Guanqiu Jian 毌丘儉

RecordsRomance Wei Courtesy name 仲恭 Zhonggong毌丘倹관구검중공毋丘儉毌丘俭

Profile
OccupationRNGeneral · General Who Guards the EastFactionWei
AppearsRNBiography inBook of Wei
BornR? N? UnverifiedNative placeHedong Commandery Wenxi County
DiedR255 N(same) UnverifiedPlace of deathRNShen County
Cause of deathRKilled NKilled Unverified
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR65

Profile

Guanqiu Jian, courtesy name Zhonggong, was a native of Wenxi County in Hedong Commandery. An old retainer who had served Emperor Ming, Cao Rui, since Cao Rui was in the Eastern Palace, he was treated with close favor; as Inspector of You Province he took part in the campaign against Gongsun Yuan of Liaodong, and he twice attacked Goguryeo, destroying its capital Wandu. Records, Wei 28 §12–17

Later, as General Who Guards the East commanding Yang Province, in the 1st month of the 2nd year of Zhengyuan (255) he and Wen Qin forged an edict of the Empress Dowager and raised troops against the General-in-Chief Sima Shi. But his forces collapsed without fighting a proper battle; hiding in the grass by the water near Shen County, he was shot dead with an arrow, and his three sets of kin were exterminated. Records, Wei 28 §19–25Records, Wei 4 §54

In his assessment, Chen Shou wrote that he was outstanding in talent and insight and capable, but that his ambitions were great while his aims went astray, and he failed to foresee calamity. In the Romance he first appeared in Chapter 105 as the Inspector of You Province who reported Gongsun Yuan's rebellion, and featured in 4 of its 120 chapters, but his name does not appear in any chapter title. In Chapter 110, angered by Sima Shi's deposing and enthroning of emperors, he raised troops, was defeated and died. Records, Wei 28 §140Romance, Ch. 105 §51Romance, Ch. 110 §1 · 25–26

In the Records

His father Guanqiu Xing distinguished himself as Administrator of Wuwei during the Huangchu era and was enfeoffed as Marquis of Gaoyang District. Guanqiu Jian inherited his father's title and became Literary Scholar (wenxue) to the Marquis of Pingyuan, and when Emperor Ming, Cao Rui, took the throne, he became a Gentleman of the Imperial Secretariat and was promoted to Supervisor of the Feathered Forest Guard. As an old retainer from the Eastern Palace days, he was treated with great intimacy. While serving as Agricultural Officer of Luoyang, when farmers were conscripted to build palaces, he submitted a memorial saying that what must urgently be eliminated were the two enemies and what must urgently be attended to were clothing and food. He later became Inspector of Jing Province. Records, Wei 28 §12–13

During the Qinglong era, when Emperor Ming planned to attack Liaodong, Guanqiu Jian, deemed to have ability and strategy in handling affairs, was transferred to Inspector of You Province and given the additional titles of General Who Crosses the Liao and Colonel Protector of the Wuhuan. Guanqiu Jian memorialized that Liaodong could be pacified with the idle troops of this region, but Wei Zhen opposed it as a petty stratagem of the Warring States. Guanqiu Jian encamped at Liaosui, and the Wuhuan chanyu Koulou Dun and others came with more than five thousand followers to surrender. In the 1st year of Jingchu (237) he went with a sealed letter to summon Gongsun Yuan, but Gongsun Yuan raised troops and met him in battle at Liaosui, and as the fighting went badly he withdrew. Gongsun Yuan afterwards proclaimed himself King of Yan. The following year, when Sima Yi, leading Guanqiu Jian and others with tens of thousands of troops, pacified Liaodong, Guanqiu Jian was promoted to Marquis of Anyi with a fief of 3,900 households. Records, Wei 22 §84–85Records, Wei 28 §14–15Records, Wei 8 §46Records, Wei 3 §54

During the Zhengshi era, when Goguryeo repeatedly raided and rebelled, Guanqiu Jian led ten thousand infantry and cavalry out from Xuantu. Gung, the king of Goguryeo, came out to the Feiliu River with twenty thousand men but was defeated time after time at Liangkou, and Guanqiu Jian, tethering his horses and hoisting his carts over the rugged roads, climbed to Wandu and massacred its capital. For the peizhe Delai, who had repeatedly remonstrated with Gung and starved himself to death, he forbade the destruction of his tomb or the felling of its trees and released his wife and children. In the 6th year of Zhengshi (245) he attacked again, and when Gung fled to Maigou, he sent the Administrator of Xuantu in pursuit for more than a thousand li past Woju; reaching the southern border of the Sushen, they carved a record of their achievement in stone. Those killed or taken in surrender numbered more than eight thousand. Records, Wei 28 §16–18

After serving as General of the Left and Inspector of Yu Province, he became General Who Guards the South. In the 11th month of the 4th year of Jiaping (252), by edict he attacked Wu together with Wang Chang and Hu Zun; according to the biography of Sun Liang, Guanqiu Jian headed for Wuchang at this time. In the 12th month Zhuge Ke crushed the Wei forces at Dongguan, and all returned without success. Because Zhuge Dan, who had fought at Dongguan, had fared badly, the two men's posts were exchanged, and Guanqiu Jian became General Who Guards the East commanding Yang Province. The following year, when Zhuge Ke besieged the New City of Hefei, he and Wen Qin held him off, and when the Grand Commandant Sima Fu came with the central army and lifted the siege, Zhuge Ke withdrew. Records, Wei 28 §19Records, Wei 4 §34–35Records, Wu 3 §4

Guanqiu Jian was on close terms with Xiahou Xuan, Li Feng and others. Wen Qin, Inspector of Yang Province, was a man from the same town as Cao Shuang and had many battle merits, but he had inflated his counts of spoils in hope of rewards and was refused, so he bore a deep grudge; Guanqiu Jian treated him generously and won his heart. In the 1st month of the 2nd year of Zhengyuan (255), when a comet rising from the field of Wu and Chu stretched across the sky to the northwest, the two took it as an auspicious omen for themselves. They then forged an edict of the Empress Dowager, circulated an indictment of the General-in-Chief Sima Shi to the commanderies and kingdoms, and rebelled. They made all the commanders, officials and people of Huainan enter the city of Shouchun, swore an oath at an altar west of the city, and, leading fifty or sixty thousand men, crossed the Huai and reached Xiang County. Records, Wei 28 §20–21

Sima Shi had Zhuge Dan threaten Shouchun from Anfengjin and had Hu Zun cut off their line of retreat, had the Army Supervisor Wang Ji occupy Nandun, and ordered all his armies to hold firm and not give battle. Guanqiu Jian and Wen Qin could neither advance to fight nor retreat for fear that Shouchun would be attacked, and they were at their wits' end. Since the families of the officers and men of Huainan were all in the north, one after another they surrendered. When Deng Ai feigned weakness at Lejia, Wen Qin came to attack him by night, but at daybreak he saw the main army and withdrew; pursued by swift cavalry, he was badly defeated and fled. Records, Wei 28 §22–24

On hearing that Wen Qin had been defeated, Guanqiu Jian fled in fear by night and his forces collapsed. By the time he neared Shen County, even his attendants and soldiers had left him, and taking only his younger brother Guanqiu Xiu and his grandson Guanqiu Zhong, he hid in the grass by the water. Zhang Shu, a commoner under the Chief Commandant of Anfengjin, approached and shot him dead and sent his head to the capital, and Zhang Shu was made a marquis. Guanqiu Xiu and Guanqiu Zhong fled to Wu. His son Guanqiu Dian, knowing that the uprising was about to break out, had fled with his family to Mount Ling in Xin'an, but the place was taken, and Guanqiu Jian's three sets of kin were exterminated. Earlier, Guan Lu, passing Guanqiu Jian's family tombs, had said that within two years the clan would be destroyed, and it turned out as he said. Records, Wei 28 §24–25Records, Wei 4 §54Records, Wei 29 §81

In his assessment, Chen Shou named him together with Wang Ling, Zhuge Dan and Zhong Hui, writing that Guanqiu Jian was outstanding in talent and insight and capable, so that he made his name and rose to honored posts; but that all of them had great ambitions while their aims went astray, failed to foresee calamity, and when their revolts sprang like a released crossbow, their clans were crushed into the earth. Records, Wei 28 §140

In the Romance

In Chapter 105 of the Romance, Guanqiu Jian, Inspector of You Province, submitted a memorial reporting that Gongsun Yuan of Liaodong had styled himself King of Yan and changed the era name to the 1st year of Shaohan. In Chapter 108, when Sima Zhao attacked Wu, he led a hundred thousand troops toward Wuchang as Commander Who Guards the South, and at Dongxing, deployed on the flanks with Wang Chang, he heard of the defeat of the vanguard Hu Zun. When Zhuge Ke gathered his sick troops at the New City and withdrew, Guanqiu Jian raised a great army, pursued and attacked them, and crushed the Wu army. Romance, Ch. 105 §51Romance, Ch. 108 §8–10 · 17 · 25–26

In Chapter 110, in the 1st month of the 2nd year of Zhengyuan, Guanqiu Jian flew into a rage on hearing that Sima Shi had high-handedly deposed one emperor and enthroned another. When his eldest son Guanqiu Dian urged that one entrusted with a region could not sit idle, Guanqiu Jian summoned Wen Qin and, weeping, revealed his intention. Wen Qin recommended his second son Wen Yang as vanguard, and the two, falsely claiming a secret edict from the Empress Dowager, gathered the troops of Huainan in the city of Shouchun and swore an oath smearing their lips with the blood of a white horse. Guanqiu Jian encamped at Xiangcheng with sixty thousand men, while Wen Qin, with twenty thousand, acted as a mobile force outside. Romance, Ch. 109 §45Romance, Ch. 110 §1–4

In the camp of Sima Shi, who had set out in person despite his illness, Zheng Mao judged that Guanqiu Jian liked to scheme but lacked decisiveness. Following the advice of his vanguard Ge Yong, Guanqiu Jian went to occupy Nandun, but Wang Ji had already built his camp there, and alarmed by news that Sun Jun of Wu was making a surprise attack on Shouchun, he withdrew to Xiangcheng that night. Romance, Ch. 110 §6–10

When Wen Qin and his son were defeated at Lejia and Wen Qin fled to Wu, Guanqiu Jian led out every soldier in the city to fight. Running into Deng Ai, he saw Ge Yong cut down with a single stroke, and as Hu Zun and Wang Ji attacked from all sides, he fled with only a dozen or so horsemen and reached Shen County. The county magistrate Song Bai opened the gates to receive him and held a banquet in his honor; when Guanqiu Jian was thoroughly drunk, Song Bai had men kill him and presented his head to the Wei army. Romance, Ch. 110 §24–26

Where the Romance differs

Liaodong: In Chapter 105 of the Romance, Guanqiu Jian merely submitted a memorial reporting that Gongsun Yuan had styled himself King of Yan. In the Records, Guanqiu Jian had earlier memorialized proposing the pacification of Liaodong, went with a sealed letter to summon Gongsun Yuan in the 1st year of Jingchu (237), fought at Liaosui and withdrew after faring badly, and only afterwards did Gongsun Yuan become King of Yan. Romance, Ch. 105 §51Records, Wei 22 §84Records, Wei 8 §46Records, Wei 3 §54

The campaigns against Goguryeo: In the Records, Guanqiu Jian twice attacked Goguryeo during the Zhengshi era, destroying Wandu and carving a record of his achievement at the southern border of the Sushen. The Romance presents him in Chapter 105 as Inspector of You Province but does not record these expeditions. Records, Wei 28 §16–17Romance, Ch. 105 §51

The battle of Dongxing: In Chapter 108 of the Romance, Guanqiu Jian, while heading for Wuchang, was summoned to Sima Zhao's camp at Dongxing and deployed on the flanks with Wang Chang, then withdrew on hearing that Hu Zun had been defeated. The biography of Sun Liang in the Records states that Zhuge Dan and Hu Zun surrounded Dongxing while Wang Chang headed for Nan Commandery and Guanqiu Jian for Wuchang, so Guanqiu Jian was not at Dongxing. Romance, Ch. 108 §8–9 · 17Records, Wu 3 §4

The New City of Hefei: In Chapter 108 of the Romance, when Zhuge Ke withdrew, Guanqiu Jian pursued and attacked him and crushed the Wu army. In the Records, Guanqiu Jian held him off together with Wen Qin, and Zhuge Ke withdrew when Sima Fu came with the central army and lifted the siege. Romance, Ch. 108 §25–26Records, Wei 28 §19

The reason for the uprising: In Chapter 110 of the Romance, Guanqiu Jian, angered by Sima Shi's deposing and enthroning of emperors, rose up at the urging of his eldest son Guanqiu Dian. In the Records, he had been close to Xiahou Xuan and Li Feng, treated the resentful Wen Qin generously, and raised troops taking the comet of the 1st month of the 2nd year of Zhengyuan as an auspicious omen. Guanqiu Dian, knowing that the uprising was about to break out, fled with his family. Romance, Ch. 110 §1Records, Wei 28 §20–21 · 25

Wen Qin: In Chapter 110 of the Romance, Wen Qin was a retainer in Cao Shuang's household. In the Records, he was a man from the same town as Cao Shuang. Romance, Ch. 110 §2Records, Wei 28 §20

The last battle: In Chapter 110 of the Romance, Guanqiu Jian led out every soldier in the city and clashed with Deng Ai, and his vanguard Ge Yong was cut down by Deng Ai. In the Records, on hearing that Wen Qin had been defeated, he fled in fear by night and his forces collapsed. Ge Yong does not appear in Chen Shou's main text. Romance, Ch. 110 §24–25Records, Wei 28 §24

Death: In Chapter 110 of the Romance, Song Bai, the magistrate of Shen County, entertained him at a banquet, killed him when he was drunk and presented his head. In the Records, abandoned even by his attendants, he hid in the grass by the water with only his brother and grandson and was shot dead by Zhang Shu, a commoner under the Chief Commandant of Anfengjin. Romance, Ch. 110 §25–26Records, Wei 28 §24

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA7452−22
  • STR4545±0
  • INT5638−18
  • POL6240−22
  • CHA5650−6
  • VIR4562+17
  • ADP2422−2
  • SCH4535−10
  • DIP5042−8
  • DIS4538−7
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

LeadershipR74N52 −22

RCrushed Goguryeo and massacred Wandu, but his first Liaodong expedition fared badly and his forces collapsed in the rebellionWei 28 §16Wei 28 §15Wei 28 §22

NEncamped at Xiangcheng with sixty thousand, retreated after Nandun was taken first, but succeeded in pursuing Zhuge KeCh. 110 §4Ch. 110 §9Ch. 108 §25

PoliticsR62N40Unverified −22

RMemorialized that clothing and food should come before palace building, and cut through mountains for irrigationWei 28 §13Wei 28 §18

NNo direct record — estimated from his reporting Gongsun Yuan's rebellion as Inspector of You ProvinceCh. 105 §51

IntelligenceR56N38 −18

RPromoted for his ability and strategy, praised in the assessment for talent and insight, but his Liaodong plan was judged hollowWei 28 §14Wei 28 §140Wei 22 §84

NJudged to like scheming but lack decisiveness, and had no plan left to useCh. 110 §7Ch. 110 §10

VirtueR45N62 +17

RProtected Delai's tomb and family, but rebelled with a forged edict of the Empress DowagerWei 28 §17Wei 28 §21

NWept over Sima Shi's deposing and enthroning and sought to punish the traitor in the name of righteousness, but the secret edict was falseCh. 110 §1

ScholarshipR45UnverifiedN35Unverified −10

RNo direct record — estimated from his service as Literary Scholar to the Marquis of PingyuanWei 28 §12

NNo direct record — estimated from his office as commander of HuainanCh. 110 §1

5 similar abilities — show evidence
  • StrengthR45UnverifiedN45 ±0

    RNo direct record — estimated from his leading an expedition that tethered horses and crossed rugged roadsWei 28 §16

    NFought to the death to hold off Deng Ai's chargeCh. 110 §25

  • CharismaR56N50 −6

    RFive thousand Wuhuan submitted and Wen Qin gave him his heart, but his followers scattered in the rebellionWei 28 §14Wei 28 §20Wei 28 §23

    NThe people of Huainan all followed him gladly, though it was also said they followed under duressCh. 110 §3

  • AdaptabilityR24N22 −2

    RTook a comet as a good omen and raised troops, then at his wits' end fled by night and was shot deadWei 28 §21Wei 28 §24

    NJudged to lack decisiveness, and in flight got drunk at the magistrate's banquet and was killedCh. 110 §7Ch. 110 §25

  • DiplomacyR50N42 −8

    RAccepted the submission of the Wuhuan chanyu Koulou Dun and others and had them send tributeWei 28 §14

    NCirculated proclamations to the commanderies calling on them to raise troopsCh. 110 §4

  • DiscernmentR45UnverifiedN38 −7

    RNo direct record — estimated from his calculated generosity toward Wen QinWei 28 §20

    NWas slow to follow Ge Yong's advice to seize Nandun first, and entrusted Lejia to Wen Qin and his sonCh. 110 §9Ch. 110 §13

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (4)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Allegiance history

  1. Wei · Records · 「明帝即位,為尚書郎,遷羽林監。」

Related events (6)

Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).