Rebellion · Coup

Guanqiu Jian and Wen Qin's Rebellion 毌丘儉文欽之亂

Other names: 壽春第二叛

About this event

Guanqiu Jian and Wen Qin's Rebellion was the revolt raised at Shouchun in the 1st month of the 2nd year of Zhengyuan of Wei (255) by Guanqiu Jian, General Who Guards the East, and Wen Qin, Inspector of Yang Province, who forged an edict of the Empress Dowager listing the crimes of the General-in-Chief Sima Shi. The two advanced as far as Xiang County with 50,000 to 60,000 men, but Sima Shi's Army Supervisor Wang Ji seized Nandun first, and in the intercalary month Wen Qin, who had come to Lejia to attack Deng Ai, was defeated and fled to Wu. Guanqiu Jian, his forces having collapsed, hid in the grass by the water and was killed. Zhuge Dan entered Shouchun first, and Sun Jun of Wu, who had been coming to make a surprise attack on Shouchun, received Wen Qin's surrender and went back. Records, Wei 4 §54Records, Wei 28 §21–24 · 32Records, Wei 27 §64Records, Wu 3 §9

Chen Shou recorded this rebellion in detail in the Biography of Guanqiu Jian in Records of Wei 28, and divided it among the Annals of the Three Young Emperors in Records of Wei 4, the Biography of Wang Ji in Records of Wei 27, the Biographies of Zhuge Dan and Deng Ai in Records of Wei 28, the Biographies of the Three Successor Rulers in Records of Wu 3 and the Biography of Sun Jun in Records of Wu 19, among others. The Romance depicts this rebellion in the first part of Chapter 110, "Wen Yang Drives Back a Mighty Host Single-Handed; Jiang Wei Fights with His Back to the River and Crushes a Great Foe." Records, Wei 28 §20–27 · 32–33 · 62Records, Wei 4 §54–56Records, Wei 27 §60–64Records, Wu 3 §9–10Records, Wu 19 §75Romance, Ch. 110 §1–28

Course of events in the Records

Guanqiu Jian was on close terms with Xiahou Xuan, Li Feng and others. Wen Qin, Inspector of Yang Province and General of the Front, was from the same town as Cao Shuang; brave and fierce, he had won merit in many battles, but because he inflated the numbers of his captures in hopes of rewards, they were mostly not granted, and his resentment deepened day by day. Guanqiu Jian treated him generously, and the two became very close. In the 1st month of the 2nd year of Zhengyuan (255), when a comet several dozen zhang long stretched across the sky to the northwest, rising from the celestial field of Wu and Chu, the two took it as an auspicious omen for themselves. Records, Wei 28 §20–21

On the yichou day of the 1st month the two rose in revolt. Forging an edict of the Empress Dowager, they circulated to the commanderies and kingdoms a document listing the crimes of the General-in-Chief Sima Shi, forced the commanders of Huainan, those guarding the various outposts, and the officials and people all to enter the city of Shouchun, then built an altar west of the city and swore an oath, smearing their lips with blood. Leaving the old and weak to guard the city, the two crossed the Huai River with 50,000 to 60,000 men and reached Xiang County to the west, where Guanqiu Jian held fast while Wen Qin acted as a mobile force outside. The envoy they sent to rally the officials and people of Yu Province was beheaded by Zhuge Dan, who proclaimed it to the realm, and Deng Ai also beheaded an envoy who had come to sow confusion among the troops. Records, Wei 4 §54Records, Wei 28 §21 · 32 · 62

On the wuyin day Sima Shi set out on the campaign in person. Some said it would be enough to send the Grand Commandant Sima Fu, but Fu Gu and Wang Su urged him to go himself. Sima Shi led the armies of the capital and the provinces, had Zhuge Dan aim at Shouchun from Anfeng Ford with the troops of Yu Province, had the General Who Conquers the East Hu Zun go out between Qiao and Song with the troops of Qing and Xu provinces to cut off the rebels' way home, and himself stationed at Ruyang. The Army Supervisor Wang Ji, meeting Sima Shi at Xuchang, said that the rebellion in Huainan was not what the officials and people wanted, and that when the great army drew near they would scatter like crumbling earth. Records, Wei 4 §54Records, Wei 21 §95Records, Wei 28 §22Records, Wei 27 §60

Sima Shi ordered the various armies to hold their walls firmly and not to fight. Wang Ji repeatedly asked to advance, and when Sima Shi, who wanted to wait for the armies to gather, did not permit it, he said, "When a general is with the army, there are commands of his sovereign he does not accept," and promptly seized Nandun. Guanqiu Jian and the others, setting out from Xiang County toward Nandun, heard that Wang Ji had arrived first and went back to hold Xiang County. Unable to fight if they advanced and fearing an attack on Shouchun if they withdrew, the two were at the end of their resources, and the commanders and soldiers of Huainan, whose families were all in the north, surrendered one after another. Records, Wei 28 §22–23Records, Wei 27 §61–64

Sima Shi had Deng Ai, Inspector of Yan Province, go to Lejia with over 10,000 troops from Taishan and feign weakness to lure the enemy. Not knowing this, Wen Qin came by night to attack Deng Ai, but at dawn, seeing the strength of the great army that Sima Shi had brought in person, he turned back, and Sima Shi pursued him with swift cavalry and heavily defeated him. The Annals of the Three Young Emperors record that Wen Qin was defeated at Lejia on the jihai day of the intercalary month. Deng Ai pursued Wen Qin as far as Qiutou, and Wang Ji, taking advantage of the division of the enemy's strength, pressed Xiang County. Records, Wei 28 §23–24 · 62Records, Wei 4 §54Records, Wei 27 §64

That day Guanqiu Jian, hearing that Wen Qin had been defeated, fled in fear by night, and his forces collapsed. By the time he reached Shen County his followers had gradually left him, and Guanqiu Jian hid in the grass by the water with his young brother Guanqiu Xiu and his grandson Guanqiu Zhong, but was shot dead by Zhang Shu, a man under the jurisdiction of the Commandant of Anfeng Ford. On the jiachen day his head was sent to the capital, and Guanqiu Xiu and Guanqiu Zhong fled to Wu. His son Guanqiu Dian, who had fled beforehand with the family to Mount Ling at Xin'an, was also overcome, and Guanqiu Jian's three sets of kin were exterminated. The officers and soldiers who had been coerced all came back and surrendered, and on the renzi day Wei granted a special pardon to the gentry and commoners of Huainan. Records, Wei 28 §24–25Records, Wei 4 §54

Wen Qin fled to Wu, where he became Protector-General, Senior General Who Guards the North and Governor of You Province, and was enfeoffed as Marquis of Qiao. According to the Biographies of the Three Successor Rulers in the Records of Wu, on the renchen day of the intercalary month Sun Jun set out with the General of Agile Cavalry Lü Ju and the General of the Left Liu Zan to make a surprise attack on Shouchun, and at Dongxing heard that Wen Qin and the others had been defeated; on the renyin day, when he advanced to Tuogao, Wen Qin came to surrender, and tens of thousands of the remaining people of Huainan fled to him. The more than 100,000 people in Shouchun, fearing execution, broke open the city gates and scattered, and as Zhuge Dan entered Shouchun first, Sun Jun could not attack the city and withdrew. Jiang Ban, sent by Zhuge Dan, pursued and beheaded Liu Zan, and Zhuge Dan became Senior General Who Guards the East and again commanded Yang Province. Sima Shi died at Xuchang. Records, Wei 28 §27 · 32–33Records, Wu 3 §9–10Records, Wei 4 §55–56

In his assessment Chen Shou said that Guanqiu Jian was outstanding in talent and insight and capable, but that he, together with Wang Ling, Zhuge Dan and Zhong Hui, had great ambitions but misguided aims and failed to foresee disaster, so that upheaval broke out like the release of a crossbow trigger and their clans were crushed into the earth. Records, Wei 28 §140

In the Romance

Chapter 110 of the Romance opens in the 1st month of the 2nd year of Zhengyuan, with Guanqiu Jian, furious at Sima Shi's arbitrary deposing and enthroning of emperors, listening to his eldest son Guanqiu Dian and consulting with Wen Qin. Wen Qin, a former retainer of Cao Shuang, proposed making his son Wen Yang the vanguard, and the two, falsely claiming a secret edict from the Empress Dowager, gathered the officers and soldiers of Huainan in the city of Shouchun and swore an oath at an altar west of the city, sacrificing a white horse. Guanqiu Jian stationed himself at Xiangcheng with 60,000 men, and Wen Qin became a mobile force with 20,000. Sima Shi, who had just had a tumor cut from his eye, listened to Zhong Hui and set out in person, assigning separate routes to Zhuge Dan, Hu Zun and Wang Ji. Romance, Ch. 110 §1–6

To Sima Shi, stationed at Xiangyang, the Army Supervisor Wang Ji said that the troops and people of Huainan were merely following under coercion, and proposed seizing Nandun first. Guanqiu Jian, heading for Nandun, saw that a Wei camp had already been set up, and at news that Sun Jun of Wu was making a surprise attack on Shouchun, he withdrew to Xiangcheng. Following the advice of the Master of Writing Fu Gu, Sima Shi had Deng Ai, Inspector of Yan Province, attack the city of Lejia. Romance, Ch. 110 §7–12

Wen Qin volunteered to hold Lejia with his son Wen Yang and 5,000 men, and on the advice of the eighteen-year-old Wen Yang they decided to divide their troops in two at night and attack the Wei camp from north and south. When Wen Yang burst into the camp from the north, Sima Shi was so startled that his eyeball burst out through the wound where the tumor had been cut, but he endured it by biting his quilt. Wen Qin lost his way on the mountain roads and failed to arrive, and when Deng Ai arrived at daybreak, Wen Yang broke through the encirclement alone and repeatedly drove back the pursuing Wei commanders with his steel whip. Romance, Ch. 110 §13–21

Seeing that Shouchun had already fallen to Zhuge Dan and that the three armies of Hu Zun, Wang Ji and Deng Ai had arrived, Wen Qin went over to Sun Jun of Wu. Guanqiu Jian, coming out of Xiangcheng to fight, lost his vanguard commander Ge Yong to Deng Ai's sword and collapsed under the pincer attack of Hu Zun and Wang Ji; he fled with a dozen or so horsemen and, dead drunk at a banquet given by Song Bai, Prefect of Shen County, was killed, and Huainan was pacified. Sima Shi made Zhuge Dan Senior General Who Guards the East with command of Yang Province and returned to Xuchang, but every night he saw Li Feng, Zhang Ji and Xiahou Xuan standing before his bed, and after entrusting the succession to Sima Zhao, he died with his eyeballs bursting out. The Romance records this as happening in the 2nd month of the 2nd year of Zhengyuan. Romance, Ch. 110 §24–28

Where the Romance differs

Reason for the uprising: In Chapter 110 of the Romance, Guanqiu Jian rose at the urging of his eldest son Guanqiu Dian, angered at Sima Shi's arbitrary deposing and enthroning of emperors. The Biography of Guanqiu Jian in the Records states that Guanqiu Jian was on close terms with Xiahou Xuan and Li Feng, and that he rose together with Wen Qin, who bore a grudge for not being rewarded, taking the comet as an auspicious omen. Guanqiu Dian had fled beforehand with the family. Romance, Ch. 110 §1–2Records, Wei 28 §20–21 · 25

Troop strength: In Chapter 110 of the Romance, Guanqiu Jian stationed himself at Xiangcheng with 60,000 men and Wen Qin became a mobile force with 20,000. In the Biography of Guanqiu Jian in the Records, the two together led 50,000 to 60,000 men to Xiang County. Romance, Ch. 110 §4Records, Wei 28 §21

Nandun: In Chapter 110 of the Romance, when Wang Ji proposed seizing Nandun, Sima Shi agreed at once. In the Biography of Wang Ji in the Records, Sima Shi did not permit it because he wanted to wait for the armies to gather, and Wang Ji seized Nandun on his own, saying that there were commands of the sovereign that a general does not accept. Romance, Ch. 110 §8Records, Wei 27 §62–64

The night battle at Lejia: In Chapter 110 of the Romance, Wen Yang burst into the camp alone and drove back the pursuing Wei commanders. Chen Shou's text states only that Wen Qin, meaning to attack Deng Ai by night, saw the great army at dawn, turned back and was heavily defeated by Sima Shi's cavalry; Wen Yang does not appear in this battle. Romance, Ch. 110 §16–20Records, Wei 28 §23–24

Guanqiu Jian's death: In Chapter 110 of the Romance, Guanqiu Jian was killed while drunk at a banquet given by Song Bai, Prefect of Shen County. In the Biography of Guanqiu Jian in the Records, he hid in the grass by the water with his brother and grandson and was shot dead by Zhang Shu, a man under the jurisdiction of the Commandant of Anfeng Ford. Romance, Ch. 110 §25–26Records, Wei 28 §24

Sima Shi's death: In Chapter 110 of the Romance, Sima Shi's eyeball burst out when he was startled by Wen Yang's attack, and he returned to Xuchang and died after seeing vengeful ghosts. Chen Shou's text states only that Sima Shi died at Xuchang. Romance, Ch. 110 §17 · 26–27Records, Wei 4 §55

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Belligerents

ItemAB
FactionsWeiWu
CommandersDeng Ai, Zhuge Dan, Sima Shi, Wang Ji(王基), Hu ZunGuanqiu Jian, Sun Jun, Wen Qin, Lü Ju, Liu Zan(留贊)
Strength儉、欽自將五六萬眾渡淮

Factions, commanders, strength and casualties are checked against the source texts (3KDEX). Strength and casualties show only figures stated in the sources. Source: Wei 4 §54

Sub-events and Romance scenes (1)

Romance chapters (1)

Records volumes (7)