Xu Jing 許靖
| Occupation | RNOfficial · Minister over the Masses | Faction | Shu |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appears | RN | Biography in | Book of Shu |
| Born | R? Unverified | Native place | Runan Commandery Pingyu County |
| Died | R222 Unverified | Place of death | |
| Existence | Historical | Mentions | R38 |
Profile
Xu Jing, courtesy name Wenxiu, was a man of Pingyu County in Runan Commandery. In his youth he became known, together with his younger cousin Xu Shao, for judging people's character, and when Dong Zhuo held power he took part in the selection of officials. Records, Shu 8 §2
Fearing execution by Dong Zhuo, he fled and wandered through Yang Province and Kuaiji as far as Jiao Province, and at Liu Zhang's summons he entered Shu and served as a commandery Administrator. After Liu Bei pacified Shu he served as Chief Clerk to the General of the Left and Grand Tutor, and when Liu Bei took the imperial throne he became Minister over the Masses; he died in the 2nd year of Zhangwu (222). Records, Shu 8 §4–5 · 17–19
Chen Shou, the author of the Records, wrote in his assessment that Xu Jing had a reputation from early on and was praised as sincere and generous, and that although his conduct was not always fitting, Jiang Ji regarded him as 'on the whole a vessel for the court'. In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 65 as Liu Zhang's Administrator of Shu Commandery guarding Chengdu, and appears in 4 of its 120 chapters; his name is not in any chapter title. Records, Shu 8 §59Romance, Ch. 65 §41
In the Records
Xu Jing, courtesy name Wenxiu, was a man of Pingyu County in Runan Commandery. In his youth he became known together with his younger cousin Xu Shao, and both had a reputation for judging people's character, but they did not get along personally. When Xu Shao became Officer of Merit of the commandery, he pushed Xu Jing aside so that he could not take his place in the ranks of office, and Xu Jing supported himself by having a horse turn a millstone. When Liu Yi of Yingchuan became Administrator of Runan, he recommended Xu Jing as an accounts clerk and selected him as Filial and Incorrupt, and Xu Jing became a Gentleman of the Masters of Writing in charge of the selection of officials. Records, Shu 8 §2
When Emperor Ling died and Dong Zhuo took power, the Master of Writing for Personnel Zhou Bi, together with Xu Jing, admitted and dismissed the gentlemen of the realm. They promoted Xun Shuang, Han Rong, Chen Ji and others, and made Han Fu Governor of Ji Province, Liu Dai Inspector of Yan Province, Kong Zhou Inspector of Yu Province and Zhang Miao Administrator of Chenliu, among others, while Xu Jing was transferred to Administrator of Ba Commandery but did not take up the post and became Palace Assistant Imperial Clerk. However, once Han Fu and the others reached their posts, each raised troops intending to kill Dong Zhuo, and Dong Zhuo in anger beheaded Zhou Bi. Records, Shu 8 §2–4
Because his elder cousin Xu Yang had also plotted together with Kong Zhou, Xu Jing, fearing execution, fled to Kong Zhou. When Kong Zhou died he relied on Chen Yi, Inspector of Yang Province, and when Chen Yi died he went to place himself under Xu Gong, Commandant of Wu Commandery, and Wang Lang, Administrator of Kuaiji, both old friends of his, and he gathered and cared for his relatives and fellow villagers. When Sun Ce crossed the river they all fled to Jiao Province; Xu Jing sat at the water's edge and had those who followed him board the boats first, leaving only after all his relatives had gone, and everyone who saw this sighed in admiration. Shi Xie, the Administrator of Jiaozhi, treated him with deep respect. Records, Shu 8 §4–5
Yuan Hui of Chen State, who was staying in Jiao Province, wrote to Xun Yu that during his wanderings, whenever there was trouble or danger, Xu Jing always put others first and himself last. Zhang Xiang, who came to Jiao Province bearing the royal command, summoned him and wanted to make a pact with him, but Xu Jing refused. Records, Shu 8 §5–6
Xu Jing sent a long letter to Cao Cao. He wrote that when Yuan Shu's troops pressed in and Kuaiji fell, he crossed the sea to escape to Jiao Province; on the journey of ten thousand li their provisions ran out and they ate grass, and more than half of them died, and then they met with an epidemic in which his aunt, his cousins, and even his wife and children nearly all died, so that only one or two in ten survived. As the roads to Jing and Yi Provinces were all blocked, he asked that a way be opened for him, and he urged Cao Cao to forget old grudges and to choose men for the sake of the offices. But Zhang Xiang, resentful that Xu Jing had not come over to him, searched out the letters he had sent and threw them all into the water. Records, Shu 8 §6–10 · 14 · 16
Later, when Liu Zhang sent an envoy to summon him, Xu Jing entered Shu and became Administrator of Ba Commandery and of Guanghan, and in the 16th year of Jian'an (211) he was transferred to Shu Commandery. Xu Ci also came from Jiao Province to Shu around this time together with Xu Jing and others. In the 19th year of Jian'an (214), when Liu Bei besieged Chengdu, the Administrator of Shu Commandery Xu Jing tried to climb over the wall and surrender, but the matter was discovered and he failed; Liu Zhang, as his downfall was near, did not kill him. Records, Shu 8 §17Records, Shu 12 §26Records, Shu 7 §26
After Liu Zhang surrendered, Liu Bei looked down on Xu Jing because of this and did not want to employ him. Fa Zheng urged that although Xu Jing was a man who had gained an empty reputation without substance, his fame had spread throughout the world, and if he were not treated with courtesy people would say that their lord despised the worthy, so Liu Bei should follow the example of the King of Yan in his treatment of Guo Wei long ago. Liu Bei therefore treated Xu Jing generously and made him Chief Clerk to the General of the Left, and the Biography of the First Sovereign records that he made Xu Jing, along with Mi Zhu and Jian Yong, his guests and friends. Records, Shu 7 §26–27Records, Shu 8 §17Records, Shu 2 §33
In the autumn of the 24th year of Jian'an (219), when the ministers submitted a memorial proposing Liu Bei as King of Hanzhong, Xu Jing signed it as Chief Clerk to the General of the Left, after Ma Chao, and when Liu Bei became King of Hanzhong Xu Jing became Grand Tutor. When Cao Pi usurped the Han, the Grand Tutor Xu Jing, together with Mi Zhu, Zhuge Liang and others, asked Liu Bei to take the imperial throne. In the 1st year of Zhangwu (221) Liu Bei took the throne and issued a decree making him Minister over the Masses. Records, Shu 2 §40 · 60 · 68Records, Shu 8 §17–18
Even past the age of seventy Xu Jing loved people of quality, drew in the younger generation and never tired of pure conversation, and everyone, beginning with the Chancellor Zhuge Liang, bowed to him. When Xu Jing lost his son, Dong Yun and Fei Yi set out together for the funeral. Chen Zhi, the grandson of Xu Jing's elder brother through a daughter, lost his father young and was raised in Xu Jing's household. Xu Jing died in the 8th month, in autumn, of the 2nd year of Zhangwu (222), and his son Xu Qin had died before him. Records, Shu 8 §19Records, Shu 14 §20Records, Shu 9 §34Records, Shu 2 §72
Xu Jing had early on served Chen Ji of Yingchuan as an elder brother and was close to Yuan Huan, Hua Xin, Wang Lang and others. Hua Xin, Wang Lang and Chen Ji's son Chen Qun became high ministers early in Wei, and all of them wrote to Xu Jing reaffirming their old friendship. Records, Shu 8 §19
In his assessment Chen Shou said that Xu Jing had a reputation from early on, was praised as sincere and generous, and took an interest in people. He wrote that although his conduct was not always fitting, Jiang Ji regarded him as 'on the whole a vessel for the court'. Records, Shu 8 §59
In the Romance
In Chapter 65 of the Romance, when Liu Bei surrounds Chengdu, a report comes in while Liu Zhang is listening to Qiao Zhou that the Administrator of Shu Commandery Xu Jing has climbed over the wall and gone out to surrender, and Liu Zhang returns to his residence weeping loudly. After taking charge as Governor of Yi Province, Liu Bei fixes the titles and ranks of the civil and military officials who surrendered and makes Xu Jing Chief Clerk to the General of the Left. Romance, Ch. 65 §41 · 46
In Chapter 73, when an altar is built at Mianyang in the 7th month, in autumn, of the 24th year of Jian'an (219), Xu Jing and Fa Zheng have Liu Bei mount the altar and present him with the crown and robes, the jade seal and the ribbon. Having become King of Hanzhong, Liu Bei makes Xu Jing Grand Tutor and Fa Zheng Prefect of the Masters of Writing. Romance, Ch. 73 §8–9
In Chapter 77, Xu Jing, who has gone to the office of the Military Advisor to report secret news, meets Zhuge Liang outside the palace gate and passes on the rumor going around outside that Lü Meng of Eastern Wu has made a surprise attack on Jing Province and that Lord Guan has come to harm. When Liu Bei comes out of the hall and asks how they can hide such ill news, Xu Jing, together with Zhuge Liang, soothes him, saying that it is only a passing rumor and not to be believed too deeply. Meanwhile Ma Liang and Yi Ji, and then Liao Hua, arrive and report that Jing Province has fallen. Romance, Ch. 77 §40 · 42–43
In Chapter 80, when Cao Pi usurps the Han, Zhuge Liang consults the Grand Tutor Xu Jing and the Grand Master of Splendid Happiness Qiao Zhou about elevating the King of Hanzhong to emperor, and leads the officials in submitting a memorial together with Xu Jing. When the King of Hanzhong refuses, saying he cannot imitate what traitors do, three days later Xu Jing advises that the Han emperor has already been murdered by Cao Pi, and that if he does not take the throne and attack the traitor it cannot be called loyalty and righteousness. When Liu Bei takes the throne, Xu Jing becomes Minister over the Masses. Romance, Ch. 80 §30–32 · 42
Where the Romance differs
Climbing over the wall: In Chapter 65 of the Romance, Xu Jing actually climbs over the wall and surrenders to Liu Bei. In the Records, the Administrator of Shu Commandery Xu Jing tried to climb over the wall and surrender, but the matter was discovered and he failed, and Liu Zhang, as his downfall was near, did not kill him. This is recorded not in the Biography of Xu Jing but in the biography of Fa Zheng. Romance, Ch. 65 §41Records, Shu 7 §26
His treatment in Shu: In Chapter 65 of the Romance, Liu Bei makes Xu Jing Chief Clerk to the General of the Left as soon as he gains Yi Province. In the Records, Liu Bei looked down on Xu Jing for his attempt to climb over the wall and did not want to employ him, and treated him generously only after Fa Zheng urged him to honor Xu Jing for his reputation. Romance, Ch. 65 §46Records, Shu 7 §26–27Records, Shu 8 §17
The altar of the King of Hanzhong: In Chapter 73 of the Romance, Xu Jing and Fa Zheng have Liu Bei mount the altar and present him with the crown and robes, the jade seal and the ribbon. The Biography of the First Sovereign in the Records says only that an altar was set up at Mianyang and that, with the ministers in attendance, the memorial was read and the royal crown was placed on the First Sovereign, without saying who presented it. Xu Jing had signed the earlier memorial proposing him as king. Romance, Ch. 73 §8Records, Shu 2 §47 · 40
News of Guan Yu: In Chapter 77 of the Romance, Xu Jing passes on to Zhuge Liang the rumor that Lü Meng has made a surprise attack on Jing Province and that Guan Yu has come to harm. This is not in the Biography of Xu Jing in the Records. Romance, Ch. 77 §40Records, Shu 8 §1–19
His life before entering Shu: The Romance merely brings him on in Chapter 65 as Administrator of Shu Commandery, and does not deal with his discord with Xu Shao, his part in the selection of officials under Dong Zhuo's government, his wanderings as far as Jiao Province when he had his relatives board the boats first, or his letter to Cao Cao. The Biography of Xu Jing in the Records records these in detail. Romance, Ch. 65 §41Records, Shu 8 §2–16
His death: The Romance stops dealing with Xu Jing after he becomes Minister over the Masses in Chapter 80, so his death does not appear. In the Records, Xu Jing died as Minister over the Masses in the 8th month, in autumn, of the 2nd year of Zhangwu (222). Romance, Ch. 80 §42Records, Shu 2 §72Records, Shu 8 §19
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
Abilities
The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.
- LEA3131±0
- STR3131±0
- INT5545−10
- POL6052−8
- CHA7448−26
- VIR6442−22
- ADP4060+20
- SCH5540−15
- DIP5255+3
- DIS7840−38
Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more
RPut his followers on the boats first when fleeing, drawing sighs of admiration; even Zhuge Liang bowed to himShu 8 §5Shu 8 §19
NNo direct record — estimated from his standing as an elder who led the officials in urging accessionCh. 80 §31
RThe assessment calls him sincere and generous but not always fitting in conduct; tried to climb over the wall and surrenderShu 8 §59Shu 7 §26
NAs Administrator of Shu Commandery, climbed over the wall and went out to surrenderCh. 65 §41
RWas discovered trying to climb over the wall and surrender, and the First Sovereign looked down on him and would not employ himShu 7 §26Shu 7 §27
NWas the first to climb over the wall of besieged Chengdu and surrender to Liu BeiCh. 65 §41
RNever tired of judging people and pure conversation even in old ageShu 8 §19
NNo direct record — estimated from his role as an elder civil officialCh. 80 §30
RYuan Hui judged that his wisdom and strategy were enough to plan affairsShu 8 §5
NNo direct record — estimated from little more than his being first to report the rumor of Jing Province's fallCh. 77 §40
4 similar abilities — show evidence
RSelected officials as Gentleman of the Masters of Writing, and rose through commandery Administrator to Minister over the MassesShu 8 §2Shu 8 §18
NRose through Chief Clerk to the General of the Left and Grand Tutor to be appointed Minister over the MassesCh. 65 §46Ch. 80 §42
RSet out his situation and the way of employing men in a long letter to Cao CaoShu 8 §6Shu 8 §13
NUrged the King of Hanzhong to take the throne and attack the traitorCh. 80 §32
Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)
3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.
Romance chapters (4)
AppearsNot present Chapter list →
Allegiance history
- Shu · Records · Records vol. 38 「先主克蜀,以靖為左將軍長史」