RNo direct record — estimated from his use of Bei Yan and Yang Zuo as generalsWei 8 §47
NKilled Jia Fan and Lun Zhi for their sound remonstrance, and Sima Yi later raised their grave moundsCh. 106 §5Ch. 106 §27
| Occupation | RNRuler · King of Yan | Faction | Gongsun Yuan faction |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appears | RN | Biography in | Book of Wei |
| Born | R? Unverified | Native place | Liaodong Commandery Xiangping County Unverified |
| Died | R238 Unverified | Place of death | RNXiangping County |
| Cause of death | RKilled in battle NExecuted Unverified | ||
| Existence | Historical | Mentions | R47 |
Gongsun Yuan was the son of Gongsun Kang, who ruled Liaodong, and the grandson of Gongsun Du. In the 2nd year of Taihe (228) he seized the position of his uncle Gongsun Gong, and Emperor Ming of Wei, Cao Rui, appointed him General Who Displays Valor (Yanglie Jiangjun) and Administrator of Liaodong. Records, Wei 8 §41 · 43
He came to terms with Sun Quan of Wu and was enfeoffed as King of Yan, then beheaded Wu's envoys and sent their heads to Wei; but in the 1st year of Jingchu (237) he made himself King of Yan and turned against Wei. The following year, besieged at Xiangping by Sima Yi, he broke through the siege and fled, and was beheaded together with his son Gongsun Xiu. Records, Wei 8 §44–47 · 49
Chen Shou, author of the Records, wrote in his assessment that Gongsun Du was cruel and violent without restraint, and that Gongsun Yuan, inheriting his enterprise, added to its viciousness, which served only to overturn his own clan. In the Romance he first appears in a memorial from Guanqiu Jian at the end of Chapter 105 and appears in 2 of its 120 chapters; the title of Chapter 106 reads 'Gongsun Yuan, Defeated in Battle, Dies at Xiangping'. Records, Wei 8 §71Romance, Ch. 105 §51Romance, Ch. 106 §1 · 26
His grandfather Gongsun Du, a man of Xiangping in Liaodong, seized Liaodong in the 6th year of Zhongping (189) and made himself Marquis of Liaodong and Governor of Ping Province. When Gongsun Du died in the 9th year of Jian'an (204), his son Gongsun Kang succeeded him; in the 12th year of Jian'an (207) Gongsun Kang cut off the head of Yuan Shang, who had fled to Liaodong, and sent it off, and was made Marquis of Xiangping and General of the Left. When Gongsun Kang died, his sons Gongsun Huang, Gongsun Yuan and the others were all young, so the people set up Gongsun Kang's younger brother Gongsun Gong as Administrator of Liaodong. Records, Wei 8 §36 · 39–41 · 50
Gongsun Gong had been made a eunuch by illness and was too weak to govern the state. In the 2nd year of Taihe (228) Gongsun Yuan coerced Gongsun Gong and seized his position, and Emperor Ming, Cao Rui, at once appointed him General Who Displays Valor and Administrator of Liaodong. Liu Ye urged that troops be sent while he was newly established, saying that the Gongsun family had long held power for generations and would become a source of disaster later if not destroyed now. In the 4th year of Taihe (230) he was made General of Chariots and Cavalry. Records, Wei 8 §43Records, Wei 3 §10 · 18Records, Wei 14 §108
Gongsun Yuan sent envoys south to come to terms with Sun Quan, and they exchanged gifts. In the 10th month of the 1st year of Jiahe (232) he sent the Colonel Su Shu and the Chamberlain of the Palace Gentlemen Sun Zong to declare himself Sun Quan's vassal and present sable furs and horses. In the 3rd month of the following year Sun Quan gave Zhang Mi, Xu Yan, He Da and others 10,000 soldiers, gold, silver and treasures, and the ceremonial gifts of the Nine Bestowals, and had them cross the sea to make Gongsun Yuan King of Yan. The Chancellor Gu Yong and the entire court below him, as well as Zhang Zhao, remonstrated that Gongsun Yuan could not be trusted, but Sun Quan would not listen. Records, Wei 8 §43–44Records, Wu 2 §72–73 · 75Records, Wu 7 §13
Fearing that Sun Quan was too far away to be relied upon, and coveting the goods as well, Gongsun Yuan lured the envoys in, cut off the heads of Zhang Mi, Xu Yan and the others and sent them to Wei, and seized their soldiers and supplies. In the 12th month of that year Emperor Ming made Gongsun Yuan Grand Marshal and enfeoffed him as Duke of Lelang. Sun Quan, in a great rage, wanted to attack him in person, but gave it up at the remonstrance of Xue Zong, Lu Xun and others. Records, Wei 8 §44–45Records, Wei 3 §34Records, Wu 2 §76Records, Wu 13 §39
When envoys from Wei came, Gongsun Yuan arrayed armored troops as if in battle formation before going out to meet them, and he repeatedly spoke insolently before the guests in his state. In the 1st year of Jingchu (237), when Guanqiu Jian, Inspector of You Province, came bearing an edict under the imperial seal to summon him, Gongsun Yuan raised troops and met him in battle at Liaosui County, and Guanqiu Jian, faring badly, withdrew. The Annals of Emperor Ming record that rain fell for ten days at this time, the Liao River rose greatly, and Guanqiu Jian was recalled. Gongsun Yuan then made himself King of Yan, established a full set of officials and proclaimed the 1st year of Shaohan; he lent a seal to the Xianbei chanyu and enticed the Xianbei to harass the north. Records, Wei 8 §46Records, Wei 3 §53–54
In the spring of the 2nd year of Jingchu (238) Emperor Ming sent the Grand Commandant Sima Yi to attack Gongsun Yuan. His ministers said that 40,000 men were too many and the cost would be hard to bear, but Emperor Ming, saying that a campaign of 4,000 li required a full commitment of strength, sent 40,000 men. In the 6th month, when the Wei army reached Liaodong, Gongsun Yuan gave his generals Bei Yan, Yang Zuo and others several tens of thousands of infantry and cavalry and had them hold Liaosui County behind more than twenty li of encircling trenches. Sima Yi sent Hu Zun and others to defeat Bei Yan, and, feigning a move to the southeast, turned sharply northeast and made straight for Xiangping. Fearing that Xiangping was undefended, Bei Yan and the others fled by night, and at Mount Shou they fought again to the death but were heavily defeated. Records, Wei 8 §47–48Records, Wei 3 §61–62
The Wei army reached the foot of the walls of Xiangping and dug siege trenches. Just then heavy rains fell for more than thirty days and the Liao River rose, so that transport ships came straight from Liaokou to the foot of the walls. Some at court proposed recalling Sima Yi, but Emperor Ming said that Sima Yi met danger by adapting to change, and that the capture of Gongsun Yuan could be counted in days. When the rain cleared, the Wei army raised earthen mounds and towers and shot into the city with catapults and repeating crossbows. Gongsun Yuan was hard pressed; food ran out, people ate one another, and his general Yang Zuo and others surrendered. Records, Wei 8 §48Records, Wei 3 §62
On the night of the bingyin day of the 8th month, a great meteor several tens of zhang long fell from northeast of Mount Shou to the southeast of the city of Xiangping. On the renwu day Gongsun Yuan's forces collapsed, and he and his son Gongsun Xiu, leading several hundred horsemen, broke through the siege and fled southeast. The main army attacked swiftly and beheaded Gongsun Yuan and his son on the very spot where the meteor had fallen. When the city fell, those beheaded from the Chancellor of State downward numbered in the thousands; Gongsun Yuan's head was sent to Luoyang, and Liaodong, Daifang, Lelang and Xuantu were all pacified. Records, Wei 8 §49
His elder brother Gongsun Huang, who was at court as a hostage, had repeatedly reported the coming trouble before Gongsun Yuan rebelled. Gao Rou memorialized that if his words were true he should be spared death, but Emperor Ming would not listen and made Gongsun Huang and his wife and children drink powdered gold. Records, Wei 24 §49–50
Earlier, strange things had often happened in Gongsun Yuan's household. A dog wearing a cap and headcloth and a red robe climbed onto the roof; when rice was being steamed, a small child was found steamed to death in the pot; and in the northern market of Xiangping a lump of flesh appeared that had a head, eyes and a mouth but no hands or feet, and wriggled. The divination said, 'It has form but is not complete, it has a body but no voice; that state will perish.' From Gongsun Du's seizure of Liaodong to Gongsun Yuan, the family lasted three generations, fifty years in all, before it fell. Records, Wei 8 §50
In his assessment, Chen Shou wrote that Gongsun Du was cruel and violent without restraint, and that Gongsun Yuan, inheriting his enterprise, added to its viciousness, which served only to overturn his own clan. Records, Wei 8 §71
At the end of Chapter 105 of the Romance, Guanqiu Jian, Inspector of You Province, submits a memorial reporting that Gongsun Yuan of Liaodong has rebelled, calls himself King of Yan and has changed the reign title to the 1st year of Shaohan, and that he is building palaces, establishing offices and raising troops, throwing the north into turmoil. Romance, Ch. 105 §51
Chapter 106 introduces Gongsun Yuan as the grandson of Gongsun Du and the son of Gongsun Kang, who in the 2nd year of Taihe (228), grown to manhood, accomplished in both letters and arms and of a stubborn, combative nature, seized the position of his uncle Gongsun Gong. Out of fear of the Central Plains he beheads Sun Quan's envoys Zhang Mi and Xu Yan and sends their heads to Wei, and becomes Grand Marshal and Duke of Lelang, but still unsatisfied he makes himself King of Yan. When the Deputy General Jia Fan and the Army Adviser Lun Zhi try to dissuade him, citing Sima Yi's generalship and strange omens in the state, he has the two men beheaded in the marketplace, makes Bei Yan Commander-in-Chief and Yang Zuo leader of the vanguard, and raises 150,000 troops of Liaodong. Romance, Ch. 106 §1–5
Sima Yi sets out with 40,000 troops, saying that for Gongsun Yuan to abandon his city and flee would be the best plan, to resist in Liaodong the middling plan, and to sit and hold Xiangping the worst. When Sima Yi leaves the Liao River behind and heads for Xiangping, Bei Yan, giving chase, dies by the blade of Xiahou Ba, and Gongsun Yuan enters the city of Xiangping and holds it fast. After a month of autumn rain, when the food in the city runs out, Gongsun Yuan sends the Chancellor of State Wang Jian and the Imperial Counselor Liu Fu to ask for surrender, but Sima Yi beheads them both. When he then sends the Palace Attendant Wei Yan to offer his heir Gongsun Xiu as a hostage, Sima Yi sends him back, saying that one who cannot fight should defend, one who cannot defend should flee, one who cannot flee should surrender, and one who cannot surrender has only to die. Romance, Ch. 106 §6–7 · 9 · 11–14 · 21–23
Gongsun Yuan, together with Gongsun Xiu, leads a thousand men and horses out through the south gate by night and flees southeast, but before he has gone ten li he is surrounded by Sima Yi, Sima Shi, Sima Zhao, Hu Zun, Xiahou Ba, Xiahou Wei, Zhang Hu and Yue Chen, and dismounts and surrenders. Sima Yi says that on the bingyin day he saw a great star fall at this spot and that it has come true on the renshen day, and he has Gongsun Yuan and his son beheaded facing each other. He then kills Gongsun Yuan's clan and more than seventy officials who took part in the plot, and raises burial mounds over the graves of Jia Fan and Lun Zhi, who had died at Gongsun Yuan's hands. Romance, Ch. 106 §19 · 24–27
Why he beheaded Sun Quan's envoys: In Chapter 106 of the Romance, Gongsun Yuan beheads Zhang Mi and Xu Yan out of fear of the Central Plains. In the Records, fearing that Sun Quan was too far away to be relied upon and coveting the goods, he lured the envoys in and beheaded them, and seized the soldiers and supplies they had brought. Romance, Ch. 106 §2Records, Wei 8 §44Records, Wu 2 §76
How he became King of Yan: In Chapter 106 of the Romance, dissatisfied with being Grand Marshal and Duke of Lelang, he makes himself King of Yan and sets out with 150,000 troops to attack the Central Plains. In the Records, he made himself King of Yan after meeting and repelling Guanqiu Jian at Liaosui County when Guanqiu Jian came with an edict to summon him in the 1st year of Jingchu (237). Romance, Ch. 106 §3 · 5Records, Wei 8 §46Records, Wei 3 §53–54
Jia Fan and Lun Zhi: In Chapter 106 of the Romance, the two men die for remonstrating with him about strange omens. They do not appear in Chen Shou's text in the Records, where the strange events are recorded, together with the divination, as things that happened in Gongsun Yuan's household. Romance, Ch. 106 §3–5Records, Wei 8 §42–50
Size of Sima Yi's army: In Chapter 106 of the Romance, Sima Yi says 40,000 will be enough and Cao Rui worries that it is too few. In the Records, when Emperor Ming proposed to send 40,000, his ministers said it was too many and the cost would be hard to bear, and Emperor Ming, calling it a campaign of 4,000 li, sent the 40,000 as planned. Romance, Ch. 106 §6Records, Wei 3 §61–62
Bei Yan: In Chapter 106 of the Romance, Xiahou Ba beheads Bei Yan in the battle at Mount Shou. In the Records, Hu Zun and others only defeated Bei Yan at Liaosui County and defeated him heavily again at Mount Shou; there is no record of Bei Yan's death, nor any mention of Xiahou Ba. Romance, Ch. 106 §12–13Records, Wei 8 §47–48
Envoys asking to surrender: In Chapter 106 of the Romance, the Chancellor of State Wang Jian, the Imperial Counselor Liu Fu and the Palace Attendant Wei Yan come to ask for surrender. These envoys are absent from Chen Shou's text in the Records, which records that the general Yang Zuo and others surrendered. Romance, Ch. 106 §21–22Records, Wei 8 §48
Manner of death: In Chapter 106 of the Romance, Gongsun Yuan and his son, surrounded, dismount and surrender and are beheaded. In the Records, they were beheaded where the meteor had fallen, after breaking through the siege and fleeing under attack by the main army, and there is no mention of surrender. Romance, Ch. 106 §25–26Records, Wei 8 §49
Dates: In Chapter 106 of the Romance, Sima Yi sees the star on the bingyin day and speaks of five days later, and he beheads Gongsun Yuan on the renshen day. In the Records, the meteor fell on the night of the bingyin day of the 8th month, and Gongsun Yuan's forces collapsed on the renwu day. Romance, Ch. 106 §19 · 25Records, Wei 8 §49
Number killed: In Chapter 106 of the Romance, Sima Yi kills Gongsun Yuan's clan and more than seventy officials who took part in the plot. In the Records, when the city fell, those beheaded from the Chancellor of State downward numbered in the thousands. Romance, Ch. 106 §26Records, Wei 8 §49
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.
RNo direct record — estimated from his use of Bei Yan and Yang Zuo as generalsWei 8 §47
NKilled Jia Fan and Lun Zhi for their sound remonstrance, and Sima Yi later raised their grave moundsCh. 106 §5Ch. 106 §27
RNo direct record — estimated from his breaking through the siege and fleeingWei 8 §49
NDescribed as accomplished in letters and arms, stubborn by nature and fond of fightingCh. 106 §2
RNo direct record — estimated from his overall conductWei 8 §43
NNo record beyond the description of him as accomplished in letters and armsCh. 106 §2
RRepelled Guanqiu Jian at Liaosui but was twice heavily defeated by Sima YiWei 8 §46Wei 8 §47
NRaised 150,000 troops, but Bei Yan was beheaded and he was driven into XiangpingCh. 106 §5Ch. 106 §12
RHis general Yang Zuo and others surrendered and his forces collapsedWei 8 §48Wei 8 §49
NEveryone in the city resented him and wanted to cut off his head and surrenderCh. 106 §21
RBeheaded Sun Quan's envoys and sent them to Wei; Bei Yan fled by night at Sima Yi's flanking marchWei 8 §44Wei 8 §47
NIgnored remonstrance warning him about Sima Yi, and fell into an ambush while fleeingCh. 106 §3Ch. 106 §24
RNo direct record — estimated from his setting up officials as King of Yan; food in the city ran outWei 8 §46Wei 8 §48
NNo direct record — estimated from the food in the city running outCh. 106 §21
RSeized his uncle's position and beheaded envoys out of greed; assessment: added to the viciousnessWei 8 §43Wei 8 §44Wei 8 §71
NSeized his uncle's position and beheaded Jia Fan and Lun Zhi in the marketplace for remonstratingCh. 106 §2Ch. 106 §5
RIntimidated Wei's envoys and proclaimed himself king; assessment: served only to overturn his own clanWei 8 §46Wei 8 §71
NRebelled by proclaiming himself king; when cornered, offered to surrender if the enemy withdrew twenty liCh. 106 §3Ch. 106 §21
RAllied with Sun Quan and then betrayed him; drew in the Xianbei chanyu by giving him a sealWei 8 §43Wei 8 §46
NSent envoys asking for terms of surrender but was refusedCh. 106 §21
Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)
3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.
AppearsNot present Chapter list →
| Parents | Gongsun Kang Novel & History |
|---|---|
| Children | Gongsun Xiu Romance |
Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.
Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).