RFell out with Wu Zhou but reconciled at Hu Zhi's words; conveyed Guan Yu's intentions just as they wereWei 27 §15Shu 6 §5
NEven as a captive he reviled Cao Cao and awaited death; Guan Yu vouched for his loyaltyCh. 19 §62Ch. 20 §1Ch. 25 §36
| Occupation | RGeneral · General of the Front | Faction | Wei |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appears | RN | Biography in | Book of Wei |
| Born | R? N? Unverified | Native place | Yanmen Commandery Mayi County |
| Died | R222 N224 Unverified | Place of death | RJiangdu County NXuchang County |
| Cause of death | RIllness Unverified | ||
| Existence | Historical | Mentions | R65 |
Zhang Liao, courtesy name Wenyuan, was a native of Mayi County in Yanmen Commandery. He led troops successively under Ding Yuan, He Jin, Dong Zhuo and Lü Bu, and when Cao Cao crushed Lü Bu at Xiapi, he surrendered at the head of his men. Records, Wei 17 §2–3
He led the way for Cao Cao in the battle at Liucheng in which the Chanyu Tadun was beheaded, and in the 20th year of Jian'an (215), holding Hefei, he broke Sun Quan's army of 100,000 with 800 men he had recruited. Under Cao Pi he rose to General of the Front and Marquis of Jinyang; after setting out, though ill, to hold off Sun Quan, he died at Jiangdu and received the posthumous title Marquis Gang. Records, Wei 17 §6 · 10–17Records, Wei 1 §145 · 149
In his assessment, Chen Shou counted him among the five fine generals of Cao Cao's time, while noting that the records of the others were not as detailed as those of Zhang Liao and Xu Huang. In the Romance he first appeared in Chapter 11, at the battle of Puyang, as the first of Lü Bu's eight generals, and featured in 31 of its 120 chapters; his name appears in the titles of Chapter 53, "Sun Zhongmou Fights a Great Battle with Zhang Wenyuan," and Chapter 67, "Zhang Liao's Might Shakes Xiaoyao Ford." Records, Wei 17 §74Romance, Ch. 11 §47Romance, Ch. 53 §32Romance, Ch. 67 §48
He was originally a descendant of Nie Yi, but changed his surname to escape a feud. At the end of the Han, Ding Yuan, Inspector of Bing Province, summoned him as an Assistant Officer (congshi) because his martial strength surpassed that of other men, and He Jin sent him north of the Yellow River to recruit troops, and he raised more than a thousand men. On his return he found that He Jin had fallen, so he placed his troops under Dong Zhuo, and when Dong Zhuo fell he placed them under Lü Bu and became Chief Commandant of Cavalry. When Lü Bu was defeated by Li Jue, Zhang Liao followed him to Xu Province and concurrently served as Chancellor of Lu; he was twenty-eight at the time. Records, Wei 17 §2–3
When Cao Cao crushed Lü Bu at Xiapi, Zhang Liao surrendered at the head of his men and was made General of the Household (zhonglang jiang) and Marquis Within the Passes, and after repeated feats in battle he was promoted to Assistant General (pi jiangjun). In the 5th year of Jian'an (200), Cao Cao put Zhang Liao and Guan Yu in the vanguard at Baima, and they slew Yuan Shao's general Yan Liang. When Cao Cao, sensing that Guan Yu had no intention of staying long, had Zhang Liao sound him out as a friend, Zhang Liao asked, and Guan Yu replied that he would leave only after repaying Cao Cao with a deed of merit. Records, Wei 17 §3Records, Wei 1 §61Records, Shu 6 §4–5
He besieged Chang Xi at Donghai together with Xiahou Yuan, but after several months their provisions ran out. Zhang Liao, noting that Chang Xi kept fixing his eyes on him and that his arrows had grown sparse, judged that he was wavering and called out to him to talk. When Chang Xi came down and agreed to surrender, Zhang Liao went up Mount Sangong alone, entered his house, and bowed to his wife and children. Cao Cao rebuked him, saying, "This is not the way of a senior general," and Zhang Liao apologized, saying he had judged that, in awe of his illustrious lord's majesty and good faith, Chang Xi would not dare to harm him. Records, Wei 17 §3–5
He joined the campaign against Yuan Tan and Yuan Shang and served as acting General of the Firm Center (zhongjian jiangjun); after Ye fell he campaigned through Zhao State and Changshan, bringing about the surrender of Sun Qing of the Heishan and others, and campaigning along the seacoast he defeated the Liaodong bandit Liu Yi and others. When he returned to Ye, Cao Cao came out in person to greet him, had him ride in his own carriage, and made him General Who Sweeps Away Bandits (dangkou jiangjun). When Cao Cao attacked Yuan Shang at Liucheng and they suddenly ran into the barbarians, Zhang Liao urged battle in high spirits, and Cao Cao handed him the command banner he himself was holding. In the end they won a great victory and beheaded the Chanyu Tadun. Records, Wei 17 §5–6
Just as he was setting out to garrison Changshe, men plotting rebellion in the army raised a disturbance at night. Saying that the whole camp could not have rebelled, Zhang Liao ordered those not involved to stay seated where they were, and stood in the middle of the formation with a few dozen of his personal guards; once the disturbance died down, he seized the ringleader and put him to death. When Chen Lan and Mei Cheng rebelled and built fortifications on top of Mount Tianzhu, Zhang Liao advanced in command of Zhang He, Niu Gai and others. When the generals said their troops were few and the road was steep, he said, "When it is one against one, the brave will get ahead," and took the heads of Chen Lan and Mei Cheng; his fief was increased and he was granted the tally of authority (jiajie). Records, Wei 17 §7–9
Cao Cao had Zhang Liao, Yue Jin, Li Dian and others garrison Hefei with over 7,000 men, and on setting out to attack Zhang Lu he left with the Protector of the Army Xue Ti a written instruction marked "Open when the enemy arrives." In the 20th year of Jian'an (215), when Sun Quan besieged Hefei with an army of 100,000, they opened the instruction, which said that Zhang Liao and Li Dian were to go out and fight and Yue Jin was to guard the Protector of the Army. Zhang Liao said that they could hold the city only if they struck before relief came, while the enemy had not yet completed the encirclement, and broke their momentum. According to the biography of Li Dian, the three generals had never been on good terms, but Li Dian, asking how he could forget the public good for a private grudge, went out with him. Records, Wei 17 §10–11Records, Wei 1 §145 · 149Records, Wei 18 §7–8
That night Zhang Liao recruited 800 men willing to follow him and slaughtered oxen to feast them; at dawn, clad in armor and wielding a halberd (ji), he led the charge, killing dozens of men and beheading two generals. Shouting his own name, he reached the foot of Sun Quan's banner; Sun Quan, who had fled to the top of a high mound, could not move, but on seeing how few men Zhang Liao had, he surrounded him several layers deep. Zhang Liao broke through the encirclement, but at the cry of the men left behind, "General, are you abandoning us?", he plunged back in and rescued them. Sun Quan withdrew after more than ten days, and Zhang Liao pursued him and very nearly captured him, for which he was made General Who Conquers the East (zhengdong jiangjun). Records, Wei 17 §11–13
In the 21st year of Jian'an (216), Cao Cao came to Hefei, toured the places where Zhang Liao had fought, and sighed for a long time. When Guan Yu besieged Cao Ren at Fancheng, Zhang Liao was summoned to relieve him, but before he arrived Xu Huang had defeated Guan Yu. When Cao Pi became King of Wei, Zhang Liao was made General of the Front (qian jiangjun), and when Sun Quan turned against Wei again he returned to Hefei and was raised to Marquis of a Chief Village (duxiang hou). Cao Pi sent Zhang Liao's mother to his garrison. When Cao Pi ascended the imperial throne, Zhang Liao became Marquis of Jinyang, and his fief reached 2,600 households. Records, Wei 17 §13–15
In the 2nd year of Huangchu (221), when Zhang Liao came to court at the Luoyang palace, Cao Pi asked him in person how he had defeated Wu and sighed, "This man too is a Shao Hu of old," and he made all the recruited foot soldiers who had followed Zhang Liao in battle into Rapid as Tigers guards (huben). When Zhang Liao fell ill at Yongqiu, Cao Pi sent the Palace Attendant Liu Ye with the imperial physician to see him, and when he did not recover, Cao Pi brought him to the imperial traveling lodge, visited him in person, took his hand, and bestowed imperial clothing on him. Records, Wei 17 §15–16
Once his illness had eased a little, he returned to his garrison. When Sun Quan turned against Wei once more, Cao Pi had Zhang Liao board a ship and go with Cao Xiu to Hailing to face the Yangtze, and Sun Quan ordered his generals, "Though Zhang Liao is ill, he cannot be withstood. Be careful!" That year Zhang Liao, together with the other generals, defeated Sun Quan's general Lü Fan. The biography of the Sovereign of Wu dates the campaign of Cao Xiu, Zhang Liao and the others to the 9th month of the 1st year of Huangwu (222). Zhang Liao's illness became critical and he died at Jiangdu; Cao Pi wept for him and gave him the posthumous title Marquis Gang. His son Zhang Hu succeeded him. In the 6th year of Huangchu (225), Cao Pi issued an edict declaring that Zhang Liao and Li Dian's defeat of 100,000 enemies with 800 foot soldiers had no precedent since ancient times, and granted one son of each the rank of Marquis Within the Passes. Records, Wei 17 §16–18Records, Wu 2 §41–42
In his assessment, Chen Shou said that when Cao Cao achieved his military successes, five of the fine generals of the time stood foremost. He wrote that the deeds of Yu Jin, Zhang He and Yue Jin did not live up to their reputations, and that perhaps there were omissions in the records, so that theirs were not as detailed and complete as those of Zhang Liao and Xu Huang. Records, Wei 17 §74
In Chapter 11 of the Romance, at the battle of Puyang, he first appeared as the first of the eight stalwart generals lined up on either side of Lü Bu, introduced as "a man of Mayi in Yanmen, surnamed Zhang, named Liao, styled Wenyuan," and he intercepted and fought Xiahou Dun on Cao Cao's side. In Chapter 18, attacking the west gate of Xiaopei, he heard Guan Yu on the city wall ask him, "Why have you given yourself to a rebel?", and he lowered his head and withdrew his troops. Romance, Ch. 11 §47 · 49Romance, Ch. 18 §26–27
In Chapter 19, when Lü Bu begged for his life, Zhang Liao, as he was being dragged in, shouted, "Lü Bu, you common fellow! If you die, you die. What is there to fear?" When Cao Cao said his face looked familiar, Zhang Liao scolded him, saying it was a pity the fire inside Puyang had not been big enough to burn a traitor to the state like him to death, and stretched out his neck to await execution. In Chapter 20, when Liu Bei caught hold of Cao Cao's arm and Guan Yu knelt and vouched for him with his own life, Cao Cao threw down his sword and untied his bonds with his own hands, and Zhang Liao, moved by this, surrendered. Romance, Ch. 19 §59 · 61–62Romance, Ch. 20 §1–2
In Chapter 25 he went alone to Guan Yu, who was cut off on an earthen hill, and argued that dying in battle now would incur three offenses while surrendering for the time being would bring three advantages; he then conveyed to Cao Cao the three conditions Guan Yu set. In Chapter 26, chasing Wen Chou together with Xu Huang, he had the tassel of his helmet shot away by an arrow, and when his horse was struck in the cheek by an arrow, he fell to the ground. Romance, Ch. 25 §6–13Romance, Ch. 26 §10–11
At White Wolf Mountain in Chapter 33 he received the command banner from Cao Cao and descended the mountain by four routes with Xu Chu, Yu Jin and Xu Huang, cutting Tadun down from his horse. At Chibi in Chapter 49 he moved Cao Cao onto a small boat, and amid the flames he shot Huang Gai, who was pursuing them, into the water with an arrow. Romance, Ch. 33 §35–37Romance, Ch. 49 §49–50
In Chapter 53 at Hefei he challenged Sun Quan to a decisive battle and fought Taishi Ci for seventy or eighty bouts. That night, though victorious, he ordered that no one take off his armor, and when fire broke out in the rear camp and cries of rebellion arose, he did not stir, saying, "How could a whole city rebel?" He then opened the city gates to make it look as though an uprising had broken out inside, lured Taishi Ci in, and rained arrows on him; Taishi Ci died of the wounds he received there at the age of forty-one. Romance, Ch. 53 §32–33 · 39–43
In Chapter 67 he opened the box from Cao Cao that Xue Ti had brought, and when Li Dian, with whom he had never been on good terms, gave no answer, he moved Li Dian by declaring that he would go out and fight even alone. He had Li Dian lie in ambush north of Xiaoyao Ford to cut the Xiaoshi Bridge and pursued Sun Quan with over 2,000 horsemen, and Sun Quan backed his horse up, then galloped forward and leapt across the broken bridge. The Romance wrote that after this battle the mere mention of Zhang Liao's name kept the little children of Jiangnan from crying at night. In Chapter 68 Sun Quan said, "If Mengde has Zhang Liao, I have Gan Xingba." Romance, Ch. 67 §44–46 · 48–50 · 53Romance, Ch. 68 §10
In Chapter 86, when Cao Pi set out to attack Wu in the 8th month, in the autumn of the 5th year of Huangchu (224), Zhang Liao went ahead as a senior general. As Cao Pi fled in defeat, Zhang Liao rode out to meet Ding Feng, who had attacked from the riverbank, was hit in the waist by an arrow, and was rescued by Xu Huang. After he returned to Xuchang, his arrow wound burst open and he died, and Cao Pi gave him a lavish burial. Romance, Ch. 86 §28 · 45–46
How he surrendered: In Chapters 19–20 of the Romance, the captured Zhang Liao reviled Cao Cao as a traitor to the state and nearly died, and Liu Bei and Guan Yu saved his life. The biography of Zhang Liao in the Records says only that he surrendered at the head of his men and was made General of the Household and Marquis Within the Passes. Romance, Ch. 19 §62Romance, Ch. 20 §1Records, Wei 17 §3
Persuading Guan Yu: In Chapter 25 of the Romance, Zhang Liao urged Guan Yu on the earthen hill to surrender by setting out three offenses and three advantages, and conveyed Guan Yu's three conditions. In the Records, Guan Yu was captured and made Lieutenant General, and Zhang Liao merely asked Guan Yu, at Cao Cao's request, whether he intended to stay. Romance, Ch. 25 §8–12Records, Shu 6 §4–5
Who slew Tadun: In Chapter 33 of the Romance, Zhang Liao personally cut Tadun down from his horse. The biography of Zhang Liao in the Records says that they attacked after Cao Cao handed him the command banner and beheaded Tadun, and the Annals of Emperor Wu likewise say that, with Zhang Liao in the vanguard, Tadun and the kings of note below him were beheaded; neither says who did the beheading. Romance, Ch. 33 §37Records, Wei 17 §6Records, Wei 1 §100
Shooting Huang Gai: The scene in Chapter 49 of the Romance in which Zhang Liao shot Huang Gai into the water amid the flames at Chibi is not in the biography of Zhang Liao in the Records. Romance, Ch. 49 §50Records, Wei 17 §1–18
Hefei after Chibi and Taishi Ci: In Chapter 53 of the Romance, Zhang Liao defeated Sun Quan at Hefei, and Taishi Ci died of arrow wounds from that battle. In the Records, Sun Quan at this time besieged Hefei for more than a month and withdrew on hearing that Zhang Xi's relief force was coming, and Zhang Liao's name does not appear. Taishi Ci died in the 11th year of Jian'an (206) at the age of forty-one. Romance, Ch. 53 §33 · 41–43Records, Wei 1 §105Records, Wu 2 §14Records, Wu 4 §33
The sequence at Xiaoyao Ford: In Chapter 67 of the Romance, Zhang Liao struck the advancing Sun Quan from ambush, and Li Dian cut the Xiaoshi Bridge in advance. In the Records, he broke into Sun Quan's lines at dawn with 800 men before the encirclement was complete, and Sun Quan leapt the bridge when he was attacked north of the ford while withdrawing his army after a siege of more than ten days. The biography of Ling Tong says only that it was the enemy who broke the bridge. Romance, Ch. 67 §46 · 48–50Records, Wei 17 §11–13Records, Wu 2 §22Records, Wu 10 §74
The three generals at Hefei: In Chapter 67 of the Romance, only Li Dian was on bad terms with Zhang Liao and at first gave no answer, while Yue Jin argued for holding firm. The biography of Li Dian in the Records says that Yue Jin, Li Dian and Zhang Liao had never been on good terms with one another, and that when Zhang Liao worried that the others would not follow him, Li Dian stepped forward first and invoked the public good. Romance, Ch. 67 §45–46Records, Wei 18 §7–8
His death: In Chapter 86 of the Romance, he was hit in the waist by Ding Feng's arrow during Cao Pi's campaign against Wu in the 5th year of Huangchu (224), and died at Xuchang when the wound burst open. In the Records, he fell ill at Yongqiu and was visited by Cao Pi, and in the year in which, though ill, he went out to Hailing with Cao Xiu and defeated Lü Fan, he died of illness at Jiangdu. Romance, Ch. 86 §28 · 45–46Records, Wei 17 §16–17
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.
RFell out with Wu Zhou but reconciled at Hu Zhi's words; conveyed Guan Yu's intentions just as they wereWei 27 §15Shu 6 §5
NEven as a captive he reviled Cao Cao and awaited death; Guan Yu vouched for his loyaltyCh. 19 §62Ch. 20 §1Ch. 25 §36
RPersuaded Chang Xi to surrender and won over Sun Qing of the Heishan and othersWei 17 §4Wei 17 §6
NPersuaded Guan Yu with three offenses and three advantages and negotiated his conditionsCh. 25 §9Ch. 25 §13
RBroke 100,000 with 800 foot soldiers at Hefei; the edict called it unprecedented since ancient timesWei 17 §11Wei 17 §17Wei 17 §9
NDrove Sun Quan hard at Xiaoyao Ford until even Jiangnan's children stopped crying; turned the enemy's inside-collaboration ploy against themCh. 67 §48Ch. 53 §39Ch. 33 §36
RMartial strength surpassing other men; at Hefei led the charge, killing dozens and beheading two generalsWei 17 §2Wei 17 §11
NFought Taishi Ci to a draw over seventy or eighty bouts; slew Tadun; Guan Yu acknowledged his martial skillCh. 53 §33Ch. 33 §37Ch. 18 §27
RSaw through Chang Xi's hesitation, judged the true nature of the night disturbance, and read the intent of the written instructionWei 17 §3Wei 17 §7Wei 17 §11
NStayed on guard even on the night of victory and saw through the revolt; Zhuge Jin called him resourcefulCh. 53 §39Ch. 53 §37
RNo direct record — estimated from his concurrent post as Chancellor of LuWei 17 §3
NNo direct record — estimated from his conduct as commander at HefeiCh. 50 §35
RGathered 800 men for a do-or-die charge; Rapid as Tigers guards inquiring after his illness lined the roads; Sun Quan feared himWei 17 §11Wei 17 §16Wei 17 §17
NLi Dian followed once private grudges were set aside; Guan Yu let him go out of old friendshipCh. 67 §46Ch. 50 §30
RKept calm through the mutiny scare and restored order; resolved on the decisive battle at HefeiWei 17 §7Wei 17 §11
NDid not relax his guard even on the day of victory; resolved to strike first and break the enemy's momentumCh. 53 §39Ch. 67 §45
RNo direct record — estimated as a warrior who began as a commandery clerkWei 17 §2
NNo direct record — estimated as a warrior under Lü BuCh. 11 §47
RNo direct record — at most the record of his praising Wu Zhou and later falling out with himWei 27 §16
NNo direct record — at most his sounding out of Guan Yu's true feelingsCh. 25 §34
NSkilled +10 Shot Ju Hu and Huang Gai down with arrowsCh. 32 §35Ch. 49 §50
Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)
3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.
AppearsNot present Chapter list →
| Children | Zhang Hu(張虎) Novel & History |
|---|
Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.
Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).