Battle

Battle of Ruxu 濡須之戰

About this event

The Battle of Ruxu was the battle from the winter of the 21st year of Jian'an (216) to the spring of the 22nd (217) in which Cao Cao, King of Wei, attacked Sun Quan at Ruxukou. Cao Cao, who had halted at Juchao, advanced to Haoxi in Jiangxi in the 2nd month of the 22nd year and pressed Sun Quan, who had built a city at Ruxukou to hold him off, and Sun Quan made Lü Meng commander and resisted from the fortification. In the spring of the 22nd year, when Sun Quan sent the Commandant Xu Xiang to ask to surrender, Cao Cao replied that he would restore friendly relations and renew the marriage alliance, and in the 3rd month he went back, leaving Xiahou Dun, Cao Ren, Zhang Liao and others at Juchao. Records, Wu 2 §23–24Records, Wei 1 §156Records, Wu 9 §76

Chen Shou recorded this battle in Records of Wei 1 (the Annals of Emperor Wu) and Records of Wei 18 (the Biographies of the Two Lis, Zang, Wen, Lü, Xu, Dian, the Two Pangs and Yan), and in Records of Wu 2 (the Biography of the Lord of Wu) and Records of Wu 9 (the Biographies of Zhou Yu, Lu Su and Lü Meng). The Romance depicts this battle at the end of Chapter 67, where Cao Cao turns his troops from Hanzhong toward Ruxuwu, and in Chapter 68, "Gan Ning Raids the Wei Camp with a Hundred Horsemen." Records, Wei 1 §155–156Records, Wei 18 §27–28Records, Wu 2 §23–24Records, Wu 9 §76Romance, Ch. 67 §54–55Romance, Ch. 68 §1–26

Course of events in the Records

In the 5th month of the 21st year of Jian'an (216) Cao Cao became King of Wei. Readying his troops in the 10th month, winter, of that year and setting out to attack Sun Quan, he reached Qiao in the 11th month, and the Biography of the Lord of Wu records that in the winter of the 21st year Cao Cao halted at Juchao and then attacked Ruxu. Records, Wei 1 §154–155Records, Wu 2 §23

In the 1st month, spring, of the 22nd year (217) Cao Cao encamped at Juchao, and in the 2nd month he advanced and stationed himself at Haoxi in Jiangxi. The Annals of Emperor Wu record that when Sun Quan built a city at Ruxukou and held it, Cao Cao closed in and attacked, and Sun Quan retreated and fled. The Biography of Lü Meng records that when Cao Cao again came out to Ruxu with a large army, Sun Quan made Lü Meng commander and had him hold the fortification built earlier, placing ten thousand powerful crossbows on top of it to resist, and that Lü Meng attacked and broke Cao Cao's vanguard before it had finished building its camp, whereupon Cao Cao withdrew. Records, Wei 1 §156Records, Wu 9 §76

Zang Ba served as vanguard together with Zhang Liao when attacking Sun Quan at Ruxukou. The Biography of Zang Ba records that on the march they met heavy rains, the waters rose and the enemy ships drew near, so that all the officers and men grew uneasy, and when Zhang Liao wanted to leave, Zang Ba stopped him, asking whether the Duke would abandon them. The next day the order did indeed come, and Cao Cao, approving of this, appointed Zang Ba General Who Spreads Might and granted him a provisional tally. Records, Wei 18 §27–28

The Biographies of Gan Ning, Dong Xi and Zhou Tai in Records of Wu 10 also record events from when Cao Cao came out to Ruxu, but do not give the year. Gan Ning, as Commander of the Front Division, fed wine and food to his more than one hundred men, then at the second watch went out with gags in their mouths and struck the enemy's forward camp, and Dong Xi was stationed at Ruxukou in command of a five-storied tower ship and died when it capsized in a violent wind at night. Zhou Tai stayed behind to supervise Ruxu after Cao Cao withdrew. Records, Wu 10 §62–63 · 51 · 29

In the spring of the 22nd year Sun Quan sent the Commandant Xu Xiang to Cao Cao to ask to surrender, and Cao Cao sent an envoy in reply, restored friendly relations and swore to renew the marriage alliance. In the 3rd month, leading his army back, Cao Cao left Xiahou Dun, Cao Ren, Zhang Liao and others stationed at Juchao, and the Biography of Zang Ba records that after Sun Quan asked to surrender, Zang Ba too stayed at Juchao with Xiahou Dun and others. Around this time Sima Lang, who had reached Juchao with Xiahou Dun, Zang Ba and others, died in the Epidemic of 217 that spread among the soldiers. Records, Wu 2 §24Records, Wei 1 §156Records, Wei 18 §28Records, Wei 15 §26

In the Romance

At the end of Chapter 67 of the Romance, Zhang Liao at Hefei, hearing that Sun Quan was raising troops at Ruxu, asked Cao Cao in Hanzhong for help, and Cao Cao left Xiahou Yuan and Zhang He to hold Hanzhong and marched on Ruxuwu. In Chapter 68, on the report that Cao Cao was coming with 400,000, Sun Quan had Dong Xi and Xu Sheng lie in ambush at Ruxukou with fifty large ships, and Ling Tong went out with 3,000 troops and fought Zhang Liao for fifty bouts. Romance, Ch. 67 §54–55Romance, Ch. 68 §1–3

Gan Ning raided Cao Cao's camp at night with a hundred horsemen and came back without losing a single man, and Sun Quan said that if Mengde had Zhang Liao, he had Gan Xingba. The next day, while Ling Tong was fighting Yue Jin, Cao Xiu's arrow struck his horse and he fell, whereupon Gan Ning shot Yue Jin in the face to save Ling Tong, and the two became friends sworn to live and die together. Romance, Ch. 68 §4–13

Cao Cao attacked Ruxu along five routes, and while Xu Sheng charged into Li Dian's army, Dong Xi's ship capsized in a fierce wind and he died at the river mouth. Sun Quan, surrounded by Zhang Liao and Xu Huang, was rescued by Zhou Tai, who charged in three times, and Chen Wu, chased by Pang De, died when his sleeve caught on a tree. Lu Xun came with 100,000 troops and drove off Cao Cao's army, and at a banquet Sun Quan asked about Zhou Tai's scars one by one, having him drink a cup of wine for each wound. Romance, Ch. 68 §14–24

When more than a month of confrontation brought no victory, Zhang Zhao and Gu Yong advised making peace, and Sun Quan sent Bu Zhi and promised to pay tribute every year. Sun Quan left Jiang Qin and Zhou Tai at Ruxukou and returned to Moling, and Cao Cao left Cao Ren and Zhang Liao at Hefei and returned to Xuchang. After this, the Romance places the officials' discussion of making Cao Cao King of Wei. Romance, Ch. 68 §25–26

Where the Romance differs

Timing of the battle: In Chapter 67 of the Romance, Cao Cao came to Ruxu directly from Hanzhong, and in Chapter 68 he was made King of Wei in the 5th month, summer, of the 21st year of Jian'an, after the fighting had ended. In the Annals of Emperor Wu in the Records, Cao Cao set out to attack Sun Quan in the 10th month, winter, of the 21st year, after becoming King of Wei in the 5th month of that year, and the fighting lasted from the 1st to the 3rd month of the 22nd year. Romance, Ch. 67 §55Romance, Ch. 68 §26–28Records, Wei 1 §154–156

The peace envoy: In Chapter 68 of the Romance, Sun Quan sent Bu Zhi and offered to pay tribute every year. In the Biography of the Lord of Wu in the Records, the man Sun Quan sent was the Commandant Xu Xiang, and Cao Cao swore to restore friendly relations and renew the marriage alliance. Romance, Ch. 68 §25Records, Wu 2 §24

Chen Wu's death: In Chapter 68 of the Romance, Chen Wu was killed by Pang De at Ruxu. In the Biography of Chen Wu in the Records, Chen Wu joined the battle at Hefei in the 20th year of Jian'an and died fighting with all his might. Romance, Ch. 68 §21Records, Wu 10 §35

Dong Xi's death: In Chapter 68 of the Romance, Dong Xi died when his ship capsized during a daytime battle against Cao Cao's attack along five routes. In the Biography of Dong Xi in the Records, the five-storied tower ship stationed at Ruxukou was suddenly struck by a violent wind at night and capsized, and he died. Romance, Ch. 68 §14–16Records, Wu 10 §51

Zhou Tai's scars: In Chapter 68 of the Romance, Sun Quan, moved by Zhou Tai's having saved him, asked about Zhou Tai's scars at a banquet. In the Biography of Zhou Tai in the Records, when Zhu Ran and Xu Sheng would not obey Zhou Tai, who had been put in charge of Ruxu, Sun Quan came to Ruxuwu, held a banquet and asked about his scars one by one, whereupon Xu Sheng and the others at last submitted. Romance, Ch. 68 §23–24Records, Wu 10 §29–30

Lu Xun's reinforcements: In Chapter 68 of the Romance, Lu Xun came with 100,000 troops and drove off Cao Cao's army. In Chen Shou's text Lu Xun does not appear in this battle, and the one who broke Cao Cao's vanguard with the crossbows on the fortification was Lü Meng (Biography of Lü Meng). Romance, Ch. 68 §22Records, Wu 9 §76

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Belligerents

ItemAB
FactionsWuWei
CommandersSun Quan, Lü Meng, Gan NingCao Cao, Zang Ba, Zhang Liao

Factions, commanders, strength and casualties are checked against the source texts (3KDEX). Strength and casualties show only figures stated in the sources. Source: Wei 1 §156

Sub-events and Romance scenes (1)

Romance chapters (2)

Records volumes (6)