Lü Fan 呂範

RecordsRomance Wu Courtesy name 子衡 Ziheng여범자형吕范

Profile
OccupationRGeneral · Grand Marshal NStrategist · Patrol Commissioner of the Four QuartersFactionWu
AppearsRNBiography inBook of Wu
BornR? UnverifiedNative placeRunan Commandery Xiyang County
DiedR228 UnverifiedPlace of death
Cause of deathRIllness Unverified
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR45

Profile

Lü Fan, courtesy name Ziheng, was a man of Xiyang County in Runan Commandery. Having taken refuge from the disorders at Shouchun, he came over to Sun Ce with a hundred of his private retainers, and together with Sun He he always followed Sun Ce without shrinking from hardship, so that he was treated like a kinsman. Records, Wu 11 §32–33

Under Sun Quan he resisted Cao Cao at Red Cliffs together with Zhou Yu and others, and as General Who Establishes Might and Administrator of Danyang he guarded Jianye. In the 1st year of Huangwu (222) he resisted Cao Xiu with the navy at Dongkou, and after serving as General of the Front and Governor of Yang Province he was transferred to Grand Marshal in the 7th year of Huangwu (228), but died of illness before the seal and ribbon were conferred. Records, Wu 11 §36–38 · 41Records, Wu 2 §42

In his assessment, Chen Shou, who wrote the Records, said that he and Zhu Zhi 'were employed as old retainers', and wrote that despite his fault of extravagance he came to a good end. In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 15 as a strategist of Yuan Shu who helps Sun Ce launch his expedition to Jiangdong; he appears in 7 of its 120 chapters, and no chapter title bears his name. Records, Wu 11 §67Romance, Ch. 15 §13–15

In the Records

Lü Fan, courtesy name Ziheng, was a man of Xiyang County in Runan Commandery. In his youth he became a county clerk and was of fine bearing and appearance. When he asked a wealthy Liu family of his town for their daughter, the girl's mother was reluctant, but Master Liu said, 'Looking at Lü Ziheng, how could he be a man who stays poor for long?' and gave her to him in marriage. Records, Wu 11 §32

Later he took refuge from the disorders at Shouchun; when Sun Ce saw him and thought him remarkable, Lü Fan attached himself to him and came over with a hundred of his private retainers. Sun Ce sent Lü Fan to escort the Dowager Lady, who was at Jiangdu. Tao Qian, Governor of Xu Province, took Lü Fan for a spy of the Yuan and had the county arrest him and interrogate him under the lash, but his close retainers and stalwarts snatched him away and brought him back. The Biography of Sun Ce records that because Tao Qian was wary of him, Sun Ce moved his mother to Qu'e and went with Lü Fan and Sun He to his maternal uncle Wu Jing. At this time only Lü Fan and Sun He always followed Sun Ce and did not shrink from danger, so Sun Ce treated him like a kinsman and drank with him in the presence of the Dowager Lady. Records, Wu 11 §32–33Records, Wu 1 §25

Following Sun Ce, he helped break Lujiang, crossed the river eastward and defeated Zhang Ying and others at Hengjiang and Dangli, and took Little Danyang and Hushu, taking charge as Chancellor of Hushu. When Sun Ce pacified Moling and Qu'e and took in the remnants of Ze Rong and Liu Yao, Lü Fan was given an additional 2,000 soldiers and 50 horses. Later, as Prefect of Wanling, he crushed the bandits of Danyang, and on returning to Wu he became Chief Commander. Records, Wu 11 §33–34

When Chen Yu of Xiapi styled himself Administrator of Wu Commandery and was in league with Yan Baihu, Sun Ce personally attacked Yan Baihu and separately sent Lü Fan and Xu Yi to attack Chen Yu at Haixi, and Lü Fan beheaded his chief general Chen Mu and displayed the head. He also attacked Zu Lang at Lingyang and Taishi Ci at Yongli. When seven counties had been pacified he became General of the Household Who Conquers Caitiffs, and after campaigning against Jiangxia he returned and pacified Poyang. When Sun Ce died, he hastened to Wu for the mourning. Records, Wu 11 §35

At first Sun Ce put Lü Fan in charge of finances and accounts. When the still-young Sun Quan made private requests, Lü Fan always reported them to Sun Ce and would not approve them on his own, and so incurred resentment. Whenever Sun Ce checked on the private spending of Sun Quan, then Chief of Yangxian, the Officer of Merit Zhou Gu doctored the accounts so that Sun Quan escaped reproach. Sun Quan liked Zhou Gu at the time, but after he took charge of the government he trusted Lü Fan deeply as loyal and sincere, and did not employ Zhou Gu, who knew how to falsify accounts. Records, Wu 11 §39–40

The Biography of the Lord of Wu records that Sun Quan made Zhou Yu, Cheng Pu, Lü Fan and others his commanders, and that in the 8th year of Jian'an (203), returning from an attack on Huang Zu, he had Lü Fan pacify Poyang. When Sun Quan attacked Jiangxia again, Lü Fan stayed behind on guard with Zhang Zhao. When Cao Cao reached Red Cliffs, he resisted and routed him together with Zhou Yu and others, became Assistant General and concurrently Administrator of Pengze, and received Pengze, Chaisang and Liyang as his fief towns. Records, Wu 2 §5 · 7Records, Wu 11 §36

When Liu Bei came to Jing to meet Sun Quan, Lü Fan secretly asked that Liu Bei be detained. The biography of Zhou Yu also records that at this time Zhou Yu memorialized proposing to move Liu Bei to Wu and hold him there with palaces and beautiful women, but Sun Quan, considering that with Cao Cao in the north he should gather heroes widely, did not accept it. Lü Fan was later transferred to General Who Pacifies the South and stationed at Chaisang. Records, Wu 11 §36Records, Wu 9 §19–20

On his way to attack Guan Yu, Sun Quan called at Lü Fan's residence, said, 'Had I followed your advice earlier, there would have been none of this trouble,' and asked him to guard Jianye. After defeating Guan Yu and making Wuchang his capital, Sun Quan made Lü Fan General Who Establishes Might and Marquis of Wanling, concurrently Administrator of Danyang, governing Jianye and supervising the region from Fuzhou down to the sea. Records, Wu 11 §37

In the autumn of the 1st year of Huangwu (222), when Wei's Cao Xiu, Zhang Liao, Zang Ba and others invaded toward Dongkou, Lü Fan, supervising five commanderies and leading Xu Sheng, Quan Cong, Sun Shao and others, resisted them with the navy. He was transferred to General of the Front with the tally of authority (jiajie) and his fief changed to Marquis of Nanchang. In the 11th month of that winter a great wind struck, capsizing boats and drowning several thousand men, and after withdrawing the army he became Governor of Yang Province. The Biography of Cao Xiu in the Wei records says that in this battle Cao Xiu defeated Lü Fan and others at Dongpu. Records, Wu 2 §42 · 47Records, Wu 11 §37–38Records, Wei 9 §57

Lü Fan loved dignified ceremony, and among the people of the province, men like Lu Xun and Quan Cong as well as the sons of noble families all treated him with respect and restraint. His residence and dress were extravagant for the time, but because he was diligent in his duties and upheld the law, Sun Quan was pleased with his loyalty and did not fault his extravagance. Records, Wu 11 §39

In the 7th year of Huangwu (228) Lü Fan was transferred to Grand Marshal, but died of illness before the seal and ribbon were conferred. Sun Quan put on plain white mourning, lamented him and sent an envoy to confer the seal and ribbon posthumously. Later, after the capital was moved back to Jianye, Sun Quan passed his tomb, called out 'Ziheng!' and wept, and sacrificed to him with the tailao offering. His eldest son had died before him, so his second son Lü Ju succeeded him; when Lü Fan fell ill, Lü Ju had become Colonel Deputy of the Army and assisted in commanding the troops. Records, Wu 11 §41 · 43Records, Wu 2 §60

In his assessment, Chen Shou wrote that Zhu Zhi and Lü Fan were employed as old retainers, and that whereas Lü Fan with his extravagance and Zhu Huan with his narrowness were still able to come to a good end despite such faults, Lü Ju and Zhu Yi met disaster without having them, because the times they met were different. Records, Wu 11 §67

In the Romance

In Chapter 15 of the Romance, as Sun Ce discusses with Zhu Zhi his plan to go out to Jiangdong, a man comes in and offers to help with a hundred picked, sturdy men under his command. He is a strategist of Yuan Shu, 'a man of Xiyang in Runan, surnamed Lü, named Fan, courtesy name Ziheng'. Lü Fan, worried that Yuan Shu will not lend troops, says, when Sun Ce proposes to offer the Imperial Seal of State as a pledge, that Yuan Shu has long wanted it and will surely provide troops. Sun Ce raises his army leading Zhu Zhi, Lü Fan, Cheng Pu, Huang Gai, Han Dang and others, and introduces Zhou Yu, whom he meets on the way, to Zhu Zhi, Lü Fan and the others. Romance, Ch. 15 §12–15 · 17

In Chapter 29, when Sun Ce imprisons Yu Ji, Lü Fan says he has long known that the Taoist Yu can summon wind and pray for rain, and proposes that since there is a drought, Yu Ji be made to pray for rain to atone for his crime. Sun Ce agrees, brings Yu Ji out and has him mount the altar. Romance, Ch. 29 §18

In Chapter 44, Lü Fan comes to see Zhou Yu together with Zhuge Jin and other civil officials. When Zhou Yu sets out to attack Cao Cao, Lü Fan and Zhu Zhi serve as Patrol Commissioners of the Four Quarters, urging on and supervising the government troops of six commanderies. Romance, Ch. 44 §7 · 38

In Chapter 54, Sun Quan, following Zhou Yu's plan, says, 'Only Lü Fan will do,' and sends him to Jing Province as matchmaker. Lü Fan tells the widowed Liu Bei that a man without a wife is like a house without a ridgepole, that the Marquis of Wu's sister surpasses men in spirit so that age need not be a concern, and that the wedding must be held in Eastern Wu. He returns south of the river with Sun Qian, obtains Sun Quan's consent, and acts as matchmaker for the bride's side at the wedding. Romance, Ch. 54 §15–20 · 23 · 28

In the same chapter, when Dowager Wu says she will see Liu Bei at Ganlu Temple, Lü Fan urges Sun Quan to have Jia Hua lie in ambush in the side galleries with 300 axe-and-sword men. When Liu Bei reveals the ambush and the Dowager is enraged, Lü Fan, summoned, shifts the blame onto Jia Hua. Romance, Ch. 54 §33 · 38

In Chapter 76, when Guan Yu at Maicheng rejects the call to surrender, Lü Fan offers to divine the outcome, counts the yarrow stalks, obtains the Shi hexagram ('Earth over Water'), and interprets it as a sign that the enemy will flee far away. In Chapter 77 he divines again and reports that Guan Yu will flee to the northwest and will surely be captured that night in the hour of hai. Romance, Ch. 76 §45–46Romance, Ch. 77 §2

In Chapter 85, when Cao Pi attacks Wu by three routes, Wu has Lü Fan resist Cao Xiu, and Cao Pi, on receiving the report that 'Cao Xiu too has been defeated by Lü Fan', withdraws his army. Lü Fan does not appear in the Romance after this, and his death is not recorded. Romance, Ch. 85 §8 · 14

Where the Romance differs

How he came to Sun Ce: In Chapter 15 of the Romance, Lü Fan is a strategist of Yuan Shu who joins the discussion between Sun Ce and Zhu Zhi and backs the plan to borrow troops from Yuan Shu by pledging the Imperial Seal of State. In the Biography of Lü Fan in the Records, having taken refuge from the disorders at Shouchun, he came over with a hundred private retainers when Sun Ce thought him remarkable; there is no mention of his being Yuan Shu's strategist, nor of the seal. Romance, Ch. 15 §13–15Records, Wu 11 §32

Yu Ji: In Chapter 29 of the Romance, Lü Fan proposes having Yu Ji pray for rain. The main texts of the Biography of Sun Ce and the Biography of Lü Fan written by Chen Shou contain no story of Yu Ji. Romance, Ch. 29 §18Records, Wu 1 §23–39Records, Wu 11 §32–41

Red Cliffs: In Chapter 44 of the Romance, Lü Fan appears as a civil official along with Zhuge Jin and others, and in the battle he urges on the troops as Patrol Commissioner of the Four Quarters. In the Records, when Cao Cao reached Red Cliffs, he resisted and routed him together with Zhou Yu and others, and for this he became Assistant General and Administrator of Pengze. Romance, Ch. 44 §7 · 38Records, Wu 11 §36

Lady Sun's marriage: In Chapter 54 of the Romance, Lü Fan goes to Jing Province as matchmaker and lures Liu Bei to Eastern Wu. The Biography of the First Sovereign in the Records says only that Sun Quan, growing wary of Liu Bei, gave him his sister in marriage to strengthen their friendship; there is no mention of Lü Fan acting as matchmaker. On the contrary, the Biography of Lü Fan records that when Liu Bei came to Jing to meet Sun Quan, Lü Fan secretly asked that he be detained. Romance, Ch. 54 §16–19Records, Shu 2 §24Records, Wu 11 §36

The ambush at Ganlu Temple: In Chapter 54 of the Romance, Lü Fan urges an ambush of axe-and-sword men under Jia Hua and then shifts the blame onto Jia Hua. This is not in the Records, where Sun Quan, later setting out to attack Guan Yu, told Lü Fan that had he followed his advice earlier there would have been none of this trouble. Romance, Ch. 54 §33 · 38Records, Wu 11 §36–37

Who divined Guan Yu's fate: In Chapters 76–77 of the Romance, Lü Fan divines with yarrow stalks and correctly predicts that Guan Yu will flee and be captured. In the Records, Lü Fan was guarding Jianye when Sun Quan attacked Guan Yu, and the man who divined the time of Guan Yu's capture, saying he had signs of flight, was Wu Fan of the Biographies of the Fangji. Romance, Ch. 76 §46Romance, Ch. 77 §2Records, Wu 11 §37Records, Wu 18 §5–6

The outcome at Dongkou: In Chapter 85 of the Romance, Cao Xiu is defeated by Lü Fan. In the Records, Lü Fan resisted Cao Xiu with the navy, but a great wind capsized his boats and several thousand men drowned. The Wei biographies of Cao Xiu, Zang Ba and Jia Kui all record defeating Lü Fan at Dongpu, and the biography of Wang Ling records that a great wind in the night drove the boats of Lü Fan and others onto the northern shore, where Wang Ling and others met and attacked them. Romance, Ch. 85 §14Records, Wu 11 §38Records, Wu 2 §47Records, Wei 9 §57Records, Wei 18 §29Records, Wei 15 §78Records, Wei 28 §3

The end: The Romance does not portray Lü Fan again after Chapter 85. In the Records, Lü Fan was transferred to Grand Marshal in the 7th year of Huangwu (228) but died of illness before receiving the seal and ribbon, and Sun Quan, passing his tomb, called out 'Ziheng!' and wept. Romance, Ch. 85 §14Records, Wu 11 §41

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA6858−10
  • STR4230−12
  • INT7065−5
  • POL7240−32
  • CHA6250−12
  • VIR6250−12
  • ADP6855−13
  • SCH3840+2
  • DIP3868+30
  • DIS4040±0
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

PoliticsR72N40Unverified −32

RIn charge of finances and accounts, he blocked private requests and was diligent in upholding the lawWu 11 §39Wu 11 §40

NNo direct record — estimated from his career as Yuan Shu's strategistCh. 15 §13

DiplomacyR38UnverifiedN68 +30

RNo direct record — estimated from the record of his proposing to detain Liu BeiWu 11 §36

NTrusted by Sun Quan as matchmaker, he persuaded Liu Bei to the marriageCh. 54 §16Ch. 54 §19Ch. 54 §20

AdaptabilityR68N55 −13

RRecognized Sun Ce's worth and entrusted himself to him, and kept to principle even at the cost of resentmentWu 11 §32Wu 11 §39

NLeft Yuan Shu and threw in his lot with Sun Ce's ventureCh. 15 §13

StrengthR42UnverifiedN30Unverified −12

RNo direct record — estimated from the record of his following Sun Ce without shrinking from dangerWu 11 §33

NNo direct record — estimated from his background as a strategistCh. 15 §13

CharismaR62N50 −12

RCame over with a hundred retainers, and even Lu Xun and Quan Cong respected his dignityWu 11 §32Wu 11 §39

NJoined Sun Ce leading a hundred picked, sturdy followersCh. 15 §13

3 similar abilities — show evidence
  • IntelligenceR70N65 −5

    RUrged detaining Liu Bei, and Sun Quan later regretted not following his adviceWu 11 §36Wu 11 §37

    NSettled the plan to borrow troops from Yuan Shu by pledging the Imperial SealCh. 15 §13Ch. 15 §14

  • ScholarshipR38UnverifiedN40Unverified +2

    RNo direct record — estimated from his early career as a county clerkWu 11 §32

    NNo direct record — estimated from his skill at divinationCh. 76 §46

  • DiscernmentR40UnverifiedN40Unverified ±0

    RNo direct record — estimated from his career managing financesWu 11 §39

    NNo direct record — estimated from his career as a strategistCh. 15 §13

Special — talents Records +0 · Romance +10

  • Divination & astronomy

    NSkilled +10 Obtained a hexagram with yarrow stalks and foretold that Guan Yu would flee northwest and be capturedCh. 76 §46Ch. 77 §2

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (7)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Allegiance history

  1. Wu · Records · 「範遂自委暱,將私客百人歸策。」

Family

ChildrenLü Ju Records

Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.

Related events (4)

Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).