi's personal campaign and was entrusted with decisions on state affairsCh. 86 §29

StrengthR35UnverifiedN45 +10

RNo direct record — estimated from his role as commanderWei 3 §4

NFought Wei Yan with a spear at the mouth of Shangfang ValleyCh. 103 §28

7 similar abilities — show evidence

Special — talents Records +0 · Romance +10

  • Divination & astronomy

    NSkilled +10 Observed the heavens at night to gauge the situation and Gongsun Yuan's downfallCh. 102 §7Ch. 106 §19

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (29)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Allegiance history

  1. Wei · Records · Records vol. 3 「以大將軍司馬宣王爲太尉」

Family

ParentsSima Fang Romance
SiblingsSima Lang Novel & History, Sima Fu Romance
ChildrenSima Zhao Romance, Sima Shi Romance

Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.

Related events (21)

Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).

Items owned or made (1)

Ownership and authorship assigned by 3KDEX from source sentences — not yet reviewed (unverified).

Related works (2)

Linked via Wikidata "depicts" and character names in titles (unverified) — not yet reviewed.