RPersuaded Cao Cao to send relief to GuanglingWei 22 §59
NNo direct record — estimated from his cowing of the officialsCh. 78 §36
| Occupation | ROfficial · Minister over the Masses NOfficial · Minister of War | Faction | Wei |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appears | RN | Biography in | Book of Wei |
| Born | R? Unverified | Native place | Guangling Commandery Dongyang County |
| Died | R237 Unverified | Place of death | |
| Existence | Historical | Mentions | R21 |
Chen Jiao, courtesy name Jibi, was a man of Dongyang County in Guangling Commandery. While serving as Officer of Merit to Chen Deng, the Administrator of Guangling, he sought relief from Cao Cao for the commandery when it was besieged by Sun Quan, and he was later summoned by Cao Cao and served as Administrator of Wei Commandery, Master of Writing and in other posts. Records, Wei 22 §58–62
When Cao Cao died at Luoyang, he persuaded ministers bound by precedent and had the Crown Prince Cao Pi enthroned within a single day, and under Emperor Wen (Cao Pi) he became Prefect of the Masters of Writing. Under Emperor Ming he rose to Minister over the Masses, and he died in the 1st year of Jingchu (237) and received the posthumous title Marquis Zhen. Records, Wei 22 §62–64Records, Wei 3 §53
In his assessment Chen Shou called him, together with Xu Xuan, 'firm, decisive and upright', and wrote that he long held the office of Master of Writing without disgracing his post. In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 51 as an adviser to Cao Ren, who is holding Nan Commandery, and appears in 3 of its 120 chapters; no chapter title bears his name. In Chapter 78 he cuts off the sleeve of his robe with a sword and forces through the enthronement of the heir. Records, Wei 22 §108Romance, Ch. 51 §15Romance, Ch. 78 §36
Chen Jiao, courtesy name Jibi, was a man of Dongyang County in Guangling Commandery. Fleeing the disorders, he stayed in Jiangdong and Dongcheng, but declined summonses from Sun Ce and Yuan Shu and returned to his home commandery. The Administrator Chen Deng invited him to be his Officer of Merit and sent him to Xu, saying that opinion in the capital did not treat him fairly and asking Chen Jiao to look into it and come back to instruct him. On his return Chen Jiao reported that people near and far said the Administrator was arrogant and conceited. Chen Deng replied that he respected Chen Yuanfang and his brother, Hua Ziyu, Zhao Yuanda, Kong Wenju and Liu Xuande each for their virtue and talent, so how could he be called arrogant? Yet this same Chen Deng deeply respected Chen Jiao and made him his friend. Records, Wei 22 §58
According to the Biography of Xu Xuan, Chen Jiao and Xu Xuan both held key posts in the commandery and were equally renowned, but privately they were not on good terms; both were valued by Chen Deng, and together with Chen Deng they set their hearts on Taizu (Cao Cao). When Guangling Commandery was besieged by Sun Quan at Kuangqi, Chen Deng sent Chen Jiao to ask Taizu for relief. Chen Jiao persuaded him that Guangling, though small, was a place of strategic advantage, and that if it were relieved and made an outer bulwark, the schemes of the men of Wu would be thwarted and Xu Province would be lastingly secure. When Taizu, marveling at him, wished to keep him by his side, Chen Jiao declined, saying that he had hurried there because his home state was in dire peril, as if hanging upside down: 'Even if I lack the merit of Shen Xu, how could I dare forget the righteousness of Hong Yan?' Taizu sent troops, the Wu army withdrew, and Chen Deng set many ambushes, pursued them and inflicted a great defeat. Records, Wei 22 §68 · 59–60
Taizu summoned Chen Jiao and made him a clerk on the staff of the Minister of Works. According to the Biography of Chen Qun, Chen Qun recommended Chen Jiao of Guangling and Dai Qian of Danyang, and Taizu employed both; Chen Jiao eventually became a renowned minister, and the world held that Chen Qun knew how to judge men. Chen Jiao served as Prefect of Xiang County, Chief Clerk to the General Who Conquers the South, Administrator of Pengcheng and of Leling, and Commandant of the Western Division of Wei Commandery. Records, Wei 22 §61 · 13
According to the Biography of Cao Ren, after Jing Province was pacified, Cao Ren remained at Jiangling as acting General Who Conquers the South to resist Zhou Yu, and when 300 men under the company commander Niu Jin were surrounded by Zhou Yu's vanguard, Cao Ren called for his horse. The Chief Clerk Chen Jiao and others with him on the wall urged him not to plunge in himself, saying that the enemy was strong and there would be no harm in abandoning a few hundred men. Cao Ren did not answer, but sallied out with a few dozen horsemen, charged the enemy ranks twice and brought back Niu Jin's soldiers, and Chen Jiao and the others sighed, 'The general is truly a man sent down from Heaven.' Records, Wei 9 §36–38
When a man of Quzhou whose father fell ill sacrificed an ox in prayer, the county convicted him and he was to be executed in the marketplace. Chen Jiao said, 'This man is a filial son,' and submitted a petition to have him pardoned. When he was transferred to Administrator of Wei Commandery, the prisoners held there numbered in the thousands, some for years; holding it wrong to weigh only the severity of punishments while neglecting the harm of long detention, he personally examined all their cases and decided them at once. When the great army campaigned east, he entered the court as Chief Clerk to the Chancellor, and when the army returned he again became Administrator of Wei Commandery, then was transferred to Officer of the Western Bureau. He accompanied the campaign against Hanzhong and on his return became Master of Writing. Records, Wei 22 §61–62
Chen Jiao had gone ahead and not yet reached Ye when, in the 1st month of the 25th year of Jian'an (220), Taizu died at Luoyang. The ministers, bound by precedent, held that the Crown Prince's accession required an imperial decree from the Son of Heaven. Chen Jiao said that the King had died away from home and the realm was in fear, so the Crown Prince should suppress his grief and take the throne; moreover, the King's beloved son was at his side, and if trouble arose on either side, the state would be in danger. He at once assembled the officials and prepared the rites, settling everything in a single day, and the next morning, by order of the Queen, the Crown Prince was enthroned by written mandate and a general amnesty was proclaimed. Emperor Wen (Cao Pi) said, 'Chen Jibi, facing a great crisis, showed clear strategy surpassing others; he is truly an outstanding man of his age.' Records, Wei 22 §62–63Records, Wei 1 §171–172
When Emperor Wen became emperor, Chen Jiao was put in charge of personnel and enfeoffed as Marquis of Gaoling Village, and was promoted to Prefect of the Masters of Writing. When Emperor Ming took the throne, his rank was raised to Marquis of Dongxiang with a fief of 600 households. Once, when Emperor Ming's carriage suddenly arrived at the gate of the Masters of Writing, Chen Jiao knelt and said that examining documents was properly his own duty, and that if he was not equal to it, he should be dismissed; he asked the emperor to go back, and Emperor Ming, ashamed, turned his carriage around. The Biography of Du Shu relates that when the Gentleman of the Masters of Writing Lian Zhao impeached the Left Assistant Cao Fan and said he would separately report those who should be implicated, the Prefect of the Masters of Writing Chen Jiao himself memorialized that he would not decline punishment, but would not make a show of humility by asking for a heavy one either. Records, Wei 22 §63–64Records, Wei 16 §54
He was given the additional titles of Palace Attendant and Household Counselor, and was promoted to Minister over the Masses. According to the Annals of Emperor Ming, he became Minister over the Masses from Prefect of the Masters of Writing in the 6th month of the 1st year of Jingchu (237) and died in the 7th month of that year. He was given the posthumous title Marquis Zhen. His son Chen Ben succeeded him, held posts as commandery administrator and one of the Nine Ministers, and as General Who Guards the North was in command of the armies north of the Yellow River; Chen Ben's younger brother Chen Qian became General of Chariots and Cavalry in the Xianxi era. Also, when Chen Jiao, as Officer of Merit, passed through Taishan on a mission, the Administrator of Taishan Xue Ti thought him remarkable and made him a close friend; Xue Ti later became Administrator of Wei Commandery and Prefect of the Masters of Writing, in both cases succeeding Chen Jiao. Records, Wei 22 §64–66Records, Wei 3 §51 · 53
In his assessment Chen Shou said that in the Wei era the affairs of government were concentrated in the Imperial Secretariat, and the Eight Seats and Masters of Writing held the duties of the Six Ministers of old; Chen Jiao, Xu Xuan, Wei Zhen and Lu Yu long held these posts. He wrote that Chen Jiao and Xu Xuan were firm, decisive and upright, while Wei Zhen and Lu Yu governed with clarity through their standards and discernment, and that none of them disgraced their posts. Records, Wei 22 §108
In Chapter 51 of the Romance he first appears after the battle of Red Cliffs as an adviser to Cao Ren, who is holding Nan Commandery. When Zhou Yu sends Gan Ning to attack Yiling, Cao Ren consults Chen Jiao, who says that if Yiling is lost Nan Commandery cannot be held either, so it must be relieved at once. When Cao Ren's troops abandon the city and feign flight and Zhou Yu enters the barbican, Chen Jiao, watching from the watchtower, marvels to himself, 'The Chancellor's clever plan is truly divine!' Romance, Ch. 51 §15 · 24
In the same chapter, when Cao Ren, on the word of sham deserters that Zhou Yu has died, plans to raid his camp, Chen Jiao urges him to act quickly. Cao Ren leaves only Chen Jiao with a few troops to hold the city and goes out with all his forces, but is badly defeated and flees to Xiangyang, and the city of Nan Commandery is taken by Zhao Yun. Cheng Pu tells Zhou Yu that Zhuge Liang captured Chen Jiao and obtained the military tallies, and used them to lure out the troops of Jingzhou and Xiangyang and seize both cities. Romance, Ch. 51 §35–41
In Chapter 78, when Cao Cao dies, the officials hesitate, saying that the heir should succeed him but they have not received an imperial decree from the Son of Heaven. The Minister of War Chen Jiao steps forward and says, 'The King has passed away away from home; if a favored son enthrones himself privately and trouble arises on either side, the state will be in danger.' He draws his sword and cuts off the sleeve of his robe, crying that anyone with a different opinion will end up like this robe, and the officials tremble with fear. Then Hua Xin rushes in from Xuchang and produces the decree he has obtained from the Han emperor. Romance, Ch. 78 §35–37
In Chapter 79 he is among the group of more than forty civil and military officials, including Hua Xin, Wang Lang, Xin Pi, Jia Xu, Liu Ye and Chen Qun, who enter the inner palace and ask Emperor Xian of Han to yield the throne to Cao Pi, King of Wei. Romance, Ch. 79 §39
His career before appearing: The Romance first introduces him in Chapter 51 as a man consulting with Cao Ren at Nan Commandery. In the Records, Chen Jiao, as Officer of Merit to Chen Deng, the Administrator of Guangling, obtained relief from Taizu for Guangling when it was besieged by Sun Quan, and was employed by Taizu on Chen Qun's recommendation. These events do not appear in the Romance. Romance, Ch. 51 §15Records, Wei 22 §58–61 · 13
The battle of Nan Commandery: In Chapter 51 of the Romance, Chen Jiao discusses stratagems with Cao Ren and stays behind alone to hold the city. In the Biography of Cao Ren in the Records, the Chief Clerk Chen Jiao, on the wall of Jiangling, tried to stop Cao Ren from going out to rescue Niu Jin, and on seeing Cao Ren return sighed that 'the general is truly a man sent down from Heaven.' Romance, Ch. 51 §15 · 36Records, Wei 9 §36–38
Capture and the military tallies: In Chapter 51 of the Romance, Zhuge Liang captures Chen Jiao, obtains the military tallies and seizes Jingzhou and Xiangyang. The Records have no record of Chen Jiao being captured, and his biography records that after serving as Chief Clerk to the General Who Conquers the South he was Administrator of Pengcheng and of Leling and Commandant of the Western Division of Wei Commandery. Romance, Ch. 51 §39–41Records, Wei 22 §61Records, Wei 9 §36–38
Office: Chapter 78 of the Romance calls him Minister of War. In the Records he became Master of Writing on returning from the campaign against Hanzhong, and after Emperor Wen (Cao Pi) became emperor he was put in charge of personnel and then promoted to Prefect of the Masters of Writing. Romance, Ch. 78 §36Records, Wei 22 §62–63
The heir's enthronement: In Chapter 78 of the Romance, Chen Jiao cows the officials by cutting off the sleeve of his robe with his sword, and just as they are about to set up the heir on the authority of Queen Bian, Hua Xin arrives with the Han emperor's decree. In the Records, Chen Jiao said the Crown Prince should suppress his grief and take the throne and had the officials and rites prepared within a single day, and the next morning the Crown Prince was enthroned by order of the Queen. The story of the sword and the robe sleeve is not in Chen Jiao's biography. Romance, Ch. 78 §36–37Records, Wei 22 §62–63
The abdication: In Chapter 79 of the Romance, Chen Jiao is among the more than forty who, together with Hua Xin and others, ask Emperor Xian of Han to abdicate. His biography says only that when Emperor Wen took the throne he was put in charge of personnel and enfeoffed as Marquis of Gaoling Village, and does not record his asking for the abdication. Romance, Ch. 79 §39Records, Wei 22 §57–66
Later years: In the Romance, Chen Jiao does not appear after Chapter 79. In the Records, there is the episode in which he sent Emperor Ming's carriage back from the gate of the Masters of Writing, and he rose to Minister over the Masses and died in the 1st year of Jingchu (237). Romance, Ch. 79 §39Records, Wei 22 §64Records, Wei 3 §53
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.
RPersuaded Cao Cao to send relief to GuanglingWei 22 §59
NNo direct record — estimated from his cowing of the officialsCh. 78 §36
RPersonally decided the cases of long-held prisoners; assessment: did not disgrace his post in the SecretariatWei 22 §61Wei 22 §108
NNo direct record — estimated from his role as Minister of WarCh. 78 §36
RUpright and forthright in sending back the emperor's carriage, and kept faith with his home commanderyWei 22 §64Wei 22 §59
NForced through the heir's enthronement, but asked the Han emperor to abdicateCh. 78 §36Ch. 79 §39
RHastened Cao Pi's enthronement to forestall trouble, and was praised for clear strategyWei 22 §62
NBelieved the sham-surrender ruse and urged a swift raidCh. 51 §24Ch. 51 §35
RChen Deng deeply respected him as a friend, and Xue Ti formed a close friendship with himWei 22 §58Wei 22 §66
NNo direct record — estimated from his role as an adviserCh. 51 §15
RBroke with precedent to settle the enthronement in a single day; assessment: firm and decisiveWei 22 §62Wei 22 §108
NCut his robe with his sword and decided on the heir's immediate enthronementCh. 78 §36
RNo direct record — estimated from his charge of personnelWei 22 §61
NNo direct record — estimated from his role as an adviserCh. 51 §15
RNo direct record — estimated from his civil career, such as Chief Clerk to the General Who Conquers the SouthWei 22 §61
NCaptured by Zhuge Liang while holding Nan CommanderyCh. 51 §36Ch. 51 §41
RNo direct record — estimated from his career as a civil officialWei 9 §37
NNo direct record — estimated from his career as a civil officialCh. 51 §36
RNo direct record — estimated from his career as a civil officialWei 22 §58
NNo direct record — estimated from his career as a civil officialCh. 78 §36
Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)
3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.
AppearsNot present Chapter list →
Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).