Battle

Campaign against Dong Zhuo 討伐董卓之戰

Other names: 董卓討伐戰

About this event

The Campaign against Dong Zhuo was the war in which the provinces and commanderies east of the passes raised troops all at once in the 1st month of the 1st year of Chuping (190), chose Yuan Shao, Administrator of Bohai, as leader of the alliance, and set out to attack Dong Zhuo, who held Luoyang. In the 2nd month Dong Zhuo moved the Son of Heaven to Chang'an and burned the palaces of Luoyang, while the various armies deferred to one another and did not advance. Cao Cao advanced alone as far as the Bian River at Xingyang and was defeated by Dong Zhuo's general Xu Rong, and Sun Jian beheaded Hua Xiong and others at Yangren and entered Luoyang. When its provisions ran out the alliance scattered, ending with Liu Dai killing Qiao Mao and Yuan Shao intimidating Han Fu into giving up Ji Province. Records, Wei 1 §7–9 · 14 · 18Records, Wei 6 §11Records, Wu 1 §17 · 20Records, Wei 7 §39

Chen Shou did not gather this war into a single volume. The rising and Cao Cao's fighting are in the Annals of Emperor Wu in Records of Wei 1, the affairs on Dong Zhuo's side in the biographies of Dong Zhuo and Yuan Shao in volume 6, Sun Jian's fighting in Records of Wu 1, and the oath at Suanzao in the biography of Zang Hong in volume 7. The Romance portrays this war from the gathering of the lords of the seventeen garrisons in Chapter 5 to Sun Jian hiding the imperial seal and the lords dispersing in Chapter 6. Records, Wei 1 §6–17Records, Wei 6 §10–11 · 39Records, Wu 1 §13–20Records, Wei 7 §37–39Romance, Ch. 5 §7–9Romance, Ch. 6 §28–34

Course of events in the Records

After Dong Zhuo deposed the emperor and set up another, Cao Cao changed his name and went back east, dispersed his family's wealth at Chenliu to gather volunteer troops, and first raised his army at Jiwu in the 12th month, winter, of the 6th year of Zhongping (189). Han Fu, Liu Dai, Kong Zhou, Zhang Zi, Zhang Miao and others, recommended by Zhou Bi and Wu Qiong, whom Dong Zhuo trusted, joined forces to attack Dong Zhuo once they reached their posts, and Dong Zhuo beheaded Zhou Bi and Wu Qiong, saying they had betrayed him. Yuan Shao, who had become Administrator of Bohai, also raised troops in Bohai. Records, Wei 1 §6Records, Wei 6 §10 · 39

In the 1st month, spring, of the 1st year of Chuping (190), Yuan Shu, General of the Rear; Han Fu, Governor of Ji Province; Kong Zhou, Inspector of Yu Province; Liu Dai, Inspector of Yan Province; Wang Kuang, Administrator of Henei; Yuan Shao, Administrator of Bohai; Zhang Miao, Administrator of Chenliu; Qiao Mao, Administrator of Dong Commandery; Yuan Yi, Administrator of Shanyang; and Bao Xin, Chancellor of Jibei, raised troops at the same time, each with a following of tens of thousands, and chose Yuan Shao as leader of the alliance. Yuan Shao styled himself General of Chariots and Cavalry, and Cao Cao served as acting General of Vehement Might (fenwu jiangjun). According to the biography of Zang Hong, Liu Dai, Kong Zhou, Zhang Miao, Qiao Mao, Zhang Chao and others gathered at Suanzao each deferred the oath to the others and put forward Zang Hong, who mounted the altar, drank the blood and swore that they would harbor no divided loyalty. Records, Wei 1 §7Records, Wei 6 §39Records, Wei 7 §37–39

In the 2nd month, hearing that troops had risen, Dong Zhuo moved the Son of Heaven to Chang'an while he himself stayed behind at Luoyang, burned the palaces, dug up every one of the imperial tombs and took their treasures. Wang Kuang, Administrator of Henei, who had stationed troops from Taishan at Heyangjin, was crushed by Dong Zhuo's surprise attack and lost nearly all his men. Hearing that Yuan Shao had won the lands east of the passes, Dong Zhuo killed every member of the Yuan clan, including Yuan Shao's uncle, the Grand Tutor Yuan Wei, and Yuan Shao had Wang Kuang kill Huwu Ban, Bearer of the Golden Mace, and the others whom Dong Zhuo had sent bearing an edict. Records, Wei 1 §8Records, Wei 6 §11 · 46–47

Yuan Shao was stationed at Henei; Zhang Miao, Liu Dai, Qiao Mao and Yuan Yi at Suanzao; Yuan Shu at Nanyang; Kong Zhou at Yingchuan; and Han Fu was at Ye; but because Dong Zhuo's troops were strong, no one dared advance first. Saying that now, when Dong Zhuo had burned the palaces and moved the Son of Heaven, was the moment Heaven was destroying him, Cao Cao advanced west alone intending to seize Chenggao, and Zhang Miao detached troops under Wei Zi to follow him. He fought Dong Zhuo's general Xu Rong on the Bian River at Xingyang and fared badly, with many of his men killed; Cao Cao was hit by an arrow and his horse was wounded, but his cousin Cao Hong gave him his horse and he escaped by night. Xu Rong, seeing them fight hard all day with few troops, concluded that Suanzao would not be easy to attack and withdrew. Records, Wei 1 §8–10Records, Wei 9 §48

The armies at Suanzao, more than a hundred thousand strong, did nothing but hold drinking parties every day and made no attempt to advance and attack. Cao Cao proposed a plan in which Yuan Shao would advance to Mengjin, the generals at Suanzao would hold Chenggao and Aocang and block Huanyuan and Taigu, and Yuan Shu would enter the Wu Pass to shake the Three Adjuncts, all of them raising their ramparts high and not giving battle, but Zhang Miao and the others could not adopt it. The biography of Sima Lang records that the hosts of the lands east of the passes, several hundred thousand gathered at Xingyang and Henei, could not unite and gave themselves to plunder, so that nearly half the common people died, and the biography of Zang Hong records that the armies, none willing to advance first, scattered when their provisions ran out. Records, Wei 1 §11–12Records, Wei 15 §21Records, Wei 7 §39

In the south, Sun Jian met Yuan Shu at Luyang and became acting General Who Smashes the Caitiffs; he suffered a heavy defeat at the hands of Dong Zhuo's army east of Liang, then gathered his troops again, won a great victory at Yangren and beheaded its commander Hua Xiong and others. Sun Jian rejected Li Jue, who came to ask for peace, and advanced to Dagu, ninety li from Luoyang, and when Dong Zhuo burned Luoyang as he went into Guanzhong, he entered Luoyang, repaired the imperial tombs and returned to Luyang. Records, Wu 1 §15–20

Cao Cao, short of troops, went to Yang Province with Xiahou Dun and others to recruit soldiers and then stationed himself at Henei. Liu Dai fell out with Qiao Mao and killed him. Yuan Shao, together with Han Fu, wanted to set up Liu Yu, Governor of You Province, as emperor, but Cao Cao refused, and in spring of the 2nd year of Chuping (191) Liu Yu too in the end would not accept. In the 4th month, summer, Dong Zhuo returned to Chang'an, and in the 7th month, autumn, Yuan Shao intimidated Han Fu and took Ji Province. Records, Wei 1 §13–18

In the Romance

In Chapter 5 of the Romance, Cao Cao, having fled after trying to stab Dong Zhuo, obtains Wei Hong's wealth at Chenliu, sends a false edict to every region and gathers volunteer troops, and the lords who receive the call to arms rise, seventeen garrisons gathering from Yuan Shu, General of the Rear, to Yuan Shao, Administrator of Bohai. Liu Bei, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei also come, following Gongsun Zan, Administrator of Beiping. Yuan Shao, who becomes leader of the alliance on Cao Cao's recommendation, mounts the altar and swears the oath, entrusts the provisions to Yuan Shu and sends Sun Jian as vanguard to Sishui Pass. Romance, Ch. 5 §2–3 · 6–12 · 13–17

At Sishui Pass Hua Xiong beheads Bao Zhong, Zu Mao, Yu She and Pan Feng, but the mounted archer Guan Yu brings back Hua Xiong's head before the wine has cooled. Dong Zhuo wipes out Yuan Wei's household and holds Hulao Pass in person, but Lü Bu is chased by the three men Liu Bei, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei and flees up onto the pass. Romance, Ch. 5 §20 · 28 · 32 · 36 · 40–41 · 48–54

In Chapter 6, Dong Zhuo, on Li Ru's advice, decides to move the capital to Chang'an, dismisses Yang Biao, Huang Wan and Xun Shuang, who oppose it, and beheads Zhou Bi and Wu Qiong. He kills several thousand wealthy families of Luoyang and seizes their goods, drives millions of the common people off toward Chang'an, and as he leaves sets fire to the palaces and the ancestral temples and has Lü Bu dig up the imperial tombs. Romance, Ch. 6 §3–11

When the lords do not move, Cao Cao pursues Dong Zhuo alone with over ten thousand men, is badly beaten at Xingyang by Lü Bu, Li Jue, Guo Si and Xu Rong's ambush, and barely survives when Cao Hong gives him his horse and carries him across a river on his back. Sun Jian, entering Luoyang, puts out the fires and covers over the tombs, and finds the Imperial Seal of State in a well south of the Jianzhang Hall. Romance, Ch. 6 §13–21 · 22–25

When Sun Jian hides the seal and tries to leave on the pretext of illness, Yuan Shao challenges him, and after the two come to the point of drawing swords Sun Jian leaves Luoyang and finds his road blocked by Liu Biao of Jing Province. Cao Cao leaves for Yang Province, saying the lords each harbor their own designs; Gongsun Zan makes Liu Bei Chancellor of Pingyuan and goes back; and when Liu Dai kills Qiao Mao, Yuan Shao too leaves Luoyang for the lands east of the passes. Romance, Ch. 6 §28–31 · 33–34 · 36–37

Where the Romance differs

The start of the rising: In Chapter 5 of the Romance, Cao Cao summons the lords by sending a false edict to every region. In the Annals of Emperor Wu in the Records, Cao Cao raised his army at Jiwu in the 12th month of the 6th year of Zhongping, and in the 1st month of the following year ten men including Yuan Shu raised troops at the same time and chose Yuan Shao as leader of the alliance; there is no false edict. Romance, Ch. 5 §3 · 7Records, Wei 1 §6–7

The lords who gathered: In Chapter 5 of the Romance, seventeen garrisons gather, including Kong Rong of Beihai, Tao Qian of Xu Province, Ma Teng of Xiliang, Gongsun Zan of Beiping and Sun Jian of Changsha. The simultaneous rising recorded in the Annals of Emperor Wu involved ten men—Yuan Shu, Han Fu, Kong Zhou, Liu Dai, Wang Kuang, Yuan Shao, Zhang Miao, Qiao Mao, Yuan Yi and Bao Xin; Sun Jian raised troops separately, and Kong Rong, Tao Qian, Ma Teng and Gongsun Zan are not on this list. Romance, Ch. 5 §7–9Records, Wei 1 §7Records, Wu 1 §13

Who swore the oath: In Chapter 5 of the Romance, Yuan Shao, the leader of the alliance, mounts the altar and reads the oath. In the biography of Zang Hong in the Records, at Suanzao the provinces and commanderies deferred to one another, so Zang Hong mounted the altar and swore the oath, and its text is almost the same as Yuan Shao's in the Romance. Romance, Ch. 5 §14–15Records, Wei 7 §38–39

Who beheaded Hua Xiong: In Chapter 5 of the Romance, Guan Yu beheads Hua Xiong before Sishui Pass. In the Biography of Sun Jian in the Records, Sun Jian defeated Dong Zhuo's army at Yangren and beheaded its commander Hua Xiong and others. Romance, Ch. 5 §35–36Records, Wu 1 §17

The move of the capital and Cao Cao's defeat: In Chapter 6 of the Romance, Dong Zhuo decides to move the capital after Lü Bu's defeat at Hulao Pass, and Cao Cao, pursuing Dong Zhuo on his way to Chang'an, is defeated at Xingyang. In the Annals of Emperor Wu in the Records, Dong Zhuo, hearing that troops had risen, moved the Son of Heaven to Chang'an in the 2nd month while he himself remained at Luoyang; Cao Cao, setting out to seize Chenggao, was defeated by Xu Rong on the Bian River at Xingyang; and Dong Zhuo returned to Chang'an only in the 4th month of the 2nd year of Chuping. Romance, Ch. 6 §3–5 · 14–17Records, Wei 1 §8–9 · 17

The Imperial Seal of State: In Chapter 6 of the Romance, Sun Jian finds the Imperial Seal of State in a well, hides it and comes to the point of drawing swords with Yuan Shao. The Biography of Sun Jian in Chen Shou's text says only that Sun Jian entered Luoyang, repaired the imperial tombs and returned to Luyang. Romance, Ch. 6 §24–31Records, Wu 1 §20

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Belligerents

ItemAB
FactionsYuan Shao factionDong Zhuo faction
CommandersCao Cao, Sun Jian, Wang Kuang, Yuan Shao(袁紹), Yuan Shu, Han Fu(韓馥), Kong Zhou(孔伷), Liu Dai(劉岱), Zhang Miao, Qiao Mao, Yuan Yi, Bao XinDong Zhuo, Xu Rong, Hua Xiong
Strength同時俱起兵,衆各數萬

Factions, commanders, strength and casualties are checked against the source texts (3KDEX). Strength and casualties show only figures stated in the sources. Source: Wei 7 §39

Sub-events and Romance scenes (4)

Romance chapters (2)

Records volumes (6)