Battle

Conquest of Shu by Wei 魏滅蜀漢之戰

About this event

The Conquest of Shu by Wei was the war in which, in the 4th year of Jingyuan (263), Wei sent Deng Ai, Zhuge Xu and Zhong Hui along several routes to attack Shu, and in the 11th month of that year the Later Ruler Liu Shan surrendered to Deng Ai at Chengdu. While Zhong Hui took Hanzhong and faced Jiang Wei at Jiange, Deng Ai passed from Yinping through more than 700 li of uninhabited land, entered Shu from the rear and beheaded Zhuge Zhan at Mianzhu. Jiang Wei and the others, on the Later Ruler's orders, surrendered to Zhong Hui, and Wei pacified all of Ba and Shu. Records, Wei 4 §124–125 · 127Records, Wei 28 §103 · 71–73 · 114–115

Chen Shou recorded this war in several places, including the Annals of the Three Young Emperors in Records of Wei 4, the biographies of Deng Ai and Zhong Hui in Records of Wei 28, the Biography of the Later Ruler in Records of Shu 3, the biography of Jiang Wei in Records of Shu 14, the biography of Zhuge Zhan in Records of Shu 5, and the biography of Qiao Zhou in Records of Shu 12. The Romance prepares the expedition at the end of Chapter 115, and from Chapter 116 to Chapter 118 depicts Zhong Hui's capture of Hanzhong and Zhuge Liang at Mount Dingjun, Deng Ai's crossing from Yinping and Zhuge Zhan's death in battle, and the death of Liu Chen, Prince of Beidi, and the Later Ruler's surrender. Records, Wei 4 §124–127Records, Wei 28 §67–73Records, Shu 3 §43–46Records, Shu 14 §43–47Records, Shu 5 §60–61Records, Shu 12 §67–69Romance, Ch. 115 §31–41Romance, Ch. 116 §1–45Romance, Ch. 117 §1–47Romance, Ch. 118 §1–19

Course of events in the Records

Because Jiang Wei repeatedly harassed the frontier, Sima Zhao judged that Shu was a small state with an exhausted people and wished to raise a great army; seeing that only Zhong Hui thought Shu could be attacked, he worked out the terrain together with him. In the winter of the 3rd year of Jingyuan (262) Zhong Hui was made General Who Guards the West and Commander of All Military Affairs in Guanzhong, and ships were built in various provinces as if to attack Wu. An edict of the 5th month of the 4th year (263) ordered Deng Ai to advance on Gansong and Tazhong to pin down Jiang Wei, the Inspector of Yong Province Zhuge Xu to attack him from front and rear together, and Zhong Hui to attack Shu by way of the Luo Valley. That autumn, by edict, Deng Ai and Zhuge Xu set out with over 30,000 men each, Zhuge Xu going to cut off Jiang Wei's way back, and Zhong Hui, with over 100,000, entered by the Xie Valley and the Luo Valley in separate columns, repairing the roads, and when a horse's hoof broke through a bridge he beheaded the General of the Standard Xu Yi. Records, Wei 28 §102–103Records, Wei 4 §124–125

Hearing that Zhong Hui was training troops in Guanzhong, Jiang Wei submitted a memorial proposing that Zhang Yi and Liao Hua be sent to guard the mouth of Yang'an Pass and the bridgehead at Yinping, but the eunuch Huang Hao, who trusted in spirits and shamans, said the enemy would not come and had the Later Ruler shelve the matter. Only when Zhong Hui was about to enter by the Luo Valley and Deng Ai by Tazhong were Liao Hua sent to Tazhong and Zhang Yi and Dong Jue to the mouth of Yang'an Pass. The Later Ruler changed the era name to Yanxing. Records, Shu 14 §43–44Records, Shu 3 §43

Shu had its various garrisons avoid battle and fall back to hold the two cities of Hancheng and Lecheng. Zhong Hui had Xun Kai besiege Hancheng and Li Fu besiege Lecheng, went out west by the Yang'an pass mouth, sent men to sacrifice at Zhuge Liang's tomb, and with Hu Lie and others in the lead broke the pass fort and obtained the grain in its storehouses. At the pass fort Jiang Shu opened the gates and came out to surrender, while Fu Qian fought and died. Zhong Hui attacked Lecheng but pressed on without taking it. Records, Wei 28 §104–105Records, Shu 14 §45

Jiang Wei at Tazhong, under attack by Wang Qi (王頎), Qian Hong and Yang Xin, sent by Deng Ai, withdrew on hearing that Zhong Hui had already entered Hanzhong. He was defeated by Yang Xin at Qiangchuankou, and when Zhuge Xu blocked the road, he entered the northern road from the Konghan Valley as if to come out behind Yong Province, making Zhuge Xu fall back thirty li, and then passed the bridgehead. At Yinping, hearing that the pass fort had fallen, he fell back to Baishui, joined Zhang Yi and Liao Hua, and held Jiange. Zhong Hui attacked Jiange but could not prevail, and since his grain transport was far extended, discussed going back. Records, Wei 28 §67–69 · 105Records, Shu 14 §45–46

Deng Ai reported that if he went from Yinping by a byway through the Deyang Pavilion of Han and came out at Fu (涪), he could stab the enemy in the belly at a point 100 li west of Jiange and some 300 li from Chengdu. Zhuge Xu declined his proposal to go together, saying it was not his original order, and joined Zhong Hui, but Zhong Hui secretly reported that Zhuge Xu was afraid and would not advance, had him recalled in a prisoner's cart, and took over his troops. In the 10th month Deng Ai went by the Yinping road through more than 700 li of uninhabited land, cutting through mountains and building bridges and plank roads, and he himself wrapped his body in a felt blanket and rolled down the slopes. When he reached Jiangyou (江由), the Shu garrison commander Ma Miao surrendered. Records, Wei 28 §69 · 71 · 113–114

Zhuge Zhan led his troops to Fu and stopped there, but when his vanguard was broken he fell back to Mianzhu and drew up his ranks. When Deng Ai sent a letter promising to have him made Prince of Langya if he surrendered, Zhuge Zhan beheaded the messenger. Deng Ai sent his son Deng Zhong and Shi Zuan out on the right and left, and when they came back saying the situation was unfavorable he was about to behead them; the two fought again and crushed the enemy. Zhuge Zhan died on the battlefield, and his eldest son Zhuge Shang and the Master of Writing Zhang Zun (張遵) and others died with him. Records, Shu 5 §60–61Records, Wei 28 §71–72

When Deng Ai came over Jiangyou (江由), Chengdu was thrown into great confusion, and the ministers' counsel was divided between fleeing to Wu and fleeing to Nanzhong. Qiao Zhou proposed surrendering to Wei, saying that no one had ever become Son of Heaven by relying on another state, and the Later Ruler followed his plan and had Zhang Shao (張紹), Qiao Zhou and Deng Liang carry the imperial seal and ribbons to ask for surrender. That day Liu Chen, Prince of Beidi, grieving at the fall of the state, killed his wife and children and then himself. When Deng Ai reached the north of the city, the Later Ruler came out to the camp gate bound, with a coffin carried along, and Deng Ai untied him, burned the coffin and, acting on imperial authority, made the Later Ruler General of Agile Cavalry. The Annals of the Three Young Emperors record that in this month Liu Shan, ruler of Shu, surrendered to Deng Ai and Ba and Shu were all pacified. Records, Shu 12 §67–69Records, Shu 3 §43 · 45–46Records, Wei 28 §73Records, Wei 4 §127

Hearing that Zhuge Zhan had been defeated, Jiang Wei and the others went east into Ba and advanced toward Guanghan and the Qi road to see how matters stood, but on receiving the Later Ruler's order they laid down their arms and surrendered to Zhong Hui at Fu. The officers and men were all so enraged that they drew their swords and hacked at the rocks. In the 12th month Wei made Deng Ai Grand Commandant and Zhong Hui Minister over the Masses. In the 1st month of the following year (264) Deng Ai was summoned in a prisoner's cart, and Zhong Hui rose in revolt at Chengdu and died. This was Zhong Hui's Rebellion. Records, Shu 14 §47Records, Wei 28 §114–115Records, Wei 4 §127–128

In the Romance

In Chapter 115 of the Romance, worried about Jiang Wei's military colonies at Tazhong, Sima Zhao makes Zhong Hui General Who Guards the West and Deng Ai General Who Conquers the West and has them attack Shu, and Zhong Hui, after building ships as if to attack Wu, sets out in the 7th month, in autumn, of the 4th year of Jingyuan. In Chapter 116 Zhong Hui enters Hanzhong by three routes with Xu Yi, son of Xu Chu, as vanguard, and Deng Ai sends Zhuge Xu, Wang Qi, Qian Hong and Yang Xin to attack Jiang Wei at Tazhong. In Chengdu the Later Ruler believes the words of a shaman brought in by Huang Hao and shelves Jiang Wei's memorial. Romance, Ch. 115 §31–41Romance, Ch. 116 §3–15

When a bridge collapses at Nanzheng Pass and he nearly dies, Zhong Hui beheads Xu Yi, and at Yang'an Pass, as Jiang Shu surrenders and Fu Qian dies fighting, he gains the pass. Meeting a whirlwind at Mount Dingjun, Zhong Hui sacrifices at Zhuge Liang's tomb, and on the instructions of Zhuge Liang, who appears to him in a dream, forbids the reckless killing of the people. Jiang Wei at Tazhong, pressed by Deng Ai and the others, hears that Hanzhong has fallen, shakes off Zhuge Xu by feigning an attack on Yong Province through the Konghan Valley, joins Zhang Yi and Liao Hua and goes to Jiange. Romance, Ch. 116 §15–45

In Chapter 117 Zhong Hui sends Zhuge Xu, defeated below Jiange, to Luoyang in a prisoner's cart and takes over his troops. Deng Ai proposes a plan to attack Chengdu by the byway from Yinping, and Zhong Hui scoffs at it. In the 10th month Deng Ai passes through more than 700 li of uninhabited land, wraps himself in a felt blanket and rolls down at Motianling, and bows on seeing a stele left by Zhuge Liang. Ma Miao of the city of Jiangyou surrenders, and his wife, Lady Li, hangs herself. When Deng Ai has taken the city of Fu, Zhuge Zhan opposes him with 70,000 men from Chengdu and, putting a wooden statue of Kongming at the front, twice defeats Deng Zhong and Shi Zuan, but he is beaten by Deng Ai's ambush and stabs himself in the throat at Mianzhu, and his son Zhuge Shang follows him in death. Romance, Ch. 117 §1–47

In Chapter 118 the Later Ruler, following Qiao Zhou's advice, sends Zhang Shao and Deng Liang to present the document of surrender and the imperial seal. Liu Chen, Prince of Beidi, after his wife Lady Cui dies first, kills his three sons, weeps bitterly at the temple of Emperor Zhaolie and cuts his own throat. The Later Ruler goes out of the north gate bound, with a coffin carried along, and surrenders, and Deng Ai makes him General of Agile Cavalry. The generals at Jiange hack at the rocks with their swords and vent their indignation, and Jiang Wei surrenders to Zhong Hui, harboring a plan to restore the house of Han. Romance, Ch. 118 §1–19

Where the Romance differs

Date of departure and strength: The Romance says Zhong Hui set out on the 3rd day of the 7th month, in autumn, of the 4th year of Jingyuan with over 100,000 men, and has Sima Zhao say he will give Zhong Hui 200,000 or 300,000 picked troops of Guanzhong. Chen Shou's text records that by an edict that autumn Deng Ai and Zhuge Xu each led over 30,000 men and Zhong Hui over 100,000. Romance, Ch. 115 §37 · 40Romance, Ch. 116 §5Records, Wei 28 §103

Zhuge Liang at Mount Dingjun: In Chapter 116 of the Romance, Zhong Hui, frightened by a whirlwind and by Zhuge Liang appearing in a dream, offers sacrifices and raises a banner reading "Protect the State and Pacify the People." In Chen Shou's text, as Zhong Hui went out by the Yang'an pass mouth he sent men to sacrifice at Zhuge Liang's tomb and forbade his soldiers to cut fodder or gather firewood around the tomb. Romance, Ch. 116 §26–32Records, Wei 28 §105Records, Shu 5 §43

Ma Miao: In Chapter 117 of the Romance, Ma Miao surrenders after being rebuked by his wife, Lady Li, and Lady Li hangs herself. Chen Shou's text says only that when Deng Ai reached the city, the Shu garrison commander Ma Miao surrendered. Romance, Ch. 117 §20–23Records, Wei 28 §71

Mianzhu: In the Romance, Zhuge Zhan twice defeats the Wei army with a wooden statue of Kongming and asks Eastern Wu for help, then, struck by an arrow, stabs himself in the throat. In Chen Shou's text, Zhuge Zhan stopped at Fu and fell back to Mianzhu when his vanguard was broken; Deng Zhong and Shi Zuan were at first at a disadvantage but fought again and won a great victory, and Zhuge Zhan died on the battlefield. Romance, Ch. 117 §33–44Records, Shu 5 §61Records, Wei 28 §72

Liu Chen, Prince of Beidi: Chapter 118 of the Romance depicts the scene in which Lady Cui first dashes her head against a pillar and dies, and Liu Chen kills his three sons and then weeps bitterly at the temple of Emperor Zhaolie and dies. The Biography of the Later Ruler in Chen Shou's text records in a single line that Liu Chen, grieving at the fall of the state, first killed his wife and children and then himself. Romance, Ch. 118 §9–11Records, Shu 3 §46

Jiang Wei's surrender: In the Romance, Jiang Wei surrenders to Zhong Hui harboring a plan to restore the house of Han. In Chen Shou's text, Jiang Wei, on receiving the Later Ruler's order, laid down his arms and surrendered to Zhong Hui at Fu, and his officers and men hacked at the rocks with their swords in indignation. Romance, Ch. 118 §17–19Records, Shu 14 §47

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Belligerents

ItemAB
FactionsWeiShu
CommandersDeng Ai, Sima Zhao, Zhong Hui, Zhuge Xu, Hu Lie, Wang Qi(王頎), Qian Hong, Yang Xin, Tian Zhang, Deng Zhong, Shi Zuan, Xun Kai, Li Fu(李輔)Jiang Wei, Liao Hua, Zhuge Zhan, Zhang Yi(張翼), Dong Jue, Jiang Bin, Wang Han, Fu Qian, Zhang Zun
Strength鄧艾、諸葛緒各統諸軍三萬餘人 · 會統十餘萬眾

Factions, commanders, strength and casualties are checked against the source texts (3KDEX). Strength and casualties show only figures stated in the sources. Source: Wei 4 §127

Sub-events and Romance scenes (5)

Romance chapters (4)

Records volumes (6)