Zhuge Xu 諸葛緒

RecordsRomance Wei 제갈서诸葛绪

Profile
OccupationRNGeneral · Inspector of Yong ProvinceFactionWei
AppearsRNBiography in
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR9

Profile

Zhuge Xu served Wei as Administrator of Taishan and Inspector of Yong Province. The Records has no separate biography of him, and neither his courtesy name nor his place of origin is recorded. After Guanqiu Jian rose in revolt, when the Wu army was about to cross the river, he was sent by Deng Ai to resist at Lijiang and fought the enemy until they fled. Records, Wei 28 §62

In the 4th year of Jingyuan (263), when Wei attacked Shu, he led more than 30,000 men from various armies as Inspector of Yong Province with the task of cutting off Jiang Wei's way home, but he missed Jiang Wei, who slipped past Qiaotou, by one day. When Deng Ai proposed that they go together by a byway from Yinping, he refused because it was not in his original edict and joined Zhong Hui; but Zhong Hui, who wanted the command of the army for himself, secretly reported that he was afraid and would not advance, and he was recalled in a prisoner's cart. Records, Wei 28 §103 · 68 · 113–114

Chen Shou did not mention him in his assessment in volume 28. In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 116 as the Inspector of Yong Province summoned by Deng Ai and appears in 2 of its 120 chapters; no chapter title bears his name. Records, Wei 28 §140Romance, Ch. 116 §6

In the Records

After the Duke of Gaogui Village came to the throne, Guanqiu Jian rose in revolt and was defeated, and Wen Qin fled to Wu; then the Wu General-in-Chief Sun Jun and others, claiming a host of 100,000, were about to cross the Yangtze. Zhuge Dan, General Who Guards the East, sent Deng Ai to occupy Feiyang, but Deng Ai, judging it too far from the enemy to be a strategic point, moved to encamp at Futing and sent Zhuge Xu, Administrator of Taishan, and others to resist at Lijiang, and in the end they drove the enemy off. Records, Wei 28 §62

In the 5th month, in summer, of the 4th year of Jingyuan (263), an edict ordered Deng Ai, General Who Conquers the West, to oversee various armies and go to Gansong and Tazhong to capture Jiang Wei, and Zhuge Xu, Inspector of Yong Province, to oversee various armies and go to Wudu and Gaolou to attack him from front and rear. Once Jiang Wei was captured, they were to advance side by side from east and west and sweep away Ba and Shu. Zhong Hui, General Who Guards the West, was ordered to attack Shu by way of the Luo Valley. Records, Wei 4 §123–125

That autumn an edict put Deng Ai and Zhuge Xu each in command of more than 30,000 men from various armies; Deng Ai was to advance to Gansong and Tazhong to pin Jiang Wei down, and Zhuge Xu to advance to Wujie and Qiaotou to cut off Jiang Wei's way home. The General-in-Chief Sima Zhao directed them all and issued their orders, and Zhong Hui, with a host of over 100,000, entered by the Xie and Luo Valleys in separate columns. The proclamation Zhong Hui sent to Shu also said that the armies of the General Who Conquers the West, of Yong Province and of the General Who Guards the West were advancing side by side along five routes. The Biography of the Later Sovereign of Shu records that in the summer of that year Wei ordered Deng Ai, General Who Conquers the West, Zhong Hui, General Who Guards the West, and Zhuge Xu, Inspector of Yong Province, to attack together along several routes. Records, Wei 28 §67 · 103 · 107Records, Shu 3 §43

In Shu, Zhang Yi, General of Chariots and Cavalry of the Left, Dong Jue, General-in-Chief Who Supports the State, and others were sent to the mouth of Yang'an Pass to support the various strongholds from outside; when they reached Yinping, they heard that the Wei commander Zhuge Xu was heading for Jianwei, and halted there to wait. Records, Shu 14 §44

Jiang Wei withdrew on hearing that Zhong Hui's armies had already entered Hanzhong. Defeated by Yang Xin and others at Qiangchuankou, Jiang Wei heard that the Yong Province army had already blocked the road and was encamped at Qiaotou, and tried to enter the northern road from the Konghan Valley to come out behind the Yong Province army. Hearing of this, Zhuge Xu fell back 30 li. Jiang Wei went more than 30 li along the northern road, then, hearing that Zhuge Xu's army had fallen back, promptly turned around and passed by Qiaotou. Zhuge Xu hurried to cut Jiang Wei off but was one day too late. Records, Wei 28 §68

Deng Ai pursued Jiang Wei to Yinping and, choosing picked troops, planned to go from Handeyang by the road through Jiangyou (江由) and Zuodan to Mianzhu and advance on Chengdu, and wanted Zhuge Xu to go with him. Zhuge Xu, saying that his original orders were to intercept Jiang Wei and that going west was not in his original edict, led his army forward to Baishui and joined Zhong Hui. Records, Wei 28 §113

The armies of Zhong Hui and Zhuge Xu headed for Jiange. Zhong Hui, wanting the command of the army for himself, secretly reported that Zhuge Xu was afraid and would not advance, and Zhuge Xu was recalled in a prisoner's cart. His troops all came under Zhong Hui. Chen Shou's main text records nothing further about Zhuge Xu, and he did not mention him in his assessment in volume 28 either. Records, Wei 28 §114 · 140

In the Romance

In Chapter 116 of the Romance, Deng Ai, in Longxi, receives the edict to attack Shu, has Sima Wang hold off the Qiang, and sends word to Zhuge Xu, Inspector of Yong Province, Wang Qi, Administrator of Tianshui, Qian Hong, Administrator of Longxi, and Yang Xin, Administrator of Jincheng, to bring the troops under their command and come to take orders. When Zhong Hui's proclamation arrives, Deng Ai has Zhuge Xu lead 15,000 troops to cut off Jiang Wei's way home in advance. Romance, Ch. 116 §6 · 8

In the same chapter, when Deng Ai's troops arrive behind him, Jiang Wei tries to retake Hanzhong, but receives a report that Zhuge Xu, Inspector of Yong Province, has already cut off his way back. The Wei army is encamped at the head of the Yinping bridge. When Jiang Wei, following the plan of his lieutenant Ning Sui, enters the Konghan Valley and pretends to attack Yong Province, Zhuge Xu is greatly alarmed and says, 'Yong Province is the land I am bound to defend; if anything goes wrong, the court will surely hold me guilty.' He pulls in his main army and goes by the southern road to save Yong Province, leaving only one detachment at the bridgehead. Romance, Ch. 116 §40–42

Jiang Wei goes about 30 li along the northern road, then turns his troops around, scatters the troops guarding the bridgehead and burns their camp and palisades. Zhuge Xu hears that fire has broken out at the bridgehead and comes back, but Jiang Wei's troops passed half a day earlier, and he dares not pursue. Romance, Ch. 116 §42–43

In Chapter 117, while Jiang Wei is talking with Dong Jue at Jiange, Zhuge Xu leads his troops in an attack right up to the foot of the pass. Jiang Wei comes down with 5,000 troops and charges back and forth through the Wei ranks, and Zhuge Xu, badly defeated, falls back several dozen li and pitches camp. Romance, Ch. 117 §1–2

Zhuge Xu comes of his own accord to Zhong Hui, who has pitched camp 20 li from Jiange, and asks to be punished. Zhong Hui rebukes him: he was told to hold the bridgehead at Yinping and cut off Jiang Wei's way home but let him slip, and now he has again sent out troops on his own without orders and been defeated. Zhuge Xu answers that Jiang Wei got away while he went to save Yong Province because Jiang Wei pretended to attack it, and that he pursued him to the foot of the pass and was defeated again. When Zhong Hui orders him beheaded, the Army Supervisor Wei Guan objects that Zhuge Xu is a man under the command of General Deng, the General Who Conquers the West, and that killing him would harm good relations, and everyone else urges against it as well. Zhong Hui sends Zhuge Xu to Luoyang in a prisoner's cart to be dealt with by the Duke of Jin and takes the troops he commanded under his own command. Hearing of this, Deng Ai is furious. Romance, Ch. 117 §3–5

Where the Romance differs

The fight at Lijiang: In the Romance, Zhuge Xu first appears in Chapter 116 already as Inspector of Yong Province, and nothing from his time as Administrator of Taishan is included. In the Biography of Deng Ai in the Records, when the Wu army was about to cross the Yangtze after Guanqiu Jian's revolt, Zhuge Xu, Administrator of Taishan, and others, on Deng Ai's orders, resisted at Lijiang and drove the enemy off. Romance, Ch. 116 §6Records, Wei 28 §62

Chain of command: In Chapter 116 of the Romance, Deng Ai receives the edict, summons Zhuge Xu to take his orders and gives him 15,000 troops to cut off the road, and in Chapter 117 Wei Guan also calls him a man under Deng Ai's command. In the Records, the edict put Deng Ai and Zhuge Xu each in command of more than 30,000 men from various armies and assigned each a different route, and the direction and orders came from the General-in-Chief Sima Zhao. Romance, Ch. 116 §8Romance, Ch. 117 §4Records, Wei 28 §67 · 103

How Jiang Wei got away: In Chapter 116 of the Romance, Zhuge Xu, alarmed that he might lose Yong Province, goes by the southern road to save it, and by the time he returns half a day has passed and he dares not pursue. In the Records, when Jiang Wei tried to come out behind the Yong Province army by the northern road, Zhuge Xu fell back 30 li, and when Jiang Wei turned back and passed by Qiaotou, he hurried to cut him off but was one day too late. Romance, Ch. 116 §42–43Records, Wei 28 §68

Deng Ai's proposal: In the Romance, Deng Ai does not ask Zhuge Xu to go with him. In the Records, Deng Ai, planning to advance from Yinping by a byway to Mianzhu and Chengdu, wanted Zhuge Xu to go with him, but Zhuge Xu said that going west was not in his original edict, advanced to Baishui and joined Zhong Hui. Romance, Ch. 117 §2–5Records, Wei 28 §113

The fight at Jiange: In Chapter 117 of the Romance, Zhuge Xu attacks right up to the foot of the pass at Jiange and is badly defeated by Jiang Wei. The Records says only that the armies of Zhong Hui and Zhuge Xu headed for Jiange, and has no record of Zhuge Xu fighting Jiang Wei and being defeated. Romance, Ch. 117 §2Records, Wei 28 §114

Why he was put in a prisoner's cart: In Chapter 117 of the Romance, when Zhuge Xu comes of his own accord to ask for punishment, Zhong Hui is about to behead him for sending out troops without orders and being defeated, but at the urging of Wei Guan and others sends him to Luoyang in a prisoner's cart instead. In the Records, Zhong Hui, wanting the command of the army for himself, secretly reported that Zhuge Xu was afraid and would not advance, and Zhuge Xu was recalled in a prisoner's cart. Romance, Ch. 117 §3–4Records, Wei 28 §114

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA4835−13
  • STR3838±0
  • INT3025−5
  • POL4240−2
  • CHA3838±0
  • VIR5245−7
  • ADP3030±0
  • SCH3533−2
  • DIP3538+3
  • DIS3838±0
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

LeadershipR48N35 −13

RDrove the Wu army off at Lijiang, but missed Jiang Wei by one dayWei 28 §62Wei 28 §68

NLet Jiang Wei slip away, then went to the foot of the pass on his own and was badly defeatedCh. 116 §43Ch. 117 §2

9 similar abilities — show evidence
  • StrengthR38UnverifiedN38Unverified ±0

    RNo direct record — estimated from his career as a military commanderWei 28 §62

    NNo direct record — estimated from his being a military commanderCh. 117 §2

  • IntelligenceR30N25 −5

    RWhen Jiang Wei entered the northern road, fell back 30 li and let him throughWei 28 §68

    NLeft the bridgehead empty, fooled by Jiang Wei's feint against Yong ProvinceCh. 116 §42Ch. 116 §43

  • PoliticsR42UnverifiedN40Unverified −2

    RNo direct record — estimated from his office as Inspector of Yong ProvinceWei 4 §125

    NNo direct record — estimated from his office as Inspector of Yong ProvinceCh. 116 §8

  • CharismaR38UnverifiedN38Unverified ±0

    RNo direct record — a record of commanding more than 30,000 menWei 28 §103

    NNo direct record — a record of leading 15,000 troopsCh. 116 §8

  • VirtueR52N45Unverified −7

    RKept to his original orders and refused to go west, which was not in the edictWei 28 §113

    NNo direct record — a record of coming of his own accord to ask for punishmentCh. 117 §3

  • AdaptabilityR30N30 ±0

    RRecalled in a prisoner's cart after Zhong Hui slandered him as afraidWei 28 §114

    NWent to ask for punishment, was sent to Luoyang in a prisoner's cart and lost his troopsCh. 117 §3Ch. 117 §4

  • ScholarshipR35UnverifiedN33Unverified −2

    RNo direct record — estimated from his being a military commanderWei 28 §62

    NNo direct record — estimated from his being a military commanderCh. 116 §8

  • DiplomacyR35UnverifiedN38 +3

    RNo direct record — estimated from his careerWei 28 §113

    NPleaded that he feared losing Yong Province, but Zhong Hui did not accept itCh. 117 §3

  • DiscernmentR38UnverifiedN38Unverified ±0

    RNo direct record — estimated from his careerWei 28 §62

    NNo direct record — estimated from his careerCh. 116 §8

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (2)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Allegiance history

  1. Wei · Romance · Romance ch. 116 「又遣雍州刺史诸葛绪」 · Q124695435

Related events (1)

Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).