Battle

Battle of Dongxing 東興之戰

About this event

The Battle of Dongxing was the battle in the 12th month of the 1st year of Jianxing of Wu (252) in which Wei's Zhuge Dan, Hu Zun and others surrounded the great embankment and two forts at Dongxing with 70,000 infantry and cavalry and were heavily defeated by Zhuge Ke's army, which came to the rescue. Taking advantage of Sun Quan's death, Wei set out along three routes, sending Wang Chang against Nan Commandery and Guanqiu Jian against Wuchang. In the snow, Ding Feng, Liu Zan, Lü Ju and Tang Zi took off their armor and climbed the embankment with short weapons to strike the Wei troops, who were holding a drinking party, and when the pontoon bridge broke, tens of thousands of Wei soldiers died. This victory led Zhuge Ke to underestimate the enemy, and the following year he set out to attack Xincheng. Records, Wu 3 §4–5Records, Wu 19 §28–31Records, Wu 10 §99–101

Chen Shou recorded this battle in detail in the Biography of Zhuge Ke in Records of Wu 19, and also included it in the Biographies of the Three Successor Rulers in Records of Wu 3, the Biography of Ding Feng in Records of Wu 10, and the Annals of the Three Young Emperors in Records of Wei 4. The Wei records call this place Dongguan. The Romance depicts this battle in the first part of Chapter 108, "Ding Feng Wields Short Weapons in the Snow; Sun Jun Carries Out a Secret Plot at the Banquet." Records, Wu 19 §28–30Records, Wu 3 §4–6Records, Wu 10 §99–101Records, Wei 4 §34Romance, Ch. 108 §7–17

Course of events in the Records

In the 2nd year of Huanglong (230) Sun Quan built an embankment at Dongxing to dam the waters of Chao Lake, but after his defeat in the campaign against Huainan he left it abandoned. In the 10th month of the 1st year of Jianxing (252), after Sun Quan had died and Sun Liang had taken the throne, the Grand Tutor Zhuge Ke gathered his forces at Dongxing, built a great embankment again and built two forts leaning against the hills on either side; he had Quan Duan guard the western fort and Liu Lüe the eastern fort, each with a thousand men, and then returned. Records, Wu 19 §28Records, Wu 3 §4

Wei regarded the entry of Wu troops into its territory as an insult. According to the Annals of the Three Young Emperors, in the 11th month of the 4th year of Jiaping (252) an edict ordered the Senior General Who Conquers the South Wang Chang, the General Who Conquers the East Hu Zun, the General Who Guards the South Guanqiu Jian and others to attack Wu. In the 12th month Zhuge Dan, Hu Zun and others surrounded Dongxing with 70,000 infantry and cavalry, while Wang Chang headed for Nan Commandery and Guanqiu Jian for Wuchang. Hu Zun and the others laid a pontoon bridge, deployed on the embankment and attacked the two forts, but the forts were high and steep and could not be taken quickly. Records, Wei 4 §34Records, Wu 3 §4Records, Wu 19 §28–29

Zhuge Ke raised 40,000 troops and hurried day and night to the rescue. The commanders said that when the enemy heard the Grand Tutor himself had come they would flee, but Ding Feng said that since Wei had mobilized all the troops of Xu and Luo, it would not go back empty-handed. Ding Feng had the slow-moving armies give way, led his own 3,000 men, raised sail with the north wind and in two days seized Xutang. Records, Wu 19 §29Records, Wu 10 §99–100

The weather was cold and snowy, and the Wei commanders had gathered to drink. Ding Feng had his soldiers take off their armor, keep only their helmets and carry short weapons, and Liu Zan, Lü Ju, Tang Zi and others likewise, equipped with only helmets, swords and shields, climbed the embankment with bare bodies. Seeing how few they were, the Wei troops laughed at them and made no preparations. The Wu troops who reached the top of the embankment beat their drums, shouted and cut about them wildly, breaking the Wei forward camp, and when Lü Ju and the others arrived, the Wei army collapsed. Records, Wu 10 §100–101Records, Wu 19 §29–30

The fleeing Wei troops rushed to cross the pontoon bridge, and when the bridge broke they threw themselves into the water and trampled one another. Huan Jia, Administrator of Le'an, and others were killed, and the dead numbered tens of thousands; Han Zong, a former Wu traitor who had become Wei's Commander of the Vanguard, was also beheaded. The Wu army captured thousands each of carts, oxen, horses, donkeys and mules. In the 1st month of the following year Wang Chang and the others attacking Nan Commandery also withdrew. In Wei, Zhuge Dan, who had been defeated at Dongguan, and Guanqiu Jian exchanged posts. Records, Wu 19 §30Records, Wu 3 §5–6Records, Wei 22 §9Records, Wei 28 §19

Zhuge Ke was promoted in his enfeoffment to Marquis of Yangdu and given the additional post of Governor of Jing and Yang provinces, but this victory bred in him contempt for the enemy, and rejecting the remonstrances of the high ministers he sent out troops again the following spring. He besieged Hefei Xincheng, lost more than half his troops to an epidemic and returned, and that winter he was killed by Sun Jun. Wei's Wang Ji later warned against carelessness after a great victory, citing how Zhuge Ke, riding on his victory at Dongguan, had attacked Xincheng and lost more than half his men. Records, Wu 19 §30–31Records, Wu 3 §6Records, Wei 27 §69

In the Romance

In Chapter 108 of the Romance, when Sun Quan died and Sun Liang took the throne, Sima Shi rejected Fu Gu's remonstrance, had Wang Chang, Hu Zun and Guanqiu Jian attack Nan Commandery, Dongxing and Wuchang respectively with 100,000 men each, and made his younger brother Sima Zhao Grand Commander. In the 12th month, in the winter of that year, Sima Zhao made Hu Zun his vanguard and had him lay a pontoon bridge and seize the great embankment at Dongxing. Romance, Ch. 108 §7–10

Zhuge Ke gave Ding Feng 3,000 marines to advance along the river and had Lü Ju, Tang Zi and Liu Zan follow by three routes. Hu Zun, encamped on the embankment, had Huan Jia and Han Zong attack the two forts held by Quan Duan and Liu Lüe but could not take them, and in the heavy snow he held a drinking party with his commanders. When Ding Feng's thirty boats arrived, Hu Zun said they were no more than 3,000 men and went on drinking. Romance, Ch. 108 §11–14

Ding Feng had his troops take off their armor and helmets and carry only short swords, drawing the mockery of the Wei troops, then at the signal of cannon fire leapt ashore and charged into the Wei camp. Ding Feng cut down Han Zong, struck Huan Jia down with his sword and then stabbed him with a spear, and Hu Zun fled. The pontoon bridge broke and more than half the Wei troops fell into the water and drowned, and at the news of the defeat at Dongxing, Sima Zhao, Wang Chang and Guanqiu Jian also withdrew. Romance, Ch. 108 §15–17

Where the Romance differs

Command of the Wei army: In Chapter 108 of the Romance, Sima Shi made his younger brother Sima Zhao Grand Commander in overall charge of the three routes. In Chen Shou's text, the Annals of the Three Young Emperors record that the edict was issued to Wang Chang, Hu Zun and Guanqiu Jian, and the Biographies of the Three Successor Rulers record that those who surrounded Dongxing were Zhuge Dan, Hu Zun and others; Sima Zhao does not appear. Romance, Ch. 108 §8–10Records, Wei 4 §34Records, Wu 3 §4

Troop strength: In Chapter 108 of the Romance, Wei sent 100,000 men along each of the three routes. In the Records, the Biographies of the Three Successor Rulers put the Wei army that surrounded Dongxing at 70,000 infantry and cavalry, and the Biography of Zhuge Ke also gives 70,000; Zhuge Ke's relief army of 40,000 appears only in the Biography of Zhuge Ke. Romance, Ch. 108 §8Records, Wu 19 §28–29Records, Wu 3 §4

Zhuge Dan: Zhuge Dan does not appear in the fighting at Dongxing in Chapter 108 of the Romance. In Chen Shou's text, Zhuge Dan was a commander who attacked Dongxing together with Hu Zun, and after fighting without success at Dongguan he exchanged posts with Guanqiu Jian and became General Who Guards the South. Romance, Ch. 108 §8–17Records, Wu 3 §4Records, Wei 28 §19 · 31

The deaths of Han Zong and Huan Jia: In Chapter 108 of the Romance, Ding Feng cut down Han Zong with his sword and stabbed Huan Jia to death with a spear. The Biography of Zhuge Ke and the Biographies of the Three Successor Rulers in the Records state only that Han Zong, Huan Jia and others died, without saying who killed them. Romance, Ch. 108 §16–17Records, Wu 19 §30Records, Wu 3 §5

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Belligerents

ItemAB
FactionsWuWei
CommandersDing Feng(丁奉), Liu Zan(留贊), Lü Ju, Tang Zi, Zhuge Ke, Zhu YiGuanqiu Jian, Sima Zhao, Wang Chang(王昶), Zhuge Dan, Hu Zun
Strength恪興軍四萬步騎七萬
Casualties死者數萬

Factions, commanders, strength and casualties are checked against the source texts (3KDEX). Strength and casualties show only figures stated in the sources. Source: Wu 3 §5

Romance chapters (1)

Records volumes (8)