Sima Shi 司馬師

RecordsRomance Wei Ziyuan사마사자원子元司马师

Profile
OccupationRNGeneral · General-in-ChiefFactionWei
AppearsRNBiography in
BornR? N? UnverifiedNative placeHenei Commandery Wen County Unverified
DiedR255 N(same) UnverifiedPlace of deathRNXuchang County
Cause of deathNIllness Unverified
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR70

Profile

Sima Shi was a General-in-Chief of Wei who assisted in governing the state. Chen Shou's main text does not give his courtesy name or origin and usually calls him "Sima Jingwang" (Sima, King Jing) or "Jingwang"; the Romance introduces him as the eldest son of Sima Yi, with the courtesy name Ziyuan. Records, Wei 4 §33–34Records, Wei 28 §58Romance, Ch. 94 §38

In the 3rd year of Jiaping (251) he became General-in-Chief Who Pacifies the Army and Intendant of the Affairs of the Imperial Secretariat (lu shangshu shi), and the following year he rose to General-in-Chief. In the 6th year of Jiaping (254) he crushed the plot of Li Feng and others to kill him, and in the 9th month of that year he reported to the Empress Dowager on deposing the emperor Cao Fang, after which Cao Mao, Duke of Gaogui Village, was enthroned. When Guanqiu Jian and Wen Qin rebelled in the first month of the 2nd year of Zhengyuan (255), he marched against them in person and defeated them, and then died at Xuchang. Records, Wei 4 §33–34 · 44–49 · 54–55Records, Wei 9 §123–124

Chen Shou's Records of the Three Kingdoms contains neither a biography of Sima Shi nor any assessment of him by Chen Shou, so his deeds are scattered across the imperial annals and various biographies. In the Romance his name first appears in a later poet's verse in Chapter 78; he first appears in person in Chapter 94 and features in 11 of its 120 chapters. No chapter title bears his name, but 'Deposing Cao Fang' in the title of Chapter 109 refers to his deed, and he dies in Chapter 110. Records, Wei 4 §33Records, Wei 9 §122Records, Wei 28 §21Romance, Ch. 78 §25Romance, Ch. 94 §38Romance, Ch. 109 §38–40Romance, Ch. 110 §27

In the Records

In Chen Shou's main text Sima Shi's deeds appear from the 3rd year of Jiaping (251). On the wuyin day of the 7th month of that year, when the Grand Tutor Sima Xuanwang died, Sima Jingwang, then General of the Guards, became General-in-Chief Who Pacifies the Army and Intendant of the Affairs of the Imperial Secretariat, and on the guimao day of the first month of the following year he became General-in-Chief. His younger sister was the wife of Xun Yi, so the brothers Sima Jingwang and Sima Wenwang were on friendly terms with Xun Yi; they were also close friends of Chen Tai. Records, Wei 4 §33–34Records, Wei 10 §49Records, Wei 22 §55

When Sima Jingwang newly took charge of the government, Wang Ji wrote to him urging him to be cautious and diligent, and named Xu Yun, Fu Gu, Yuan Kan and Cui Zan as upright gentlemen with whom he could share the conduct of affairs. Jingwang accepted his advice. He also adopted many of Deng Ai's proposals, including gradually moving the Qiang and Hu out from among the people. Records, Wei 27 §59Records, Wei 28 §58

In the winter of the 4th year of Jiaping (252), the year he became General-in-Chief, an edict ordered Wang Chang, Hu Zun, Guanqiu Jian and others to attack Wu, but in the 12th month they were heavily defeated by Zhuge Ke at Dongguan and returned. The imperial annals do not record his name in this campaign. The following year, when Zhuge Ke besieged the New City of Hefei, failed to take it and withdrew, Deng Ai told Jingwang that since Zhuge Ke had mobilized the whole host of his state and been thwarted beneath a strong city, his downfall need only be awaited. Zhuge Ke did indeed return home and was put to death. Records, Wei 4 §34–35Records, Wei 28 §59–60

In the 2nd month of the 6th year of Jiaping (254), the Prefect of the Palace Secretariat (zhongshu ling) Li Feng, although he had long enjoyed the affection and favor of the General-in-Chief Sima Jingwang, was privately devoted to Xiahou Xuan. He colluded with Zhang Ji, the Empress's father, plotting to kill the General-in-Chief on the day a Noble Lady was to be invested and replace him with Xiahou Xuan. Li Feng drew in the eunuchs by telling them that the General-in-Chief was stern and resolute and had repeatedly spoken of their lawlessness in the palace. The General-in-Chief caught wind of the plot, invited Li Feng to see him, and killed him on the spot when he came unsuspecting. Records, Wei 9 §122–124

Xiahou Xuan, Zhang Ji and the others were handed over to the Commandant of Justice, and the Commandant of Justice Zhong Yu memorialized that, having plotted to coerce the Supreme One and to kill the chief minister on their own authority, they were guilty of great treason and depravity. Li Feng, Xiahou Xuan, Zhang Ji and the others all had their three sets of kin exterminated, and Xiahou Xuan's expression did not change even when he was beheaded at the Eastern Market. In the 3rd month Empress Zhang was deposed. Xu Yun, who earlier had received a forged edict naming Xiahou Xuan General-in-Chief but had burned it without presenting it to Sima Jingwang, was transferred to General Who Guards the North after the affair came to light; then, for distributing government property without authority, he was exiled to Lelang and died on the way. Records, Wei 9 §124–126 · 128Records, Wei 4 §43

In the autumn, in the 9th month of that year, the General-in-Chief Sima Jingwang, intending to depose the emperor, reported to the Empress Dowager. On the jiaxu day the Empress Dowager issued an order stating that the emperor Fang, though of full age, did not attend to government in person, indulged in women and summoned entertainers and actors for obscene amusements, and sent him back to his fief in Qi; he was then twenty-three. On the dingchou day the Empress Dowager ordered that Cao Mao, Duke of Gaogui Village, be made heir to Emperor Ming; Wang Su, escorting the imperial carriage, received him at Yuancheng, and Cao Mao ascended the throne on the gengyin day of the 10th month. Records, Wei 4 §44–49Records, Wei 13 §93

On the guisi day of the 10th month of the 1st year of Zhengyuan (254), the General-in-Chief Sima Jingwang was granted the Yellow Axe and the privileges of entering court without hastening his step, being announced without his personal name, and ascending the hall wearing his sword and shoes. That year, when a white vapor stretched across the sky, Jingwang asked Wang Su the reason, and Wang Su replied that it was the Banner of Chiyou and that there would be disorder in the southeast. Records, Wei 4 §53Records, Wei 13 §93

In the first month of the 2nd year of Zhengyuan (255), Guanqiu Jian, General Who Guards the East, and Wen Qin, Inspector of Yang Province, forged an edict of the Empress Dowager listing the General-in-Chief's crimes and rebelled. Some suggested that Jingwang should not go in person but send the Grand Commandant Sima Fu, but Fu Gu and Wang Su alone urged him to go himself. When Jingwang asked for a plan, Wang Su cited how Guan Yu's troops had collapsed overnight after losing their families to Sun Quan, and said that since the parents, wives and children of the soldiers of Huainan were all in the interior provinces, if he only hurried to block them they would crumble like a heap of earth. Jingwang set out on the wuyin day; Zhong Hui went with him in charge of confidential matters, and Sima Wenwang, General of the Guards, followed as the rear support of the main army. Records, Wei 28 §20–21 · 96Records, Wei 4 §54Records, Wei 21 §95Records, Wei 13 §93–95

The General-in-Chief led the armies of the capital and the provinces, sent Zhuge Dan with the troops of Yu Province from Anfeng Ford to threaten Shouchun, and had Hu Zun, General Who Campaigns in the East, cut off the enemy's line of retreat with the troops of Qing and Xu provinces. He himself was stationed at Ruyang, had the Army Supervisor Wang Ji lead the vanguard to occupy Nandun, and ordered all the armies to hold their walls firmly and not give battle. When Wang Ji, meeting him at Xuchang, said that the rebellion in Huainan was not what the officials and people wanted and that they would scatter like crumbling earth once the main army drew near, Jingwang said 'Good' and placed him at the front of the army. But when Wang Ji repeatedly asked to advance, Jingwang allowed him only as far as the Yin River, and would not permit him to go farther, wishing to wait for the armies to assemble. Wang Ji advanced on his own and occupied Nandun. Records, Wei 28 §22Records, Wei 27 §60–64

Since the families of the soldiers of Huainan were all in the north, men surrendered one after another. The General-in-Chief sent Deng Ai, Inspector of Yan Province, to Lejia to feign weakness and lure the enemy out, and soon followed in person. Wen Qin came at night to attack Deng Ai, but at dawn, seeing the great strength of the main army, he withdrew; the General-in-Chief loosed his swift cavalry in pursuit and routed him. The imperial annals record that Wen Qin was defeated at Lejia on the jihai day of the intercalary month. Wen Qin fled to Wu, and Guanqiu Jian, his host having collapsed, fled and was killed by a commoner under the Commandant of Anfeng Ford. Records, Wei 28 §23–24 · 62Records, Wei 4 §54

Afterwards Zhuge Dan became General-in-Chief Who Guards the East, and Sima Jingwang died at Xuchang. Chen Shou's main text records neither the cause of his death nor his age. When Jingwang died, Sima Wenwang took overall command of the Six Armies and, on the advice of Zhong Hui and Fu Gu, returned straight to Luoyang, becoming General-in-Chief and Intendant of the Affairs of the Imperial Secretariat on the dingsi day of the 2nd month. Records, Wei 4 §55Records, Wei 28 §96–97Records, Wei 21 §96

Chen Shou did not give a separate assessment of Sima Shi. The assessment in the Annals of the Three Young Emperors states that Emperor Ming, bound by private affection, handed the great patrimony to a small child and did not entrust affairs wholly to one man, so that in the end Cao Shuang was executed and the Prince of Qi was deposed from the throne. Records, Wei 4 §152

In the Romance

In Chapter 78 of the Romance, when Cao Cao dreams of three horses eating from one trough, a later poet's verse says that Cao Cao failed to recognize 'Sima Shi within the court.' He first appears in Chapter 94 as the eldest son of Sima Yi; his courtesy name is Ziyuan, and together with his younger brother Sima Zhao he is said to have harbored great ambitions and mastered the military classics. On news of Meng Da's revolt he urges his father to first send a memorial to the Son of Heaven, but Sima Yi, saying that would take a month, sets out with his troops at once. Romance, Ch. 78 §24–25Romance, Ch. 94 §38 · 41

In Chapter 102 he advises his father, who trusts Zheng Wen's letter and plans a raid on the Shu camp, to send another general first, and in Chapter 103 he urges him to fix a day for a decisive battle with Zhuge Liang, but Sima Yi holds firm. At Shangfang Valley he rides at his father's left in pursuit of Wei Yan and is trapped by fire; Sima Yi, weeping with his two sons in his arms, escapes thanks to a sudden downpour. In Chapter 106, together with Sima Zhao, he blocks the escape of Gongsun Yuan and his son. Romance, Ch. 102 §34–35Romance, Ch. 103 §13–14 · 28–31Romance, Ch. 106 §24–25

In Chapter 107, as General of Agile Cavalry, he blocks Jiang Wei's retreat before Yangping Pass. The Romance depicts him with a round face and large ears, a square mouth and thick lips, and a black wen growing hair beneath his left eye. He is driven off by Jiang Wei within three bouts, and when he tries to take the pass he loses his vanguard to the repeating crossbows left behind by the Marquis Wu, escaping with only his life. In Chapter 108, when Sima Yi dies, the Wei ruler Cao Fang makes him General-in-Chief with overall charge of the confidential affairs of the Imperial Secretariat. Romance, Ch. 107 §54–55Romance, Ch. 108 §1–3

When Sun Quan dies, the Master of Writing Fu Gu tries to dissuade him, but Sima Shi, declaring that 'the Way of Heaven changes once every thirty years,' resolves to attack Wu, has Wang Chang, Hu Zun and Guanqiu Jian advance by three routes, and makes his younger brother Sima Zhao Grand Commander. When Zhuge Ke besieges the New City, he follows the advice of the Registrar Yu Song, sending Sima Zhao to hold off Jiang Wei and Guanqiu Jian and Hu Zun to hold off the Wu army. Romance, Ch. 108 §7–8 · 20–21

In Chapter 109 Sima Shi ascends the hall wearing his sword and decides affairs himself without reporting them to the Wei ruler. When Cao Fang gives Xiahou Xuan, Li Feng and Zhang Ji an edict written in blood from his bitten finger, Sima Shi questions the three at the Donghua Gate about their tear-reddened eyes, finds the blood edict on Zhang Ji's person, has them cut in half at the waist in the marketplace and exterminates their three sets of kin. He then enters the inner palace, rebukes Cao Fang, and has Empress Zhang, Zhang Ji's daughter, dragged out and strangled with white silk. Romance, Ch. 109 §24–25 · 26–28 · 29–33 · 34–36

The next day he declares that the sovereign's crimes exceed those of the King of Changyi of Han and that he will set up a new ruler following the precedent of Yi Yin and Huo Guang, and he recommends Cao Ju, Prince of Pengcheng, to the Empress Dowager. When the Empress Dowager puts forward Cao Mao, Duke of Gaogui Village, and his clan uncle Sima Fu agrees, Sima Shi sends Cao Fang back as Prince of Qi and welcomes and enthrones Cao Mao. The era name is changed to Zhengyuan, and the General-in-Chief Sima Shi is granted the Yellow Axe. Romance, Ch. 109 §38–40 · 44

In Chapter 110, when Guanqiu Jian and Wen Qin rise up, Sima Shi is recuperating after having the wen under his left eye cut away, but declaring, 'Unless I go in person, the rebels cannot be defeated,' he leaves Luoyang in Sima Zhao's charge and sets out in a soft litter. At Lejia, startled by Wen Yang's night raid, his eyeball bursts out through the wound, and fearing to shake the army's morale he bites through his quilt and endures the pain. After returning to Xuchang he sees Li Feng, Zhang Ji and Xiahou Xuan standing before his bed every night, and he hands the seal to Sima Zhao and dies as his eyes burst from their sockets. The time is the 2nd month of the 2nd year of Zhengyuan, and in Chapter 119 Sima Yan honors him posthumously as Emperor Jing. Romance, Ch. 110 §4–6 · 16–17 · 26–28Romance, Ch. 119 §47

Where the Romance differs

First appearance: In Chapters 94 to 106 of the Romance, Sima Shi accompanies his father on the campaign against Meng Da, at Shangfang Valley and in the war in Liaodong. In Chen Shou's main text his deeds begin in the 3rd year of Jiaping (251), when, as General of the Guards, he became General-in-Chief Who Pacifies the Army and Intendant of the Affairs of the Imperial Secretariat. Romance, Ch. 94 §42Romance, Ch. 103 §28Romance, Ch. 106 §24Records, Wei 4 §33

Yangping Pass: In Chapters 107 and 108 of the Romance, Sima Shi blocks Jiang Wei's retreat and is heavily defeated by the repeating crossbows. In the Records, the battle at Qushan was fought by Guo Huai and Chen Tai, who put Jiang Wei to flight and received the surrender of Gou An and others, and Sima Shi does not appear. Romance, Ch. 107 §54Romance, Ch. 108 §1Records, Wei 22 §39–41

How he became General-in-Chief: In Chapter 107 of the Romance he is already General of Agile Cavalry, and in Chapter 108 he becomes General-in-Chief as soon as his father dies. In the imperial annals of the Records, he was General of the Guards when Sima Xuanwang died and then became General-in-Chief Who Pacifies the Army and Intendant of the Affairs of the Imperial Secretariat, becoming General-in-Chief in the first month of the following year. Romance, Ch. 107 §54Romance, Ch. 108 §3Records, Wei 4 §33–34

The Dongxing campaign: In Chapter 108 of the Romance, Sima Shi resolves to attack Wu and makes Sima Zhao Grand Commander. The imperial annals of the Records say only that an edict ordered Wang Chang, Hu Zun, Guanqiu Jian and others to attack Wu and that they were heavily defeated by Zhuge Ke at Dongguan; neither Sima Shi nor Sima Zhao appears. Romance, Ch. 108 §7–8Records, Wei 4 §34

Li Feng's plot: In Chapter 109 of the Romance, Cao Fang writes a blood edict for Xiahou Xuan, Li Feng and Zhang Ji, and Sima Shi discovers it and has the three cut in half at the waist. In the Records, Li Feng colluded with Zhang Ji to kill the General-in-Chief on the day a Noble Lady was to be invested and replace him with Xiahou Xuan; the General-in-Chief caught wind of it, summoned Li Feng and killed him. Xiahou Xuan and the others were beheaded at the Eastern Market after deliberation by the Commandant of Justice, and no blood edict from the emperor appears. Romance, Ch. 109 §28 · 32–33Records, Wei 9 §122–126

Empress Zhang: In Chapter 109 of the Romance, Sima Shi has Empress Zhang, Zhang Ji's daughter, strangled with white silk. The imperial annals of the Records say only that Empress Zhang was deposed in the 3rd month of that year. Romance, Ch. 109 §36Records, Wei 4 §43

The new ruler: In Chapter 109 of the Romance, Sima Shi recommends Cao Ju, Prince of Pengcheng, and the Empress Dowager puts forward Cao Mao. In the imperial annals of the Records, the Empress Dowager issued an order making Cao Mao, Duke of Gaogui Village, heir to Emperor Ming, and the high ministers deliberated on welcoming and enthroning him. The recommendation of Cao Ju does not appear. Romance, Ch. 109 §39Records, Wei 4 §46 · 48

Why he went in person: In Chapter 110 of the Romance, Sima Shi goes in person after Zhong Hui says that sending someone else would be disadvantageous, and Sima Zhao stays behind in Luoyang. In the Records, some proposed sending the Grand Commandant Sima Fu, but only Fu Gu and Wang Su urged him to go himself. Zhong Hui went with him in charge of confidential matters, and Sima Wenwang, General of the Guards, set out with him as the rear support of the main army. Romance, Ch. 110 §6Records, Wei 21 §95Records, Wei 28 §96

Where he was stationed: In Chapter 110 of the Romance, Sima Shi is stationed at Xiangyang and places his central army at the Yin Bridge. In the Biography of Guanqiu Jian in the Records, the General-in-Chief was stationed at Ruyang. Romance, Ch. 110 §7–8Records, Wei 28 §22

The battle of Lejia: In Chapter 110 of the Romance, Wen Yang charges into the camp at night, and Sima Shi is so startled that his eyeball bursts out. In the Biography of Guanqiu Jian in the Records, Wen Qin came at night to attack Deng Ai, withdrew at dawn on seeing the main army, and the General-in-Chief loosed his swift cavalry and routed him. Wen Yang does not appear in the Biography of Guanqiu Jian. Romance, Ch. 110 §16–17Records, Wei 28 §20–27

Death: In Chapter 110 of the Romance, Sima Shi suffers from his eye wound and dies at Xuchang as his eyes burst from their sockets, and the time is given as the 2nd month of the 2nd year of Zhengyuan. The imperial annals of the Records say only that he died at Xuchang, placing this after the victory at Lejia in the intercalary month and before Sima Wenwang's appointment as General-in-Chief on the dingsi day of the 2nd month. Romance, Ch. 110 §26–28Records, Wei 4 §54–55

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA7062−8
  • STR3538+3
  • INT6260−2
  • POL5245−7
  • CHA4540−5
  • VIR3515−20
  • ADP6060±0
  • SCH4042+2
  • DIP4040±0
  • DIS6050−10
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

VirtueR35N15 −20

RPlotted to depose the emperor and reported it to the Empress Dowager; Guanqiu Jian denounced his crimesWei 4 §44Wei 28 §21

NExterminated three sets of kin, had the Empress strangled and deposed the emperorCh. 109 §33Ch. 109 §38

8 similar abilities — show evidence
  • LeadershipR70N62 −8

    RDeployed several armies and put down the rebellion of Guanqiu Jian and Wen QinWei 28 §22Wei 4 §54

    NWas badly defeated by an ambush of repeating crossbows, but put down the rebellion on the Huainan campaignCh. 108 §1Ch. 110 §6

  • StrengthR35UnverifiedN38Unverified +3

    RNo direct record — estimated from his conduct as General-in-ChiefWei 4 §54

    NNo direct record — estimated from his deeds on the battlefieldCh. 107 §54

  • IntelligenceR62N60 −2

    RPinned the enemy by having his forces hold their walls, and lured them out with Deng Ai feigning weaknessWei 28 §22

    NWarned his father against rash ventures and saw through the plot from tear stains, but misjudged the pursuitCh. 102 §35Ch. 108 §1Ch. 109 §31

  • PoliticsR52N45Unverified −7

    RAssisted in government as Intendant of the Imperial Secretariat and adopted Deng Ai's frontier policyWei 28 §58Wei 4 §33

    NNo direct record — estimated from his deciding government affairs aloneCh. 109 §25

  • CharismaR45UnverifiedN40 −5

    RNo direct record — estimated from his conduct as General-in-ChiefWei 4 §53

    NThe ministers submitted to him out of fear, and there were those who sought revengeCh. 109 §24Ch. 110 §22

  • AdaptabilityR60N60 ±0

    RConsolidated his power by leading the deposition, but slowed the advance on campaignWei 4 §44Wei 27 §63

    NResolved to campaign in person and, with his eye burst out, bit his quilt and held onCh. 110 §6Ch. 110 §17

  • ScholarshipR40UnverifiedN42Unverified +2

    RNo direct record — estimated from his asking Wang Su about astronomyWei 13 §93

    NNo direct record — estimated from the statement that he mastered the military classicsCh. 94 §38

  • DiplomacyR40UnverifiedN40Unverified ±0

    RNo direct record — estimated from his conduct as General-in-ChiefWei 13 §93

    NNo direct record — estimated from his gathering of the ministers at the depositionCh. 109 §38

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (11)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Allegiance history

  1. Wei · Romance · Romance ch. 108 「原来姜维取雍州之时,郭淮飞报入朝,魏主与司马懿商议停当,懿遣长子司马师引兵五万,前来雍州助战」 · Q124394507

Family

ParentsSima Yi Romance
SiblingsSima Zhao Romance

Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.

Related events (7)

Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).