RChen Shou assessed him as loyal and upright, never acting for himselfWu 7 §100Wu 7 §12
NDenounced as a minister out to save his own skin and family, yet rebuked the Wei envoyCh. 43 §47Ch. 82 §17
| Occupation | ROfficial · Chief Clerk NStrategist · Chief Clerk | Faction | Wu |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appears | RN | Biography in | Book of Wu |
| Born | R156 Unverified | Native place | Pengcheng Commandery |
| Died | R236 Unverified | Place of death | |
| Existence | Historical | Mentions | R82 |
Zhang Zhao, courtesy name Zibu, was a native of Pengcheng. Fond of learning from his youth, he studied the Zuo Commentary on the Spring and Autumn Annals and read widely in many books; in the turmoil at the end of the Han he crossed the Yangtze southward and then became Sun Ce's Chief Clerk. Records, Wu 7 §2–3
When Sun Ce, on his deathbed, entrusted his younger brother Sun Quan to him, he led the officials in setting Sun Quan up and assisting him. His forthright remonstrances often brought him into conflict with Sun Quan; never rising to Chancellor, he lived in retirement as General Who Assists Wu (fuwu jiangjun) and Marquis of Lou, and died in the 5th year of Jiahe (236) at the age of eighty-one. Records, Wu 7 §4 · 9–16
In his assessment, Chen Shou wrote that Zhang Zhao received the dying charge and achieved meritorious service, and was loyal and upright, never acting for himself, yet because he was stern and lofty he became neither chief minister nor imperial tutor, which made it plain that Sun Quan fell short of Sun Ce. In the Romance he first appeared in Chapter 15 as one of the "two Zhangs" whom Zhou Yu recommended to Sun Ce, and featured in 25 of its 120 chapters; as in the title of Chapter 43, "Zhuge Liang Debates the Assembled Scholars," he came forward as the adviser in Jiangdong who was first to test Zhuge Liang. Records, Wu 7 §100Romance, Ch. 15 §17–19Romance, Ch. 43 §9–11
Zhang Zhao wrote a fine clerical script and studied the Zuo Commentary on the Spring and Autumn Annals under Baihou Zi'an. He won renown together with Zhao Yu of Langya and Wang Lang of Donghai, and they were on friendly terms; around the age of twenty he was nominated as Filial and Incorrupt but did not take up office. When Tao Qian, Inspector of Xu Province, nominated him as Abundant Talent and he did not respond, Tao Qian, feeling slighted, had him arrested and detained, and he was released only after Zhao Yu threw himself into securing his rescue. At the end of the Han, when the gentry and commoners of Xu Province fled the turmoil to Yang Province, he too crossed the Yangtze southward. Records, Wu 7 §2–3
When Sun Ce founded his enterprise, he made Zhang Zhao Chief Clerk (zhangshi) and General of the Household Who Supports the Army (fujun zhonglangjiang), ascended the hall to pay his respects to Zhang Zhao's mother, treated him like an old friend, and entrusted him with all civil and military affairs. When letters from gentlemen of the north gave the praise to Zhang Zhao alone, leaving him uneasy because he could neither report them nor keep them to himself, Sun Ce laughed and said, "When Guan Zhong served as chief minister of Qi, it was 'Uncle Zhong' first and 'Uncle Zhong' second, yet Duke Huan became the foremost of the hegemons. Zibu is worthy and I am able to employ him; will not the merit and fame be mine?" Records, Wu 7 §3–4
In the 5th year of Jian'an (200), Sun Ce on his deathbed entrusted his younger brother Sun Quan to Zhang Zhao. When Sun Quan could not stop weeping, Zhang Zhao told him that to grieve for kin and heed only the rites at such a time was like opening the gate and bowing to robbers; he personally helped Sun Quan onto his horse and had him ride out with the troops drawn up in array, and the people then knew where their allegiance lay. Zhang Zhao again became Sun Quan's Chief Clerk, and Sun Quan treated him with the courtesy due to a mentor. In the 7th year of Jian'an (202), Sun Quan's mother, Lady Wu, summoned Zhang Zhao and others before she died and entrusted to them the affairs after her death. Records, Wu 7 §4–5Records, Wu 2 §3–5Records, Wu 5 §6
When Liu Bei memorialized to make Sun Quan Acting General of Chariots and Cavalry, Zhang Zhao became Military Adviser (junshi). Whenever Sun Quan went hunting he rode out to shoot tigers, and Zhang Zhao remonstrated that a ruler was one who commanded heroes and led the worthy, not one who matched his courage against wild beasts in the open field. Sun Quan apologized but could not give it up, and had a tiger-shooting carriage built. When Gan Ning proposed attacking Huang Zu, Zhang Zhao objected that the land of Wu was unsettled and that turmoil would follow if the army left; he also often disparaged Lu Su as young and rough and not yet fit for office, but on both occasions Sun Quan did not heed him. Records, Wu 7 §5–7Records, Wu 10 §56–57Records, Wu 9 §39
Sun Quan later recalled to Lu Xun that when Cao Cao, having gained Jing Province, boasted that he would come down upon them, he had asked his generals for advice, and Zibu and Wenbiao had both said that envoys should be sent to welcome Cao Cao, while Lu Su alone said no and urged him to summon Zhou Yu. Records, Wu 9 §90–91
In the 2nd year of Huangchu (221) of Wei, when the envoy Xing Zhen, who had come to name Sun Quan King of Wu, entered the gate without getting down from his carriage, Zhang Zhao rebuked him: the law was carried out only because the rites admitted no disrespect; did he think that Jiangnan had not even an inch of blade? Xing Zhen hastily got down from his carriage. Zhang Zhao was made General Who Pacifies Distant Lands (suiyuan jiangjun) and Marquis of Youquan. When Sun Quan, very drunk at the Fishing Terrace in Wuchang, had water sprinkled on his officials and declared that the drinking would stop only when they fell down drunk, Zhang Zhao went out without a word and sat in his carriage, and then answered that King Zhou's lake of wine had also been thought a pleasure in its day; Sun Quan, ashamed, ended the banquet. Records, Wu 7 §7–8
When Sun Quan was to appoint a Chancellor, opinion converged on Zhang Zhao, but Sun Quan declined, saying that with so many affairs the burden was heavy and this was no way to honor him. When Sun Shao died and the officials again recommended Zhang Zhao, Sun Quan said that this man was unbending by nature and that resentment would arise if his words were not accepted, and he appointed Gu Yong. When Sun Quan took the imperial title, Zhang Zhao, pleading old age and illness, returned his office and the troops under his command; he was made General Who Assists Wu, ranking next to the Three Excellencies, and his fief was changed to Marquis of Lou. Living at leisure in his village residence, he wrote explications of the Zuo Commentary on the Spring and Autumn Annals and annotations on the Analects. Records, Wu 7 §9–10
At every court audience Zhang Zhao's words and bearing were forceful and stern, and once, having offended Sun Quan with blunt words, he stayed away from audiences for a time. When an envoy from Shu extolled the virtue of Shu and none of the officials rebutted him, Sun Quan sighed that had Lord Zhang been present, the man would have been either broken or silenced, and the next day he invited Zhang Zhao to see him. When Zhang Zhao left his seat to apologize, Sun Quan knelt to stop him, and Zhang Zhao said that since the Empress Dowager and King Huan had entrusted His Majesty to their old servant, he would simply serve until his life was spent, and could not steal glory and seek favor by base compliance. Records, Wu 7 §11–12
In the 2nd year of Jiahe (233), when Sun Quan was about to send Zhang Mi and Xu Yan to make Gongsun Yuan, who had declared himself a vassal, King of Yan, Zhang Zhao remonstrated that Gongsun Yuan had turned against Wei and, fearing punishment, was merely seeking help, and that if he changed his mind the two envoys would never return. Sun Quan put his hand on his sword in anger, but when Zhang Zhao cited the Empress Dowager's last edict and wept, he threw down the sword and wept with him; even so, he sent the envoys in the end. When Zhang Zhao, pleading illness, stayed away from court, Sun Quan blocked the gate of his house with earth, and Zhang Zhao in turn sealed the gate with earth from inside. When Gongsun Yuan did indeed kill the envoys, Sun Quan went so far as to set fire to the gate before having it put out, waited a long time until Zhang Zhao's sons helped him out, took him in his carriage back to the palace, and blamed himself deeply. Records, Wu 2 §73Records, Wu 7 §13–15
Zhang Zhao's appearance was grave and commanding, so that Sun Quan often said, "When I speak with Lord Zhang, I dare not speak carelessly," and the whole state held him in awe. He died in the 5th year of Jiahe (236) at the age of eighty-one. By his last instructions he wore a plain cloth headband and was laid in an undecorated coffin in everyday clothes; Sun Quan came in plain white to mourn him and gave him the posthumous title Marquis Wen. Because his eldest son Zhang Cheng had already been enfeoffed as a marquis in his own right, his youngest son Zhang Xiu inherited the title. Records, Wu 7 §16
In his assessment, Chen Shou said that Zhang Zhao received the dying charge and gave his assistance, accomplishing meritorious service, and was loyal, outspoken, upright and unbending, never acting for himself. Yet he was dreaded for his sternness and kept at a distance for his loftiness, so that he held neither the post of chief minister nor the position of imperial tutor and spent his old age in his village; Chen Shou wrote that this made it plain that Sun Quan fell short of Sun Ce. Records, Wu 7 §100
In Chapter 15 of the Romance, Zhou Yu recommended to Sun Ce the "two Zhangs" of Jiangdong, Zhang Zhao of Pengcheng and Zhang Hong of Guangling, saying that both had talents to order heaven and earth. When the two declined his gifts, Sun Ce went in person to their homes to engage them, and made Zhang Zhao Chief Clerk and concurrently General of the Household Who Supports the Army. Romance, Ch. 15 §17–19
In Chapter 29, before dying, Sun Ce summoned Zhang Zhao and others and asked them to support his younger brother well, and told his mother that if internal matters could not be decided she should consult Zhang Zhao. When Sun Ce died, Zhang Zhao told the weeping Sun Quan that this was no time for tears and that he must conduct the funeral while handling the great affairs of the army and state; he put Sun Jing in charge of the funeral and brought Sun Quan out to the hall to receive the congratulations of the officials. Romance, Ch. 29 §32–34 · 37
In Chapter 38, when Cao Cao demanded that a son be sent as a hostage, Zhang Zhao said it would be dangerous not to send one, and the following year he opposed the proposal to attack Huang Zu on the grounds that a year of mourning had not yet passed. In Chapter 43, on receiving Cao Cao's proclamation, he took the lead in urging that they submit, saying that the barrier of the Yangtze was now shared with Cao Cao, and when Zhuge Liang came to Jiangdong he was the first to test him, challenging him over his comparing himself to Guan Zhong and Yue Yi and over the loss of Jing Province. Romance, Ch. 38 §28 · 42Romance, Ch. 43 §3–4 · 9–12
In Chapter 44 Zhang Zhao went with Gu Yong, Zhang Hong and Bu Zhi to Zhou Yu to urge surrender, but Sun Quan, having resolved to fight, told Zhou Yu, "Zibu has no strategy and has greatly disappointed me." Later, too, Zhang Zhao repeatedly offered stratagems concerning Liu Bei. In Chapter 62 he proposed sending letters to Liu Zhang and Zhang Lu to harass Liu Bei from front and rear, and in Chapter 66 he proposed feigning the imprisonment of Zhuge Jin's household and sending Zhuge Jin to Xichuan. Romance, Ch. 44 §3–4 · 35Romance, Ch. 62 §1–2Romance, Ch. 66 §1–2
In Chapter 77, after Guan Yu's death, Zhang Zhao hurried from Jianye and warned that Liu Bei would come for revenge with the forces of his entire state, and devised the stratagem of sending Guan Yu's head to Cao Cao to turn Liu Bei's hatred toward Cao Cao. In Chapter 82 he rebuked Xing Zhen, the Wei envoy who would not get down from his carriage, until he did so, and in Chapter 83 he opposed the appointment of Lu Xun, calling him a mere scholar and no match for Liu Bei. Romance, Ch. 77 §28–30Romance, Ch. 82 §16–17Romance, Ch. 83 §35
In Chapter 98, citing phoenixes alighting at Wuchang and yellow dragons appearing in the Yangtze, Zhang Zhao urged Sun Quan to take the imperial throne first, and Sun Quan built an altar and ascended it. The Romance says that Zhang Zhao, as assistant to the King of Wu, ranked above the Three Dukes, and has him advise after the accession that they should not move troops but cultivate civil government and ally with Shu. In the same chapter Zhang Zhao declined the wine Zhuge Ke was passing around, but, silenced by Zhuge Ke's citing the example of Jiang Shangfu, was forced to drink. Romance, Ch. 98 §26–27 · 30–32
How he came to Sun Ce: In Chapter 15 of the Romance, Zhou Yu recommended the "two Zhangs" and Sun Ce went in person to their homes to engage them. The Records says only that when Sun Ce founded his enterprise he made Zhang Zhao, who had crossed the river to escape the turmoil, Chief Clerk and General of the Household Who Supports the Army, and does not mention any recommendation by Zhou Yu. Romance, Ch. 15 §17–19Records, Wu 7 §3
Sun Quan's weeping: In Chapter 29 of the Romance, Zhang Zhao told Sun Quan to conduct the funeral while handling the great affairs of the army and state, and put Sun Jing in charge of the funeral. In the Records, Zhang Zhao said that grieving in this way was like opening the gate and bowing to robbers, had Sun Quan change his clothes, personally helped him onto his horse, and had him make a tour of inspection of the troops. Romance, Ch. 29 §37Records, Wu 2 §3–4Records, Wu 7 §4–5
The campaign against Huang Zu: In Chapter 38 of the Romance, Zhang Zhao objected that a year of mourning had not yet passed. In the Records, when Gan Ning proposed attacking Huang Zu, Zhang Zhao objected that the land of Wu was unsettled and that turmoil would follow if the army left, and Gan Ning retorted by asking whether a man entrusted with the role of Xiao He should do nothing but worry about turmoil. Romance, Ch. 38 §42Records, Wu 10 §57
The debate with Zhuge Liang: In Chapter 43 of the Romance, Zhang Zhao challenged Zhuge Liang over his comparing himself to Guan Zhong and Yue Yi and over the loss of Jing Province. This debate appears in neither Zhang Zhao's nor Zhuge Liang's biography in the Records. Romance, Ch. 43 §9–12Records, Wu 7 §1–16Records, Shu 5 §1–54
The case for surrender: In Chapters 43 and 44 of the Romance, Zhang Zhao took the lead in urging surrender before Sun Quan and went with Gu Yong and others to Zhou Yu to try to persuade him. Zhang Zhao's biography in the Records does not record this; it appears only in Sun Quan's recollection, preserved in the Biography of Lü Meng, that Zibu and Wenbiao had said envoys should be sent to welcome Cao Cao. Romance, Ch. 43 §3–4Romance, Ch. 44 §3–4Records, Wu 7 §1–16Records, Wu 9 §91
Guan Yu's head: In Chapter 77 of the Romance, Guan Yu's head was sent to Cao Cao on Zhang Zhao's stratagem. There is no such stratagem in Zhang Zhao's biography in the Records. Romance, Ch. 77 §29–30Records, Wu 7 §1–16
Xing Zhen: In Chapter 82 of the Romance, after Zhang Zhao rebuked Xing Zhen, a man behind the carriage wept that their lord had accepted enfeoffment from another. In the Records, the man who, on the occasion when Zhang Zhao grew angry, burst out in indignation and wept in this way was Xu Sheng. Romance, Ch. 82 §17Records, Wu 7 §7–8Records, Wu 10 §84
The accession: In Chapter 98 of the Romance, Zhang Zhao cited auspicious omens to urge Sun Quan to take the throne. Zhang Zhao's biography in the Records contains no such urging, and records that when Sun Quan took the imperial title, Zhang Zhao, pleading old age and illness, returned his office and his troops. Romance, Ch. 98 §26–27Records, Wu 7 §10
His standing: Chapter 98 of the Romance says that Zhang Zhao, as assistant to the King of Wu, ranked above the Three Dukes. In the Records, Sun Quan twice declined to make Zhang Zhao Chancellor; after the accession Zhang Zhao ranked next to the Three Excellencies, and Chen Shou assessed that he became neither chief minister nor imperial tutor. Romance, Ch. 98 §31Records, Wu 7 §9–10 · 100
His last years: The Romance does not depict Zhang Zhao after Chapter 98. In the Records, he clashed with Sun Quan over sending envoys to Gongsun Yuan, until the gate of his house was blocked with earth by each of them, and he died in the 5th year of Jiahe (236) at the age of eighty-one. Romance, Ch. 98 §31–32Records, Wu 7 §13–16
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.
RChen Shou assessed him as loyal and upright, never acting for himselfWu 7 §100Wu 7 §12
NDenounced as a minister out to save his own skin and family, yet rebuked the Wei envoyCh. 43 §47Ch. 82 §17
RRebuked the Wei envoy Xing Zhen into getting down from his carriage; deemed the man to humble Shu's envoyWu 7 §7Wu 7 §11
NCould not answer a single word in the debate with Zhuge Liang, but rebuked Xing ZhenCh. 43 §18Ch. 82 §17
RStudied the Zuo Commentary and read widely; wrote explications of the Zuo Commentary and annotations on the AnalectsWu 7 §2Wu 7 §10
NDebated Zhuge Liang as a scholar of Jiangdong and was recommended as a talented recluseCh. 43 §9Ch. 15 §18
RRecognized Zhang Wen and entrusted him with his hopes, but disparaged Lu Su as unfit for officeWu 9 §39Wu 12 §25
NOpposed Lu Xun as a mere scholar and wrongly suspected Zhuge Jin of betrayalCh. 83 §35Ch. 82 §6
RNorthern gentlemen gave the praise to him, and the whole state held him in aweWu 7 §3Wu 7 §16
NThe advisers agreed that Zibu's words were right and followed his leadCh. 43 §4Ch. 98 §27
ROnly a record that he marched on Dangtu and his troops fared badlyWu 2 §14
NNo direct record — estimated from his civil role as Chief ClerkCh. 15 §19
RNo direct record — estimated from his career as a civil official entrusted, as Chief Clerk, with civil and military affairsWu 7 §3
NNo direct record — estimated from his civil roleCh. 15 §19
RSun Ce entrusted him with civil and military affairs, and at Sun Quan's succession he put duties at court and in the field in orderWu 7 §3Wu 7 §4Wu 7 §100
NRecommended as having talents to order heaven and earth; internal matters were to be referred to himCh. 15 §18Ch. 29 §34
RDreaded for his sternness and pushed aside for his loftiness; sealed his gate and held outWu 7 §100Wu 7 §14Wu 7 §2
NInsisted on surrender before Chibi, and Sun Quan was disappointed in him as lacking strategyCh. 43 §46Ch. 44 §35
RMaster +25 Recorded as skilled in clerical script from his youthWu 7 §2
Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)
3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.
AppearsNot present Chapter list →
| Children | Zhang Cheng(張承) Records, Zhang Xiu(張休) Novel & History |
|---|
Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.
Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).