Sima Zhao 司馬昭

RecordsRomance Wei Zishang사마소자상子上司马昭

Profile
OccupationRNRuler · King of JinFactionWei
AppearsRNBiography in
BornR? UnverifiedNative placeHenei Commandery Wen County Unverified
DiedR265 UnverifiedPlace of death
Cause of deathNIllness Unverified
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR78

Profile

Sima Zhao was the General-in-Chief who succeeded his elder brother Sima Shi in assisting the government of Wei. Chen Shou's main text in the Records does not give his courtesy name or origin and usually calls him 'Sima Wenwang' or 'Wenwang', while the Romance introduces him as the second son of Sima Yi, with the courtesy name Zishang. Records, Wei 4 §55Records, Wei 28 §96Romance, Ch. 94 §38

When his elder brother died at Xuchang in the 2nd year of Zhengyuan (255), he became General-in-Chief and Intendant of the Affairs of the Imperial Secretariat, and in the 3rd year of Ganlu (258) he took Shouchun and beheaded Zhuge Dan. In the 4th year of Jingyuan (263) he directed the campaign against Shu and pacified it, the following year he was raised to King of Jin, and in the 8th month of the 2nd year of Xianxi (265) he died as Chancellor of State and King of Jin. Records, Wei 4 §55 · 88 · 127 · 129 · 148Records, Wei 28 §67

The Records has neither a biography of Sima Zhao nor an assessment of him by Chen Shou. His deeds are scattered through the annals in Records of Wei 4 and the biographies of Zhuge Dan, Zhong Hui, Deng Ai, Wang Ji and others. In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 94 and appears in 19 of its 120 chapters; his name is in the title of Chapter 111, 'Zhuge Dan Attacks Sima Zhao in the Name of Righteousness', and in Chapter 119 he becomes King of Jin and then dies. Records, Wei 4 §55Records, Wei 28 §37 · 102 · 79Records, Wei 27 §67Romance, Ch. 94 §38Romance, Ch. 111 §28–30Romance, Ch. 119 §31 · 34

In the Records

In Chen Shou's main text, Sima Zhao's deeds first appear in the 2nd year of Zhengyuan (255). In the 1st month of that year, when Guanqiu Jian and Wen Qin rebelled, the General-in-Chief Sima Jingwang (Sima Shi) set out on a campaign to the east, and Sima Wenwang, General of the Guards, followed the main army as its rear force. The brothers' sister was the wife of Xun Yi (荀霬), and the two were also close friends of Chen Tai. Records, Wei 4 §54Records, Wei 28 §96Records, Wei 10 §49Records, Wei 22 §55

When Sima Jingwang died at Xuchang, Sima Wenwang took overall command of the Six Armies. The court issued an edict ordering the General of the Guards to stay for the time being at Xuchang and the Master of Writing Fu Gu to lead the armies back, but Zhong Hui plotted with Fu Gu to have Fu Gu submit a memorial, and they returned at once together with the General of the Guards and camped south of the Luo River. In the 2nd month the court then made Sima Wenwang General-in-Chief and Intendant of the Affairs of the Imperial Secretariat to assist the government. Records, Wei 28 §96–97Records, Wei 21 §96Records, Wei 4 §55

In the 8th month of that year, when Jiang Wei of Shu defeated Wang Jing, Inspector of Yong Province, at Taoxi and surrounded the city of Didao, Sima Wenwang said, 'Zhuge Liang too always cherished this ambition, but in the end he could not achieve it,' and judged that the best plan was for Chen Tai, General Who Conquers the West, to go to the rescue quickly. When Chen Tai asked for no more troops and sent few reports, Sima Wenwang praised him to Xun Yi (荀顗), saying that this was just how a commander-in-chief and senior general ought to be. In the 1st year of Ganlu (256) he was granted the ceremonial robes and crown, and the title of Grand Commander and the yellow battle-axe were added. Records, Wei 4 §57 · 61 · 77Records, Wei 22 §52–53

In the 5th month of the 2nd year of Ganlu (257), when the court summoned Zhuge Dan, General-in-Chief Who Conquers the East, to be Minister of Works, Zhong Hui, then in mourning, hurried to warn that Zhuge Dan would not obey, but Wenwang did not change it, since the order had already been carried out. Zhuge Dan rebelled, killed Yue Chen, Inspector of Yang Province, and asked Wu for help. Wenwang decided to lead the punitive campaign in person, and in the 6th month, when the imperial carriage reached Xiang County, he led the inner and outer armies, 260,000 men, and camped at Qiutou. Records, Wei 4 §56Records, Wei 28 §35–37 · 98Records, Wei 13 §24

He had Wang Ji, Chen Qian and others encircle the city on all sides in a double ring, and put Shi Bao and Zhou Tai in charge of mobile forces to guard against Wu's relief army. To those who urged a swift assault he replied that since the city was strong and its defenders many, he would pin them down with a sure plan and subdue them without stirring. Following Zhong Hui's plan, he used a stratagem of sowing discord to induce Quan Yi and others to open the city gate and come out, and when Wen Yang and Wen Hu, whose father Wen Qin had been killed by Zhuge Dan, came over to him, he rejected the army officers who wanted them killed, pardoned them and had them ride around the city calling out. Records, Wei 28 §37–38 · 99–100 · 40–41 · 43

In the 2nd month of the 3rd year of Ganlu (258) he went to the siege lines in person, advanced from all sides and took Shouchun, and Zhuge Dan was beheaded by the troops of Hu Fen, Major under the General-in-Chief. An edict renamed Qiutou as Wuqiu to display his achievement, and in the 5th month he was ordered to be Chancellor of State and Duke of Jin with the Nine Bestowments, but Wenwang declined nine times and the matter was dropped. After Shouchun fell he wanted to send light troops deep into Wu to shake it, but gave up the idea when Wang Ji remonstrated. Records, Wei 4 §88–90Records, Wei 28 §41–42Records, Wei 27 §68–70

In the 5th month of the 5th year of Ganlu (260), Cao Mao, Duke of Gaogui Village, summoned Wang Chen, Wang Ye and Wang Jing to put a plan into action, but Wang Chen and Wang Ye rushed to inform the General-in-Chief. Cao Mao went out through the Yunlong Gate, drew his sword himself and entered among the ranks of troops, where he was struck down and killed by the vanguard. According to the Empress Dowager's decree, she had said several times that he ought to be deposed, but the General-in-Chief had restrained her, saying he was still young and would mend his ways. Records, Wei 4 §98–101

Wenwang submitted a memorial saying that he had ordered the soldiers not to harm the Duke, but that Cheng Ji, Retainer of the Crown Prince, had rashly rushed into the ranks and harmed him, and so military law had been applied; and he handed Cheng Ji's family over to the Commandant of Justice. When the Empress Dowager decreed that Cao Mao be buried with the rites of a commoner, he joined Sima Fu and others in asking for the rites of a king. He sent Sima Yan to welcome the Duke of Changdao Village, Cao Huan (then named Cao Huang), and in the 6th month, when Cao Huan took the throne, he was granted the posts of Chancellor of State and Duke of Jin with the Nine Bestowments, ten million cash and ten thousand bolts of silk, but firmly declined, and he also declined the orders of the 2nd year of Jingyuan (261) and of the 2nd month of its 4th year (263). Records, Wei 4 §102–105 · 107–110 · 113–114 · 121 · 123

As Jiang Wei repeatedly troubled the border, Wenwang reckoned that Shu was a small state with an exhausted people and meant to raise a great army, and he went over the terrain and the strategic situation with Zhong Hui, who was of the same mind. In winter of the 3rd year of Jingyuan (262) he made Zhong Hui General Who Guards the West and Commander of All Military Affairs in Guanzhong, and had the provinces build ships as if he meant to attack Wu. When Shao Ti, Clerk of the Western Bureau, advised against it on the grounds that Zhong Hui had no family ties to hold him, Wenwang replied that everyone said Shu could not be attacked and only Zhong Hui shared his view, and that if Zhong Hui harboured other intentions after destroying Shu, he would only bring destruction on his own clan. In autumn of the 4th year of Jingyuan (263) he directed the whole campaign against Shu, and that year Liu Shan surrendered to Deng Ai. Records, Wei 28 §102 · 131–133 · 67Records, Wei 4 §127

In the 10th month of that year an order came again raising his position and rank, and this time there is no record of his declining. When Deng Ai made appointments to office, claiming to act on the emperor's authority, Wenwang sent the Army Supervisor Wei Guan to tell him to wait for approval. When Zhong Hui reported that Deng Ai was rebelling, Wenwang had Deng Ai brought back in a cage cart, ordered Zhong Hui to advance to Chengdu, and had Deng Ai's army admonished with an order in his own hand. He then informed Zhong Hui that he was sending Jia Chong into the Xie Valley and would himself lead 100,000 men to camp at Chang'an. In the 1st month of the 1st year of Xianxi (264) Zhong Hui raised troops, declaring that he would depose Wenwang, and was killed by his own men; by the time Wenwang's army reached Chang'an, it was already all over. Records, Wei 4 §126 · 128Records, Wei 28 §79 · 121 · 123–124 · 128 · 134–135

In the 3rd month of the 1st year of Xianxi he was raised to King of Jin and received twenty commanderies as his fief; in the 5th month he proposed restoring the five ranks of nobility, and later he made Sima Yan Heir of Jin. He sent Xu Shao and Sun Yu, men of Wu captured at Shouchun, to admonish Sun Hao, and enfeoffed Qiao Zhou of Shu as Marquis of Yangcheng Precinct. In the 5th month of the 2nd year of Xianxi (265) he was permitted twelve strings of jade beads on his crown and the banners of the Son of Heaven, and on the day xinmao of the 8th month he died as Chancellor of State and King of Jin. Sima Yan, who succeeded him, received the abdication of Wei in the 12th month of that year. Records, Wei 4 §128–129 · 142–144 · 145–148 · 150Records, Wu 3 §51Records, Shu 12 §75

The appraisals that remain in Chen Shou's main text are all the words of others. An edict of the 10th month of the 1st year of Xianxi said that, thanks to the loyalty and martial valour of the chief minister, Shu had been pacified in a single campaign, and an edict of the 5th month of the 2nd year of Xianxi said that the martial achievements of the Chancellor of State and King of Jin had shaken even the distant frontiers. The assessment in the Annals of the Three Young Emperors records that the King of Chenliu merely faced south in reverent humility while the chief minister ran the government. Records, Wei 4 §139–140 · 146 · 153

In the Romance

In Chapter 94 of the Romance he is introduced as the second son of Sima Yi, with the courtesy name Zishang, and is said to have cherished great ambitions and mastered the military classics together with his elder brother Sima Shi. In Chapter 95 he scouts Jieting and reports that the Shu army can be beaten because it is all on top of the hill, and at Xicheng he asks whether Zhuge Liang is not bluffing because he has no troops, but Sima Yi pulls the army back. In Chapter 103, amid the flames of the Shangfang Valley, Sima Yi weeps with his arms around his two sons. Romance, Ch. 94 §38Romance, Ch. 95 §19–20 · 44–45Romance, Ch. 103 §28–30

In Chapter 107 he escorts Sima Yi, camps by the Luo River and guards the floating bridge. In Chapter 108 he proposes taking advantage of Sun Quan's death, and his elder brother Sima Shi makes him Grand Commander in charge of three columns of troops, but he is defeated at Dongxing and returns north. In Chapter 109, trapped by Jiang Wei on Mount Tielong and out of water, he follows the advice of his Registrar Wang Tao, bows and prays to the spring, and obtains water from it. Romance, Ch. 107 §4Romance, Ch. 108 §8–10 · 17–18Romance, Ch. 109 §11–14

In Chapter 110 Sima Shi hands him the seal and ribbon as he dies, and following Zhong Hui's advice, he sets aside the edict ordering him to stay at Xuchang, returns south of the Luo River and becomes General-in-Chief and Intendant of the Affairs of the Imperial Secretariat. In Chapter 111, angered by what Zhuge Dan said when Jia Chong sounded him out, he summons Zhuge Dan to be Minister of Works, and when Zhuge Dan rises in revolt, he sets out with an army of 260,000, taking the Empress Dowager and Cao Mao with him. In Chapter 112 he calls Zhong Hui 'my Zifang', wants to behead Wen Yang but follows Zhong Hui's advice, and after entering Shouchun he exterminates Zhuge Dan's three sets of kin and kills several hundred of his men who refuse to the last to surrender, then buries them with a sigh. Romance, Ch. 110 §27–30Romance, Ch. 111 §27–28 · 33–35Romance, Ch. 112 §5 · 13 · 18–19

In Chapter 114, enraged at hearing that Cao Mao has written the 'Poem of the Hidden Dragon', he goes up into the hall wearing his sword and demands to know whether he should not be made Duke of Jin. When Cao Mao sets out toward the Southern Gate Tower, Jia Chong, declaring it 'the order of Lord Sima', has Cheng Ji stab Cao Mao, and Sima Zhao, after pretending to weep in shock, condemns Cheng Ji for high treason, has his tongue cut out and exterminates his three sets of kin. He rejects the urging to take the throne, citing the example of King Wen of Zhou, sets up Cao Huan and becomes Chancellor of State and Duke of Jin. Romance, Ch. 114 §6–7 · 12–17 · 22–23

In Chapter 115 he beheads Deng Dun, who opposes the campaign against Shu, and sends Zhong Hui and Deng Ai to attack Shu; to Shao Ti, who warns him not to give Zhong Hui great power, he laughs that he already knows. In Chapter 118, suspecting Deng Ai of rebellion from his letter, he has Zhong Hui arrest him, and saying that it is really because of Zhong Hui, he goes to Chang'an together with Cao Huan. Romance, Ch. 115 §35–36 · 41Romance, Ch. 118 §25–27 · 33–35

In Chapter 119 he enfeoffs Liu Shan, who has come to Luoyang, as Duke of Anle, and at a banquet he laughs at Liu Shan's reply, 'I am happy here and do not miss Shu,' and ceases to suspect him. After becoming King of Jin he intends to make Sima You his heir, but on hearing remonstrance he names his eldest son Sima Yan instead. Secretly delighted by a memorial urging him to adopt the rites of the Son of Heaven, he suffers a stroke and loses the power of speech, and the next day he points to Sima Yan with his hand and dies. Romance, Ch. 119 §25 · 27–29 · 31–35

Where the Romance differs

At Sima Yi's side: In Chapters 95 and 103 of the Romance, Sima Zhao accompanies his father on the scouting of Jieting and the battle at the Shangfang Valley. In Chen Shou's main text his deeds begin with his taking the field as General of the Guards in the campaign against Guanqiu Jian in the 2nd year of Zhengyuan (255). Romance, Ch. 95 §19–20Romance, Ch. 103 §28–30Records, Wei 28 §96Records, Wei 4 §55

The battle of Dongxing: In Chapter 108 of the Romance, Sima Zhao is put in charge of three columns of troops as Grand Commander and is defeated at Dongxing. In the annals in Records of Wei 4 in the Records, it is Wang Chang, Hu Zun, Guanqiu Jian and others who attack Wu and are defeated by Zhuge Ke at Dongguan, and Sima Zhao does not appear. Romance, Ch. 108 §8 · 18Records, Wei 4 §34Records, Wu 10 §99

Mount Tielong: In Chapter 109 of the Romance, Sima Zhao is trapped on Mount Tielong and survives by praying to a spring, while Guo Huai dies at the hands of Jiang Wei. Sima Zhao does not appear in that year's fighting in the Biography of Jiang Wei in the Records, and it says only that Guo Huai died in the 2nd year of Zhengyuan (255). Romance, Ch. 109 §11–14 · 23Records, Shu 14 §36Records, Wei 26 §78

How he became General-in-Chief: In Chapter 110 of the Romance, Sima Shi, on the point of death, summons Sima Zhao from Luoyang and hands him the seal and ribbon. In the Records, Sima Zhao had already accompanied the campaign as General of the Guards and took overall command of the Six Armies when his brother died, and his return in defiance of the edict was arranged by Zhong Hui and Fu Gu. Romance, Ch. 110 §27 · 29Records, Wei 28 §96–97

Summoning Zhuge Dan: In Chapter 111 of the Romance, Jia Chong sounds out Zhuge Dan and reports back, and Sima Zhao summons him in anger. In the Records, the court summoned him to gauge his intentions, and even though Zhong Hui advised against it, Sima Zhao did not change the order because it had already been carried out. Jia Chong does not appear in this passage. Romance, Ch. 111 §24–28Records, Wei 28 §34–35 · 98

Zifang: In Chapter 112 of the Romance, Sima Zhao calls Zhong Hui 'my Zifang'. In the Biography of Zhong Hui in the Records, it was because Zhong Hui's plans contributed most to the fall of Shouchun that people at the time called him Zifang. Romance, Ch. 112 §5Records, Wei 28 §100

The pardon of Wen Yang: In Chapter 112 of the Romance, Sima Zhao wants to behead Wen Yang out of resentment but follows Zhong Hui's advice. In the Records, when the army officers urged that he be killed, Sima Zhao pardoned him by his own order. Romance, Ch. 112 §13Records, Wei 28 §40–41

The death of Cao Mao: In Chapter 114 of the Romance, Jia Chong, declaring it 'the order of Lord Sima', has Cheng Ji stab Cao Mao. Sima Zhao's memorial recorded in the annals of the Records says that he had ordered the soldiers not to harm the Duke but that Cheng Ji rashly harmed him, and Jia Chong does not appear. Romance, Ch. 114 §13–17Records, Wei 4 §98–110

Chancellor of State and Duke of Jin: In Chapter 114 of the Romance, as soon as Cao Huan is set up, Sima Zhao becomes Chancellor of State and Duke of Jin and receives 100,000 cash and 10,000 bolts of silk. In the Records he repeatedly declined the orders issued from the 3rd year of Ganlu (258) onward, and the grant of the 1st year of Jingyuan (260) was ten million cash and ten thousand bolts of silk. The order with no record of his declining is that of the 10th month of the 4th year of Jingyuan (263). Romance, Ch. 114 §23Records, Wei 4 §90 · 114 · 126

The debate on attacking Shu: In Chapter 115 of the Romance, Sima Zhao beheads Deng Dun, who opposes the campaign. In the Biography of Zhong Hui in the Records, he says only that everyone says Shu cannot be attacked, and there is no beheading of an opponent. Romance, Ch. 115 §35–36Records, Wei 28 §131–132

Liu Shan and Sima You: The exchange in Chapter 119 of the Romance, 'I am happy here and do not miss Shu', and Sima Zhao's intention to make Sima You his heir do not appear in Chen Shou's main text. The Biography of the Later Sovereign says only that Liu Shan was enfeoffed as Duke of Anle County, and the annals only that Sima Yan was made heir. Romance, Ch. 119 §27–28 · 32–33Records, Shu 3 §48–52Records, Wei 4 §144

His death: In Chapter 119 of the Romance, he rejoices at hearing of a giant at Xiangwu County as an auspicious omen and then dies of a stroke. The Records says only that the Chancellor of State and King of Jin died on the day xinmao of the 8th month, and the giant of Xiangwu County appears as something reported in the month of his death. Romance, Ch. 119 §33–35Records, Wei 4 §148

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA8070−10
  • STR3233+1
  • INT8678−8
  • POL5050±0
  • CHA5245−7
  • VIR4012−28
  • ADP8480−4
  • SCH3835−3
  • DIP4845−3
  • DIS8074−6
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

VirtueR40N12 −28

RDeclined the Nine Bestowments nine times and claimed to treat people with good faith, but the Duke of Gaogui Village died among his troopsWei 4 §90Wei 4 §107Wei 28 §134

NAfter Cao Mao's murder feigned shock, cut out Cheng Ji's tongue and exterminated his three sets of kin, as he also did Zhuge Dan'sCh. 114 §14Ch. 114 §17Ch. 112 §18

8 similar abilities — show evidence
  • StrengthR32UnverifiedN33Unverified +1

    RNo direct record — estimated from a career of command alone as General-in-ChiefWei 28 §37

    NNo direct record — estimated from his fleeing when surroundedCh. 109 §11

  • IntelligenceR86N78 −8

    RPointed out Jiang Wei's limits and foresaw the fall of Shu and Zhong Hui's failure, all of which came trueWei 22 §53Wei 28 §131Wei 28 §135

    NSaw through Zhu Yi's pincer attack and cut his route, foresaw Zhong Hui's rebellion, and was called a crafty hero by Jiang WeiCh. 112 §7Ch. 118 §34Ch. 114 §30

  • PoliticsR50UnverifiedN50Unverified ±0

    RNo direct record — estimated from his assisting the government as General-in-Chief and Intendant of the Affairs of the Imperial SecretariatWei 4 §55Wei 21 §96

    NNo direct record — estimated from all affairs great and small, inside and outside the court, passing to himCh. 110 §30

  • CharismaR52N45 −7

    RQuan Hui and Quan Yi crossed the river with their retainers and came over to him of their own accordWei 28 §99

    NGave high posts to the defectors Jiang Ban and Jiao Yi, but was told that everyone knew of his intent to usurpCh. 112 §11Ch. 114 §30

  • AdaptabilityR84N80 −4

    RReturned straight to Luoyang when his brother died to take over power, and camped at Chang'an with a great army ahead of Zhong HuiWei 21 §96Wei 28 §97Wei 28 §123

    NHesitated but followed advice to return to Luoyang and seized supreme power; declined abdication and set his hopes on his sonCh. 110 §29Ch. 114 §22

  • ScholarshipR38UnverifiedN35Unverified −3

    RNo direct record — estimated since there is no record of learning apart from his memorialsWei 4 §107

    NNo direct record — estimated since there is no record apart from his citing ancient precedentsCh. 114 §22

  • DiplomacyR48N45 −3

    RWrote to Wang Ji commending his achievement, and sought to summon and welcome the sons and brothers of Tang Zi and others of WuWei 27 §68

    NOverbore Cao Mao with intimidation and rebuked the Later Sovereign after his surrenderCh. 111 §34Ch. 119 §25

  • DiscernmentR80N74 −6

    RRecognized Chen Tai's qualities as a general, praised Wang Ji, and used Zhong Hui for the Shu campaign knowing what he wasWei 22 §53Wei 27 §68Wei 28 §132

    NEmployed Deng Ai and Zhong Hui on Xun Yi's recommendation and accepted Pei Xiu's counsel and Shan Tao's remonstranceCh. 115 §33Ch. 112 §22Ch. 119 §33

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (19)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Allegiance history

  1. Wei · Records · Records vol. 4 「命大將軍司馬文王加號大都督」

Family

ParentsSima Yi Romance
SiblingsSima Shi Romance
ChildrenSima Yan Novel & History, Sima You Novel & History

Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.

Related events (12)

Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).