RAsked for extensions on the pretext of his wife's illness and did not returnWei 29 §21Wei 29 §22
NCame on hearing of Guan Yu's righteous spirit and declined a reward of a hundred taels of goldCh. 75 §4Ch. 75 §11
| Occupation | RNPhysician | Faction | Wei |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appears | RN | Biography in | Book of Wei |
| Born | Native place | Pei Commandery Qiao County | |
| Died | Place of death | RXuchang County | |
| Cause of death | RExecuted NExecuted Unverified | ||
| Existence | Historical | Mentions | R29 |
Hua Tuo, courtesy name Yuanhua, was a native of Qiao County in Pei State, also known by the name Fu. He was versed in several classics but did not take up either a recommendation as Filial and Incorrupt or a summons from the Grand Commandant; he was expert in prescriptions and drugs, acupuncture and moxibustion, and he had patients drink mafeisan, then cut open the abdomen and removed the disease. Records, Wei 29 §2–3
Summoned by Taizu (Cao Cao), he treated Taizu's head-wind ailment with acupuncture, but after returning home he stayed away on the pretext of his wife's illness and was thrown into the prison at Xu. Xun Yu asked that he be pardoned, but Taizu had him tortured to death, and later, when his son Cangshu (Cao Chong) was critically ill, Taizu regretted having killed Hua Tuo. Records, Wei 29 §18 · 21–23
In his assessment in the Biographies of Technicians, Chen Shou called Hua Tuo's medicine and diagnosis a subtle and singular skill, an extraordinary art. In the Romance he first appeared in Chapter 15 as a divine physician who healed Zhou Tai, and featured in 4 of its 120 chapters. In Chapter 75 he scraped Guan Yu's bone to treat the poison, and in Chapter 78 he proposed splitting Cao Cao's head open and then died in prison; the title of that chapter names him as 'the divine physician'. Records, Wei 29 §86Romance, Ch. 15 §67–68Romance, Ch. 75 §7–8Romance, Ch. 78 §14–18
Hua Tuo, courtesy name Yuanhua, was a native of Qiao County in Pei State, also known by the name Fu. He traveled to study in the region of Xu and became versed in several classics. Chen Gui, Chancellor of Pei, recommended him as Filial and Incorrupt and the Grand Commandant Huang Wan summoned him, but he took up neither. He understood the arts of nurturing life, and although people of the time thought he was nearly a hundred years old, his face still looked like that of a man in his prime. Records, Wei 29 §2
He was expert in prescriptions and drugs; his decoctions used only a few ingredients, and he gauged the doses without weighing them on a scale. When he applied moxibustion it was seven or eight cones at one or two points, and when he used acupuncture it was likewise at no more than one or two points. When a disease was knotted inside where needles and drugs could not reach, he had the patient drink mafeisan, and when the patient lay as if drunk or dead, aware of nothing, he cut open the abdomen and removed the diseased part. If the disease was in the intestines, he cut and washed the intestines, sewed up the abdomen and applied ointment; it healed in four or five days, and within a month the patient was fully recovered. Records, Wei 29 §2–4
Chen Shou recorded many cases in which Hua Tuo's diagnoses proved right. When the wife of a former Chancellor of Ganling had abdominal pain six months into her pregnancy, he took her pulse, said the fetus was already dead, and had it expelled with a decoction. To the clerks Ni Xun and Li Yan, who suffered from the same symptoms, he said, 'Ni Xun is replete on the outside and Li Yan is replete on the inside,' gave one a purgative and made the other sweat, and the next morning both were up. He told Yan Xin of Yandu that an acute illness showed in his face and that he should not drink much wine; on his way home Yan Xin fell from his carriage and died that night. Records, Wei 29 §5 · 7–8
Seeing on the road a sick man whose throat was so blocked that he could not swallow food, he had him drink three sheng of minced garlic and strong vinegar from a cake seller's shop, and the man vomited up a snake; on the north wall of Hua Tuo's house dozens of such snakes were hanging. Believing that a certain Administrator would recover if he flew into a great rage, he took his goods without treating him and left with a letter abusing him; the Administrator's fury reached its height, and he vomited several sheng of black blood and recovered. Records, Wei 29 §14–15
When Chen Deng, Administrator of Guangling, felt oppressed in his chest, flushed in the face and unable to eat, Hua Tuo said that from eating raw food several sheng of worms had formed in his stomach, and had him take two sheng of a decoction, whereupon he vomited about three sheng of worms, half of whose bodies were raw fish slices. Hua Tuo said that the disease would recur in three years and that he could be saved only if he found a good physician; when the time came and the disease recurred, Hua Tuo was not at hand, and Chen Deng died as he had said. Records, Wei 29 §17
Taizu (Cao Cao) heard of him and summoned him, and Hua Tuo was always at his side. Taizu suffered from a head-wind ailment, and at every attack his mind grew confused and his eyes dizzy, but when Hua Tuo needled him at the diaphragm he recovered as soon as the needle went in. Hua Tuo, however, had originally been a scholar, and he always regretted in his heart that he had come to make his living by medicine. Records, Wei 29 §18 · 21
Later, when Taizu took personal charge of affairs, his illness grew grave and he had Hua Tuo attend to him exclusively, and Hua Tuo said, 'This illness is hard to cure at once, but with constant treatment your years can be prolonged.' Having been away from home a long time, Hua Tuo said he had received a letter from home and went back for a while, and once home he repeatedly asked for extensions on the pretext of his wife's illness and did not return. Taizu summoned him by letter many times and ordered the commanderies and counties to send him, but Hua Tuo, relying on his skill and disliking serving others, still did not set out. Records, Wei 29 §21–22
Taizu flew into a great rage and sent men to investigate, ordering that if the wife really was ill, forty hu of small beans should be granted and the deadline extended, but that if it was a lie, he should be arrested and sent. Hua Tuo was then handed over to the prison at Xu, interrogated, and confessed his crime. Xun Yu pleaded, 'Hua Tuo's skill is truly excellent and men's lives depend on him; he should be leniently pardoned,' but Taizu said, 'Will the world lack rats of this kind?' and in the end had Hua Tuo tortured to death. Records, Wei 29 §22
Facing death, Hua Tuo gave a volume of writings to the jailer, saying it could save lives, but when the jailer, fearing the law, would not accept it, he did not press him, asked for fire and burned it. Even after Hua Tuo's death Taizu's head-wind ailment was not cured, and Taizu said that Hua Tuo had nurtured his illness to raise his own worth, and that even had he not killed him, Hua Tuo would never have cut out its root for him. Later, when his beloved son Cangshu fell critically ill, Taizu lamented, 'I regret having killed Hua Tuo.' Cangshu was the courtesy name of Cao Chong, who died of illness in the 13th year of Jian'an (208) at the age of thirteen. Records, Wei 29 §23Records, Wei 20 §9 · 12
The army clerk Li Cheng had once been cured by Hua Tuo of an illness in which he coughed up pus and blood, and had received a powder to take when it recurred eighteen years later. He lent the medicine, however, to a relative suffering from the same illness, and when he went to Qiao County to ask for more, it happened to be just when Hua Tuo had been arrested, so he could not ask. When the illness recurred eighteen years later, Li Cheng had no medicine to take and died. Records, Wei 29 §24–25
Wu Pu of Guangling and Fan A of Pengcheng studied under Hua Tuo. Hua Tuo taught Wu Pu that the body should be moved and worked but not to the point of exhaustion, and taught him the Five Animals Exercise, modeled on the tiger, deer, bear, monkey and bird; practicing it, Wu Pu still had sharp ears and eyes and sound teeth past the age of ninety. Fan A, skilled in acupuncture, cured illnesses by needling deep into the back and chest, which other physicians avoided, and by taking the lacquer-leaf and qingnian powder he had received from Hua Tuo he lived past a hundred. Records, Wei 29 §26–29
In his assessment in the Biographies of Technicians, Chen Shou called Hua Tuo's medicine and diagnosis, together with Du Kui's music, Zhu Jianping's physiognomy, Zhou Xuan's dream interpretation and Guan Lu's divination, subtle and singular skills and extraordinary arts, and said that he recorded them here to bring wondrous things to light, just as Sima Qian had written the biographies of Bian Que and Canggong. Records, Wei 29 §86
The Romance first brought Hua Tuo on in Chapter 15. When Sun Ce's general Zhou Tai, wounded by spears in twelve places while saving Sun Quan, lay near death, Yu Fan, whom Sun Ce had invited on Dong Xi's advice, brought 'a man of Qiao in Pei State, surnamed Hua, named Tuo, courtesy name Yuanhua, the divine physician of the age'. As Sun Ce saw him, he had the face of a child and hair as white as a crane's, and when Hua Tuo applied his medicine Zhou Tai recovered within a month. In Chapter 29, when Sun Ce was wounded while hunting and sent for Hua Tuo, Hua Tuo had already left for the Central Plains, and only his disciple remained in Wu. Romance, Ch. 15 §66–68Romance, Ch. 29 §7–8
In Chapter 75, when Guan Yu, attacking Fancheng, was wounded in the right arm by a poisoned arrow, Hua Tuo, having heard that General Guan was a hero of the realm, came on purpose from Jiangdong in a small boat. He said that the poison of aconite had seeped into the bone, and that a ring must be fixed to a pillar to bind the arm and his head covered with a quilt before the bone was scraped, but Guan Yu laughed and held out his arm while playing weiqi with Ma Liang. Though the knife scraped the bone with a rasping sound and the blood filled a basin, Guan Yu remained calm, and Hua Tuo said, 'I have practiced medicine all my life but never seen anything like this; Your Lordship is truly a god of heaven.' Hua Tuo urged him to refrain from anger for a hundred days, and declining a hundred taels of gold, left behind a single dose of medicine and departed. Romance, Ch. 75 §1 · 3–9 · 11
The title of Chapter 78 was 'Treating a Wind Ailment, the Divine Physician Loses His Life'. When Cao Cao was tormented by headaches, Hua Xin recommended summoning Hua Tuo, who lived at Jincheng, citing his art of having patients drink mafeitang and then cutting open the abdomen to wash the organs, and how he had made Chen Deng vomit up worms. Hua Tuo said that the root of Cao Cao's illness lay inside his head, so that after drinking mafeitang his head must be split open with an axe to remove the wind-phlegm, and he cited his scraping of Guan Yu's bone as an example. Cao Cao, saying that Hua Tuo was close to Guan Yu and wanted to avenge him, had him thrown into prison and interrogated under torture, and despite Jia Xu's remonstrance, declaring him no different from Ji Ping, had the torture carried through to the end. Romance, Ch. 78 §9–16
In prison Hua Tuo gave the Qingnang Book to Jailer Wu, the jailer who had brought him wine and food every day, so that he might carry on his medical art, and ten days later he died in prison. When Jailer Wu returned home, his wife was burning the book and only one or two leaves remained, and for this reason, the Romance wrote, the Qingnang Book was never handed down to the world, and only such methods as gelding chickens and pigs were passed on. After killing Hua Tuo, Cao Cao's illness grew worse. Romance, Ch. 78 §16–19 · 21
Sun Ce's camp: In Chapter 15 of the Romance, Hua Tuo came to Sun Ce on Yu Fan's recommendation and healed Zhou Tai, and in Chapter 29 his disciple, who had stayed in Wu, treated Sun Ce. Sun Ce, Zhou Tai and Yu Fan do not appear in the biography of Hua Tuo in the Records, and the only disciples recorded are Wu Pu of Guangling and Fan A of Pengcheng. Romance, Ch. 15 §67–68Romance, Ch. 29 §8Records, Wei 29 §1–29
The physician who scraped Guan Yu's bone: In Chapter 75 of the Romance, the physician who scraped Guan Yu's arm bone to remove the poison was Hua Tuo. The biography of Guan Yu in the Records also tells how the arrow's poison entered the bone and a physician cut open the arm and scraped the bone, but the physician is not named, and Guan Yu does not appear in the biography of Hua Tuo either. Romance, Ch. 75 §3–8Records, Shu 6 §9Records, Wei 29 §1–29
The wounded arm and the scene: In Chapter 75 of the Romance, Guan Yu, wounded in the right arm by a poisoned arrow while attacking Fancheng, underwent the operation while playing weiqi with Ma Liang. In the biography of Guan Yu in the Records, a stray arrow had once pierced his left arm, and even after it healed the bone ached whenever the weather was cloudy or rainy, so he underwent the operation, during which Guan Yu ate, drank and chatted with his generals. Romance, Ch. 75 §1 · 7–8Records, Shu 6 §9
The anesthetic: In Chapter 78 of the Romance, Hua Xin said that Hua Tuo had patients drink mafeitang and then cut open the abdomen. In the biography of Hua Tuo in the Records, the drug Hua Tuo had patients drink is named mafeisan. Romance, Ch. 78 §10Records, Wei 29 §3
The prediction about Chen Deng: In Hua Xin's words in Chapter 78 of the Romance, Hua Tuo said that if Chen Deng's illness recurred three years later he could not be saved. In the Records, he said that when it recurred three years later Chen Deng could be saved if he found a good physician, and when the time came Hua Tuo was not at hand and Chen Deng died. Romance, Ch. 78 §12Records, Wei 29 §17
Treating Cao Cao: In Chapter 78 of the Romance, Hua Tuo, on first being summoned, proposed splitting open Cao Cao's head with an axe to remove the wind-phlegm, and so aroused his suspicion. In the Records, Hua Tuo, summoned by Taizu (Cao Cao), was always at his side and needled his head-wind ailment so that he recovered as soon as the needle went in, and when the illness grew grave, he said it was hard to cure at once but that continued treatment could prolong his years. Romance, Ch. 78 §14Records, Wei 29 §18 · 21
Why he was imprisoned: In Chapter 78 of the Romance, Cao Cao, suspecting that Hua Tuo meant to avenge Guan Yu, threw him into prison. In the Records, when Hua Tuo went home and did not return, pleading his wife's illness, Taizu sent men to investigate, confirmed the lie and handed him over to the prison at Xu. Romance, Ch. 78 §15Records, Wei 29 §21–22
The man who pleaded for him: In Chapter 78 of the Romance, the one who remonstrated that Hua Tuo should not be done away with was Jia Xu. In the Records, the one who asked for Hua Tuo's pardon was Xun Yu. Romance, Ch. 78 §15Records, Wei 29 §22
The fate of the medical book: In Chapter 78 of the Romance, Hua Tuo gave the Qingnang Book to the jailer, Jailer Wu, and Jailer Wu's wife burned it. In the Records, Hua Tuo gave an untitled volume to the jailer, but when the jailer, fearing the law, would not accept it, Hua Tuo himself asked for fire and burned it. Romance, Ch. 78 §16–18Records, Wei 29 §23
When he died and where he lived: The Romance has Hua Tuo summoned as a man living at Jincheng and die in prison in Chapter 78, shortly before Cao Cao's death. The Records do not give the year of Hua Tuo's death, but record that Taizu regretted killing Hua Tuo when his son Cangshu (Cao Chong), who died in the 13th year of Jian'an (208), was critically ill, and that Hua Tuo had been arrested when Li Cheng went to Qiao County to ask for medicine. Romance, Ch. 78 §13 · 18Records, Wei 29 §23 · 25Records, Wei 20 §12
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.
RAsked for extensions on the pretext of his wife's illness and did not returnWei 29 §21Wei 29 §22
NCame on hearing of Guan Yu's righteous spirit and declined a reward of a hundred taels of goldCh. 75 §4Ch. 75 §11
RNo direct record — estimated as a physicianWei 29 §2
NNo direct record — estimated as a physicianCh. 15 §67
RNo direct record — estimated as a physicianWei 29 §2
NNo direct record — estimated as a physicianCh. 15 §67
RNo direct record — estimated as a physician with no recorded stratagemsWei 29 §21
NNo direct record — estimated as a physicianCh. 78 §14
RNo direct record — estimated from his never taking officeWei 29 §2
NNo direct record — estimated as a physicianCh. 15 §67
RWu Pu and Fan A followed him and studied under himWei 29 §26
NRecommended by Yu Fan and Hua Xin as the divine physician of the ageCh. 15 §67Ch. 78 §10
RRelying on his skill, defied the summons and was handed over to prisonWei 29 §22
NProposed splitting Cao Cao's head open and invoked Guan Yu, arousing suspicionCh. 78 §14Ch. 78 §15
RTraveled to study in Xu and became versed in several classicsWei 29 §2
NPossessed the medical book, the Qingnang Book, and sought to hand it down to the worldCh. 78 §16
RNo direct record — estimated as a physicianWei 29 §21
NTried to persuade Cao Cao with Guan Yu's example but only deepened his suspicionCh. 78 §15
RNo direct record — estimated from his having disciplesWei 29 §26
NNo direct record — estimated as a physicianCh. 78 §17
RNPeerless +40 Chen Shou called his medicine an extraordinary art; in the Romance he scraped the bone to treat the poisonWei 29 §86Ch. 75 §8
Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)
3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.
AppearsNot present Chapter list →
Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).
Ownership and authorship assigned by 3KDEX from source sentences — not yet reviewed (unverified).
Linked via Wikidata "depicts" and character names in titles (unverified) — not yet reviewed.