Foreign peoples

Nanman 南蠻

About this faction

In the Romance, the Nanman are the following of Meng Huo, King of the Man, who invade the four commanderies of Yizhou, Yongchang, Zangke and Yuexi in the south of Shu. The Romance depicts how the chiefs of various caves and the kings of neighboring states fought to help Meng Huo, until Meng Huo, captured seven times by Zhuge Liang and released seven times, submitted in his heart. Romance, Ch. 85 §32Romance, Ch. 87 §32Romance, Ch. 90 §60–61

Neither the name "Nanman" nor Meng Huo appears in Chen Shou's main text. After the First Sovereign, Liu Bei, died, Gao Ding, a Yi king of Yuexi, Yong Kai, a powerful clan leader of Yizhou Commandery, and Zhu Bao of Zangke rebelled, and in the 3rd year of Jianxing (225) Zhuge Liang campaigned in the south and pacified it all that autumn. But once the army withdrew, the southern Yi rebelled again, and rebellions continued after that. Records, Shu 13 §15 · 17 · 31 · 49Records, Shu 3 §4Records, Shu 5 §24

Chen Shou recorded the affairs of Nanzhong in several places: the Biography of the Later Sovereign (Records of Shu 3), the Biography of Zhuge Liang (Records of Shu 5), and the biographies of Li Hui, Lü Kai, Ma Zhong, Zhang Ni and others in Records of Shu 13. The Romance first brings this power onto the stage in Chapter 85, in the passage where Sima Yi proposes sending an envoy to the Nanman to have Meng Huo, King of the Man, raise 100,000 troops and attack the four commanderies. Records, Shu 3 §4–6Records, Shu 5 §23–24Records, Shu 13 §15 · 27 · 30 · 49Romance, Ch. 85 §32

Rise and fall in the Records

In Chen Shou's main text, the affairs of the south begin with the Nanzhong rebellion. When Liu Zhang died, Yong Kai, a leader of the powerful clans of Nanzhong, rebelled from his base in Yizhou Commandery and attached himself to Wu, and Sun Quan made Liu Zhang's surviving son Liu Chan Inspector of Yi Province and stationed him on the border between Jiao and Yi Provinces. In summer of the 1st year of Jianxing (223), Zhu Bao, Administrator of Zangke, rebelled with his commandery. Before this, Yong Kai had sent the Administrator Zhang Yi (張裔) off to Wu, seized the commandery and refused to submit, and Gao Ding, the Yi king of Yuexi, had also rebelled. Records, Shu 1 §19Records, Shu 3 §4

All the commanderies of Nanzhong rebelled, but because Zhuge Liang had just suffered a great bereavement, he did not send troops at once and first sent envoys to Wu to make peace. When the Protector-General Li Yan wrote him six sheets explaining where his interests lay, Yong Kai answered with a single sheet, saying that there are not two suns in the sky nor two kings on earth, yet now the realm stood like the legs of a tripod and there were three calendars; and when he surrendered to Wu, Wu appointed him from afar Administrator of Yongchang. Lü Kai, Officer of Merit of Yongchang, together with the Commandery Assistant Wang Kang, led the officials and people in closing the borders to keep Yong Kai out. Records, Shu 5 §23Records, Shu 13 §20–21

In spring of the 3rd year of Jianxing (225) Zhuge Liang led his host south on campaign. Zhuge Liang went first by way of Yuexi, while Li Hui followed the road toward Jianning and was surrounded at Kunming by the forces of the various counties. Li Hui deceived the southerners, telling them that the government army had run out of food and meant to withdraw, but that he would not go north again and would make plans together with them; when the siege slackened he crushed them, reaching the Pan River in the south and Zangke in the east, and joined forces with Zhuge Liang. By the time Zhuge Liang had set out, Yong Kai had already been killed by Gao Ding's retainers. Records, Shu 5 §24Records, Shu 13 §15–16 · 27

The Biography of the Later Sovereign records that when Zhuge Liang campaigned against the four southern commanderies that year and pacified them all, Yizhou Commandery was renamed Jianning Commandery, Yunnan Commandery was created out of Jianning and Yongchang, and Xinggu Commandery out of Jianning and Zangke, and that in the twelfth month Zhuge Liang returned to Chengdu. The Biography of Zhuge Liang says that all was pacified that autumn and that the military supplies it yielded made the state rich, and in his Memorial on Dispatching the Troops Zhuge Liang said that in the fifth month he had crossed the Lu River and gone deep into barren land where not a blade of grass grows. Records, Shu 3 §6Records, Shu 5 §24 · 29

Zhuge Liang memorialized to make Lü Kai Administrator of Yunnan, but Lü Kai was killed by rebel Yi, and Wang Kang became Administrator of Yongchang. Ma Zhong, who became Administrator of Zangke, cared for the commandery after the rebellion and won both awe and gratitude. Li Hui had the greatest merit in pacifying the southern lands, but when the army withdrew the southern Yi rebelled again and killed the garrison commanders. Li Hui went in person to suppress them, moved their leaders to Chengdu, and levied plough oxen, warhorses, gold and silver, and rhinoceros hides from the Sou and Pu peoples to supplement the army's supplies. Records, Shu 13 §27 · 30 · 17

In the 11th year of Jianxing (233), Liu Zhou, a leader of the southern Yi, rebelled and threw several commanderies into disorder. Zhang Yi (張翼), Area Commander of Laixiang, kept strictly to the law and did not win the goodwill of the Yi; he was recalled, but did not leave the battlefield until his replacement arrived, and he stockpiled grain. Ma Zhong, who succeeded him, built on that foundation to behead Liu Zhou and pacify the southern lands. Ma Zhong moved his seat to Mei County to live among both the people and the Yi, and Chen Shou wrote that the Man and Yi both feared and loved him and set up a temple to him when he died. Records, Shu 13 §31–33Records, Shu 15 §12–13

In Yuexi Commandery, after Zhuge Liang suppressed Gao Ding, the Sou Yi rebelled several times and killed the Administrators Gong Lu and Jiao Huang, and thereafter the administrators stayed only at Anding County, more than eight hundred li from the commandery. Zhang Ni, who became Administrator of Yuexi, won the Man and Yi over with kindness and good faith so that many came to surrender, and captured or beheaded the leaders who would not comply. Zhang Ni recovered the salt, iron and lacquer of the three counties of Dingzuo, Taideng and Beishui, long held by the Yi, and after more than a hundred years reopened the old road to Chengdu by way of Maoniu. Records, Shu 13 §49–56

In winter of the 6th year of Jingyao (263), when Deng Ai drove deep into Shu, some proposed withdrawing into the south. Qiao Zhou submitted a memorial saying that the south was a land of distant Yi who had rebelled repeatedly even in ordinary times, and had submitted only because they were pressed by military force after Zhuge Liang's southern campaign; since then they had been made to pay taxes to the government to supply the army and were resentful, so if the court went there to rely on them, they would surely rebel again. Records, Shu 12 §67 · 70–71

In his assessment in Records of Shu 13, Chen Shou said that Li Hui was fair and clear-sighted, with purpose and achievement; Lü Kai held to his integrity without bending; Ma Zhong was gentle yet capable of firmness; and Zhang Ni was clear and decisive in judgment; and he wrote that each of them made his name through his own strengths because he met the right time. Records, Shu 13 §65

In the Romance

In Chapter 85 of the Romance, Sima Yi proposed to Cao Pi an attack on Shu along five routes, including sending an envoy to the Nanman with letters of appointment and gifts as rewards, to have Meng Huo, King of the Man, raise 100,000 troops and attack the four commanderies of Yizhou, Yongchang, Zangke and Yuexi. Zhuge Liang had Wei Yan use a stratagem of decoy troops, and in Chapter 86 Meng Huo's troops attacked the four commanderies but were driven back by the decoy stratagem and returned to their caves. Romance, Ch. 85 §32 · 44Romance, Ch. 86 §4

In Chapter 87, urgent news arrived that in the 3rd year of Jianxing Meng Huo, King of the Man, had invaded the border with 100,000 Man troops, that Yong Kai, Administrator of Jianning, had joined him, and that Zhu Bao, Administrator of Zangke, and Gao Ding, Administrator of Yuexi, had surrendered their cities. Saying that the Nanman's refusal to submit was a great danger to the state, Zhuge Liang set out in person despite Wang Lian's remonstrance that the south was a barren land of miasma and pestilence, saying that the Nanman lands were far away and their people unaccustomed to the king's civilizing influence. When Zhuge Liang released captured soldiers to sow discord, E Huan, Gao Ding's lieutenant, stabbed Yong Kai and Zhu Bao to death, and Gao Ding presented their heads. Romance, Ch. 87 §2–7 · 13–26

When Zhuge Liang had gone deep into the Nanman lands, Ma Su told him that the Nanman, relying on their remote land and steep mountains, had long refused to submit, so attacking their hearts was the best policy. Meng Huo sent out the marshals of three caves, Jinhuan Sanjie, Dongtuna and Ahuinan, and was captured, and thereafter King Duosi of Tulong Cave, Yang Feng (楊鋒), chief of Yinye Cave, his wife Lady Zhurong, King Mulu, chief of Bana Cave, his brother-in-law the Dailai Cave Chief, and Wutugu, lord of the Wuge Kingdom, in turn either helped Meng Huo or bound him and handed him over. Wutugu's 30,000 rattan-armored troops were burned to death in Panshe Valley. Romance, Ch. 87 §29–32Romance, Ch. 89 §18–19 · 47–51Romance, Ch. 90 §12 · 19–20 · 27–28 · 31–35 · 49–51

In Chapter 90, Meng Huo, captured for the seventh time, heard that he would be released again; saying that capturing a man seven times and releasing him seven times had never happened since ancient times, he bared his shoulders with his clan and begged forgiveness, saying that the people of the south would never rebel again. Zhuge Liang made Meng Huo cave chief in perpetuity and returned all the land he had taken, and to Fei Yi, who asked why he left no officials behind, he cited three difficulties. The people of the Man lands set up a shrine to him while he was still alive, sent pearls, gold and silver, cinnabar, lacquer, medicinal herbs, plough oxen and warhorses, and swore never to rebel again. Romance, Ch. 90 §60–62 · 64–65

In Chapter 91, when the returning Shu army reached the Lu River, wind and waves rose so that it could not cross, and Meng Huo said that in the past sacrifices had been made there with forty-nine human heads and black oxen and white sheep. Zhuge Liang, without killing anyone, performed the sacrifice in person and got the army across, then left Wang Kang and Lü Kai at Yongchang to guard the four commanderies and sent Meng Huo home. In Chapter 118, when Chengdu was in danger, the ministers proposed fleeing to the seven commanderies of Nanzhong and borrowing Man troops, but Qiao Zhou objected that the Nanman were a people who had long been in rebellion and that no kindness had ever been shown them. Romance, Ch. 91 §1–5 · 9–10Romance, Ch. 118 §1–2

Where the Romance differs

Name and leader: Chapters 85–91 of the Romance call the southern non-Han peoples the "Nanman" and set up Meng Huo, King of the Man, as their leader. Chen Shou's main text has neither the name "Nanman" nor Meng Huo, and records that all the commanderies of Nanzhong rebelled. Romance, Ch. 85 §32Romance, Ch. 87 §2Records, Shu 5 §23

Leaders of the rebellion: In Chapter 87 of the Romance, Meng Huo is the head of the rebellion, Yong Kai, Administrator of Jianning, joins him, and Zhu Bao, Administrator of Zangke, and Gao Ding, Administrator of Yuexi, surrender their cities. In the Biography of the Later Sovereign in the Records, Yong Kai was a powerful clan leader of Yizhou Commandery who had sent the Administrator Zhang Yi (張裔) off to Wu, Gao Ding was the Yi king of Yuexi, and Zhu Bao was the Administrator of Zangke who rebelled with his commandery. Romance, Ch. 87 §2Records, Shu 3 §4

Yong Kai's end: In Chapter 87 of the Romance, Gao Ding, taken in by Zhuge Liang's ruse to sow discord, attacks Yong Kai, and his lieutenant E Huan kills Yong Kai and Zhu Bao. In the Records, by the time Zhuge Liang had set out to attack Yong Kai, Yong Kai had already been killed by Gao Ding's retainers, and Zhuge Liang suppressed Gao Ding. Romance, Ch. 87 §19–26Records, Shu 13 §27 · 49

The allied state: In Chapter 85 of the Romance, the Nanman move as one of the five routes of invasion devised by Sima Yi of Wei. In the Records, Yong Kai attached himself to Wu, and Wu appointed him from afar Administrator of Yongchang. Romance, Ch. 85 §32Records, Shu 1 §19Records, Shu 13 §21

After the pacification: In Chapter 90 of the Romance, Zhuge Liang, saying he would leave no one behind and transport no grain, made Meng Huo cave chief and returned the land, and the people of the Man lands swore never to rebel again. In the Records, Yizhou Commandery was renamed Jianning Commandery, Yunnan Commandery and Xinggu Commandery were newly established, and Lü Kai, Wang Kang and Ma Zhong were made administrators, but when the army withdrew the southern Yi rebelled again. In the 11th year of Jianxing (233) Liu Zhou rebelled, and the Sou Yi of Yuexi rebelled repeatedly and killed administrators. Romance, Ch. 90 §61–65Records, Shu 3 §6Records, Shu 13 §27 · 30 · 17 · 31 · 49

The proposal to flee south: In Chapter 118 of the Romance, Qiao Zhou objects that the Nanman have long been in rebellion and that no kindness has ever been shown them. Qiao Zhou's memorial in the Records gives as its reasons that the south had submitted under military pressure after Zhuge Liang's southern campaign, and that it had since been made to pay taxes to the government to supply the army and was resentful. Romance, Ch. 118 §2Records, Shu 12 §70–71

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Lineage

  • Absorbed by: Shu (225) — 「三年春,亮率眾南征,其秋悉平」

Members (12)

Related events (1)

Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).