RUsed the bandits of Wei Commandery as spies and struck them, defeating them badly every timeWei 14 §47
NNo direct record — estimated as a civil official serving as Consultant on PolicyCh. 14 §17
| Occupation | RStrategist · Minister over the Masses | Faction | Wei |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appears | RN | Biography in | Book of Wei |
| Born | R156 Unverified | Native place | Jiyin Commandery Dingtao County |
| Died | R236 Unverified | Place of death | |
| Existence | Historical | Mentions | R37 |
Dong Zhao, courtesy name Gongren, was a native of Dingtao County in Jiyin Commandery. Under Yuan Shao he was put in charge of Julu and Wei Commandery, but left after falling under suspicion, and by persuading Zhang Yang he helped Cao Cao open contact with the court at Chang'an. In the 1st year of Jian'an (196) he advised Cao Cao to move the emperor's carriage to Xu. Records, Wei 14 §45–49 · 53–55
He proposed the canals for the campaign against the Wuhuan, and was the first to plan Cao Cao's receiving the titles of Duke of Wei and King of Wei. He served Emperor Wen and Emperor Ming, rising through the posts of Palace Attendant, Minister of Ceremonies and Minister of the Guards to Minister over the Masses (situ), and died in the 4th year of Qinglong (236) at the age of eighty-one. Records, Wei 14 §63 · 66 · 70 · 76–78 · 81Records, Wei 3 §45
In his assessment, Chen Shou called him, together with Cheng Yu, Guo Jia, Liu Ye and Jiang Ji, 'remarkable men of their age in talent, strategy and planning,' and said that although in honest governance and virtuous conduct they differed from Xun You, in their stratagems they were of his kind. In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 14, when he comes to Cao Cao's camp as the emperor's envoy, and he appears in 3 of its 120 chapters; there is no chapter whose title bears his name. Records, Wei 14 §158Romance, Ch. 14 §16–17
Dong Zhao was nominated as Filial and Incorrupt and served as Chief of Yingtao and Prefect of Boren, then became Army Adviser (canjunshi) to Yuan Shao. When Yuan Shao was fighting Gongsun Zan at Jieqiao and Li Shao, Administrator of Julu, and others wanted to go over to Gongsun Zan, Yuan Shao put Dong Zhao in charge of Julu; Dong Zhao forged a proclamation from Yuan Shao, beheaded Sun Kang and several dozen others who had led the plot, and then soothed and settled the commandery. Next, as acting Administrator of Wei Commandery, he used the bandits' envoys as spies and attacked them where they were unprepared, defeating them every time. Records, Wei 14 §45–47
His younger brother Dong Fang was in Zhang Miao's army, and when Zhang Miao fell out with Yuan Shao, Yuan Shao listened to slander and was about to charge Dong Zhao with a crime. Dong Zhao set out to join Emperor Xian, but was detained by Zhang Yang in Henei and made Chief Commandant of Cavalry. When the Grand Progenitor, then governing Yan Province, wanted passage through to Chang'an, Dong Zhao, saying that 'Cao Cao is weak now, but he is truly the hero of the realm,' persuaded Zhang Yang to pass on the Grand Progenitor's memorial to the court and recommend him, and he also wrote letters on the Grand Progenitor's behalf to Li Jue, Guo Si and others. When the emperor was at Anyi, he went to him and became a Gentleman-Consultant. Records, Wei 14 §48–49
In the 1st year of Jian'an (196) the emperor returned to Luoyang, but Han Xian, Yang Feng, Dong Cheng and Zhang Yang could not get along with one another. Dong Zhao wrote a letter in the Grand Progenitor's name to Yang Feng, who had the strongest army but few allies, saying, 'I have provisions, and you, General, have soldiers.' Delighted, Yang Feng together with the other generals memorialized to make the Grand Progenitor General Who Guards the East and to let him inherit the title of Marquis of Fei Precinct. Dong Zhao became Prefect of Tallies and Seals. Records, Wei 14 §50–52
At Luoyang the Grand Progenitor had Dong Zhao sit beside him and asked his advice. Dong Zhao said that the generals would not necessarily obey, so there was no choice but to move the imperial carriage to Xu, and that 'only by doing extraordinary things are extraordinary achievements made.' To the Grand Progenitor, who was worried about Yang Feng, he said that if he told Yang Feng, 'There is no grain in the capital, so I intend to escort the carriage to Luyang for a while,' Yang Feng, brave but short on forethought, would not suspect anything. When the carriage was moved to Xu, Yang Feng, his hopes dashed, turned to plundering and was put down by the Grand Progenitor. The Annals of Emperor Wu also record that Dong Zhao and others urged him to make Xu the capital. Records, Wei 14 §53–56Records, Wei 1 §39
In the 3rd year of Jian'an (198) he became Intendant of Henan. When Zhang Yang was killed by his subordinate general Yang Chou (楊醜), Dong Zhao went into the city alone, talked to Zhang Yang's Chief Clerk Xue Hong and others, and got them to surrender that same day, and he became Governor of Ji Province. When the Grand Progenitor had Liu Bei block Yuan Shu, Dong Zhao said that Liu Bei was brave and ambitious, with Guan Yu and Zhang Fei as his wings, so his true intentions could not be gauged. When Liu Bei killed Che Zhou, Inspector of Xu Province, and rebelled, Dong Zhao became Governor of Xu Province, and when Yuan Shao sent Yan Liang, he was transferred to Administrator of Wei Commandery and followed the campaign against Yan Liang. Records, Wei 14 §56–57
During the siege of Ye, he wrote to Yuan Chunqing, a member of Yuan Shao's clan who was inside the city, urging him to change sides. After Ye was pacified he became Counsellor Remonstrant (jianyi dafu). When Yuan Shang took refuge with Tadun of the Wuhuan and the Grand Progenitor was about to campaign against them, it was Dong Zhao's proposal to dig the two canals Pinglu and Quanzhou to reach the sea and carry provisions. The Grand Progenitor memorialized to enfeoff him as Marquis of Qianqiu Precinct and made him Libationer of the Army under the Minister of Works. Records, Wei 14 §58–63
Dong Zhao proposed establishing the five ranks of nobility according to the ancient system. When the Grand Progenitor said it was not a matter for a subject to decide, Dong Zhao said that since antiquity no one who had achieved merit like his had remained long in the position of a subject, and urged him to secure his foundation with land and people. The later receipt by the Grand Progenitor of the titles of Duke of Wei and King of Wei was all first planned by Dong Zhao. Xun Yu's biography records that in the 17th year of Jian'an (212) Dong Zhao and others secretly sounded out Xun Yu about the rank of duke of a state and the Nine Bestowments, and Xun Yu opposed it. Records, Wei 14 §64–66Records, Wei 10 §42
When Guan Yu besieged Cao Ren at Fan, Sun Quan sent an envoy saying he would make a surprise attack on Guan Yu and asking that the secret be kept. The ministers all said it should be kept secret, but Dong Zhao said they should agree outwardly and leak it inwardly. His reasons were that if Guan Yu went back the siege would be lifted and they could set the two enemies against each other and wait for them to wear each other out; that if the generals in the besieged city did not know help was coming they might have second thoughts; and that Guan Yu, being stubborn and fierce, would rely on the defenses of his two cities and not withdraw quickly. When Xu Huang shot Sun Quan's letter by arrow into the besieged city and into Guan Yu's camp, the morale inside the city rose a hundredfold, and Guan Yu hesitated, lost his two cities and was defeated. Records, Wei 14 §67–69
When Emperor Wen became king, Dong Zhao became Court Architect, and when he ascended the imperial throne, Grand Herald, and was enfeoffed as Marquis of You District; in the 2nd year of Huangchu (221) he was transferred to Palace Attendant. In the 3rd year of Huangchu (222), when Cao Xiu memorialized that he would sweep through the land south of the Yangtze, Emperor Wen worried that he would cross the river straight away, but Dong Zhao said that Zang Ba and the other generals were already rich and noble and would not take risks, so Cao Xiu's resolve would collapse of itself. Records, Wei 14 §70–71
When Xiahou Shang, attacking Jiangling, wanted to camp on a sandbar in the middle of the river and go back and forth by a pontoon bridge, Dong Zhao memorialized that this was extremely deep, dangerous and narrow, things military men avoid. Emperor Wen had Xiahou Shang and the others hurriedly withdraw, and ten days after the army came out, the river suddenly rose. Emperor Wen said that even Zhang Liang and Chen Ping could have done no better. In the 5th year of Huangchu (224) his fief was changed to Marquis of Chengdu District; he became Minister of Ceremonies, then Household Grandee and Supervisor of the Palace (jishizhong), and in the 7th year (226) Minister Coachman. Records, Wei 14 §73–77
When Emperor Ming took the throne, Dong Zhao's rank was raised to Marquis of Leping and he was transferred to Minister of the Guards. In the 4th year of Taihe (230) he became acting Minister over the Masses, and in the 6th year (232) he was formally made Minister over the Masses. He memorialized that the young men no longer took learning as their foundation but devoted themselves to socializing and forming cliques, and Emperor Ming issued a stern edict dismissing Zhuge Dan, Deng Yang and others. According to the Annals of Emperor Ming, Dong Zhao, Minister over the Masses, died in the 5th month of the 4th year of Qinglong (236). He was eighty-one; his posthumous title was Marquis Ding, and his son Dong Zhou succeeded him. Records, Wei 14 §77–81Records, Wei 3 §26 · 45
In his assessment, Chen Shou said that Cheng Yu, Guo Jia, Dong Zhao, Liu Ye and Jiang Ji were remarkable men of their age in talent, strategy and planning, and that although their achievements in honest governance and virtuous conduct differed from those of Xun You, in devising plans and making estimates they were of his kind. Records, Wei 14 §158
In Chapter 14 of the Romance, Emperor Xian sends someone to summon Cao Cao to the palace, and that envoy is Dong Zhao. When Cao Cao asks why he alone is well fed while the people of Luoyang all look hungry, Dong Zhao answers, 'I have eaten plain food for thirty years.' He explains that he was nominated as Filial and Incorrupt, served as an attendant officer to Yuan Shao and Zhang Yang, and came when he heard the emperor had returned, receiving the post of Consultant on Policy (zhengyi lang); he gives his origin as Dingtao in Jiyin and his courtesy name as Gongren. Saying he has long heard his name, Cao Cao holds a banquet for him and has him meet Xun Yu. Romance, Ch. 14 §16–17
When Cao Cao is worried at seeing Yang Feng and Han Xian heading east, Dong Zhao says they are a witless lot and nothing to worry about, and that Li Jue and Guo Si are 'tigers without claws and birds without wings.' Then, citing the achievements of the Five Hegemons, he says that moving the imperial carriage to Xudu is the best plan, and advises sending Yang Feng a letter to reassure him and telling the ministers that Xudu is close to Luyang, making it easy to transport provisions. Cao Cao takes his hand and says, 'Whenever I have something to plan, I ask only you to teach me.' Xun Yu supports moving the capital to Xudu, saying that the words of Dong Zhao and Wang Li are right. After the move to Xudu, Cao Cao makes Dong Zhao Prefect of Luoyang together with Fan Cheng. Romance, Ch. 14 §18–22 · 25 · 34
In Chapter 61, the Chief Clerk Dong Zhao steps forward, saying that the Chancellor's achievements surpass even those of the Duke of Zhou and Lü Wang, and that Cao Cao should accept the rank of Duke of Wei and be granted the Nine Bestowments. When Xun Yu objects, he says, 'How can the hopes of the many be blocked for the sake of one man?' and submits a memorial asking that Cao Cao be raised to Duke of Wei. Romance, Ch. 61 §30 · 33
In Chapter 76, when Eastern Wu sends a letter saying it will make a surprise attack on Jing Province and asking that this not be leaked, the Registrar Dong Zhao proposes shooting the letter into Fancheng to reassure the troops and also to let Lord Guan learn of it. If Lord Guan, fearing the loss of Jing Province, hurriedly withdraws, Xu Huang can strike him while he is exposed. Cao Cao follows this plan. Romance, Ch. 76 §5–6
First meeting with Cao Cao: In Chapter 14 of the Romance, Dong Zhao first meets Cao Cao when he comes to his camp as Emperor Xian's envoy, and Cao Cao says he has long heard his name. In the Records, Dong Zhao had earlier persuaded Zhang Yang to help Cao Cao open contact with the court at Chang'an, and had written to Yang Feng in Cao Cao's name so that Cao Cao became General Who Guards the East. Cao Cao summoned him at Luoyang, had him sit beside him, and asked his advice. Romance, Ch. 14 §16–17Records, Wei 14 §48–53
His service under Yuan Shao: In Chapter 14 of the Romance, Dong Zhao says only that he was an attendant officer to Yuan Shao and Zhang Yang. In the Records, as Yuan Shao's Army Adviser he governed Julu and Wei Commandery, and left Yuan Shao after being slandered. Romance, Ch. 14 §17Records, Wei 14 §45–48
His offices: In Chapter 14 of the Romance, Dong Zhao says he received the post of Consultant on Policy, and after the move of the capital he becomes Prefect of Luoyang. In the Records, he became a Gentleman-Consultant at Anyi, then Prefect of Tallies and Seals, and in the 3rd year of Jian'an (198) Intendant of Henan. Romance, Ch. 14 §17 · 34Records, Wei 14 §49 · 52 · 56
Luyang: In Chapter 14 of the Romance, he advises telling the ministers that Xudu is close to Luyang, making it easy to transport provisions. In the Records, he advised reassuring Yang Feng by telling him, 'There is no grain in the capital, so I intend to escort the carriage to Luyang for a while.' Romance, Ch. 14 §21Records, Wei 14 §55
Duke of Wei and the Nine Bestowments: In Chapter 61 of the Romance, the Chief Clerk Dong Zhao openly requests the dukedom of Wei and the Nine Bestowments and stands up to Xun Yu, who opposes it. In Xun Yu's biography in the Records, Dong Zhao and others secretly sounded out Xun Yu in the 17th year of Jian'an (212), and Dong Zhao's biography records that he proposed establishing the five ranks of nobility and that the titles of Duke of Wei and King of Wei were all first planned by him. Chief Clerk is not among the offices listed in Dong Zhao's biography. Romance, Ch. 61 §30 · 33Records, Wei 10 §42Records, Wei 14 §45–81
Sun Quan's letter: In Chapter 76 of the Romance, Dong Zhao predicts that Lord Guan, fearing the loss of Jing Province, will hurriedly withdraw. In the Records, he said that Guan Yu, being stubborn and fierce, would rely on the defenses of his two cities and not withdraw quickly, and proposed setting the two enemies against each other and waiting for them to wear each other out. Romance, Ch. 76 §5–6Records, Wei 14 §67–68
His later career: In the Romance, Dong Zhao no longer appears after Chapter 76. In the Records, he served Emperor Wen and Emperor Ming, gave his views on Cao Xiu's crossing of the Yangtze and Xiahou Shang's camp at Jiangling, rose to Minister over the Masses, and died in the 4th year of Qinglong (236) at the age of eighty-one. Romance, Ch. 76 §5Records, Wei 14 §70–81Records, Wei 3 §45
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.
RUsed the bandits of Wei Commandery as spies and struck them, defeating them badly every timeWei 14 §47
NNo direct record — estimated as a civil official serving as Consultant on PolicyCh. 14 §17
RSettled Julu and Wei Commandery, and proposed the Pinglu and Quanzhou canalsWei 14 §47Wei 14 §63
NNo direct record — a record of explaining the move of the capital in terms of transporting provisionsCh. 14 §21
RPersuaded Zhang Yang to recommend Cao Cao, and single-handedly got Xue Hong and others to surrenderWei 14 §48Wei 14 §56
NGot on so well with Cao Cao that he was asked to teach him from then onCh. 14 §20Ch. 14 §22
REscaped Yuan Shao's slander by going to Emperor Xian and took Cao Cao's sideWei 14 §48Wei 14 §81
NFell in with Cao Cao's wishes and took the lead in proposing him as Duke of WeiCh. 61 §33
RNo direct record — estimated from his career as a civil officialWei 14 §45
NNo direct record — estimated as a civil officialCh. 14 §17
RPointed out the danger of the sandbar camp and had it withdrawn; the assessment calls him a man of strategyWei 14 §158Wei 14 §74
NDevised the plan to move the capital to Xudu and the plan to shoot the letter into FanchengCh. 14 §20Ch. 14 §21Ch. 76 §5
RNo direct record — a record of soothing and settling a commanderyWei 14 §47
NNo direct record — a record of Cao Cao saying he had long heard his nameCh. 14 §17
RForged Yuan Shao's proclamation, and Su Ze pushed him away as a flattererWei 14 §46Wei 16 §15
NUrged that Cao Cao become Duke of Wei with the Nine Bestowments and overrode Xun Yu's objectionCh. 61 §30Ch. 61 §33
RNo direct record — a memorial urging that learning be made the foundationWei 14 §78
NNo direct record — estimated from his memorial of proposalCh. 61 §30
RRecognized the weak Cao Cao as the hero of the realm and had others join hands with himWei 14 §49
NJudged Yang Feng and Han Xian to be a witless lotCh. 14 §18
Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)
3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.
AppearsNot present Chapter list →
Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).