Sun Xiu 孫休

RecordsRomance Wu Courtesy name 子烈 Zilie손휴자열孙休

Profile
OccupationRNRuler · Emperor of WuFactionWu
AppearsRNBiography inBook of Wu
BornR235 UnverifiedNative placeWu Commandery Fuchun County Unverified
DiedR264 UnverifiedPlace of death
Cause of deathRIllness NIllness Unverified
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR52

Profile

Sun Xiu, courtesy name Zilie, was the sixth son of Sun Quan. Enfeoffed as Prince of Langya, he lived at Hulin, then moved by way of Danyang to Kuaiji. Records, Wu 3 §20

In the 3rd year of Taiping (258), when Sun Chen deposed the emperor Sun Liang, Sun Xiu was brought in and ascended the throne, changing the reign title to Yong'an. In the 12th month of that year he had Sun Chen, whose family had produced five marquises and who wielded power at will, beheaded at the La festival assembly. He established school officials and loved reading the classics, but he entrusted the government to Puyang Xing and Zhang Bu, to whom he owed old favors. He died in the 7th month of the 7th year of Yong'an (264) at the age of thirty, and his posthumous title was Emperor Jing. Records, Wu 3 §18 · 21–24 · 26 · 28 · 30 · 37–38 · 45–46

Chen Shou, author of the Records, wrote in his assessment that although Sun Xiu was well-intentioned and loved learning, he employed Puyang Xing and Zhang Bu and failed to promote men of talent, and so could not remedy the disorder; and that in not letting the deposed Sun Liang die a natural death he showed little brotherly duty. In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 113 and appears in 5 of its 120 chapters; the title of Chapter 113, 'Ding Feng Settles a Plan and Beheads Sun Chen', concerns his removal of Sun Chen. Records, Wu 3 §88Romance, Ch. 113 §12 · 17–20

In the Records

Sun Xiu's mother, Lady Wang, won Sun Quan's favor during the Jiahe era and bore him. At thirteen Sun Xiu studied under the Gentleman of the Palace Secretariat She Ci and the Gentleman of the Palace Sheng Chong, and at the end of the Chiwu era Sun Quan took Lady Zhu, daughter of Zhu Ju, as his consort. In the 1st month of the 2nd year of Taiyuan (252) he was enfeoffed as Prince of Langya and lived at Hulin. Records, Wu 5 §23 · 31Records, Wu 3 §20

In the 4th month of that year Sun Quan died and Sun Xiu's younger brother Sun Liang succeeded him. Zhuge Ke, who held power, did not want the princes to be in the military strongholds along the Yangtze, and moved Sun Xiu to Danyang Commandery. When Li Heng, Administrator of Danyang, repeatedly harassed him on various pretexts, Sun Xiu petitioned to move and went to Kuaiji. During the Wufeng era, when Sun Jun, listening to Princess Quan (Sun Luban), unjustly put to death Princess Zhu (Sun Luyu), the mother of Sun Xiu's consort Lady Zhu, Sun Xiu in fear sent his consort back to Jianye, but Sun Jun returned her to him. Records, Wu 3 §20Records, Wu 5 §31–32

After he had spent some years in Kuaiji, he dreamed that he was riding a dragon up to heaven and, looking back, could not see its tail. In the 9th month of the 3rd year of Taiping (258) Sun Chen deposed Sun Liang and, on the advice of the Commandant of the Guard Shi Zheng, sent the Director of the Imperial Clan Sun Kai and the Gentleman of the Palace Secretariat Dong Chao to receive Sun Xiu. At first Sun Xiu was suspicious and stayed for a day and two nights before setting out. In the 10th month at Qu'e an old man kowtowed and begged him to hurry, saying, 'When matters drag on, trouble arises'; Sun Xiu thought this right and that same day pressed on as far as Busai Pavilion. Records, Wu 3 §18 · 21–22Records, Wu 19 §90

At Yongchang Pavilion, Sun En came to meet him at the head of the officials. Sun Xiu advanced in a hand-drawn carriage and received the obeisance of the ministers, and after declining three times he accepted the imperial seal and tallies. When Sun Chen, leading a thousand soldiers, bowed at the roadside, Sun Xiu got down from his carriage and bowed in return. That same day he entered the main hall, proclaimed a general amnesty and changed the reign title. This year was the 3rd year of Ganlu in Wei. Records, Wu 3 §22–23

In the 10th month of the 1st year of Yong'an (258) he rewarded those who had received him, making Sun Chen Chancellor and Governor of Jing Province and Zhang Bu General Who Assists Righteousness and Marquis of Yongkang, among others. To Li Heng, the Administrator of Danyang who had harassed him, he said that 'shooting the belt hook and cutting off the sleeve were each done for the lord of the time', and sent him back to his commandery so that he would have no misgivings. He enfeoffed his nephew Sun Hao as Marquis of Wucheng. As Sun Chen's family had produced five marquises, all commanding the palace guards, and his power overshadowed the sovereign's, Sun Xiu, fearing an upheaval, repeatedly added to his rewards. Records, Wu 3 §24–26 · 48

When Sun Chen offered beef and wine and Sun Xiu did not accept them, Sun Chen went to Zhang Bu and complained that without him the emperor would never have been set up, and Zhang Bu reported this. When Sun Chen asked through Meng Zong (Meng Ren) to go out and garrison Wuchang, Sun Xiu granted it and ordered that he be given more than ten thousand elite troops of the Central Camp and the weapons of the armory. When the general Wei Miao and the Martial Guardsman Shi Shuo reported signs of rebellion, Sun Xiu secretly consulted Zhang Bu, and Ding Feng, recommended by Zhang Bu, proposed killing Sun Chen at the La festival assembly. Records, Wu 19 §97–98Records, Wu 3 §28Records, Wu 10 §104

On the wuchen day of the 12th month of the 1st year of Yong'an (early 259 CE), Sun Chen pleaded illness to avoid the La festival assembly, but Sun Xiu sent messengers more than ten times and forced him to come. When a fire broke out outside the palace and Sun Chen tried to leave, Sun Xiu stopped him, saying, 'There are plenty of troops outside; there is no need to trouble the Chancellor', and Ding Feng and Zhang Bu signaled to the attendants to bind him. When Sun Chen begged to be exiled to Jiao Province, Sun Xiu asked why he had not exiled Teng Yin and Lü Ju, and had him beheaded. He had Sun Jun's coffin dug up and his seal and ribbon taken, and had Zhuge Ke, Teng Yin and Lü Ju reburied. Ashamed to be of the same clan as Sun Jun and Sun Chen, Sun Xiu struck them from the register of the imperial clan. Records, Wu 3 §28Records, Wu 19 §99–102

Sun Xiu issued an edict establishing school officials and appointing Erudites of the Five Classics. In the 3rd month of the 2nd year of Yong'an (259), declaring that he would lay down arms and cultivate learning, he asked whether it was not because taxes were heavy that the people abandoned farming to trade on the Yangtze, and had his ministers discuss ways to open up more farmland and lighten taxes. Records, Wu 3 §30–34

In the 3rd year of Yong'an (260), on the proposal of the Commandant Yan Mi, the Puli Dike was built. The Biography of Puyang Xing records that when all the officials opposed it, he alone said it could be done, and that the cost was beyond counting and soldiers died, so the people resented it bitterly. In the same year a rumor spread in Kuaiji Commandery that Sun Liang would return to become Son of Heaven again, and it was reported that Sun Liang had had a shaman utter ill-omened words. Sun Liang was demoted to Marquis of Houguan and killed himself on the way to his fief. Records, Wu 3 §35Records, Wu 19 §105

In the 5th year of Yong'an (262) he made Lady Zhu empress and his son Sun Wan crown prince, and appointed Puyang Xing Chancellor. Sun Xiu entrusted affairs to Puyang Xing and Zhang Bu, to whom he owed old favors, Zhang Bu taking charge of the palace and Puyang Xing of military and state affairs. Sun Xiu wished to read all the writings of the Hundred Schools, and put down his books only when he went out pheasant shooting in spring and summer. When he wished to hold discussions with the Libationer of the Erudites Wei Yao and the Erudite Sheng Chong, Zhang Bu, fearing that his faults would be exposed, blocked it. Sun Xiu rebuked him, saying that he had already read all about treacherous ministers and rebels, but fearing that Zhang Bu would become suspicious and afraid, he gave up the discussions in the end. Records, Wu 3 §37–42

That year he sent inspectors to Jiaozhi to requisition peacocks and great pigs, and in the 5th month of the 6th year of Yong'an (263), Lü Xing and other officials of Jiaozhi Commandery stirred up soldiers and commoners who feared being carried off again, and killed the Administrator Sun Xu. In the 10th month, when Shu reported Wei's attack, he had the General-in-Chief Ding Feng head for Shouchun and sent other generals to Nan Commandery and Mianzhong, but called them off at the news that Liu Shan had surrendered to Wei. On the guiwei day of the 7th month of the 7th year of Yong'an (264), Sun Xiu died at the age of thirty; his posthumous title was Emperor Jing. On the advice of Wan Yu, Puyang Xing and Zhang Bu set aside Sun Xiu's legitimate heir and put Sun Hao on the throne. Records, Wu 3 §42–46Records, Wu 19 §106

In his assessment, Chen Shou said that Sun Xiu employed Puyang Xing and Zhang Bu out of old affection and past favors and failed to promote outstanding men to reform the government, so that even though he was well-intentioned and loved learning, of what help was that in remedying the disorder? He also wrote that in not letting the already deposed Sun Liang die a natural death, Sun Xiu showed little brotherly duty. Records, Wu 3 §88

In the Romance

In Chapter 113 of the Romance, after deposing Sun Liang as Prince of Kuaiji, Sun Chen sends the Director of the Imperial Clan Sun Kai and the Gentleman of the Palace Secretariat Dong Chao to Hulin to receive Sun Xiu, Prince of Langya. At Hulin Sun Xiu dreams that he is riding a dragon up to heaven and, looking back, cannot see the dragon's tail. At Qu'e an old man who gives his surname as Gan and his personal name as Xiu urges him to hurry. When Sun En meets him at Busai Pavilion with the imperial carriage, Sun Xiu does not dare to ride in the hand-drawn carriage and enters in a small cart, and when the officials bow at the roadside he hastily gets down from the cart to return their greeting. After declining repeatedly he accepts the imperial seal and changes the reign title to Yong'an, makes Sun Chen Chancellor and Governor of Jing Province, and enfeoffs his elder brother's son Sun Hao as Marquis of Wucheng. Romance, Ch. 113 §10 · 12–13

When Sun Chen's family produces five marquises who command the palace guards, Sun Xiu outwardly bestows favors on him while inwardly remaining on guard. In the winter, in the 12th month, when Sun Xiu refuses the beef and wine Sun Chen offers, Sun Chen goes to Zhang Bu to complain, and Zhang Bu secretly reports it. When Sun Chen has the Gentleman of the Palace Secretariat Meng Zong (Meng Ren) assign him 15,000 elite troops of the Central Camp to garrison Wuchang and hand over all the weapons of the armory, Wei Miao and Shi Shuo warn of an uprising. On Zhang Bu's recommendation Sun Xiu summons the veteran general Ding Feng, and they decide to invite Sun Chen to a banquet on the pretext of gathering the ministers on the La festival day. Romance, Ch. 113 §14–17

At the banquet, when word comes that a fire has broken out outside the palace and Sun Chen tries to rise, Sun Xiu holds him back, saying, 'There are plenty of troops outside,' and Zhang Bu comes up with more than thirty armed men and seizes Sun Chen. When Sun Chen asks to be exiled to Jiao Province, Sun Xiu rebukes him—'Why did you not exile Teng Yin, Lü Ju and Wang Dun?'—and has him beheaded. He exterminates Sun Chen's family to the third degree, has Sun Jun's grave dug up and his corpse defiled, and restores the graves of Zhuge Ke and the others. When Xue Xu, returning from Shu, reports that Huang Hao holds power there and no honest words can be heard, Sun Xiu sighs, 'Had Zhuge Wuhou been alive, how could it have come to this?', and sends a state letter to Chengdu urging preparations. Romance, Ch. 113 §19–23

In Chapter 117, when Peng He, sent by Zhuge Zhan, who is besieged at Mianzhu, presents a letter asking for help, Sun Xiu says that he cannot sit and watch while Shu is in peril, and gives the veteran general Ding Feng 50,000 troops to relieve Shu in three columns. In Chapter 119, when Shu has fallen and Ding Feng returns, Sun Xiu, following the advice of the Assistant of the Palace Secretariat Hua He, makes Lu Kang Grand General Who Guards the East and Governor of Jing Province to hold Jiangkou, and has several hundred camps set up along the river to guard against Wei. Romance, Ch. 117 §41–42Romance, Ch. 119 §23

In Chapter 120, hearing that Sima Yan has usurped the throne of Wei and knowing that he will surely attack Wu, Sun Xiu falls ill with worry and takes to his bed. He summons the Chancellor Puyang Xing to the palace, has the crown prince Sun Wan come out to bow, and, grasping Puyang Xing's arm and pointing at Sun Wan, breathes his last. Puyang Xing wishes to set up Sun Wan, but Wan Yu and Zhang Bu put forward Sun Hao, Marquis of Wucheng, and at the word of Empress Dowager Zhu, Sun Hao is enthroned. In the same chapter Lu Kai states in a memorial that the palace women of the harem, who numbered fewer than a hundred in the time of Emperor Da, have come to number in the thousands since Emperor Jing. Romance, Ch. 120 §1–3 · 6

Where the Romance differs

The dream and where he was received: In Chapter 113 of the Romance, Sun Xiu has his dream at Hulin and receives the envoys there. In the Records, Sun Xiu lived at Hulin, moved by way of Danyang to Kuaiji, and had the dream after spending some years in Kuaiji. The Biography of Puyang Xing also states that Sun Xiu was in Kuaiji at this time. Romance, Ch. 113 §12Records, Wu 3 §20–21Records, Wu 19 §104

The old man at Qu'e: The old man in Chapter 113 of the Romance gives his surname as Gan and his personal name as Xiu. In the Records he is a nameless old man who stops Sun Xiu and kowtows to him. Romance, Ch. 113 §12Records, Wu 3 §21

Entry for the enthronement: In Chapter 113 of the Romance, Sun Xiu does not dare to ride in the hand-drawn carriage and enters in a small cart, and Sun Chen invites him into the great hall and seats him on the throne. In the Records, Sun Xiu advanced in a hand-drawn carriage at Yongchang Pavilion and received the obeisance of the ministers, and after declining three times accepted the imperial seal and tallies presented by the Chancellor. Romance, Ch. 113 §13Records, Wu 3 §22–23

Sun Chen's garrison at Wuchang: In Chapter 113 of the Romance, Sun Chen has Meng Zong assign him 15,000 elite troops to garrison Wuchang. In the Biography of Sun Chen in the Records, Sun Chen asked through Meng Zong to go out and garrison Wuchang, and Sun Xiu granted it and ordered that he be given more than ten thousand elite troops of the Central Camp and weapons. Romance, Ch. 113 §16Records, Wu 19 §98

The beheading of Sun Chen: In Chapter 113 of the Romance, Zhang Bu comes up with more than thirty armed men, seizes Sun Chen and beheads him. In the Records, Ding Feng and Zhang Bu signaled to the attendants to bind Sun Chen, and Sun Xiu rebuked him by citing Teng Yin and Lü Ju before having him beheaded. Wang Dun, whom the Romance adds to the rebuke, does not appear in the Records. Romance, Ch. 113 §19–20Records, Wu 19 §100

Xue Xu's report: In Chapter 113 of the Romance, on hearing the words of Xue Xu, back from Shu, Sun Xiu recalls Zhuge Liang and sighs. Sun Xiu's annals in the Biographies of the Three Successor Lords in the Records have no such episode. Romance, Ch. 113 §22–23Records, Wu 3 §19–46

Relief of Shu: In Chapter 117 of the Romance, Sun Xiu sends Ding Feng in response to the request for help brought by Peng He from Zhuge Zhan. In the Records, when Shu reported Wei's attack in the 10th month of the 6th year of Yong'an (263), Sun Xiu sent Ding Feng to Shouchun and other generals to Nan Commandery and Mianzhong. Peng He and Zhuge Zhan's letter do not appear. Romance, Ch. 117 §41–42Records, Wu 3 §43–44

Lu Kang's appointment: In Chapter 119 of the Romance, after the fall of Shu, Sun Xiu makes Lu Kang Grand General Who Guards the East and Governor of Jing Province to hold Jiangkou. In the Biography of Lu Kang in the Records, Lu Kang became General Who Guards the Army and commander at Xiling in the 2nd year of Yong'an (259), and it was only after Sun Hao's accession that he became Grand General Who Guards the Army and Governor of Yi Province. Romance, Ch. 119 §23Records, Wu 13 §62

Time of death: In Chapter 120 of the Romance, Sun Xiu falls ill with worry at the news that Sima Yan has usurped the throne of Wei, and dies. In the Records, Sun Xiu died on the guiwei day of the 7th month of the 7th year of Yong'an (264), while Wei's abdication to Jin took place in the 12th month of the 2nd year of Xianxi (early 266 CE). A Wei edict also records that Sun Xiu died of illness. Romance, Ch. 120 §1Records, Wu 3 §46Records, Wei 4 §141 · 145 · 150

The final scene: In Chapter 120 of the Romance, Sun Xiu breathes his last grasping Puyang Xing's arm and pointing at the crown prince Sun Wan. This scene is not in Chen Shou's text in the Records, which states that Puyang Xing and Zhang Bu, on Wan Yu's advice, set aside Sun Xiu's legitimate heir and put Sun Hao on the throne. Romance, Ch. 120 §1Records, Wu 3 §46 · 48–49Records, Wu 19 §106

Sun Liang's end: The Romance records nothing further of Sun Liang after he is deposed as Prince of Kuaiji in Chapter 113. In the Records, in the 3rd year of Yong'an (260) Sun Liang was demoted to Marquis of Houguan and killed himself on the way to his fief, and in his assessment Chen Shou said of this that Sun Xiu showed little brotherly duty. Romance, Ch. 113 §10Records, Wu 3 §35 · 88

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA3835−3
  • STR3131±0
  • INT6260−2
  • POL6250−12
  • CHA5048−2
  • VIR5055+5
  • ADP7070±0
  • SCH7242−30
  • DIP4550+5
  • DIS2555+30
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

ScholarshipR72N42Unverified −30

RDevoted himself to the classics and wished to read all the Hundred Schools; the assessment says he loved learningWu 3 §38Wu 3 §88

NNo direct record — estimated, as there is no record of learning beyond his words recalling Zhuge WuhouCh. 113 §23

DiscernmentR25N55 +30

RThe assessment says he employed Puyang Xing and Zhang Bu out of old affection and failed to promote talentWu 3 §88Wu 3 §37Wu 3 §42

NEntrusted affairs to Ding Feng on Zhang Bu's recommendation and followed Hua He's adviceCh. 113 §17Ch. 119 §23

PoliticsR62N50 −12

RSet up school officials and Erudites of the Five Classics and lightened taxes, but the assessment says he failed to reform the governmentWu 3 §30Wu 3 §33Wu 3 §88

NRestored the graves of loyal ministers harmed by Sun Chen and pardoned the exilesCh. 113 §21

7 similar abilities — show evidence
  • LeadershipR38N35Unverified −3

    RSent Ding Feng and others to relieve Shu, but the siege of Luo Xian was abandoned when Wei's relief army arrivedWu 3 §44Wu 3 §45

    NNo direct record — estimated from his conduct as a ruler ordering defensesCh. 119 §23

  • StrengthR31UnverifiedN31Unverified ±0

    RNo direct record — estimated, as there is no record of martial skill beyond his fondness for pheasant shootingWu 3 §38

    NNo direct record — estimated from his conduct as a rulerCh. 113 §19

  • IntelligenceR62N60 −2

    ROn hearing of Sun Chen's plot, secretly planned with Zhang Bu and had him executed at the court assemblyWu 3 §28Wu 3 §39

    NForesaw Sima Zhao's usurpation and invasion of Wu and Shu, and knew Sima Yan would surely attack WuCh. 113 §23Ch. 120 §1

  • CharismaR50N48 −2

    RThe old man at Qu'e urged his accession, saying the realm was craning its neck in expectationWu 3 §21

    NSun Chen said he had set him up as ruler because he thought him worthyCh. 113 §15

  • VirtueR50N55 +5

    RForgave Li Heng despite old grievances, but the assessment says letting the deposed Sun Liang die showed little brotherly dutyWu 3 §25Wu 3 §35Wu 3 §88

    NGot down from his cart to return the officials' greeting, but exterminated Sun Chen's family to the third degree and defiled Sun Jun's corpseCh. 113 §13Ch. 113 §21

  • AdaptabilityR70N70 ±0

    RDid not defy the powerful minister Sun Chen but reassured him with added rewards, then executed him when the chance cameWu 3 §26Wu 3 §28Wu 3 §21

    NOutwardly bestowed favors while inwardly guarding against Sun Chen, then seized and beheaded him at a banquetCh. 113 §14Ch. 113 §19

  • DiplomacyR45N50 +5

    RAdmonished Zhang Bu in writing for blocking the scholars' discussions, making him apologizeWu 3 §39

    NSent envoys and a state letter to Shu proposing joint preparations against Sima ZhaoCh. 113 §22

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (5)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Allegiance history

  1. Wu · Records · Records vol. 48 「太元二年正月,封琅邪王」

Relations

  • Wu Led by · Records

Family

ParentsSun Quan Novel & History
SpouseLady Zhu (Sun Xiu) Records
SiblingsSun Liang Novel & History, Sun Deng Novel & History, Sun Fen Records, Sun Lü Records, Sun He(孫和) Novel & History, Sun Ba Records, Sun Luban Novel & History

Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.

Related events (1)

Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).