Battle
Jiang Wei's Northern Expeditions 姜維北伐
About this event
Jiang Wei's Northern Expeditions is the name given to the series of campaigns in which Jiang Wei of Shu-Han repeatedly advanced into the Longxi region of Wei after Zhuge Liang's death. In Chen Shou's text, Jiang Wei went out to Longxi in the 1st year of Zhengshi (240) and thereafter sought to draw in the Qiang and Hu and cut off and take the land west of Long; in the 18th year of Yanxi (255) he inflicted a crushing defeat on Wang Jing, Wei's Inspector of Yong Province, at Taoxi, but the following year he was heavily defeated by Deng Ai at Duangu. After going out to Houhe in the 5th year of Jingyao (262) and again being beaten by Deng Ai, Jiang Wei stayed on at Tazhong, and the following year Wei sent Deng Ai and Zhong Hui to attack Shu. Records, Wei 26 §71Records, Shu 14 §34 · 37–38 · 43Records, Wei 4 §124–125
Chen Shou recorded these campaigns in Jiang Wei's biography in Records of Shu 14 and in the Biography of the Later Sovereign in Records of Shu 3, and also spread them across the Annals of the Three Young Emperors in Records of Wei 4, the biographies of Chen Tai, Guo Huai and Deng Ai, and the biographies of Zhang Ni and Zhang Yi in the Records of Shu. The Romance portrays the repeated northern expeditions from Chapter 107, where Jiang Wei advances to Mount Qu after Xiahou Ba's surrender, through to the military farms at Tazhong in Chapter 115, and in Chapter 115 Jiang Wei says that this is his eighth campaign against Wei. Records, Shu 14 §33–48Records, Shu 3 §29–42Records, Wei 4 §57–58Records, Wei 22 §39–50Records, Wei 26 §71–77Records, Wei 28 §54–66Records, Shu 13 §63Records, Shu 15 §15Romance, Ch. 107 §38–42Romance, Ch. 115 §4 · 28–30
Course of events in the Records
After Zhuge Liang's death, Jiang Wei followed the General-in-Chief Jiang Wan to be stationed at Hanzhong in the 1st year of Yanxi (238), and as Jiang Wan's Major (sima) he several times led detached forces westward. Guo Huai's biography in Records of Wei 26 records that in the 1st year of Zhengshi (240) Jiang Wei went out to Longxi but withdrew when Guo Huai pursued him as far as Qiangzhong. In the 10th year of Yanxi (247) Jiang Wei went out to the borders of Longxi, Nan'an and Jincheng and fought Wei's Guo Huai and Xiahou Ba at Taoxi, and the Hu king Zhi Wudai and others surrendered with their tribes. Guo Huai's biography records that around this time Jiang Wei attacked Weichi, held by Xiahou Ba, but withdrew when Guo Huai arrived, and that later, when he went out to Shiying to meet Zhi Wudai, he left Liao Hua at Mount Chengzhong to build a fortress, but when Guo Huai attacked Liao Hua he hurried back to rescue him. Records, Shu 14 §33–34Records, Wei 26 §71–76
Jiang Wei, considering himself well versed in the customs of the west and confident in his talent and martial prowess, believed that if he made the various Qiang and Hu his wings, the land west of Long could be cut off and taken. But Fei Yi always held him back, and the troops he was given never exceeded 10,000 men. Jiang Wei's biography says that in the 12th year of Yanxi (249) he was granted the Tally (jiajie) and went out to Xiping but did not prevail, while the Biography of the Later Sovereign records that in the autumn of that year he attacked Yong Province without success, that the generals Gou An and Li Shao surrendered to Wei, and that in the 13th year he went out to Xiping. According to Chen Tai's biography, Jiang Wei built two forts on Mount Qu and had Gou An and Li Xin hold them, but Chen Tai surrounded the forts, cut off their supply route and the water outside the walls, and moved to block the line of retreat of Jiang Wei, who had come to the rescue by way of Mount Niutou; Jiang Wei fled and Gou An and the others surrendered. Guo Huai's biography places this in the 1st year of Jiaping (249). Records, Shu 14 §34–35Records, Shu 3 §29–30Records, Wei 22 §39–41Records, Wei 26 §77
When Fei Yi died in the spring of the 16th year of Yanxi (253), that summer Jiang Wei led tens of thousands of men out to Shiying and by way of Dongting besieged Nan'an, but when Wei's Inspector of Yong Province, Chen Tai, came as far as Luomen, Jiang Wei's provisions ran out and he withdrew. In the 6th month of the following year he went out to Longxi again, and Li Jian, Chief of Didao County, surrendered with his city; Jiang Wei besieged Xiangwu, clashed with the Wei general Xu Zhi and defeated him. In this battle Zhang Ni of Shu went into the battle line and lost his life. Jiang Wei returned bringing with him the people of the three counties of Heguan, Didao and Lintao. Records, Shu 14 §36Records, Shu 3 §33–34Records, Shu 13 §63
In the 18th year of Yanxi (255), when Jiang Wei again proposed sending out the army, Zhang Yi alone argued against it at court, saying that the state was small and the people weary, but Jiang Wei would not listen; taking Zhang Yi, Xiahou Ba and others, he went out to Didao and inflicted a crushing defeat on Wei's Inspector of Yong Province, Wang Jing, at Taoxi. Jiang Wei's biography says that in this Battle of Didao tens of thousands of Wang Jing's men died, Zhang Yi's biography says that those who died in the Tao River were counted by the ten thousand, and in the 10th month of that year an edict of the Wei emperor said that the officers and men who died numbered in the thousands. Zhang Yi said that it was now time to stop, but Jiang Wei besieged Wang Jing, who had fallen back into the city of Didao. Records, Shu 15 §15Records, Shu 14 §37Records, Wei 4 §57–58
Chen Tai rejected the advice of Deng Ai and others to hold the passes and wait for an opening, crossed the Gaocheng Ridge, and by night reached the high hills southeast of Didao, where he lit beacon fires and sounded drums and horns. At this sudden relief Jiang Wei's army was greatly alarmed; Jiang Wei came at him along the hills and was driven back, and on hearing that Chen Tai meant to head for his line of retreat together with Wang Jing, he fled and halted at Zhongti. Records, Wei 22 §44–50Records, Shu 14 §37
In the spring of the 19th year of Yanxi (256) Jiang Wei, now General-in-Chief, arranged to meet the General-in-Chief Who Guards the West Hu Ji at Shanggui, but Hu Ji did not come. Deng Ai's biography records that Jiang Wei headed for Mount Qi, but on finding that Deng Ai was prepared he turned from Dongting toward Nan'an; failing to win the contest for the strongpoints at Mount Wucheng, he crossed the Wei River by night and was making for Shanggui when he was heavily defeated at Duangu. The Biography of the Later Sovereign records it as an event of the 8th month, in autumn. A great many died, the people grumbled and the land west of Long was in turmoil, so Jiang Wei acknowledged his fault and asked to be demoted himself, and as General of the Rear he acted in the office of General-in-Chief. Records, Shu 14 §38Records, Wei 28 §65Records, Shu 3 §36
In the 20th year of Yanxi (257), when Wei's Zhuge Dan rebelled in Huainan and the troops of Guanzhong were sent east, Jiang Wei led tens of thousands of men out through the Luo Valley and reached Shenling Ridge. Changcheng had large stores of grain and few defenders, but Sima Wang and Deng Ai encamped at Changcheng, and although Jiang Wei, who had set up camp against the hills on the Mang River, offered battle many times, they held firm beside the Wei River and did not respond. In the 1st year of Jingyao (258), on hearing that Zhuge Dan had been defeated, Jiang Wei returned to Chengdu. Records, Shu 14 §39–40Records, Wei 28 §66
In the 5th year of Jingyao (262) Jiang Wei went out to Houhe, was defeated by Deng Ai, and returned to stay at Tazhong; the Annals of the Three Young Emperors record this as Deng Ai defeating him at Houhe when he raided Taoyang in the 10th month of the 3rd year of Jingyuan (262). When the eunuch Huang Hao secretly sought to remove Jiang Wei and set up Yan Yu in his place, Jiang Wei felt himself in danger and never returned to Chengdu again. The following year, saying that Jiang Wei was farming at Tazhong and harshly exploiting the Qiang, Wei sent Deng Ai, Zhuge Xu and Zhong Hui to attack Shu. Records, Shu 14 §43Records, Wei 4 §122 · 124–125
Chen Shou assessed that Jiang Wei possessed a rough measure of both civil and military ability and was set on achieving merit and fame, but that he handled his forces lightly and used his army recklessly, and his clear judgment did not reach far enough, so that in the end he came to his death; and he asked how a tiny, insignificant state could be disturbed so often. Zhang Yi was praised for having stood up to Jiang Wei's sharp momentum. Records, Shu 14 §52Records, Shu 15 §85
In the Romance
In Chapter 107 of the Romance, Jiang Wei, having welcomed Xiahou Ba, who had surrendered after being defeated by Guo Huai and Chen Tai, asks the Later Sovereign to let him recover the Central Plains, and despite Fei Yi's attempts to dissuade him he marches out, saying that by joining hands with the Qiang he can cut off and take the land west of Long. When the two forts on Mount Qu are surrounded by Chen Tai and their water supply cut off, Jiang Wei tries to circle round by Mount Niutou and strike at the rear of Yong Province but is blocked by Chen Tai, and when Guo Huai seizes the Tao River and cuts his supply route, he suffers a heavy defeat and falls back to Yangping Pass. Romance, Ch. 107 §32–34 · 38–53
In Chapter 109 Jiang Wei joins hands with Midang, King of the Qiang, and marches out again, lures the Wei general Xu Zhi into a trap and kills him, and traps Sima Zhao on Mount Tielong. But when Chen Tai and Guo Huai crush the Qiang troops by a feigned surrender and attack with the captured Midang at their head, Jiang Wei flees without even a weapon, catches in his hand an arrow shot by Guo Huai and shoots it back, killing him. In Chapter 110 Jiang Wei draws up his army with its back to the Tao River and crushes Wang Jing, but after besieging the city of Didao he takes fright at the false banners and drumbeats that Chen Tai and Deng Ai have set out in the mountain valleys, and withdraws. Romance, Ch. 109 §1–2 · 7–11 · 16–23Romance, Ch. 110 §34–37 · 40–43
In Chapter 111 Deng Ai prepares after listing five reasons why the Shu army will come out again, and Jiang Wei, trying to take Nan'an by surprise, is blocked at Mount Wucheng and, heading for Shanggui, falls into an ambush at Duangu and suffers a heavy defeat. Zhang Ni plunges into the encirclement to rescue Jiang Wei and is killed by arrows, and Jiang Wei demotes himself to General of the Rear. In Chapter 112, taking advantage of Zhuge Dan's uprising, he passes through the Luo Valley, presses Changcheng hard and crosses arms with Deng Ai's son Deng Zhong, but while Deng Ai holds firm, news comes that Zhuge Dan is dead and Jiang Wei withdraws. Romance, Ch. 111 §2–3 · 8–22Romance, Ch. 112 §23 · 28–40
In Chapter 113 Jiang Wei withstands Deng Ai's tunnel raid at Mount Qi and traps Deng Ai in the Long Snake Coiling the Ground Formation, a variation of the Eight Formations, but when Dang Jun, sent by Deng Ai, conspires with Huang Hao to spread word that Jiang Wei means to surrender to Wei, the Later Sovereign recalls him. In Chapter 114 he marches out, taking as his cause Sima Zhao's murder of Cao Mao, alters the letter of Wang Guan, who had feigned surrender, and so lures Deng Ai into Tanshan Valley and defeats him, but when Wang Guan burns the supply carts and the plank roads, Jiang Wei returns to Hanzhong. Romance, Ch. 113 §23–32 · 41–43Romance, Ch. 114 §23–38
In Chapter 115 Jiang Wei, saying that this is his eighth campaign against Wei, goes out to Taoyang, but Xiahou Ba, entering Taoyang, which has been made to look like an empty city, is killed by arrows, and Jiang Wei too is beaten by Deng Ai at Hou He (侯河). While Jiang Wei is besieging Mount Qi, the Later Sovereign, heeding Huang Hao and Yan Yu, recalls him, and does not accept Jiang Wei's plea that Huang Hao be put to death. On Xi Zheng's advice that disaster is not far off, Jiang Wei goes to Tazhong and sets up military farms there. Romance, Ch. 115 §3–11 · 19–30
Where the Romance differs
Guo Huai's death: In Chapter 109 of the Romance, Guo Huai dies after being hit in the face by the arrow Jiang Wei shot back. In Guo Huai's biography in the Records, Guo Huai died in the 2nd year of Zhengyuan (255) and was posthumously made General-in-Chief. Romance, Ch. 109 §22–23Records, Wei 26 §78
Xu Zhi and Zhang Ni: In Chapter 109 of the Romance, Xu Zhi falls into Jiang Wei's ambush and is killed, and in Chapter 111 Zhang Ni is killed by arrows at Duangu while rescuing Jiang Wei. In the Records, Jiang Wei besieged Xiangwu in the 17th year of Yanxi (254) and clashed with and defeated Xu Zhi, and Zhang Ni went into the battle line and lost his life in that very fight with Xu Zhi. Romance, Ch. 109 §10Romance, Ch. 111 §21Records, Shu 14 §36Records, Shu 13 §63
The defeat at Duangu: In Chapter 111 of the Romance, Jiang Wei is defeated after falling into the ambush Deng Ai has hidden at Duangu. Jiang Wei's biography in the Records records that Hu Ji, who was to meet him at Shanggui, broke the agreement and did not come, and Jiang Wei was defeated by Deng Ai at Duangu. Romance, Ch. 111 §12–14 · 18–19Records, Shu 14 §38
The fighting at Changcheng: In Chapter 112 of the Romance, the Shu army defeats the Wei forces at Changcheng and all but takes the city with fire arrows and brushwood, and Jiang Wei crosses arms with Deng Zhong. In the Records, Jiang Wei set up camp against the hills on the Mang River and offered battle many times, but Sima Wang and Deng Ai held firm beside the Wei River and did not respond. Romance, Ch. 112 §30–36Records, Shu 14 §40
Why Jiang Wei farmed at Tazhong: In Chapter 115 of the Romance, Jiang Wei asks for Huang Hao to be put to death, and when this is refused he sets up military farms at Tazhong on Xi Zheng's advice. In Jiang Wei's biography in the Records, Jiang Wei was defeated by Deng Ai at Houhe in the 5th year of Jingyao (262) and stayed on at Tazhong, and when Huang Hao secretly sought to remove him, he felt himself in danger and did not return to Chengdu. Romance, Ch. 115 §24–30Records, Shu 14 §43
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
Belligerents
| Item | A | B |
|---|---|---|
| Factions | Shu | Wei |
| Commanders | Jiang Wei, Liao Hua, Zhang Yi(張翼), Xiahou Ba, Zhang Ni, Gou An(句安), Li Xin | Chen Tai, Deng Ai, Guo Huai, Xiahou Ba, Wang Jing, Sima Wang, Xu Zhi(徐質) |
Factions, commanders, strength and casualties are checked against the source texts (3KDEX). Strength and casualties show only figures stated in the sources. Source: Shu 14 §43
Sub-events and Romance scenes (6)
- Jiang Wei Defeated at Mount Niutou 249
- Battle of Qucheng 249
- Battle of Didao 255
- Battle of Duangu 256
- Jiang Wei Fights Fiercely at Changcheng 257~258
- Jiang Wei Defeats Deng Ai in Battle Formation 258