Bu Zhi 步騭

RecordsRomance Wu Courtesy name 子山 Zishan歩騭보즐자산步骘

Profile
OccupationRGeneral · General of Agile CavalryFactionWu
AppearsRNBiography inBook of Wu
BornR? UnverifiedNative placeXiapi Commandery Huaiyin County
DiedR247 UnverifiedPlace of death
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR36

Profile

Bu Zhi, courtesy name Zishan, was a man of Huaiyin County in Linhuai Commandery. He fled the disorders to Jiangdong and lived in poverty until he became Sun Quan's Chief Recorder, and from the 15th year of Jian'an (210) he brought the southern lands into submission as Inspector of Jiao Province. Records, Wu 7 §68 · 71–72

When Sun Quan became emperor, Bu Zhi became General of Agile Cavalry and guarded Xiling for 20 years; in the 9th year of Chiwu (246) he succeeded Lu Xun as Chancellor, and he died the following year. Records, Wu 7 §74 · 86–87

Chen Shou, the author of the Records, said in his assessment that Zhuge Jin and Bu Zhi were both valued in their time for their virtue and magnanimity, their adherence to rules and their restraint. In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 43 as one of the scholars of Eastern Wu who debate with Zhuge Liang, and appears in 5 of its 120 chapters; his name is not in any chapter title. He appears at Sun Quan's councils, going as an envoy to seek peace and offering a plan to take Jing Province. Records, Wu 7 §100Romance, Ch. 43 §21Romance, Ch. 68 §25Romance, Ch. 73 §23

In the Records

Bu Zhi, courtesy name Zishan, was a man of Huaiyin County in Linhuai Commandery. When the world fell into disorder he fled to Jiangdong, alone and impoverished. He was on good terms with Wei Jing of Guangling, who was the same age, and together they supported themselves by growing melons, working hard with their bodies by day and reciting the classics and their commentaries by night. Records, Wu 7 §68

Jiao Zhengqiang, a powerful clan head of Kuaiji, had retainers who behaved without restraint, so the two, fearing that they would be preyed upon, prepared name cards and went to present him with melons. When Jiao Zhengqiang kept them waiting a long time, Wei Jing wanted to give up and leave, but Bu Zhi stopped him, saying that they had come in the first place because they feared his power, and that leaving now would only make an enemy of him. Jiao Zhengqiang sat leaning on an armrest inside his curtains and seated the two on mats spread on the ground outside the window, and while he himself was served at a great table, he gave the two only rice and vegetables on small plates. Wei Jing could not eat, but Bu Zhi ate his fill before leaving, and he said to the angry Wei Jing that they were poor and lowly, so it was only proper that their host treated them that way; what was there to be ashamed of? Records, Wu 7 §69–70

When Sun Quan became General Who Smites Barbarians, he summoned Bu Zhi and made him Chief Recorder. After serving as Chief of Haiyan he became Officer of the East Bureau under the General of Chariots and Cavalry, and in the 15th year of Jian'an (210) he concurrently held the post of Administrator of Poyang; that same year he was transferred to Inspector of Jiao Province and General of the Household Who Establishes Martial Might and went south leading a thousand armed officers, and the following year he became General of the Household Who Conquers the South, bearing the Credentials. When Wu Ju, the Administrator of Cangwu appointed by Liu Biao, outwardly complied but secretly harbored other intentions, Bu Zhi humbled himself to coax him, asked to meet him, and on that occasion beheaded him and displayed his head. His authority and fame resounded, and Shi Xie and his brothers led one another in obeying his orders; it was from this time that the southern lands submitted. Records, Wu 7 §71–72Records, Wu 4 §43

When Yong Kai and others of the great clans of Yi Province killed Zheng Ang, the Administrator appointed by Shu, and asked through Shi Xie to submit, Bu Zhi, exercising the emperor's authority, sent envoys to receive them. For this he was additionally made General Who Pacifies the Rong and enfeoffed as Marquis of Guangxin. In the 1st year of Yankang (220), when Sun Quan sent Lü Dai to replace him, Bu Zhi led ten thousand volunteers of Jiao Province out to Changsha. Just then Liu Bei came down to the east and the Man barbarians of Wuling rose up, so Sun Quan sent him up to Yiyang. Even after Liu Bei was defeated, several commanderies such as Lingling and Guiyang still resisted in arms here and there, and Bu Zhi went around campaigning against them and pacified them all. Records, Wu 7 §72–73Records, Wu 15 §35

In the 2nd year of Huangwu (223) he was moved to General of the Right and Protector of the Army of the Left and his fief was changed to Marquis of Linxiang, and in the 5th year of Huangwu (226) he was granted the Tally and moved his garrison to Oukou. In the 1st year of Huanglong (229), when Sun Quan took the imperial title, Bu Zhi became General of Agile Cavalry and concurrently Governor of Ji Province, and that year he took command at Xiling and watched over the two borders in place of Lu Xun. Soon afterwards Ji Province fell within Shu's share, and he was relieved of the governorship. Records, Wu 7 §73–74Records, Wu 2 §61

When the Crown Prince Sun Deng, who was at Wuchang, wrote to ask in what order he should treat the gentlemen near and far, Bu Zhi listed point by point the conduct of eleven men who held posts within the borders of Jing Province, including Zhuge Jin, Lu Xun and Zhu Ran, and in a memorial urged that a ruler does not attend to small matters in person but each of the officials takes charge of his own duties, and that now was precisely the time to entrust affairs to worthy men. Records, Wu 7 §74–77

Later, when the Palace Secretary Lü Yi took charge of examining documents and denounced many people, Bu Zhi memorialized that the examiners blew aside hairs to find blemishes and pressed charges heavily, so that the innocent suffered severe punishments, and asked that in judging cases Gu Yong be consulted in the capital, and Lu Xun and Pan Jun at Wuchang. He also cited the earthquakes of the 6th year of Jiahe (237) and the 2nd year of Chiwu (239) as signs that ministers were monopolizing the government, and said that the Chancellor Gu Yong, the Senior General-in-Chief Lu Xun and the Minister of Ceremonies Pan Jun were ministers of the altars of the state and that other officials should not be made to watch over the matters in their charge. Sun Quan too came to realize this and in the end executed Lü Yi. Records, Wu 7 §78–82 · 85

Over the years Bu Zhi submitted dozens of documents recommending men of talent who had been held down and blocked and rescuing those in trouble. Although Sun Quan could not accept them all, he adopted his words from time to time, and many people benefited. Zhang Zhao's nephew Zhang Fen was also recommended by Bu Zhi after building a great siege cart at the age of twenty. When Liu Fang of Wei altered one of Sun Quan's letters and showed it to Zhuge Liang, Zhuge Liang passed it on to Bu Zhi and other great generals of Wu, and Bu Zhi and the others showed it to Sun Quan. In the 7th year of Chiwu (244) he joined Zhu Ran and others in memorializing that Shu was about to break the alliance and communicate with Wei, but Sun Quan thought that this would not be so. Records, Wu 7 §85 · 18Records, Wei 14 §149–150Records, Wu 2 §100–101

In the 9th month of the 9th year of Chiwu (246) he went from General of Agile Cavalry to Chancellor in place of Lu Xun, but he still taught his disciples and never let a book out of his hand, and his clothing and dwelling were like those of a Confucian scholar. However, the dress of the wives and concubines in his household was extravagant and showy, and for this he was rather criticized. During his 20 years at Xiling even the neighboring enemy respected his authority and good faith. He was generous and broad-minded by nature and won people's hearts, and though he did not show joy or anger in his voice or face, all within and without were solemn. Records, Wu 7 §86Records, Wu 2 §104

He died in the 5th month of the 10th year of Chiwu (247). His son Bu Xie succeeded him and commanded his troops, and Bu Xie's younger brother Bu Chan carried on the family's work as Commander of Xiling. In the 1st year of Fenghuang (272), when Bu Chan was summoned, he feared that he would lose his post and suffer the calamity of slander, so he held the city and surrendered to Jin. Lu Kang took the city and beheaded Bu Chan and others, and the Bu clan was wiped out, with only Bu Xuan continuing the sacrifices. Records, Wu 7 §87–88Records, Wu 2 §105

In his assessment Chen Shou wrote that Zhuge Jin and Bu Zhi were both valued in their time for their virtue and magnanimity, their adherence to rules and their restraint. The same volume also includes a passage in which Zhou Zhao of Yingchuan praised Bu Zhi, together with Yan Jun and others, in a work he wrote. Records, Wu 7 §100 · 90–91

In the Romance

He first appears in Chapter 43 of the Romance, when Zhuge Liang debates with the scholars of Eastern Wu. When Bu Zhi asks whether Kongming means to imitate the tongues of Zhang Yi and Su Qin to persuade Eastern Wu, Zhuge Liang replies that Su Qin and Zhang Yi were also heroes with plans to set right and support other states, and retorts that men who take fright at Cao Cao's false threats and ask to surrender dare to laugh at Su Qin and Zhang Yi. Bu Zhi keeps his mouth shut and says nothing. Romance, Ch. 43 §21–22

In Chapter 44 he goes with Zhang Zhao, Gu Yong and Zhang Hong to Zhou Yu to urge surrender. In Chapter 68, when Sun Quan has faced Cao Cao at Ruxu for more than a month without winning, Bu Zhi, on the advice of Zhang Zhao and Gu Yong, goes to Cao Cao's camp to ask for peace and promises to pay tribute every year. When Bu Zhi returns and reports, Sun Quan leaves only Jiang Qin and Zhou Tai to guard Ruxukou and takes his main army back to Moling. Romance, Ch. 44 §3–4Romance, Ch. 68 §25–26

In Chapter 73, after Guan Yu rejects Zhuge Jin's marriage proposal, Bu Zhi says that the one Cao Cao fears is Liu Bei, so having Wu attack Shu is a way of shifting the calamity onto Wu. He then advises asking Cao Cao to have Cao Ren at Fancheng first attack Jing Province by land; Guan Yu will then pull troops out of Jing Province and go to Fancheng, and at that moment they can send a general to take Jing Province by stealth. Sun Quan follows his advice and sends an envoy to Cao Cao. Romance, Ch. 73 §22–24

In Chapter 83, when Liu Bei's might resounds, Bu Zhi advises that, since Lü Meng, Pan Zhang, Ma Zhong, Mi Fang and Fu Shiren, whom Liu Bei hates, are all dead, they should capture the remaining Fan Jiang and Zhang Da and send them back together with Zhang Fei's head, hand over Jing Province, and return his wife to seek peace. Sun Quan follows his advice and sends Cheng Bing as envoy, but Liu Bei does not accept peace. In the same chapter, when Kan Ze recommends Lu Xun, Bu Zhi objects that Lu Xun's talent is only fit for governing a commandery and that it is not proper to entrust him with great affairs. Romance, Ch. 83 §29–30 · 33–35

Where the Romance differs

The debate with Zhuge Liang: In Chapter 43 of the Romance, Bu Zhi is one of the scholars of Eastern Wu who question Zhuge Liang, and he is left speechless. In the Biography of Zhuge Liang in the Records, Zhuge Liang only meets and persuades Sun Quan at Chaisang, with no debate with the scholars, and this is not in the Biography of Bu Zhi either. Romance, Ch. 43 §21–22Records, Shu 5 §12–16Records, Wu 7 §67–88

Where he was at the time: In Chapters 68 and 73 of the Romance, Bu Zhi discusses peace at Sun Quan's side and offers a plan to take Jing Province. In the Records, Bu Zhi went south as Inspector of Jiao Province in the 15th year of Jian'an (210) and stayed in Jiao Province until he was replaced by Lü Dai in the 1st year of Yankang (220). Romance, Ch. 68 §25Romance, Ch. 73 §23Records, Wu 7 §71–73

Peace at Ruxu: In Chapter 68 of the Romance, Bu Zhi goes to Cao Cao's camp to ask for peace. In the Biography of the Lord of Wu in the Records, after Cao Cao attacked Ruxu in the winter of the 21st year of Jian'an (216), Sun Quan sent the Commandant Xu Xiang the following spring to ask to surrender. Romance, Ch. 68 §25–26Records, Wu 2 §23–24

The plan to take Jing Province: In Chapter 73 of the Romance, Bu Zhi proposes a plan to draw Guan Yu out to Fancheng and take Jing Province by stealth. This is not in the Biography of Bu Zhi in the Records, and in the Biography of the Lord of Wu it is Lü Meng who makes the surprise attack on Gong'an and Nan Commandery. Romance, Ch. 73 §23–24Records, Wu 7 §67–88Records, Wu 2 §27

Sending back Fan Jiang and Zhang Da: In Chapter 83 of the Romance, on Bu Zhi's advice, Fan Jiang, Zhang Da and Zhang Fei's head are sent to Liu Bei to seek peace. This is not in the Biography of Bu Zhi in the Records. When Liu Bei came down to the east, Bu Zhi went up to Yiyang on Sun Quan's orders, and after Liu Bei's defeat he put down the resistance in Lingling, Guiyang and elsewhere. Romance, Ch. 83 §29–30Records, Wu 7 §73

The appointment of Lu Xun: In Chapter 83 of the Romance, Bu Zhi joins Zhang Zhao and Gu Yong in opposing the use of Lu Xun. The Biography of Lu Xun in the Records says only that Sun Quan made Lu Xun Grand Commander to resist Liu Bei, and no ministers who opposed it appear. Romance, Ch. 83 §35Records, Wu 13 §17

Jiao Province, Xiling and the chancellorship: The Romance stops dealing with Bu Zhi after Chapter 83, so his beheading of Wu Ju and subjugation of Shi Xie in Jiao Province, his 20 years guarding Xiling, his becoming Chancellor and his death do not appear. In the Records, Bu Zhi became Chancellor in the 9th year of Chiwu (246) and died the following year. Romance, Ch. 83 §35Records, Wu 7 §71–72 · 86–87

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA7031−39
  • STR3830−8
  • INT6064+4
  • POL7640−36
  • CHA8040−40
  • VIR7645−31
  • ADP7545−30
  • SCH6645−21
  • DIP6450−14
  • DIS8028−52
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

DiscernmentR80N28 −52

RAssessed and reported the conduct of eleven men in Jing Province, and dozens of times recommended talents who had been held backWu 7 §75Wu 7 §85Wu 7 §82

NOpposed Lu Xun's appointment, saying his talent was only fit for governing a commanderyCh. 83 §35

CharismaR80N40Unverified −40

RGenerous and broad-minded, he won people's hearts, and even the neighboring enemy respected his authority and good faithWu 7 §86Wu 7 §72

NNo direct record — estimated from his role as a civil officialCh. 44 §3

LeadershipR70N31Unverified −39

RBrought Jiao Province into submission, pacified Lingling and Guiyang, and held Xiling for 20 yearsWu 7 §72Wu 7 §86

NNo direct record — estimated from his role as a civil officialCh. 44 §3

PoliticsR76N40Unverified −36

RHis memorials on abuse of criminal cases and surplus officials led to Lü Yi's executionWu 7 §78Wu 7 §83

NNo direct record — estimated from his role as a civil officialCh. 44 §3

VirtueR76N45Unverified −31

RThe assessment says he was valued for virtue, magnanimity and rule; also criticized for his wives' and concubines' extravaganceWu 7 §100Wu 7 §85

NNo direct record — estimated from his proposals for peaceCh. 83 §29

ScholarshipR66N45Unverified −21

RRecited the classics at night; even as Chancellor he taught disciples and never put down his booksWu 7 §68Wu 7 §86

NNo direct record — estimated from his role as a scholar of JiangdongCh. 43 §21

DiplomacyR64N50 −14

RReceived Yong Kai's submission with grace; memorialized words of encouragement to the Crown PrinceWu 7 §72Wu 7 §74

NWent to Cao Cao's camp and secured peace, but was left speechless in the debate with KongmingCh. 68 §25Ch. 43 §22

2 similar abilities — show evidence
  • StrengthR38UnverifiedN30Unverified −8

    RNo direct record — estimated from his career as a former civil officialWu 7 §68

    NNo direct record — estimated from his role as a civil officialCh. 44 §3

  • IntelligenceR60N64 +4

    RCoaxed Wu Ju, who harbored other intentions, into a meeting and beheaded him thereWu 7 §71

    NSaw through Cao Cao's design and proposed a way to take Jing ProvinceCh. 73 §23

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (5)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Allegiance history

  1. Wu · Records · 「孫權爲討虜將軍,召騭爲主記。」

Family

ChildrenBu Chan Records

Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.

Related events (1)

Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).