Zhuge Jin 諸葛瑾

RecordsRomance Wu Courtesy name 子瑜 Ziyu제갈근자유诸葛瑾

Profile
OccupationRGeneral · General-in-Chief NOfficial · Staff AdviserFactionWu
AppearsRNBiography inBook of Wu
BornR174 UnverifiedNative placeLangya Commandery Yangdu County
DiedR241 UnverifiedPlace of death
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR63

Profile

Zhuge Jin, courtesy name Ziyu, was a man of Yangdu County in Langya. At the end of the Han he fled the disorder to Jiangdong, and on the recommendation of Hong Zi, the husband of Sun Quan's elder sister, he became a guest of Sun Quan together with Lu Su and others. Zhuge Liang, whom he met when he went to Shu as an envoy, was his younger brother. Records, Wu 7 §51

He served as Sun Quan's Chief Clerk and Central Major, and after the campaign against Guan Yu he was stationed at Gong'an as Administrator of Nan Commandery. When Sun Quan proclaimed himself emperor, he became General-in-Chief and Left Protector-General and concurrently Governor of Yu Province, and he died in the 4th year of Chiwu (241) at the age of sixty-eight. Records, Wu 7 §51 · 55 · 63

In his assessment, Chen Shou, author of the Records, wrote together with Bu Zhi that he was 'valued in his time for his virtue, magnanimity, propriety and restraint.' In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 29 as a man Lu Su recommends to Sun Quan, and he appears in 18 of its 120 chapters. His name is not in any chapter title, but he goes repeatedly as an envoy to Liu Bei and Guan Yu over Jing Province. Records, Wu 7 §100Romance, Ch. 29 §48Romance, Ch. 66 §2Romance, Ch. 73 §21Romance, Ch. 82 §1

In the Records

Zhuge Jin, courtesy name Ziyu, was a man of Yangdu County in Langya. At the end of the Han he fled the disorder to Jiangdong. When Sun Ce died, Hong Zi of Qu'e, the husband of Sun Quan's elder sister, met him, thought him remarkable and recommended him to Sun Quan, and Zhuge Jin was treated as a guest together with Lu Su and others. The Biography of the Lord of Wu likewise records that when Sun Quan gathered renowned scholars, Lu Su, Zhuge Jin and others first became his guests. He later became Sun Quan's Chief Clerk and was transferred to Central Major. Records, Wu 7 §51Records, Wu 2 §5

In the 20th year of Jian'an (215) Sun Quan sent Zhuge Jin to Shu to establish friendly relations with Liu Bei. Zhuge Jin met his younger brother Zhuge Liang only at official gatherings and did not see him privately after withdrawing. According to the Biography of the Lord of Wu, when Liu Bei had taken Yi Province, Sun Quan had Zhuge Jin ask for the return of the commanderies of Jing Province, but Liu Bei refused, saying that he would give all of Jing Province once he had pacified Liang Province (Liangzhou). Later, when Cao Cao entered Hanzhong and Liu Bei sued for peace, Sun Quan again had Zhuge Jin reply, and Jing Province was divided: the land east of Changsha, Jiangxia and Guiyang belonged to Sun Quan, and the land west of Nan Commandery, Lingling and Wuling to Liu Bei. Records, Wu 7 §51Records, Wu 2 §19 · 21

When Zhuge Jin remonstrated with Sun Quan, he never pressed him sharply but only hinted at the general drift of his meaning; if they did not agree, he moved on to another subject and then returned to the point by drawing on some similar matter, so that Sun Quan's mind was often eased. Sun Quan bore a grudge against Zhu Zhi, the Administrator of Wu Commandery who had recommended him, but because he had always respected him he could not bring himself to reproach him. Zhuge Jin wrote a letter in Sun Quan's presence discussing the principles of things at large and conveying his reading of Zhu Zhi's heart, and Sun Quan laughed with pleasure and said, 'My mind is eased.' Records, Wu 7 §52–53

When the Colonel Yin Mo was charged with an unfathomable crime and Sun Quan's anger grew the more the ministers spoke for him, Zhuge Jin alone kept silent. When Sun Quan asked why, he rose from his seat and answered that he, together with Yin Mo and others, had come to submit to the sage's transforming rule after their home province was overturned, and that because he had failed to supervise and encourage Yin Mo and so let him fall into crime, he had no time even to apologise for his own fault and dared not say anything. Sun Quan was moved and pardoned Yin Mo for his sake. Records, Wu 7 §53–54

He later took part in the campaign against Guan Yu and was enfeoffed as Marquis of Xuancheng, and as General Who Pacifies the South he replaced Lü Meng as acting Administrator of Nan Commandery and was stationed at Gong'an. When Liu Bei attacked Wu in the east and the King of Wu sought peace, Zhuge Jin sent Liu Bei a letter asking how his bond with Guan Yu compared with that with the late emperor, how the size of Jing Province compared with all the land within the seas, and, if both were enemies, which should come first. At that time someone said that Zhuge Jin had separately sent a trusted man to exchange messages with Liu Bei, but Sun Quan said, 'Ziyu and I have sworn an oath that neither death nor life will change,' and that he would not betray him. Records, Wu 7 §55–56

In the 1st year of Huangwu (222) he was promoted to General of the Left, supervised Gong'an, was granted the tally, and was enfeoffed as Marquis of Wanling. In the 9th month of that year, when Cao Zhen, Xiahou Shang and others of Wei besieged Nan Commandery, Zhuge Jin went to its relief together with Pan Zhang and Yang Can. According to the Biography of Xiahou Shang, Zhuge Jin crossed to a sandbar in the middle of the river and divided his naval forces there, but Xiahou Shang secretly crossed downstream at night with many oil-soaked boats and more than ten thousand infantry and cavalry, burned those boats, and attacked by land and water and defeated him. The city did not fall, and when a great epidemic broke out the Wei army returned. Records, Wu 7 §56Records, Wu 2 §41–42Records, Wei 9 §94–95

According to the Annals of Emperor Ming of Wei, in the 8th month of the 7th year of Huangchu (226) Zhuge Jin, Zhang Ba and others raided Xiangyang but were defeated by Sima Yi, and Zhang Ba was beheaded. Zhuge Jin had a fine bearing, thoughtfulness and magnanimity, and the people of his time admired his generosity and elegance; Sun Quan consulted him whenever there was a major matter. After Cao Pi died, regarding a memorial from Lu Xun saying that Wei was instead quiet, Sun Quan separately revealed his thoughts to Zhuge Jin: Cao Rui was not the equal of Cao Pi, and if men such as Chen Changwen and Cao Zidan shared power they would quarrel with one another, so on this one matter Lu Xun seemed to fall a little short. Records, Wei 3 §3–4Records, Wu 7 §58–62

When Yu Fan was banished for his wild frankness, Zhuge Jin alone spoke up for him many times. Yu Fan wrote to a close friend that 'Lord Zhuge is sincere and benevolent, taking Heaven as his model and giving life to all things,' and that thanks to his fair counsel he had been able to keep his lot. Records, Wu 7 §57

When Sun Quan assumed the imperial title, Zhuge Jin became General-in-Chief and Left Protector-General and concurrently Governor of Yu Province. In the 5th month of the 3rd year of Jiahe (234) he was stationed at Jiangxia and Miankou together with Lu Xun. In the 5th year of Jiahe (236), when Sun Quan campaigned north, he attacked Xiangyang together with Lu Xun, and when Han Bian, sent by Lu Xun, was captured by the enemy, Zhuge Jin was greatly alarmed and wrote that they must leave at once. When Lu Xun did not reply but had turnips and beans planted and played weiqi as usual, Zhuge Jin said, 'Boyan is rich in stratagems; there must be a reason,' and went to see him in person. The two secretly laid a plan: Zhuge Jin commanded the boats while Lu Xun made as if to advance on the city of Xiangyang and then withdrew to the boats, and the enemy did not dare to attack. Records, Wu 7 §63Records, Wu 2 §77Records, Wu 13 §43–45

After Lü Yi was executed, Sun Quan issued an edict reproaching Zhuge Jin, Bu Zhi, Zhu Ran, Lü Dai and others for leaving it to others to offer their views on the grounds that they did not handle affairs of the people; Zhuge Jin each time answered according to the matter, and his words were courteous and his reasoning sound. His son Zhuge Ke enjoyed a great reputation in his day and was highly valued by Sun Quan, but Zhuge Jin always disapproved of him and worried that he was not a son who would preserve the family. Records, Wu 2 §88Records, Wu 7 §63

In the 4th month of the 4th year of Chiwu (241) the General-in-Chief Zhuge Jin took Zhazhong, and he died in the intercalary month of that year at the age of sixty-eight. He left instructions that he be laid in a plain coffin in his everyday clothes and that the funeral be kept simple. Because Zhuge Ke had already been enfeoffed as a marquis in his own right, Zhuge Ke's younger brother Zhuge Rong inherited the title and was stationed at Gong'an. Records, Wu 2 §95–96Records, Wu 7 §63 · 65

In his assessment, Chen Shou wrote that Zhuge Jin and Bu Zhi were both valued in their time for their virtue, magnanimity, propriety and restraint. Records, Wu 7 §100

In the Romance

In Chapter 29 of the Romance, Lu Su recommends to Sun Quan Zhuge Jin, 'a man of Nanyang in Langya,' who is widely learned and talented and serves his mother with perfect filial piety, and Sun Quan receives him as an honoured guest. Zhuge Jin advises him not to deal with Yuan Shao but to follow Cao Cao for the time being and plot against him later when the chance comes, and Sun Quan, following his words, breaks off relations with Yuan Shao. In Chapter 37, Zhuge Jun tells Liu Bei that his eldest brother Zhuge Jin is serving as a counsellor under Sun Zhongmou in Jiangdong. Romance, Ch. 29 §48Romance, Ch. 37 §35

In Chapter 43 he meets Zhuge Liang, who has come to Jiangdong, at the inner gate and asks why he did not come to see him. In Chapter 44 he tells Zhou Yu, 'Those who surrender find safety easily; those who fight will find it hard to survive.' Then, at Zhou Yu's request, he goes to draw Zhuge Liang over to Eastern Wu and cites Boyi and Shuqi to urge that the brothers stay together, but he cannot answer Zhuge Liang's reply that they should instead serve the Imperial Uncle Liu together, and returns saying that he cannot betray the generous favour of General Sun. Romance, Ch. 43 §32Romance, Ch. 44 §7–8 · 39–43

In Chapter 66, following Zhang Zhao's plan, Sun Quan falsely has Zhuge Jin's family held in custody and sends him to Xichuan. Zhuge Jin weeps aloud in Chengdu and, receiving from Liu Bei a letter saying that three commanderies should be returned first, goes to Jing Province, but Guan Yu grips his sword and refuses, saying, 'This sword knows nothing of face.' When Zhuge Jin returns and Sun Quan angrily asks whether this was not all Zhuge Liang's scheme, Zhuge Jin answers that his brother too had pleaded in tears. Romance, Ch. 66 §1–3 · 8–9 · 11–12

In Chapter 73 he volunteers to go and ask for Guan Yu's daughter in marriage for Sun Quan's heir, but when Guan Yu says, 'How could my tiger daughter marry a dog's son?' and that he would have beheaded him had it not been for his brother's sake, he flees clutching his head. In Chapter 76 he enters Maicheng and urges Guan Yu to surrender; Guan Ping draws his sword to cut him down, but Guan Yu stops him out of regard for the bond between the brothers and has him driven out. Romance, Ch. 73 §20–22Romance, Ch. 76 §42–45

In Chapter 81, when Liu Bei raises a great army, Zhuge Jin asks to go as envoy, and in Chapter 82 he meets the First Sovereign at Baidi and, weighing the light against the heavy and the great against the small, says that to leave Cao Pi aside and attack Wu is to abandon the great duty for a lesser one. The First Sovereign sends him back, saying, 'Had I not had regard for the Chancellor, I would have had your head first.' Meanwhile, when Zhang Zhao says that Zhuge Jin means to go over to Shu, Sun Quan says, 'Ziyu and I have a covenant that neither death nor life will change,' and trusts him, citing what Zhuge Jin once said at Chaisang. Romance, Ch. 81 §38–39Romance, Ch. 82 §1–2 · 4–7

In Chapter 85 a report reaches Cao Pi that Lu Xun inside and Zhuge Jin outside set ambushes and routed Cao Zhen and Xiahou Shang, who were besieging Nan Commandery. In Chapter 98, since Zhuge Jin has a long face, Sun Quan has 'Zhuge Ziyu' written on the face of a donkey, and the six-year-old Zhuge Ke adds 'his donkey.' In Chapter 103 he is defeated by a Wei fire attack and flees to Miankou, and when sickness spreads in the heat he goes in person to Lu Xun to discuss withdrawal, hears his plan, and withdraws in command of the boats. In Chapter 108 he appears as already dead, and it is recorded that in life he had sighed of Zhuge Ke, 'This boy is not the master to preserve the house.' Romance, Ch. 85 §13Romance, Ch. 98 §29Romance, Ch. 103 §5 · 7–10Romance, Ch. 108 §4 · 37

Where the Romance differs

Place of origin: Chapter 29 of the Romance calls Zhuge Jin 'a man of Nanyang in Langya.' The Records give him as a man of Yangdu County in Langya. Romance, Ch. 29 §48Records, Wu 7 §51

Who recommended him: In Chapter 29 of the Romance, Lu Su recommends Zhuge Jin to Sun Quan. In the Records it was Hong Zi of Qu'e, the husband of Sun Quan's elder sister, who recommended him, and Lu Su appears as one who was treated as a guest along with him. Romance, Ch. 29 §48Records, Wu 7 §51

Deliberations before Red Cliffs: In Chapter 44 of the Romance, Zhuge Jin tells Zhou Yu that surrender is the safer course, and at Zhou Yu's request goes to draw Zhuge Liang over to Eastern Wu. The Biography of Zhuge Jin in the Records has nothing about the time of Red Cliffs; its only account of his meeting Zhuge Liang is that when he went to Shu as an envoy in the 20th year of Jian'an (215) he saw him only at official gatherings and did not meet him privately. Romance, Ch. 44 §8 · 39–41Records, Wu 7 §50–63

Demand for the return of Jing Province: In Chapter 66 of the Romance, Sun Quan falsely detains Zhuge Jin's family and sends him to Xichuan, and Guan Yu grips his sword and refuses. In the Biography of the Lord of Wu in the Records, Sun Quan had Zhuge Jin demand the commanderies of Jing Province, and Liu Bei refused, saying he would give all of Jing Province once he had pacified Liang Province (Liangzhou). Neither the detention of his family nor a visit to Guan Yu appears. Romance, Ch. 66 §2 · 9Records, Wu 2 §19Records, Wu 7 §50–63

The marriage proposal: In Chapter 73 of the Romance, Zhuge Jin volunteers to ask Guan Yu for a marriage alliance and is insulted. The Biography of Guan Yu in the Records says only that Sun Quan sent an envoy to ask for Guan Yu's daughter for his son and that Guan Yu cursed and insulted the envoy, without giving the envoy's name. Romance, Ch. 73 §21–22Records, Shu 6 §11

Maicheng: In Chapter 76 of the Romance, Zhuge Jin enters Maicheng and urges Guan Yu to surrender. The Biography of Zhuge Jin in the Records says only that he took part in the campaign against Guan Yu and was enfeoffed as Marquis of Xuancheng. Romance, Ch. 76 §42–43Records, Wu 7 §55

How he sought peace with Liu Bei: In Chapter 82 of the Romance, Zhuge Jin goes in person to Baidi, meets the First Sovereign and tries to persuade him by speech. In the Records he sent Liu Bei a letter. The 'light and heavy, great and small' that Zhuge Jin raises in the Romance are words from that letter in the Records. Romance, Ch. 82 §1–2 · 4Records, Wu 7 §55–56

The suspicion against him: In Chapter 82 of the Romance, Zhang Zhao says that Zhuge Jin means to go over to Shu. In the Records it was 'someone' who said that Zhuge Jin had separately sent a trusted man to exchange messages with Liu Bei; that Sun Quan answered with an oath that neither death nor life would change is the same. The episode at Chaisang that Sun Quan cites in the Romance is not in Chen Shou's text. Romance, Ch. 82 §6–7Records, Wu 7 §56 · 50–63

The battle for Nan Commandery: In Chapter 85 of the Romance, Lu Xun and Zhuge Jin set ambushes inside and outside and rout Cao Zhen and Xiahou Shang. In the Biography of Xiahou Shang in the Records, Xiahou Shang secretly crossed the river at night and defeated Zhuge Jin's forces, and the Wei army went home because of an epidemic without having taken the city. Romance, Ch. 85 §13Records, Wei 9 §94–95

The withdrawal from Xiangyang: In Chapter 103 of the Romance, Zhuge Jin is badly defeated by a Wei fire attack and flees to Miankou before consulting Lu Xun about withdrawal. In the Biography of Lu Xun in the Records this belongs to the battle of Xiangyang in the 5th year of Jiahe (236); it says only that Zhuge Jin took fright and wrote to Lu Xun on hearing that Han Bian, sent by Lu Xun, had been captured, with no mention of an earlier defeat. Romance, Ch. 103 §5 · 7–8Records, Wu 13 §43–44

The donkey: Chapter 98 of the Romance places the episode when Zhuge Ke was six years old. The Biography of Zhuge Ke in the Records does not give his age, and records that Sun Quan gave the donkey to Zhuge Ke. Romance, Ch. 98 §29Records, Wu 19 §2–3

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA5038−12
  • STR3131±0
  • INT5850−8
  • POL5840−18
  • CHA7650−26
  • VIR8676−10
  • ADP7452−22
  • SCH4862+14
  • DIP8048−32
  • DIS6258−4
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

DiplomacyR80N48 −32

RWent to Shu as envoy to establish friendly relations, calmed Sun Quan to win Yin Mo's pardon, and conveyed peace overturesWu 7 §51Wu 7 §53Wu 2 §21

NWent to win over Kongming but was won over instead, and failed to persuade Guan Yu and the First SovereignCh. 44 §43Ch. 66 §9Ch. 82 §4

CharismaR76N50Unverified −26

RHis contemporaries admired his generosity and elegance; the assessment says he was valued in his time for virtue and magnanimityWu 7 §58Wu 7 §57Wu 7 §100

NNo direct record — estimated from Guan Yu sparing him out of regard for brotherly tiesCh. 76 §45

AdaptabilityR74N52 −22

RRemonstrated with Sun Quan gently without crossing his will, and kept his trust despite slander that he was in contact with ShuWu 7 §52Wu 7 §56

NOnly shuttled back and forth as envoy for the return of Jing Province, but came back rather than staying in ShuCh. 66 §11Ch. 82 §7

PoliticsR58N40Unverified −18

RReplaced Lü Meng as acting Administrator of Nan Commandery, and received the legal code to trim and add to itWu 7 §55Wu 2 §58

NNo direct record — estimated from his role as a guest and civil officialCh. 29 §48

ScholarshipR48UnverifiedN62 +14

RNo direct record — estimated from his courteous and well-reasoned replies to edictsWu 7 §63

NRecommended as widely learned and talentedCh. 29 §48

LeadershipR50N38 −12

RHeld Nan Commandery from Gong'an, but Xiahou Shang burned his boats and defeated him, and he was also beaten at XiangyangWu 7 §55Wei 9 §95Wei 3 §4

NGiven the task of holding Jiangling against Sima Yi, but was badly defeated at XiangyangCh. 103 §7Ch. 96 §29

VirtueR86N76 −10

RAs envoy he did not meet his brother privately, and he defended the banished Yu Fan; the assessment praises his virtue and proprietyWu 7 §51Wu 7 §57Wu 7 §100

NServed his mother with perfect filial piety, and Sun Quan trusted him as a friend of the heartCh. 29 §48Ch. 82 §7

3 similar abilities — show evidence
  • StrengthR31UnverifiedN31Unverified ±0

    RNo direct record — estimated from a career of civil-official characterWu 7 §58

    NNo direct record — estimated from a career of civil-official characterCh. 103 §7

  • IntelligenceR58N50 −8

    RLaid out for Liu Bei which enemy weighed heavier, and trusted Lu Xun's strategy and sought his intentWu 7 §55Wu 13 §44

    NWas wary of Zhang Liao's ruse, but advised surrender to Cao Cao and followed Lu Xun's planCh. 53 §37Ch. 44 §8Ch. 103 §9

  • DiscernmentR62N58 −4

    RSaw that his renowned son Zhuge Ke was not one to preserve the familyWu 7 §63Wu 13 §44

    NSaw that Zhuge Ke's brilliance showed too openly and that he was not the master to preserve the houseCh. 108 §37

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (18)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Allegiance history

  1. Wu · Records · 「薦之於權,與魯肅等並見賓待」

Family

SiblingsZhuge Liang Novel & History, Zhuge Jun Novel & History
ChildrenZhuge Qiao Records, Zhuge Ke Novel & History, Zhuge Rong Records
RelativesZhuge Dan Records

Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.

Related events (6)

Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).