RProposed reforms of official selection, abolition of commanderies and dress, which King Xuan (Sima Yi) called excellentWei 9 §101Wei 9 §111Wei 9 §118
NNo direct record — estimated from his service as Minister of CeremoniesCh. 109 §26
| Occupation | RNOfficial · Minister of Ceremonies | Faction | Wei |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appears | RN | Biography in | Book of Wei |
| Born | R209 Unverified | Native place | Pei Commandery Qiao County Unverified |
| Died | R254 Unverified | Place of death | RNLuoyang County |
| Cause of death | RExecuted NExecuted Unverified | ||
| Existence | Historical | Mentions | R37 |
Xiahou Xuan, courtesy name Taichu, was the son of Xiahou Shang and the son of Cao Shuang's paternal aunt. He was well known from his youth, and in the Zhengshi era, when Cao Shuang was assisting the government, he passed through the posts of Cavalier Attendant-in-Ordinary and Central Protector of the Army to become General Who Conquers the West, overseeing the military affairs of Yong and Liang provinces. Records, Wei 9 §98 · 100 · 122
After Cao Shuang was executed he was summoned to court and became Grand Herald and then Minister of Ceremonies, but he could not achieve his ambitions. In the 6th year of Jiaping (254), when the plot of Li Feng and Zhang Ji to install him in place of the General-in-Chief Sima Shi came to light, he was arrested along with them and his three sets of kin were exterminated; he himself was beheaded in the Eastern Market. He was forty-six at the time. Records, Wei 9 §122–126Records, Wei 4 §43
In his assessment, Chen Shou said that although he was famed for his standards and breadth of mind, he was deeply entangled with Cao Shuang and there was no word of his ever correcting Cao Shuang's faults, so how could he have escaped disaster? In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 107 as a kinsman of Cao Shuang guarding Yong Province and appears in 3 of its 120 chapters, and his name is in no chapter title. In Chapter 109 he receives Cao Fang's secret edict together with Li Feng and Zhang Ji, is discovered by Sima Shi and dies. Records, Wei 9 §132Romance, Ch. 107 §31Romance, Ch. 109 §26–33
Xiahou Xuan's courtesy name was Taichu. He was well known from his youth, and at twenty became Cavalier Gentleman of the Yellow Gate. Once, when he went in to see the emperor and was seated beside the empress's younger brother Mao Zeng, he felt ashamed and let his displeasure show on his face; Emperor Ming resented this and demoted him to Supervisor of the Feathered Forest. Records, Wei 9 §100
At the beginning of the Zhengshi era Cao Shuang assisted the government; Xiahou Xuan was the son of Cao Shuang's paternal aunt. He was promoted several times, becoming Cavalier Attendant-in-Ordinary and Central Protector of the Army. According to the Biography of Wei Zhen, Cao Shuang sent Xiahou Xuan to convey to Wei Zhen his wish to make him Prefect of the Masters of Writing and to seek a marriage for his younger brother, but Wei Zhen accepted neither. Records, Wei 9 §100Records, Wei 22 §87
When the Grand Tutor Sima Yi asked about the government of the day, Xiahou Xuan offered three proposals. First, the selection of officials should be left to the central secretariat and the ranking of conduct to the local communities, so that neither interfered with the other, and the Rectifiers (zhongzheng) of the provinces and commanderies should assess only conduct and order among peers, without promoting or demoting anyone. Second, the commandery administrators should be abolished and only the inspectors kept, so as to reduce posts and send good officials closer to the people. Third, carriages and clothing should be made plain, doing away with silk ornament, starting with the households of the court's ministers. Records, Wei 9 §101–107 · 108–114 · 115–117
In his reply, Sima Yi said that all three were excellent, but that since they were long-established, familiar practices, they could be carried through only after waiting for worthy and able men. Xiahou Xuan wrote again, saying that Emperor Wen of Han had worn coarse cloth himself yet had not reformed the laws and regulations; if the chief minister fixed the system from above, transformation would take effect below, and to say 'wait for the worthy and able' was like saying that Yi Yin and the Duke of Zhou had not corrected the statutes of Yin and Zhou, which he could not understand. Records, Wei 9 §118–121
Shortly afterwards he became General Who Conquers the West, was granted a borrowed tally and oversaw the military affairs of Yong and Liang provinces. Because he launched the Luo Valley campaign together with Cao Shuang, people of the time criticized him. In the 5th year of Zhengshi (244), Cao Shuang raised 60,000 to 70,000 troops at Chang'an and entered the Luo Valley, but supplies could not be delivered, many oxen and horses died, and with the enemy holding the mountains he could not advance and turned back. The Biography of Guo Huai records that when Xiahou Xuan attacked Shu, Guo Huai, leading the vanguard, judged the situation unfavorable and pulled his troops out, so that they avoided a heavy defeat. Records, Wei 9 §122 · 74–75Records, Wei 26 §72
When Cao Shuang was executed, Xiahou Xuan was summoned to court and made Grand Herald, and a few years later he was transferred to Minister of Ceremonies. Held down because of his ties to Cao Shuang, he inwardly could not achieve his ambitions. Around the same time Xiahou Ba, whom Cao Shuang had treated generously, heard that Cao Shuang had been executed, grew fearful for himself and fled to Shu. Records, Wei 9 §122 · 27
Li Feng, Prefect of the Palace Writers, had long enjoyed the confidence of the General-in-Chief Sima Shi, but his heart was with Xiahou Xuan. He joined with Zhang Ji, Grand Master of the Palace and father of the empress, in a plot to have Xiahou Xuan assist the government. He tried to have his younger brother Li Yi, Inspector of Yan Province, come to court and bring troops in, but this was not permitted. In the 2nd month of the 6th year of Jiaping (254), on the day an Honored Lady was to be invested, they planned to seize the moment when the Son of Heaven came out before the hall to kill the General-in-Chief, replace him with Xiahou Xuan and make Zhang Ji General of Agile Cavalry, and they also let their intentions be known to people inside the palace such as Su Shuo, Supervisor of the Yellow Gate. Records, Wei 9 §122–124Records, Wei 4 §43
Sima Shi caught wind of the plot, summoned Li Feng and killed him on the spot. Xiahou Xuan, Zhang Ji and the others were arrested and handed over to the Commandant of Justice. Zhong Yu, the Commandant of Justice, reported that Li Feng and the others had plotted to coerce the sovereign and to kill the chief minister on their own authority, which was high treason and impiety, and the deliberations of the ministers reached the same conclusion, finding that Xiahou Xuan, though ranked among the hereditary servants of the state, had harbored the intent to bring about disaster. Records, Wei 9 §124–126
Li Feng, Xiahou Xuan, Zhang Ji and the others all had their three sets of kin exterminated, and their other relatives were moved to Lelang Commandery. Xiahou Xuan was broad and generous of mind, and even when he was beheaded in the Eastern Market his expression did not change and he bore himself calmly. He was forty-six at the time. In the Zhengyuan era, to continue the lines of meritorious officials, Xiahou Shang's grandnephew Xiahou Ben was enfeoffed as Marquis of Changling Village to carry on Xiahou Shang's sacrifices. Records, Wei 9 §126
In the assessment of Records of Wei 9, Chen Shou said that Cao Shuang's virtue was thin while his position was lofty, and wrote that Xiahou Xuan was renowned in his age for his standards and breadth of mind, but was deeply entangled with Cao Shuang as his cousin; holding so glorious a position, he was never heard to have corrected Cao Shuang's faults or brought in good talent, so how could he have escaped disaster? Records, Wei 9 §132
In Chapter 107 of the Romance, Sima Yi, having killed Cao Shuang's clan, says that Xiahou Xuan is still guarding Yong Province and other areas and, as a kinsman of Cao Shuang, might suddenly rise in revolt, and he issues an edict summoning Xiahou Xuan, General Who Conquers the West, to Luoyang. Hearing this, Xiahou Xuan's uncle Xiahou Ba is greatly alarmed and rebels with the 3,000 troops of his own command, but is defeated by Guo Huai and Chen Tai, goes to Hanzhong and surrenders to the Later Sovereign, Liu Shan. Romance, Ch. 107 §31–33
In Chapter 109, after court, Cao Fang sees that only the Minister of Ceremonies Xiahou Xuan, the Prefect of the Palace Writers Li Feng and the Grand Master of the Palace Zhang Ji remain, takes them into a private chamber and weeps, saying that Sima Shi treats him like a small child. Xiahou Xuan says that his uncle Xiahou Ba surrendered to Shu because he feared harm from the Sima brothers, so that if this traitor is removed his uncle will return, and declares that as an old in-law of the ruling house he will join in receiving the edict and punishing him. Cao Fang bites his finger, writes an edict in blood on his undershirt and gives it to Zhang Ji. Romance, Ch. 109 §26–28
The three run into Sima Shi, wearing a sword, beside the Donghua Gate. When Li Feng makes the excuse that they had been reading with the Son of Heaven about Yi Yin and the Duke of Zhou, Sima Shi presses them on why they wept in the private chamber, since their eyes are still red. Knowing the matter is out, Xiahou Xuan rebukes him: 'Because you overawe your sovereign with your power and plot usurpation!' He tries to strike Sima Shi with his fists and is seized. When the blood edict is found on Zhang Ji, Sima Shi has the three cut in half at the waist in the marketplace and their three sets of kin exterminated. Arriving at the Eastern Market, the three keep cursing to the end even after all their teeth have been knocked out, and die. Romance, Ch. 109 §29–33
In Chapter 110, Sima Shi, who has put down Guanqiu Jian's rebellion and taken to his sickbed, sees the three men Li Feng, Zhang Ji and Xiahou Xuan standing before his bed every night while the pain in his eye will not stop. Romance, Ch. 110 §26
Extent of his role: The Romance first brings Xiahou Xuan on in Chapter 107, after Cao Shuang's execution, and does not cover his demotion in his youth, the three proposals he submitted to Sima Yi, or the Luo Valley campaign. In the Records these matters are set out in detail in his biography. Romance, Ch. 107 §31Records, Wei 9 §100–122
The summons and Xiahou Ba: In Chapter 107 of the Romance, when Sima Yi summons Xiahou Xuan, General Who Conquers the West, to Luoyang, his uncle Xiahou Ba is alarmed, rebels and fights Guo Huai. The Records says only that after Cao Shuang's execution Xiahou Xuan was summoned and made Grand Herald, while Xiahou Ba, hearing of Cao Shuang's execution, grew fearful for himself and fled to Shu. There is no word that Xiahou Xuan's summons moved Xiahou Ba to act, nor that he fought Guo Huai. Romance, Ch. 107 §31–33Records, Wei 9 §122 · 27
How the plot began: In Chapter 109 of the Romance, Cao Fang weeps and confers with the three in a private chamber and writes them an edict in blood. In the Records, Li Feng joined with Zhang Ji in a plot to have Xiahou Xuan assist the government; there is no blood edict from the Son of Heaven, and no word of Xiahou Xuan stepping forward in the plot to address the emperor. Romance, Ch. 109 §26–28Records, Wei 9 §122–123
Discovery: In Chapter 109 of the Romance, Sima Shi, meeting the three at the Donghua Gate, notices their red eyes and interrogates them, and finds the blood edict on Zhang Ji. In the Records, the General-in-Chief Sima Shi caught wind of the plot, summoned Li Feng and killed him on the spot, and Xiahou Xuan and the others were handed over to the Commandant of Justice and punished after the memorial of the Commandant of Justice Zhong Yu and the deliberations of the ministers. Romance, Ch. 109 §29–32Records, Wei 9 §124–126
Bearing in the face of death: In Chapter 109 of the Romance, Xiahou Xuan rebukes Sima Shi and tries to strike him with his fists, and dies at the Eastern Market cursing until his teeth are broken. The Records says that when he was beheaded in the Eastern Market his expression did not change and he bore himself calmly. Romance, Ch. 109 §31 · 33Records, Wei 9 §126
Manner of execution: In Chapter 109 of the Romance, Sima Shi has the three cut in half at the waist in the marketplace. The Records says that he was beheaded in the Eastern Market; the extermination of three sets of kin is the same in both. Romance, Ch. 109 §33Records, Wei 9 §126
After his death: In Chapter 110 of the Romance, Sima Shi sees the three, Xiahou Xuan among them, standing before his bed every night. The Records says nothing of the kind, recording instead that in the Zhengyuan era Xiahou Shang's grandnephew Xiahou Ben was enfeoffed as Marquis of Changling Village to continue Xiahou Shang's sacrifices. Romance, Ch. 110 §26Records, Wei 9 §126
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.
RProposed reforms of official selection, abolition of commanderies and dress, which King Xuan (Sima Yi) called excellentWei 9 §101Wei 9 §111Wei 9 §118
NNo direct record — estimated from his service as Minister of CeremoniesCh. 109 §26
RSubmitted writings on the official system and dress, drawing on the classics and ancient institutionsWei 9 §108Wei 9 §115
NNo direct record — estimated from his service as Minister of CeremoniesCh. 109 §26
RRebutted the reply of King Xuan (Sima Yi) and pressed for reformWei 9 §120Wei 9 §121
NNo direct record — estimated from his words and conduct before Sima ShiCh. 109 §31
RFamous from his youth, and Li Feng's heart was with him. Assessment: his name was praised in his ageWei 9 §100Wei 9 §122Wei 9 §132
NNo direct record — estimated from his place among the emperor's close attendantsCh. 109 §26
RRemained calm even when beheaded. Assessment: no word of his correcting Cao Shuang's faultsWei 9 §126Wei 9 §132
NSwore to punish the traitor, rebuked Sima Shi to his face, and died cursingCh. 109 §27Ch. 109 §31Ch. 109 §33
ROversaw Yong and Liang provinces as General Who Conquers the West, but was criticized over the Luo Valley campaignWei 9 §122
NNo direct record — estimated from his guarding Yong Province as General Who Conquers the WestCh. 107 §31
RNo direct record — estimated from his career as a civil officialWei 9 §100
NClenched his fists to strike Sima Shi but was seized by the guardsCh. 109 §31
RNo direct record — estimated from his policy proposals and the plot he was caught up inWei 9 §101Wei 9 §122
NNo direct record — estimated from his part in the secret-edict plotCh. 109 §27
RDemoted for showing his displeasure, and in the end implicated. Assessment: could not escape disasterWei 9 §100Wei 9 §122Wei 9 §132
NWhen the plot leaked, he loudly rebuked Sima Shi and got himself seizedCh. 109 §31
RDiscussed the selection system, but assessment: no word of his bringing in good talentWei 9 §101Wei 9 §132
NNo direct record — estimated from his career at courtCh. 109 §26
Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)
3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.
AppearsNot present Chapter list →
| Parents | Xiahou Shang Records |
|---|
Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.
Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).